האם עסקת החטופים הוגנת לישראל? - פרשנות

NTD Hebrew
86 followers
67 Video Views·Nov 23, 2023
האם עסקת החטופים המתגבשת הוגנת כלפי ישראל?
אלו לחצים בין-לאומיים הופעלו על ישראל?
ולמה אנו יכולים לצפות בעקבות הפסקת האש?
מגישת המהדורה המרכזית של חדשות NTD באנגלית, טיפאני מאייר שוחחה בנושא עם דיוויד וורמסר, פרשן לענייני המזה״ת, במרכז האמריקני למדיניות ביטחון.
____________________
לערוץ הטלגרם של NTD
https://t.me/+m1VZHG572qUxMzdk
בקרו באתר NTD בעברית:
https://ntdtv.co.il/
לתמיכה בערוץ:
https://donorbox.org/ntd-hebrew
לדף הטוויטר של NTD
https://twitter.com/NTDHEBREW
ערוץ NTD באתר "יומייקר" (ערוץ ללא צנזורה!)
https://youmaker.com/c/ntdhebrew
ערוץ NTD ב"רמבל" (ערוץ ללא צנזורה!)
https://rumble.com/nTDHEBREW
להצטרפות לערוץ NTD בווטסאפ
https://chat.whatsapp.com/G3K7PppDOEEIM5iF6IzKRb
לדף הפייסבוק שלנו
https://www.facebook.com/ntdhebrew
Is the hostage deal fair for Israel?
What were some of the global pressure that Israel faced?
And what can we expect to see following the ceasefire?
To take a deeper dive into Israel's hostage deal with Hamas, we have on David Wormser,
Middle East Affairs Analyst at the Center for Security Policy.
David Wormser, thank you so much for joining us.
Great to have you back on the show.
It's great to be with you.
We're hearing reports that Israel and Hamas have reached a hostage deal.
Hamas is agreeing to release 50 women and children.
This is part of a four-day ceasefire.
Israel is also set to release a number of hostages here.
How do you read this deal?
Is it a fair deal?
No, it's not a fair deal in a number of ways.
One is that the numbers, 50 Israeli children, essentially, with their mothers in exchange
for, I've heard, anything between 150 terrorists up to 300 to 400 minors who conducted support
activity for terrorism but didn't actually do terrorism.
So the numbers are already not fair.
The second thing is that the Israelis are essentially asked to equate a terrorist and
the value of a terrorist to the value of a child by bartering one for one, three for
one, five for one, whatever the actual number is.
But essentially, it creates equivalence.
And then the third thing is Israel's negotiating with Hamas, which makes, in Middle Eastern
terms, Hamas powerful because the Israelis have to come to terms with it.
So here you have a very powerful state that's legitimate in the U.N. with an army and every
thing, and it has to negotiate on equal terms with the terrorist organization.
And that raises the stature of the terrorist organization.
So in all those ways, it's an imbalanced deal.
But the Israelis, it's kids.
It's their kids.
And it's gut-wrenching for them, and it's heartbreaking.
So from their point of view, they'll do anything to get those kids back.
What about the broader geopolitical implications here?
How do you see China, Iran, these other countries viewing this deal?
Iran is trying to portray it as Israeli weakness, and it is to some extent.
In geopolitical terms, it is Israel's vulnerable to this blackmail, essentially.
But at the same time, it's what makes Israeli society so cohesive and gives them the morale
to really fight hard.
So I think Iran's underestimating that.
China and Russia are now fully aligning behind Iran and participating in a lot of the psychological
warfare against Israel at this point, as well as some warfare, I mean, most likely cyber
warfare and things like that.
So we really are now dealing with a geopolitical bloc, and they have a vested interest in not
only Israel looking weak and limping, but the United States being wounded by that, Israel
looking weak to destroy any hope that other nations in the region will form a strategic
bloc with Israel, which they were, by the way, and are still forming, and the United
States then being able to base its regional strategy and security on that bloc.
So that's what really the strategic game is here.
