New Case Study! We are looking at a married couple living in NY, 40 years old with 3 kids trying to live a comfortable life, help pay for college, and retire in their early 60's.
We talk cash flow, investment management, emergency funds, net worth statements, college savings, and much more!
School of Personal Finance is an Investment Advisor registered with the State(s) of New York. All views, expressions, and opinions included in this communication are subject to change. This communication is not intended as an offer or solicitation to buy, hold or sell any financial instrument or investment advisory services. Any information provided has been obtained from sources considered reliable, but we do not guarantee the accuracy, or the completeness of, any description of securities, markets or developments mentioned. We may, from time to time, have a position in the securities mentioned and may execute transactions that may not be consistent with this communication's conclusions. Please contact us at 914-299-3843 if there is any change in your financial situation, needs, goals or objectives, or if you wish to initiate any restrictions on the management of the account or modify existing restrictions. Additionally, we recommend you compare any account reports from SPF with the account statements from your Custodian. Please notify us if you do not receive statements from your Custodian on at least a quarterly basis. Our current disclosure brochure, Form ADV Part 2, is available for your review upon request, and on our website, www.schoolofpersonalfinance.com. This disclosure brochure, or a summary of material changes made, is also provided to our clients on an annual basis.
hey what's up everyone and welcome to
the school of personal finance so this
week I'm getting back to doing a case
study so in this example I'm going to
have a married couple in their early 40s
with three children all right they make
a decent income they live in a high cost
of living area just trying to figure
everything out right new cars saving for
kids college saving for retirement would
like to retire on the earlier side if
possible but they have a lot of
headwinds all right let's get to it
[Music]
all right so real quick before we start
head over to school ofpersonal
finance.com check out everything I've
going on over there sign up for my
newsletter I'm rolling out digital
courses personal finance 101 for high
school and college kids I'm doing some
more advanced courses I'm doing master
your family's finances in 30 days and I
am also offering what's called first
step step to Financial Freedom where we
work oneon-one together over the course
of a few months having three Zoom calls
to create your own financial plan so
come check it all out school ofpersonal
finance.com all right so let's jump into
right Capital here now we always start
on the profile page with net worth so
anytime we're building out a financial
plan we need to be able to look at the
entire picture so building out a net
worth statement is the number one
priority all right so we start out with
bank accounts so that's checking savings
accounts now for this example I named
them Rich and Karen so you know my
wife's name is Karen I figured that that
would uh make it easy um so we have
5,000 in checking 5,000 in savings so
they have $10,000 in the bank right now
and they currently owe $8,000 on a
credit card um I believe that they pay
this thing off let me just change this
that they do pay this in full every
month so maybe they got some paychecks
hitting soon but um they do not carry a
balance on that credit card all right
then if we look at their investment
accounts so rich he currently works for
mercedesbenz and he makes um I think he
makes
$110,000 a year there but we'll look at
that in the income section but for his
401k he currently has 284,000 bucks in
there which is nice and it's all
invested in this Vanguard Target
retirement fund 2055 fund and then Karen
she is a teacher she's done a very good
job saving in her
403b we will actually name this
403b right here and she has 38 Grand in
there so it's a combination of the
Vanguard Total stock market index fund
and also the Vanguard Total Bond market
index fund all right and those are the
only investment accounts they have so
now beyond that they have three children
and they have a 529 plan for each child
so you could see for their son who's the
oldest then their daughter and then
their youngest daughter all right so
that's their investment account so a
total of 690 Grand so not bad now each
of them we'll go look at the family
layout but each of them are 40 years old
so Rich and Karen are both 40 years old
all right no stock plans no uh stock
options or anything like that um let's
jump down to property so their primary
home is worth $600,000 right now and you
know as said as it is where I live a
$600,000 house um they're just not uh
what they used to be right the prices of
homes have exploded Over The Last 5
Years basically um so they bought this
house for
$400,000 and now it's worth 600 so 600
it still gets you a nice house but um
not not what it not what it used to buy
you property taxes $111,000 a year which
here in New York is uh is crazy but true
um and then you know I've seen them much
higher than that as well homeowners
insurance 2,000 bucks a year so now the
mortgage they only have a 250 $5,000
mortgage on the property so it started
out as 320 they've been paying it off uh
monthly payments 17 18 per month they
have a 30-year fixed rate mortgage at
5% all right so now we'll quickly look
at insurance so rich has term life
insurance $1.5
million it uh the term ends in
2040 all right Karen is 100% beneficiary
Karen doesn't have any private life
insurance she has she's a teacher so she
has three times her salary as a group
benefit so
$270,000 is her life insurance then they
have homeowners to have an umbrella
policy as well so in the nutshell that
is their net worth statement so total
net worth is a million bucks and you
know my first thoughts are this is
pretty damn good you know they're
looking pretty good they're doing well
