Entrée en vigueur d’une trêve de quatre jours entre Israël et le Hamas à Gaza. Celle-ci est censée permettre la libération de 50 otages israéliens contre la remise en liberté de 150 détenus palestiniens. Pour en parler, Joan Deas, directrice exécutive de l'Institut de Recherche et d'études Méditerranée Moyen-Orient (Iremmo), diplômée du Master « Organisations internationales » de Sciences Po Grenoble et doctorante en science politique dans cette même institution, est la grande invitée internationale de RFI. Que peut-on espérer de cette trêve, doit-on redouter sa fragilité, quel avenir pour la paix dans cette région ? Elle répond à Julien Coquelle-Roehm. #israel#hamas 🔔 Abonnez-vous à notre chaîne : https://rfi.my/YTfr 🔴 Suivez RFI en DIRECT vidéo ici : https://rfi.my/YTliveFR 🌍 L’actualité du monde et de l’Afrique en direct : https://www.rfi.fr/fr/ Rejoignez-nous sur Facebook : https://rfi.my/FBfr Suivez-nous sur X (Twitter) : https://rfi.my/Xfr Découvrez l’actu en images sur Instagram : https://rfi.my/IGfr Recevez les dernières infos sur Telegram : https://rfi.my/TGfr
A truce entered into force an hour ago, at least on paper.
Four days of interruption of the fighting in Gaza and an exchange.
The release of 50 Israeli hostages by Hamas against 150 Palestinian prisoners in Israel.
A first group of 13 hostages should be released this afternoon.
The result of long weeks of negotiations after 49 days of murderous war.
Are we witnessing a turnaround? What can we expect now?
Hello, Johanne Déas, Executive Director of the Mediterranean Studies Research Institute in the Middle East, IREMO.
The two camps reported a few rapes in the first quarter of the hour.
No information since then.
Difficult for the moment to say if the truce has entered into force for good.
Do you think it has a good chance of being respected?
Or should we fear, as in the past, that it will be broken?
This truce has already been elaborated in an extremely laborious way.
It took five to six weeks of negotiations with several intermediaries,
with very complicated communication shuttles.
It is clearly a truce that for me seems very fragile,
with many potential derailment factors,
many of what are called spoilers,
people who are rather interested in the fact that the truce does not work.
We have an absence of mechanism of application of the truce on the ground.
We do not have independent observers on the ground either
to make it respected, to observe its respect.
When you look at the content of the communications
made by Hamas and Israel,
there are quite contradictory things in the content of this truce.
For example, Hamas says that the Palestinian population
will be able to have total freedom of movement between the north and the south,
while Israel says the opposite,
that is, it will position its soldiers
to prevent the population of the south from returning to the north.
There have been drafts dropped in recent hours to say,
do not go to the north, it is a war zone, it is forbidden to go there.
This raises a number of questions,
knowing that we are in an extreme climate of tension,
with an army and an armed group in front of it,
who really have their finger on the trigger,
they announced it, so we will have to monitor it closely.
Who could break this agreement first?
You are talking about spoilers,
of people who could,
of camps that could put an end to it in advance.
It's very, very hard to say.
There are a lot of actors who can do it.
It is not enough to break a draft,
it is enough to make a mistake,
it is enough for someone to lose his cool.
We must also monitor what is happening in the north,
with Hezbollah, which was not really part of the negotiations,
but which decided that it would also respect this draft.
But we have seen an intensification of the bombings
and actions by Hezbollah in recent days,
so we will also have to monitor the northern front.
After this draft, we still have to talk about it.
Everything that can save civil life
and avoid war crimes,
even if it's four days, it's good.
Whatever the scenario for Qatar today,
a key mediator in these negotiations for Qatar,
can we say that it is an accomplishment in itself
to have reached an agreement between these two parties
which seem irreconcilable?
Yes, it is an accomplishment.
It is not the first time that Qatar has succeeded.
Traditionally, Qatar is the facilitator
between Hamas and Israel.
Qatar has built its so-called soft power,
its influence strategies in the world,
on its mediation capabilities.
In fact, it has strong assets to be able to do that,
since it is an intermediary that speaks to everyone,
notably Hamas, which is very close to Hamas,
which welcomes Ismail Haniyeh,
who is the leader of Hamas, who is in exile in Qatar.
