Briefing: Inequities in State Funding for 1890 Land Grant Universities

Committee on Education & the Workforce Democrats
55 followers
Nov 17, 2023
Ranking Member Robert C. “Bobby” Scott (VA-03) hosted a briefing with experts on the state of funding for 1890 land-grant Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs), which remains inequitable largely due to state underfunding, and the impact these institutions have on Black students and agriculture advancements.
uh the first moral Act of 1862 was
created created a national system of
land Grand colleges and universities
focused on teaching Agriculture and
mechanical Arts the second moral Act of
n of 1890 established 19 new
historically black colleges and
universities hbcus and prohibited any
form of racial discri racial
discrimination and admissions at those
institutions since their creation these
hbcus have educ at adverse population of
students who have historically been
unable to access higher education
through the three pillars of research
teaching and extension these land grant
HBCU provide high quality education to
students and create groundbreaking
research that supports rural communities
consequently the funding established to
support these HBCU through the
Department of Agriculture is designed to
uphold and promote these principles yet
as decades passed 16 of the 19 land grin
HBCU have consistently been funded at
lower levels than the original land
grant institutions this is due in large
part to the lack of matching funds
provided by States the land grant
hbcus these matching funds are necessary
for the schools to receive certain
federal grants and this going back this
ongoing lack of funding negatively
impacts institution's ability to invest
in Advanced research technology academic
instruction and Community programs so to
wa raise awareness of this issue I
joined Democrat Democratic and
Republican colleagues to call in state
legislators and governers to equitably
fund land grain
HBCU and recently the Secretary of
Education Miguel Miguel cordona and the
US Secretary of Agriculture Thomas filac
also sent letter to each Governor
presiding over States in which land gr
HBCU underfunding uh continues these
letters urge government officials to
Prior prioritize addressing the
collective $
13.1 billion funding Gap from 1987 to
2020 that affects the advancement of
land grant HBCU so we're here today to
help members of Congress and their
staffs have a clear understanding of the
overarching impact this issue will
continue to have on Equitable access to
education in the black community um
thank you Congressman Scott and uh I
appreciate the invitation and the chance
to talk to you and your members and look
forward to to working with you together
on this issue um I uh have a few slides
that I was uh was hoping to share uh
with you just to walk you through some
of the data analysis that we've done
around this issue um so I just wanted to
be able to share um that with you all um
and uh and just uh explain some of the
details behind um some of the statistics
that Congressman Scott just cited um so
uh in our office the office of the chief
Economist um we uh we worked with some
of the administrative data that
institutions report to us through the uh
iped survey uh in the finance module and
uh and uh produced the Topline number
that uh that Congressman Scott described
which is over the period of time 1987 to
2020 so that's the full span of time uh
for which we have these data reported To
Us by
institutions uh HBCU land grant
institutions received uh $15 billion
dollar less from their state than they
would have uh had they been funded at
the same per capita level as the
predominantly white land grant
institution in the state so that that
$15 billion is comprised of about a 13
billion uh disparity in state
Appropriations uh that Congressman Scott
was referencing uh and then we also
looked at disparities in uh grants and
contracts awarded from state governments
to institutions and well and that adds
about another two billion uh dollars in
in um disperate uh funding for these
institutions so I want to tell you a
little bit about the methodology behind
the the report um uh just so you
understand where these statistics are
coming from so like I said we we looked
at ipeds data over the period 1987 to
2020 uh and looked at the total amount
of State appropri ations and then uh
grants and contracts that were awarded
from state governments to these
institutions and then we looked at the
total enrollment levels of these
institutions to estimate the overall uh
amount of State funds that were being
transferred to these institutions per
full-time student that they have
enrolled um most HBCU institutions and
especially when you go back uh over the
history uh in the time period that we've
looked at here uh receive less uh
funding per student um than uh the
predominantly white land grant
institution in their State uh and so
what we do to estimate the funding gap
between the two institutions is we
imagine the amount of funding that the
HBCU land grant institution would have
received had they received the same
