🔵 Sign up for the American Thought Leaders ALERTS newsletter to stay up-to-date on new episodes, releases, and events 👉 https://ept.ms/ATLnewsletter
"What's crazy is that higher ed isn't just not teaching students how to have productive debates that actually get somewhere, they are allowing and even facilitating habits of dismissing people by identity, for example, [or] by finding out if someone has done something bad in their whole life, and then therefore, your opinion on something completely different is no longer taken seriously. Campuses shouldn't be within 1000 yards of these kinds of poor rhetorical tactics, but they're actually teaching them."
Greg Lukianoff, co-author of “The Canceling of the American Mind” and President of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression
what's crazy is that highed isn't just
uh um not teaching students how to have
productive debates that actually get
somewhere they are allowing and even
facilitating habits of of dismissing
people by identity for example um uh by
uh you know finding out if someone has
done something bad in their whole life
and therefore your opinion on something
completely different is is no longer
taken seriously uh campuses should not
be teaching shouldn't be with a thousand
yards of these kind of poor rhetorical
tactics but they're actually teaching
them mhm well exactly I mean it's it it
it's not just sort of encouraged but
it's like the way it's done and I I look
looking through your I think you have 10
of these different uh studies arguments
no arguments uh ways of arguing that
allow you to avoid AR having a reason
discussion yeah right and I I look
looking through this this is just what
everybody does right now it's very rare
to have just an actual conversation that
where there's some level of disagreement
where you're trying to figure out the
truth of the matter yeah well grifter is
is one and so we set it up nicely in
that we have the first Chunk we call the
obstacle course which are standard
logical fall fallacies that includes you
know accusations of bad faith um and
someone's a bad person so therefore they
have all bad opinions which which is
what we talk about as the fourth grer un
truth in the book but in this case it's
an ation the word the word that best
epitomize of this is grifter um
basically saying that uh you know like
I've been I've defended thousands of
students you know o o over the years
second and none in terms of Defending
faculty and and and student rights and
people who know nothing about my work
will immediately be like oh yeah it's a
grift talking about this stuff and it's
like well unfortunately you call
everybody grifters that you don't want
to listen to this is just an assumption
of bad faith and just an insult as a way
to avoid actually engaging in any
serious way and I wonder if I can dive
in I often wonder whether it's not also
a projection because the person
themselves has bad faith so they assume
you do I I I actually that that's a the
next one I want to talk about is what we
call hypocrisy projection okay and if
you start looking on the interwebs you
will see this everywhere particularly X
um and threads Etc um I can't tell you
how many times um someone when there's a
case in the news of and by the way you
get this both from the right and the
left sometimes when fire takes a case
where defending a lefty you know um
which is often you'll have someone from
the right come up and like where were
are you on on this case you know
involving the right and we're like
here's the lawsuit we filed on behalf of
this professor we're quoted on the
following 20 things here you only care
about one side of the political fence
you projected that on to us and because
you can't grock the idea that there
might actually be consistent Defenders
of free speech and we watch the same
thing on the left um and it's it's
really funny because like time and time
again people will be accused where are
you on this case um that I just learned
about where I Lefty got in trouble and
it's like okay first of all how about
you do something to help that Professor
first first of all second of all do your
homework we we uh we commented on this a
month ago and here are the letters that
we wrote I remember one time someone
actually uh did this citing a document
that was a fired document like fire
where the fire is not going anywhere
near this I'm like you're literally
citing a document that you didn't even
know was actually you know produced by
fire for request so hypocrisy projection
is one of these really lame and
embarrassing techniques that we tend to
use in the age of social media where
people want to just W bad w a hypocrite
w a grifter so they don't have to think
you know I'm remembering something else
and I think this appears at least twice
in in in your book it's uh it's a quote
from Salah heiton uh the line between
good and evil goes through every human
heart tell me about that well I thought
um our society was improving in our
moral sophistication um maybe 20 years
ago that increasingly our art moved from
typically uh like TV shows for example
um moved from typically you know good
versus evil you know heroic characters
or even just good characters who are
kind-hearted to more exploration of
people who were actually really bad in a
lot of different ways but then also
showing the weird relatability and
Humanity that they oftentimes had in
themselves as well and I thought we were
moving to a level at which there was
like you know what um if we if we take
human nature seriously there is good and
evil inside of all of us um and that
essentially we do have complicated
motives and things are oftentimes more
morally complicated than we think and
there are genuine moral dilemmas where
that your only choices or situations
that might be truly awful and only
slightly less um and somehow now as we
seem to be progressing that way
everything went entirely in the reverse
and in coddling of the American mind we
call this the third great untruth um and
and the untruths are the ideas of as if
the worst Guru in the world was giving
you the stupidest advice you ever heard
in your life that will make you
miserable it disagrees with ancient
wisdom and with modern psychological
thought so the first three great
untruths that we cover in coddling are
what doesn't kill you makes you weaker
uh uh always trust your feelings which
sounds nice but it's terrible advice um
and as someone said U your feelings are
are are data not directions um and three
uh life is a battle between good people
and evil people um exclusively and in
this book we introduce the fourth fourth
which is no bad person has any good
argument that essentially if I can you
know magically declare you bad I don't
have to think about any argument you
made even though I know full well bad
people sometimes make correct arguments
and good people some often make wrong
ones there's no there's kind of no
relationship between these
two don't forget to subscribe to our
alerts newsletter and you'll never miss
an
episode