So, indeed, there are many assets
that make Qatar want to position itself
as the Geneva of the Middle East.
Today, the agreement is based on a small number of hostages,
as we said, around 50 out of 240.
For the moment, we are talking about vulnerable people,
notably children, elderly people.
Is it that to free the other hostages,
still held in Gaza,
the negotiations are even more complicated?
Does Hamas, for example, have an interest
in asking more from Israel now?
Hamas has every interest in asking more,
knowing that you are looking at the previous agreements
that could have been concluded in the history of the conflict
between Hamas and Israel.
You have the negotiation, for example,
of the release of the soldier Gilad Shahid in 2011,
which was made against 1,027 prisoners.
So we have a ratio of 20 against 1,000.
Here we are on a ratio of 1 against 3.
Indeed, but Hamas, in addition,
has no interest in releasing all the hostages at once,
since it is its only currency at the moment.
It is more interested in dragging the release of the hostages,
and this is probably the strategy
that will be used by Yair Yassinouar,
the head of Hamas in the Gaza Strip,
to bet, perhaps,
on the fact that the longer the truce is extended,
the more it will be potentially complicated for Israel
to resume the fights behind
and to resume the bombings
from the point of view of the public,
internal and international opinion.
Knowing that Israel claims that the war is not over,
that it will continue its offensive,
will it be difficult for you to resume this offensive
or this precedent, if I dare say, created by the truce?
So it will really depend on the opinion,
on the Israeli opinion and the capacity
to pressure the Israeli opinion.
It will be extremely complicated for Israel
to justify the fact that a certain number of hostages
will be released, have been released, and not the rest.
So if they are in a process
of releasing the hostages,
it will be difficult to justify to families
whose hostages are still held in captivity.
So I think it's going to be complicated,
but we must not underestimate
the power of the security paradigm
within Netanyahu's administration,
which sees Gaza
through a security
and military prism only.
And you should know that the hostages
are not too concerned
at first to really be able
to focus on their strategic objectives
of the destruction of Hamas,
which are for me unattainable
and completely fanciful objectives.
So it's still very early
to draw conclusions.
You say unattainable and fanciful objectives
when talking about the objectives
of destroying Hamas. Why?
It's unattainable because
you can't kill an idea.
You can raze the Gaza Strip,
as is currently the case.
60% of the Gaza Strip is partially or totally destroyed.
You can make a parking lot out of it.
You can chase the last
Hamas fighter into the Gaza Strip.
That's not what's going to kill
Hamas.
The only way to put an end to Hamas
is to stop the blockade,
to give dignified living conditions
to the Palestinian population
and rights to the Palestinian population.
That's a political solution
that needs to be found.
And the short-term military solution
will not work
and will probably lead Israel
into a huge military swamp
that will probably be endless.
We remain for the moment in this military context,
in the humanitarian crisis as well.
You know well the Palestinian territories
where you have worked with NGOs in the past.
Humanitarian organizations
in Gaza say today
that four days of strike is largely
insufficient to respond to the crisis.
Is that also your feeling?
It is completely insufficient.
Just as an example,
to schedule a surgical intervention
and find a competent doctor,
it takes five to six days.
You really have to realize
the extent of the damage
and the extent of the humanitarian
drama that is currently taking place in Gaza.
There are about 15,000 injured
and 1.7 million people
who are displaced.
NGOs are warning of a famine.
There is no more water,
no more food,
no more electricity for more than 45 days.
People are crowded in the UN refuges
where nearly 700 people
share a shower,
160 people share a toilet.
Diseases are starting to spread.
Refuges can no longer accommodate
people sleeping outside.
The Gaza Strip is completely cut off from the world.
Humanitarian NGOs have not had access
to the north of the Gaza Strip for almost two weeks.
We have no way of knowing
the extent of the disaster
in the northern part.
This will also complicate the humanitarian
process, especially since
Israel still refuses to open
the checkpoint called the Kerem Shalom crossing.
The only crossing at the moment
to allow the 300 humanitarian
trucks that are promised by the TREV
is Rafah. Rafah is not made for this.
This will greatly hamper
humanitarian aid and its progress.