amount of funding per student uh as the
white
institution uh given their enrollment
levels uh and then we look at the actual
amount of funding they received and the
difference between those two numbers is
how we compute the Gap in any given year
uh and then we add up uh those funding
gaps over this span of 33 years um that
I've just described to calculate the
overall Gap so just to give you a sense
for uh how these data look the the chart
here is showing you the differences in
per capita funding right so this is the
the level of State funding per student
at uh the uh predominantly white land
grant institution in each state and then
the HBCU land grant in institution in
each
state you can see over the entire uh
time period here that average per capita
funding level has been substantially
lower for HBCU land grant
institutions uh if you go back to the
the late 1980s early 1990s that Gap was
almost um uh $6,000 per student so um uh
the predominantly white institutions
were receiving almost 75% more uh in
funding per capita compared to the HBCU
institutions and there's been some
closing of that Gap happily over these
years so you can see uh especially
during the Great Recession um the uh the
funding Gap has closed although um um
you know unhappily some of the closing
of that Gap has really been withdrawal
of State support from the the non HBCU
institution as opposed to Big increases
in the HBCU
institutions so I won't walk you through
through all of the details but I just
want to note in in um uh data
spreadsheets that we have released and
made available to State Higher Education
commissions and we would be happy uh to
provide those um to anyone who doesn't
have them already uh We've released the
data that we use for this analysis for
every uh institution and every state
that has an HBCU land grant
institution and you can see there's
quite a bit of variation across um
different states in terms of this
funding Gap uh per student different
states have made varying degrees of
progress some have have largely stayed
the same in their funding Gap some have
closed their funding Gap uh over time
all of that information is laid out in
great detail in the in the underlying
data that we've released uh on this
issue so I won't spend our time here
going through that but just want to note
that that some states really have made
progress um U Maryland is is one of them
and I'm sure we'll hear uh about U about
some of those efforts uh as we go along
but if you look at this cumulative the
results of this cumulative disparity uh
in funding over time and I want to
stress that we've looked at just a
snapshot of History here the most recent
33 years okay out of you know roughly a
hundred years that these institutions
have have been in place we're only
looking at the the recent window of time
where where we can observe uh these
funding disparities so I I don't want
you to come away um uh from my
presentation feeling like the dollar
values that we're presenting here are
the sum total of of kind of what it
would take to restore um the resources
that um that uh HBCU institutions uh
have not had access to throughout their
history we're really looking at just
this period since
1987 but even still you can see that uh
in the chart here when you add up uh
these um funding disparities over time
they amount to quite large sums uh
especially in some states so
Tennessee Florida and North Carolina all
have cumulative funding disparities on
the order of $2 billion uh and then you
can see there's a range um where uh in
in some other states there's been uh
less of a disparity at least over this
time period um so uh this is kind of a
summary of of what's true for for all
the different states uh in our analysis
uh again these are data files that we've
made available to the public and we'd be
happy to provide uh to your members uh
uh who are interested and want to dig
into these data um but they break down
the funding disparities and state
Appropriations the disparities in state
and state grants and contracts that are
awarded to the different institutions uh
and then they help to give a sense for
uh how um these gaps and funding have
have changed over time so uh I want to
um uh Stay Stay um there at at that
roughly high level overview and happy to
get into more of the details in the Q&A
uh part of the presentation so uh thank
you for again for the time and look
forward to your
questions no each you start off with
each um state has to match the federal
money what is what is the
match what is the match
percentage that the state has to put
up uh so um somebody from the Department
of Agriculture would be better
positioned to comment on that and one
thing I should have com on it on in the
beginning is that the data that we're
presenting here represent the total um
um total amount of State funding uh
difference between HBCU land grant
institutions and non- HBCU land grant
institutions some of that total is
accounted for by the disparate match
rates of the capacity grants from the
Department of Agriculture uh but the the
magnitude of the overall Gap that's
explained by those um differences in
