הפסקת האש בעזה - פרשנות

NTD Hebrew
86 followers
1.2K Video Views·Nov 26, 2023
לנוכח הפסקת האש בעזה שוחחנו עם ריצ'ארד קאמפ, קולונל בדימוס בצבא הבריטי, ששירת בין היתר באפגניסטן.
קאמפ סיפר לנו בהרחבה על דעתו בנוגע לעסקת החטופים בין ישראל לחמאס ומה לדעתו עלול לקרות בעתיד.
____________________
לערוץ הטלגרם של NTD
https://t.me/+m1VZHG572qUxMzdk
בקרו באתר NTD בעברית:
https://ntdtv.co.il/
לתמיכה בערוץ:
https://donorbox.org/ntd-hebrew
לדף הטוויטר של NTD
https://twitter.com/NTDHEBREW
ערוץ NTD באתר "יומייקר" (ערוץ ללא צנזורה!)
https://youmaker.com/c/ntdhebrew
ערוץ NTD ב"רמבל" (ערוץ ללא צנזורה!)
https://rumble.com/nTDHEBREW
להצטרפות לערוץ NTD בווטסאפ
https://chat.whatsapp.com/G3K7PppDOEEIM5iF6IzKRb
לדף הפייסבוק שלנו
https://www.facebook.com/ntdhebrew
With the much-anticipated truce between Israel and Hamas just around the corner,
we take a deeper dive into the deal. Retired British Army Colonel Richard Kemp, who served
from 1977 to 2006, provides a rare insider perspective on the hostage deal brokered
between Israel and Hamas. Colonel Richard Kemp, thank you so much for joining us.
My pleasure to be with you.
Colonel, you're actually in Israel right now. Given this recent Israel-Hamas hostage deal,
how do you rate it? Is it a win for either side?
It's certainly a win for Israel in terms of getting back at least some of the hostages that
were dragged off on the 7th of October, which is very important for Israel as a country and all
people. It's a win also for Hamas because Hamas is under great pressure. They've been subjected to
an enormous battering by Israel over the last few weeks. They're reeling, they're on the back foot,
and this deal suggests it's not because they're some kind of humanitarian organisation that takes
pity on their captives. It suggests they're in a desperate state and want to have some
breathing space, which they, I think, hope will eventually lead to a permanent ceasefire.
On that note, Israel has vowed to, quote, continue its complete annihilation of Hamas
after this ceasefire. What will this four-day ceasefire do from a tactical perspective?
Well, I think from the Hamas perspective, it gives them a chance to regroup, reorganise,
plan defensive operations against the IDF, and in some cases for their leaders, I think,
probably to try and escape out of Gaza to live and fight another day. For Israel, it doesn't
give them any huge advantage. Probably the opposite, in fact, because they begin to lose
military momentum over the four-day period. They can, of course, themselves reposition, prepare to
resume the offensive in an even more furious way, I think, if it's possible,
and they can operate some kind of surveillance on the enemy to see what they're doing,
where they're going to, et cetera, although there are constraints on that under the deal
that's been agreed. Now, there have been mixed reviews
to this hostage deal. Former US official John Bolton is saying negotiating with terrorists
never works. What do you see as the geopolitical impact of this deal?
Well, I think it's got a few implications, one of which is, I think it, to an extent, undermines
Israeli support among Arab states because the Arabs, what they want, they want two things.
They want Hamas to be destroyed. I'm talking about countries like Egypt, Jordan, Saudi Arabia,
the UAE, which is also, all of those countries are indirectly threatened by Hamas, so they want
Israel to destroy them. And secondly, they want a strong Israel. They want an Israel that's seen to
be able to defend itself, stand up for itself, deter its enemies, and also help in the protection
of their own countries against the common threat, which is Iran. And I think this, it may appear to
some of these Arab countries as a bit of a sign of Israeli weakness, the fact that they're willing
to pause their operations. I think the most important thing will be, for Israel, will be
to resume operations as rapidly as possible and not allow themselves to be dragged into a
protracted period of ceasefire, which I think there'll be a lot of pressure on them to do.
Now, there have been some reports that say doing this type of a deal makes Hamas almost
legitimate, that you are negotiating with them. How much do you see international pressure,
especially all of these global protests that are pro-Palestine, playing into this deal?
Well, I think it's absolutely the correct perspective. There are a lot of people
in the Western world, in particular in Europe, in the United States, in Britain,
who are sympathetic towards Hamas. I think they were really horrified by what they saw in most
cases on the 7th of October, although many people will say Israel had it coming, which, of course,
is a horrific thing to imagine. But nevertheless, that's what some people think. And there is
sympathy for Hamas. And I think them being seen to be reasonable people, reasonable actors who
are willing to release some of the hostages, I think that reinforces those people who are
sympathetic. And I think if anything, this is going to lead to probably even greater protests
around the West in favour of Hamas against Israel, because they will be given a kind of a,
I think, an incentive to be pushing hard for a longer ceasefire.
