has South Korea's fat shaming gone too
far or is the West just getting a little
sensitive yeah is it the truth is it
offensive or is the truth offensive
let's just play the
[Music]
video boom Andrew there was a bunch of
debates in the comments section of
course are you surprised this went viral
on Tik Tok no cuz anything can over I
just remind you this is from the Eastern
world and we are judging it with the
Western lens so it's going to be a
little wonky so listen guys make sure
you like subscribe and turn on your
notifications but Andrew you know what
is not heavily debated SMA sauce very
delicious check it out it's shipping out
very very soon you guys can still buy it
uh check out the Instagram for all the
content and all the chefs that have
tried it I will say that people are like
saying it's fat phobic in a weird way
because it's saying but but but it's
telling the bigger people that look like
Baymax in the silhouette to take the
escalator and the Able Body people to
take the stairs so you could look at it
two ways you could look at it like oh
they're labeling that's bad that's fat
phobic or you can say oh that's very
nice to them because they don't want the
able-bodied people who should be taking
the stairs anyway to clog up the
elevator system yeah so uh I think my
initial reaction is like labeling people
as plus-size is not wrong because we
have plus-size models we have plus-size
clothing right but is it shocking to see
it in the subway station because it's
true in the western world this would be
considered offensive no you're right
they wouldn't have this in the western
world and I guess the point is it
because of like speed and flow like if
you're a regular able-body person just
take the stairs but if you're bigger
don't slow down the stairs and then just
take the escalators but then they're
telling skinny people don't take the
escalators yeah because maybe they're
saying like the escalators those are for
the people who like made the they they
they made their choice in life of what
archetype they are okay and I guess I
just want to know how offensive it is to
have the kind of the thicker icon person
the fat icon person versus like a
wheelchair icon person I do you think it
is like offensive because it's a
government agency that obviously
sanctioned this I'm not saying this came
from the top but if it's in the sole
subway system and it's been there I
looked at the research for 10 years
clearly this is like somebody's like
some government agency has approved this
yeah yeah I I my first feeling is that
it's not that offensive but I could see
how it could be if we took this further
like if it said in Korean fat people
take the escalator don't clog up the
stairs that would be offensive your knee
is like going to fall apart anyway um I
do think that it's interesting that
South Korea is getting looked at through
an American lens because people like
relate to it so much pop culturally
they're almost wanting to put social
movements or you know correct my
language here I don't want to say woke
movements regarding regarding certain
things but trying to just depose it over
there because they relate to it but
that's a different Society right I think
a lot of people forget that South Korea
is Asia It Is East Asia and it is a
different Society despite how many shows
you like to watch from them despite if
you like the music or the music sounds
American I will tell you this the
society is still very very different
than America yeah so anyway let's just
get into the comment section these uh
are from white people and other races of
people just non-asian people who went to
South Korea and they said uh you know
when I was there I was told by a lady at
a retail store that I was too big to try
in their clothes they didn't even let me
go into the fitting room well yeah all
right so that might be a little that
that is a little bit rude but knowing
how like Asian culture is where they're
just like hey you're fat hey you're
getting too fat like that's how they
treat the people they love you can
imagine how they treat the strangers you
know and I don't think that was
necessarily meant out of malice but that
lady probably was just like in her mind
being very fact like just logical right
um some people were saying that that
they only had sizes 2 four and six for
women in Korea pretty much 95% of the
stores they're from Texas they're a size
12 or they're from yeah they're from
Texas and they're a size 12 and then
they were kind of saying like they were
kind of disappointed what but other
people were arguing back like who are
you to be a gigantic Texas girl who's a
size 12 and go to Korea and expect that
they're going to cater to you exactly
exactly it's a different Society of
course somebody came through with a more
negative comment they are one of the
most judgmental superficial cultures
ever any encounter I've had with them
has always been unpleasant I was like
damn yeah I no you know I I I think
there's there's different takes on it
yeah and this uh this fat guy who's
clearly fat from his Avatar he said you
know what I'd be more offended if it was
the other way around like if Korea was
telling me to exercise by taking the
stairs I sure appreciate that they told
me to take the escalator exactly so this
is my thing the messaging is telling the
big people to take the escalators versus
if they were saying hey if you're fat
you have to burn more calories and you
should take the stairs for your own good
that would definitely be more offensive
right cuz that would sound like a mean
sarcastic joke right because it's like
you guys are clearly not getting your 10
to 20,000 steps in a day to get your
neat like they're just being logical
like yeah if you're disabled you should
take the elevator it's kind of like that
I'm not saying fat people are
categorically disabled but I'm saying if
there was a person in a wheelchair they
would expect to take the elevator right
what it's there for um somebody said
just like climate change we cannot deny
that we're living through an obesity
epidemic here in the west I think
reminding people that we need daily
exercise is a good thing so this is
where sort of uh you know cuz and let's
be honest Tik Tok comments Yahoo
comments there is a difference in tone
the Yahoo people were like man you can't
even say the truth anymore and and
somebody who did something to themselves
they get considered a special group that
you can't talk about anymore what's
going on right right right um somebody
was just saying you know we need this in
the US especially when I'm at my coffee
shop and I just want to buy a simple