match rates for the capacity GR Grant
funds differs across States so uh in
some states it can be quite low and in
other states it can be high but in
general um um states are required to
match the federal capacity grants um at
at a 100% rate um and and um but but are
often granted waivers where they don't
need to make the full uh match and and
that accounts again for some of the
disparity that I've talked about here so
we have a a note from Paul braith weight
the matches like I said one to one for
every dollar you get you got to put up
put up a dollar and and the underfunding
is caused by the fact that they don't
put up as many dollars they don't draw
down the full amount for the HBCU and do
draw down the full amount for the other
institutions in the same
state yeah to be clear that that is part
of the disparity that I presented here
uh but the other part of the disparity
has to do with not the capacity grant
funding but just differences in in other
states Appropriations that go to HBCU
versus non HBCU land grant
institutions and um if we wanted to
correct correct it uh what numbers have
to be have to be Chang what what uh
what's our
Target you have to tell the state to do
what or the federal government to do
what yeah so on that question I would
yield s colleagues in the Department of
Education so or I'm sorry the the
Department of Agriculture um so they
they um control the terms of the uh of
the the matching program uh under uh for
these capacity Grant funds um but
generally uh you know and again um the
the data that we've presented reflects
you know broad disparities in all
sources of funding that come from state
governments to uh to HBCU institutions
and and the data really show that um
there is a a broad issue of of these
institutions being underfunded uh you
know the department thinks it's
incredibly important for all students uh
including the the the primarily black
students at these institutions to
receive the resources that they need in
order to uh be able to graduate uh and
further their uh educational goals uh
and so in general we're hoping these
data um can see the conversation that
just illustrate the magnitude of these
disparities and funding including the
capacity Grant match uh issue um in that
states and institutions can plan to get
on a course where these institutions
capacity can be built up in a way that
provides more equal opportunities to
students across all
institutions and I I'll remind the uh
participants if you have a question if
you just go into the chat function we'll
get we'll get you a question I noticed
that Virginia seemed to have um fixed
its problem at least this year do you
have anything more to more specific to
say about Virginia
no so there are a few um uh states where
that is true that that in recent years
in some cases there have been you know
legal settlements pursued or or just
agreements reached between states um uh
in in the HBCU institutions to make
steps to to reverse um some of these
historical Trends uh Virginia does
appear to be one of them but um but the
details of that are not something that
I'm I'm aware of thank you for inviting
to today's briefing it's an honor to be
here today to discuss something that is
near and dear to my heart and that is an
1890 land grant
universities I am very passionate about
1890s because I am a graduate of an 1862
land grant that's a a predominantly
white institution I also worked at three
other 1862 land grant universities and
now I happen to be the president of the
University of Maryland Eastern Shore
UMES also in 189 9 so you can say that I
actually know firsthand the funding
disparities between 1862 and
1890s UMES has distinguished ourselves
for more than 137 years delivering on
the land grant missions of teaching
Workforce Development research and
extension our success has not gone
unnoticed UMES is a doctoral to Carnegie
research high rank institution and most
recently the US News and World Report
ranked UMES as one of the top 10 public
HBCU this has been achieved through a
dogged focus on excellence in all that
we do despite doing so with
less I am also the incoming chair of the
association of public land grant
universities 1890 Council so it is
through these academic and professional
experiences that I have come to
appreciate how important it is what we
do for our students for our region for
our faculty and for our
world people often hear me talk about
high standards about pursuing Excellence
about the importance of distinguishing
yourself and especially my
University I speak of a high bar to
illustrate the importance of effort of
pushing yourself beyond what perhaps you
thought possible in order to reap a
greater reward so today I want to share
with you stories about from several of
our students who have accomplished
this I'm going to start with teer Barry
teer is an in as an infant was diagnosed
with CLE cell disease te's chronic
condition did not hold him back from
making the most of his time at UMES in
fact he thrived he completed two summer
internships with the National Oceanic
Atmospheric
Administration and he worked alongside