saving for retirement saving for college
they have no debt besides their mortgage
which is nice um the reason they don't
have car car loans is because they both
lease their cars so both of them do have
leases on their cars which um if you
watch any of my content you know that I
am not a fan of leasing cars I think
that's a terrible idea it is by far the
most expensive way to own cars unless
you're you know really well off and you
don't really care you just want to have
a nice new car every two or three years
then you know then that's fine but um if
you're not in that situation then
leasing a car is just way too expensive
uh bank accounts you know 10,000 bucks
that would make me nervous so I would
question why do they not have more of an
emergency fund so we'll look at cash
flow as well and see what the deal is
there but out of everything that jumps
out at me you know I want to start uh I
mean obviously this credit card has to
be zero every month right you got to pay
it off in full every month so it's fine
to use it and run it up as long as
you're paying it off in full by the
statement cycle so you're not carrying
the balance not paying any interest um
so as long as they're doing that that's
cool but if you subtract that from the
cash they have it leaves them with
basically no cash so priority number one
to me would be we need to build up an
emergency fund um you know we'd have a
conversation around that and see what is
a happy number I usually think it's
somewhere in the ballpark of 20 to
30,000 bucks you know is a number that
makes me sleep well at night knowing
that that is just sitting in the bank
and as inflation has taken hold and uh
the cost of everything has gone up you
know I'm closer to that $30,000 range
rather than the $20,000 range all right
so I'm just going to speed through this
because I don't want this video to take
uh you know a half hour all right so
this is where we enter goals so like
retirement goals age 62 retirement
expenses that's how much they'd like to
be able to spend every month in
retirement um that's on top of any other
expenses that we've already accounted
for so like if their mortgage is still
going to continue into retirement then
that would be included on top of this
$5,000 a month then we have health care
so now this Healthcare it might be off
if she's a teacher and maybe she gets
Healthcare in retirement where only uh
the only cost they would have would be
MediCare at 65 when they both go on
Medicare they have the uh the part B
premiums and then we have college goals
so you can see see here their college
goals it's not a tremendous amount of
money so if we click in on here you know
they uh were using a national average
for a public school in state and they
have their kids borrowing some of the
cost so basically they're taking on you
know a little more than 2third and the
child is taking on a little less than a
third of the cost of college all right
and that's for all three children then
they have a $5,000 vacation goal each
year um for their daughter's wedding so
they have two girls they want to start
planning for paying for wedd weddings so
we have a you know a goal of 40,000
bucks to start saving for that in the
future right I add I added this
emergency fund of 30,000 bucks and then
they have this goal in retirement they
want to be able to travel the world for
a few years so we're doing $30,000 a
year for four consecutive years right so
when they both retire we call those uh
the go- go years so they want to be able
to go and party during the go- go years
and four years that's not a long time of
go go years they'll have more years than
that but they want to take four years to
really really spend it up and go travel
and see the world all right so those are
our goals so income so richest salar is
110 Ken is 90 so between the two of them
they're making 200 Grand a year and
we're using a 3% inflation kicker in
here so it goes up by 3% every year then
we have social security each of them
planning on taking it at their full
retirement age then because Karen's a
teacher she gets a pension so we're
guesstimating that her pension will be
around $60,000 a year once she retires
so for savings they're each doing 5%
into their retirement plans and they're
contributing
$3,000 per child into 529 plans so now
Rich he gets a match on his 401k it's 3%
so it's 100% up to the first 3% and for
Karen's 403b that one there is no match
um in the 403b world for New York state
public
teachers all right so that's all these
savings that they're doing right
now expenses so Life currently costs
them $7,000 a month to live again not
including things we've already accounted
for so like their mortgage and their
taxes and insurance that we saw on that
net worth page that is above and beyond
the 7,000 and I'll show you where it all
comes together where we could see you
know break it down to a monthly amount
but these monthly expenses you know this
is in addition to their mortgage and
their taxes and insurance
all right and then we just take a quick
look at the family right so Rich and
Karen they're both 40 then their son is
13 their daughter is 10 and the youngest
daughter is six years
old all right so let's start let's look
at this uh investment tab so for their
investment accounts right it gives us a
nice little pie chart here so 86% stock
14% bond which in my mind sounds pretty
good right even if we look at like
Rich's 401K alone this is a little bit
more aggressive this is is in that
Target date retirement fund the 2055
fund right for Karen I think it's
actually uh that's about the same
8614 right she owns that Vanguard Total
Bond market fund in there as well and
then we got the 529 plans so everything
looks pretty good there right target
we'll say aggressive 8020 right in that
range and as we run retirement plans um
we do what's called a Glide path so as
they get older as they approach
retirement the allocation automatically
gets more conservative cuz that's
realistic you know they're not going to
be in an 85 15 portfolio their entire
lives when they retire it might look
more like 6040 somewhere in that range