black coffee and the person in front of
me is loading up some sort of special
drink with 6,000 pumps that's got an
entire day's worth of calories in a cup
why can't I go through a speedy line
just to get my black coffee
oh it's kind of like should there be
separate lines for people who are like I
don't need any extra treatment I don't
want to waste any time this is the
express line but if you want to Stack up
an order if you need to take the
escalators we're not judging you but
we're just saying for the low of things
go into this line yeah a lot of people
were just talking about having different
cultural values imposing Western IDE
ideology on South Korea even though of
course Andre South Korea it is probably
in some ways the most easily the most
Americanized East Asian country but then
how much can people expect to like input
their ideologies on something that they
just love so much but they love it on a
shallow level my question is David did
that work did the little signage work
did big people actually listen to it and
take the escalator and then everybody
else took the stairs like how much I
think it does how much do people buy
into these sign I want to know if it
works yeah it it works somebody said
people just get offended from nothing
nowadays I'm personally fat myself and I
know why I just eat a lot of bad food
and I don't play enough sports anybody
advising me to make more efforts helps
me whatever the way so basically this
guy's talking about like he's fat
himself but he believes that fat shaming
works but he knows why he ended up there
by the way guys not my words this is
from the comment section yeah yeah yeah
I'm I just wonder if this is considered
fat shaming like where is the line that
you draw for fat shaming or fat phobia
fat phobia is obviously on an upper tier
that's where you hate and you are feared
of fat people I think very few people
are actually fat phobic by definition
but I think a lot of people maybe fat
should I will tell you this here's the
biggest thing man and and this is an
ideological difference in the west
people feel that labeling people into
like regular sized and plus-sized is
already fat phobic in Asia they
definitely do not believe that right
like they're never going to believe that
just labeling people cuz they' just be
like yeah but just look at them I'm not
going to deny like the science behind
this BMI yeah I don't think that they
grow up in Asia telling people to treat
fat people differently I do think they
judge them though because is very
judgmental yeah it is judgmental but
they do say hey if you are fat you need
to do things a little bit differently
because you're fat you have to do this
and you can't wear this clothes or
something like that somebody said that
being offended by this would be akin to
being offended that the Japanese White
Glove dudes that work in the subway are
violating people's personal space by
shoving them like sardines into the can
but the thing is Andrew in Japan people
want to get shoved into that Subway cart
because they want to get home sooner
right right right but then in America
people be like dude why is this like
government worker like shoving me in my
chest and Sh cramming my briefcase it's
just a different Society dude I I don't
know um ultimately Andrew what are your
takeaways on this or is this something
where it's just simply a difference of
culture that probably will never be
rectified in the sense of like this side
will never make sense to that side uh I
think Asia operates by its own rules and
I think a lot of countries are doing
fine operating by those rules obviously
there are problems I mean listen if
there's like a a very high like rate of
depression amongst overweight people in
South Korea I would definitely look at
that and be more sensitive to that right
but you're saying if the data comes out
the Big Data if that is true but if you
are just literally talking about traffic
and you're talking about big cars and
small cars hey guys oversized trucks can
you take this Lane everybody else that
has a regularized car that chose to buy
a regularized car or could only afford a
regularized car you take this Lane it's
almost that simple that's how I see this
is a traffic sign right right I don't
know if there was other words attached
to it saying like in Korean like fed
people but I don't know if it did I
think it just had a picture and said if
you're you're a bigger person just just
just don't take up the stairs you know
some people could in the west could
interpret it as individually fat phobic
in the East they may just uh see it as
Confucian collectivism everybody's born
different everybody made different
choices everybody let's just make the
system flow as best as it can by parsing
out the smaller parts they take the
smaller stairs the bigger people they
take the electronic one if everybody
takes the electronic one the whole
system's going to break down yeah
interesting um I do think this though I
do think this when it specifically comes
to South Korea Andrew people love the
prods they they love the K drama
especially love the K-pop I don't know
if you guys know about K-pop BMI it's
low Middle High it's in the low category
no you're it's not even in the middle
category for BMI it's in the low range
you're saying if you're a person that
loves K-pop kramas loves all these stars
that are really good-looking and slim
which is what South Korea is known for
amongst having talent as well if you're
a fan of that of the K of the Hol you
wave but you get mad at this then that's
in a way it's kind of hypocritical
you're mad at the process and you're mad
at the culture that reinforces the
normative behavior I'm not saying
there's pros and there's pros and cons
to everything okay you know there's
upsides and downsides to everything but
how can you just like the upsides and
then hate all the downsides that's like
me going to Singapore being like Oh my
gosh I love how clean and crime free and
graffiti free Singapore is oh my gosh
their rules are so strict they have no
Freedom this place is totalitarian and
horrible lewanuu Andrew he always said
there was a cost to everything
yeah well anyways guys you let us know
in the comments down below is this
considered offensive is this just like a
traffic sign or is this kind of blurring
the lines of potentially fat shaming
versus I'm just trying to make things
work guys you let me know because it's
definitely says something I guess about
what you believe ideologically right so
anyways guys let me know in the comments
down below we are the Hot Pot boys and
until next time we out
peace