one of our talented faculty Dr V us as
an undergraduate assistant in her
chemistry lab where he did research on
Marine
environments this past May teer received
his degree in environmental Sciences
with a focus on Marine Science he was a
member of the honors program the Deans
List and he qualified to graduate with
with very high honors and as he said he
took advantage of every opportunity
given to him here at
UMES Destiny major in biology with the
pread focus and she completed an 8-week
internship collaborative project between
ums and UC San
Diego this was funding from the USDA
Agriculture and food research in
initiative and
nifa Destiny spent her summer working
with grape Vines and also with hemp
tissues and in Dr dey's lab here
Ates they provided the hemp Growers with
a model stock plant that was free of
viruses and disease and Destiny worked
in three other labs while she was here
at UMES and said that the in internships
and the Laboratories gave her the
experience of what a real scientists
would be involved
in Gabrielle Bressler Gabrielle's hard
work and determination paid off she
graduated last year from our UMES preet
program not only did Gabrielle finish
a full semester early but she was
accepted for early admission to my alma
Purdue University in
Indiana Gabrielle maintained a very
rigorous academic schedule while she was
here in as a general agriculture major
and she had a concentration in animal
and poetry science she received various
Hands-On programs and she even was
allowed to scrub in and Practice
Surgical and animal restraint techniques
with Dr Braxton helping to spay and
neuter cats and dogs on the campus she
worked as a veterinary assistant at the
DuPont veterinary clinic in Washington
DC going home on the
weekends and lastly I want you to know a
little bit about Dr joyn
Ellis Dr Ellis is a three-time graduate
ofes and has a PHD in food and
agriculture science that's
remarkable but what's truly remarkable
about Dr Elliot is that she achieved
those degrees under some very
challenging
circumstances she gave birth to her
daughter in the middle of her college
experience and survived a NE severe car
accident one year
later joyn never let those challenges
stop her she is passionate about the
ecosystem about the PES tiddes that are
used on our foods and finding a better
and safer way to produce food for the
growing population
there is a word that describes all of
these students and that word is
resilient it's a word that captures the
essence of 1890 land grant colleges and
universities and HBCU in general we are
resilient we know how to do much more
with so less than our
peers we emphasize the importance of
maintaining high expectations but we
also know that many of our students do
not come from backgrounds for that is
always the case so a stien here an
internship there or an opportunity to
work in a research lab are the Hallmarks
of our
universities on behalf of all of my 1890
Co colleagues throughout the country I
ask for your efforts in making our
Equitable funding to our
institutions 13 billion is a lot of
money that did not get invested in
people like teer or Gabrielle or Destiny
or
joyin here at UMES we are a proud
University and we're very proud of what
we have built earlier this year we were
able to host house agriculture chairman
GT Thompson and representative Andy
Harris on our campus to have them meet
with our students and to show them the
great work that we're doing and we also
emphasize to them that we need more
federal and state assistance to reach
our long-term strategic goals
today UMES is the only HBCU offering
eight health profession programs
producing graduates to combat the health
care disparities that exist in Rural and
medically underserved areas throughout
the
country and I am very excited to add
that we are now embarking on
establishing a veterinary medicine
program which will only be the second
such program at an HBCU in the country
it will address an area where there is
sign significant Marketplace ntion
shortage of qualified
professionals let me speak briefly about
some of the work in the food and
agriculture space that we're doing and
please understand we could not do
anything that we without the support
that is provided under the title seven
of the farm
bill we conduct highly impactful
research and extension programs funded
through the Evans Allen agricultural
research and the 1890 extension programs
of the farm bill
and I am so grateful to Governor Wes
Moore and the Maryland legislature who
for the first time provided a full match
toes in
2023 our work targets critical issues
with local Regional National and Global
dimension for UMES important F focal
areas include poultry and seafood which
are major Local Economic drivers for our
region safeguarding the Chesapeake
Watershed which is critically important
for Six States and the District of
Colombia and an important component of
our work excuse me addresses issues that
impact underserved farmers and
communities of course we are also using
these funds to invest in our most
valuable research Resource as I told you
earlier our our
students these are the people who are
researching climate change these are the
people working to fill the demand for
scientists teachers researchers and
Healthcare
Providers these are the people who can
help this country soar above and
beyond investments in 1890 universities
bear tremendous dividends when states
provide a full match of the federal
Appropriations this increases the scope
of impact through various research
extension and Workforce Development
programs help us get the states to keep
their historic commitment to the 1890
land grants all we're asking for is
equal treatment our students have been
running a race in Lane 8 for too long
while their peers at 1862 land grants
have had the inside track invest in us
and I promise that you'll get a sizable
return on your
investment thank you chairman for
allowing me to have a few take a few
moments to share with you about our
story glad to be here today thank you so
much for having me and giving me this
opportunity to talk about this important
issue and share some research with you I
am going to share my
screen um so um the landr university
system as we all know is a very
important um
historic aspect of the US higher
education system I think in a lot of
ways it epitomizes the Democratic
promise of higher education um there are
three types of land grant universities
1862 institutions 1890s and
1994sep go a little fast through some of
the um introductory material since I'm
sure many of you are are aware um but I
think it's important to highlight the
way the historical Mission continues to
be carried out um so they're a network
of public universities located in every
state every territory in the district of
Colombia they undertake a three-part
Mission teaching research and service
which is carried out through their
extension services um they were
established in the 19th century to
provide educ ation to the working
classes and spur the economic growth of
the nation through Agricultural and
Industrial
Research um today this Mission continues
through offering um high high quality
affordable education from students to
students from across the socioeconomic
spectrum and they offer comprehensive
education so you can live anywhere in
the country and get a great education in
any subject and that's due to our land
grant University system system um
they're also High research producing
institutions in agriculture stem and
other fields and um they are an
important part of our economy and our
knowledge landscape um and they extend
their benefits extend their local
communities um they share the benefits
of their staff knowledge with
surrounding regions um by offering
community service programs through
extension um there are 18 1890s
universities or sorry 19 1890s
universities located in 18 states so
there are two in Alabama tuskeegee and
Alabama
A&M um and they were um the second moral
act um was uh part um they were
established the second moral act which
also provided funding to all land grant
universities and um so this act required
that any institution um that received
federal funds through the mo through the
moral act um was not able to
discriminate in their on the basis of
race and their admissions um but it
allowed the creation of a separate
Institution for African-Americans to um
com count as compliance with this act um
but I pull up this text because I think
it's important to note that um it's very
clear and its intent ion um to have
you'll see some of these highlighted um
pieces you know it asks for a just and
Equitable division of funds of the funds
to be received under this act to be
divided between the two colleges you
know it says divided into two parts um
and paid accordingly and again I think
this blue highlighted part is very
explicit about the spirit of this of
this act um such an institution for
color students shall be entitled to the
benefits of this act and subject to its
Provisions as much as it would have been
had it been included under the act of
1862 so that's why when we're talking
about the range of disparities that
HBCU um face in relation to their pwi
counterparts um the ones in the farm
bill the ones really um related to the
history of the moral act um they really
have this legal founding basis where
they they should be funded equitably um
there are a range of reasons um and
sources of underfunding at the state
level but I think that um and the
federal level but I think the ones
related to the moral act and some of the
research and extension programs I'll
talk a little bit more about today um
have the clearest basis so in a way
they're loow hanging fruit although um
as we saw in in the Department's
presentation they are not the biggest
piece of the puzzle in terms of absolute
numbers but that we should think of that
as a ceiling and not a floor for
States um so even though the second
moral act asked for this um just
inequitable dis distribution of funding
um that was not the case over the course
of the um late 19th and 20th centuries
um as one historian writes uh funding
for these institutions was very low and
inequitable in comparison to the white
land grant colleges um in many instances
you know was sources of private funds
churches uh philanthropist Foundation
that supported um both public and
private
HBCU um and I think another thing that's
important to mention um when looking
this far back in history is that um you
know this isn't money that was just
spent by the states over the course of
time it was invested and Investments
grow so a lack of investment over time
is very challenging to account for and
to think about what would have happened
if um an institution had the fac you
know the money to build a new research
facility and attract great F attract
great faculty produce a record of
Publications attract more research
funding if they'd had dorms to attract C
the student um to attract more students
if they um had money to invest in
endowments to grow over time um so the
scale of this Gap um when we look this
far back is um a kind of historical and
accounting challenge of its
own um so yeah I think 18 so land grant
institutions are known for um their
research and extension work in
agriculture and other fields um I think
it's worth uh differentiating there are
a couple important types of of Grant
programs there are what are sometimes
called capacity grants um so what
distinguishes is those is their formula
funded um so they are guaranteed pretty
much every year to institutions um and
then they are distributed proportionally
to to States depending on their farm and
Rural populations um so oftentimes when
we're talking about the state match
we're generally talking about capacity
grants and those can be for research or
extension um and then there are also a
range of competitive Grant programs for
which all institutions can apply um and
I think yeah the matching issues um play
less of a role with those um but they do
tend to be smaller overall so capacity
grants are really what allow
institutions to build capacity and grow
over time um and have you know be able
to plan 10 years or 20 years into the
future and build a research program
based on
that um so I'm not going to go through
all of this but I just wanted to give
you a sense of you know thinking about
some of the primary work that these
institutions do through research and
extension how it was supported by the
federal government over time um and
you'll see that even before um the 1890s
were founded the um 1862 institutions
received research funding um which
established the state state experiment
stations during the um hat with the 1887
Hatch Act um and then beginning with 194
in 1914 with the Smith Smith lever act
um 1862 institutions uh began receiving
extension funding um which included a
match
requirements so yeah you can see that it
really wasn't until you know about 90
years after they're founding that um the
1890 institutions began to receive this
guaranteed capacity funding um from the
federal
government you know on this formula
basis
um so what is this what do the
disparities in federal capacity funding
look like today um so this data is from
fiscal year 2022 so you can see the um
and these are all farm bill funded um
programs administered by the USDA um so
you can see that on a per institution
basis um 1890 institutions still lag
behind pretty significantly in the
federal grants that they um are awarded
um and again these are all capacity
grants um which make up the um more of
the federal funding but there are Capac
there are also competitive grants which
vary year over-year in terms of who who
receives
them um so we have this issue of State
matching funds in the waiver which is um
you know can be thorny um I'm sure many
of you in the audience are familiar with
some of these questions but but um so I
won't
get I won't get super into depth but um
essentially as it's been covered for the
capacity programs um the states are
required to provide an equal matching
fund to the federal allocation um and if
for some reason they don't or they're
not able to then the institution would
potentially have to foro their Federal
funding um so and these usually come
from State
Appropriations um however for 1890
institutions the secretary of
agriculture can wave up to 50% of the
required State match for the 1890
institutions um and it's a little bit of
a tricky complicated issue because on
one hand um say if a state were not did
not allocate um up to 100% um this
allows the institution to still rece
receive 100% of its federal funds um so
you know questions about oh should we
just entirely get rid of the waiver um
could could potentially have a negative
impact um also I see I'm pretty far over
time so I'm going to go a little faster
and leave more of this for questions um
but yeah and I'm going to provide this
document as a resource for anyone so
this information you can look back at
and I won't go through all the details
but was there always a state match for
1990s uh no initially there was not um
it um started at 30% went up to 50% uh
the waiver went in and out um but now
since 2002 um we've been in the
situation that we're in now um how much
has this accounted for um in the past
five years across the six to nine
institutions that did not receive their
full match each year um this accounted
for over $90
million um
okay
yes um
yeah and what does and I think yeah so
on one hand maybe the waiver you might
say well you know maybe it's a matter of
of financial need um but I think when we
look by comparison to the money that
states allocate
to um to their 1862 institutions we see
that um you know they they have the
funds to invest in their predominantly
white 1862
institutions um and it's it's not it's
not close you know it's not a matter of
um 1.2 or 1.3 you know it's a matter of
many times over um so it's yeah it makes
us ask about you know where where are
states choosing to build and invest
which
communities
um so I have some recommendations um for
ways that we could address this um I
recommend um creating a joint matching
funds process so any um waved funds are
split proportionally between the two
institutions um this would result in the
1862 1862 institution losing a bit more
um so if you see my example at the
bottom of this slide with Texas um you
know the 1862 institutions do tend to be
bigger so they get more more funding um
so 20% for the 1862 would be a larger
number in absolute dollar amounts um so
I believe this would disincentivize
States from underfunding their 1890
institutions um and also there are
already so many ways that the 1862 and
1890s work together
cooperatively so this would be another
way in which um you know the State
University system would be supporting
itself and sharing its resources more
equitably um so I'm over time so I'm
going to pause this there um and let our
conversation go into recommendations but
I think there's um some Farm Bill
related things that um we can look to to
improve this um uh I came out with a
report this July which goes into these
in more detail um there are other
programs that benefit HBCU and students
who tend to um attend HBCU that can um
that would be a benefit and could help
address some of these problems um and
then yeah I think the state level is one
of the more complex ones um so as as the
department showed you know we have
Federal data going back to 1987 but
that's you know these institutions had
been around for almost a hundred years
at that point so finding and
understanding the full scope of this Gap
is very challenging um so I would look
to um what they did in Tennessee
recently uh representative state
representative Harold love um LED this
effort to do a full accounting
of what the historical Gap had been and
I think that is a place to start for
many schools and to really strive for
Equitable per state annual allocations
to make large scale investments in
infrastructure you know these are public
institutions that serve the students of
the states and um their an investment
that um will benefit everybody um so
some additional sources in Reading I
will definitely share this because I
know it a lot of information apologies
for going over and I look forward to
your questions well let's let's uh go to
questions and we had one question uh Dr
Anderson can you share more about what
it took for you to finally receive your
full match uh from the state of Maryland
thank you Congressman Scott I'll be
happy to um we received our full match
as I said last year for the first time I
arrived here in since uh 2018 and along
with my government Affairs director uh m
m Mr Jim maias we have been going back
and forth to Annapolis to explain and to
share with our Maryland legislators all
about our University what we're doing
here and the deficiency in the two in
the in the match so for the last several
years we have been making that track
right back and forth across the bay and
we were pleased like I said this past
year that they went ahead and solved the
need to give us full funding you'll
notice on the slide that Sarah had
presented that in 2020 in 2018 in 2022
we requested a waiver and we got the
waiver and so some years as I said we
were able to get waivers and uh handle
the match that way and other years we
did not get any and so last year was our
full first year funding of course this
year 2024 um legislative session we'll
be back over again and trying to make
sure that our delegates recognize this
should continue in perpetuity so we
don't have to go back and forth not that
we don't like driving that way but you
know it's now was Marilyn e Shore part
of the settlement last year that Morgan
State was involved yes yes Congressman
we were part of the settlement but the
settlement the $577 million settlement
that is split among our four
institutions does not include the
matching at all for our HBCU 1890
status uh but you got so what did you
what did you um what did you get yes our
that settlement comes in our equated to
rment so our portion of that is about 9
million nine yes nine out of 500 out of
577
million okay uh now all of the
19
um HBCU are all public uh institutions
is that right that is correct
Congressman okay and
um let me see we have another another
question Sarah in your research could
you say uh what
um what what you did in Tennessee to get
to get better
funding yeah absolutely um so this was
not something that I was involved in but
um yeah essentially representative
Harold love uh worked on this issue for
a long time and actually his father was
a representative in the same seat in the
Tennessee legislature and they're both
uh TSU grads and um his father had also
worked on the same issue when he was a
representative and it was in the wake of
the 2020 BLM protests I think um the
state was asking you know how they could
do better by their black
constituents and you know they said you
know we really need to address this
underfunding issue for TSU so they
formed a committee to do an auditing um
so it required going into historical
state budget records you know these
things are not online they're in Dusty
warehouses um and tried to come um come
up with you know a full accounting of
what that Gap really looks like and then
in response to that the Tennessee state
legislature made a large um
appropriation in its budget the next
year um so this might have been
2022 2021 um and I want to say it was on
the order of 400 million so
um yeah that I think that large scale
investment is ultimately the type of
thing that one would need to see um so
yeah that route um I think is yeah
working within the state legislature and
then other states have done it through
lawsuits um which can have you know take
a long time and be a varying success so
I think um yeah the route that Tennessee
took is absolutely one to to learn
from okay um and and um have you learned
more about why
states did not fund 1990s the same level
of
1962's yeah again I probably only an
extent to which I can speak to that um I
would say one element of it is
absolutely you know pride in their 1862
um many of them are their state Flagship
institutions you know a desire to
provide a great
education to and you know build the
economy of of their regions um but I
think in in the process um the HBCU
which were meant to be you know received
this just inequitable distribution of
funds unfortunately did not receive
receive the same attention um so yeah
it's undeniable that there's a history
of discrimination there and um there are
yeah complexities to it you know but I
think the fitting within the pattern of
not investing in um institutions that
serve black students is the
commonality okay and another question
considering
large uh the larger discussion relies on
governance um particularly during
complex political times to create
Equitable structures qu legislative and
policy recommendations would you offer
to bring about parity in capacity grant
funding between the hbcus and PWS to
address the historical disinvestments uh
discussed throughout this present
yeah thanks for this question um so I
think on the federal level
um you know I recommend the joint waiver
process um I recommend uh research and
infrastructure investments in the 1890
institutions so they can really try to
close some of those gaps and be more
competitive for uh both Federal and
private grants and contracts um and then
there are a range of other Great Farm
Bill programs that support them um you
know capacity building grants centers of
excellence at 1890 institutions you know
help them specialize and lead in in in
demand Fields uh scholarships for
students at
1890s um and then yeah then there are
non-farm Bill programs that also support
HBCU that are important um you know
title 3 funding um post-secondary
Student Success grants um to support to
include um student support and
wraparound
Services um and and but yes specific to
capacity grant funding yeah I would say
the infrastructure Investments and um
adjust addressing the matching
requirements I think are the biggest
things and I would I would agree with
Sarah I think the infrastructure and the
matching but also the centers of
excellence that you mentioned Sarah
these are also critical areas that I
think will be helpful and especially if
they're reauthorized in the farm bill
act that is longer than just a one year
that is being proposed it must it must
be
longer um
that's getting to one of the next
question I had most of the solutions
that we've discussed are the state level
what um can we um do on the federal
level to make sure that the problem
doesn't persist in the
future and that that you you alluded to
the farm
bill as um as as one target to make sure
the funding is in the farm bill for the
um for for all of the land grant
colleges Congressman I think that is one
place to start making sure that our farm
bill is approp is given the full
appropriated amount and that that is
really shared among the states as you
said or as we say earlier this only
we're talking 18 institutions in 19
different states we also have to throw
put uh Tuskegee in there Tuskegee is a
private and public h89 institution and
so they should be considered among this
as well but that would be one place to
start recognizing that this is an
investment in those States in those
institutions it is an investment in the
workforce in those states it is an
investment in Economic Development
within those States and as I share with
you in my opening remarks it is
investment in those students who go on
to become taxpayers in those particular
States and that can reap benefits for
all of
us