all right so the software is able to
account for that by using a Glide path
over time and one thing I always like to
look at in here is the tax
allocation so with the tax allocation
you know I talk about tax buckets all
the time and next week I'm actually
doing a video on year-end Tax Strategies
where I talk about tax
diversification so that'll be uh a week
from tomorrow tomorrow that I'm going to
post that video but as you can see here
all of their retirement money it is in
these tax deferred accounts the 403b and
the 401K so this is all going to be
taxed when they take it out in
retirement they don't have any Roth
money they don't have any taxable
brokerage accounts all of it is is in
tax deferred so we call this a a ticking
tax time bomb right because once they're
retired they're going to have Ken
pension they'll have social security and
then they're going to have to start
taking distributions from this and it's
all going to be taxable I don't love
having that going into retirement I
would much rather have a nice bucket of
Roth money where it's going to be
taxfree in retirement and also some
brokerage accounts as well you know
after tax money that you could pull on
that aren't tied to a retirement date
that you have access to before that
where you have capital gains and things
like that this taxfree asset those are
the kids 529 plans because those are
going to come out taxfree so this is
another uh you know point for me that
kind of sticks out that I'd like to see
some changes with all right let's get
into the meat of the retirement planning
aspect of it so if you're not familiar
with right Capital right this is what's
called a Monte Carlo simulation so with
the Monte Carlo simulation the system it
runs a thousand different
scenarios and it shows what is the
probability of success and the
definition of the probability of success
is that you do not run out of money by
the end of plan so for each of them the
end of plan is age 90 all right so they
have in this scenario they have 100%
probability of success meaning there is
no environment where they run out of
money before age 90 which is great right
we want to see 100% now I don't put
everything into these probability of
successes I use it as a guardrail right
so yes I'm happy that it says 100% but
even if it said 50% there are things
that we might be able to tweak there's
moves we might be able to make um it's
not like if it is not at 100% that means
that you're going to fail in retirement
right A lot of times if you're 80% or
better they ways that we could tweak it
ways that we could work it um that you
know you're going to be fine in
retirement and there's a lot of unknown
so anytime you do a retirement plan it's
like you know if you're 40 years old
doing a retirement plan so much is going
to change in your life between now and
retirement that you can't account for it
all right so retirement planning you
know I always refer to it as like a
living breathing document it's something
that is always changing with the times
and life throws throws curveballs at you
so you can't plan for everything you
just don't know what's going to happen
in the future but with all that said
it's good to see 100% this $10 million
Mark over here I mean that's nice number
as well that is the median amount after
all the simulations that they are left
with at the end of their lives at the
end of plan so you know this is all
looking pretty Rosy right now as we um
as we look at this so now current plan
this is based on all the data that we
just went over so their incomes how much
they're saving how much they have in the
bank all of that right that's where they
get this current plan proposed plan is
if we want to make changes right so say
for example Karen's like you know what
I'm miserable I want to get the hell out
of here and then Rich is like well if
she wants to get out of there I ain't
going until 62 maybe I'll go to 58 right
so if we change these retirement ages
down how does that impact our plan so if
we go back up we could see I mean it's
still you know if if I was working with
these clients like my initial thought
would be it's doable if that's something
that you really want to do it might take
some sacrifice right there's definitely
more risk in retiring early maybe you
could add uh another small part-time job
when you're retired do something that
you love that you're passionate about
and bring in a little bit extra income
but I think it would totally be feasible
right so what if they said you know what
I'd also like to be able to spend more
in retirement as well I want to retire
early and I want to spend more right now
we're going to start seeing this drop
right so now we're getting into a risky
Zone where I would be like you know that
that uh that might be pretty hard to
pull off all right so that is what the
proposed plan means what we're changing
in here from their current situation all
right so I'm going to go back ahead and
reset these let's go to 60 62 62 and
then 5,000 and we will hit
refresh all right one other tab that I
love to look at is savings right so I
like to look at savings rates all right
so for this year so they're making
$200,000 and they're going to be saving
26,588 so that is
13.3% would be consider their savings
rate so I use as a rule of thumb if you
could have a 20% savings rate that is
awesome that would be a good good place
to be where you're saving 20% of your
gross income all right so we can see in
their retirement account they were each
doing 5% that would be 10,000 plus Rich
gets the employer match that's where we
get up to this 133 right the kids 529
plans this is that 9,000 and then
whatever excess cash flow they have left
we're dumping into a taxable brokerage
account all right and they're not
currently doing this but after working
with me that's what they would be doing
right because if we run the numbers and
we see that they do have excess cash
flow we got to give that money a job
we're not going to just let it uh you
know wither away so the job that I would
give it in this instant and maybe we
would put other goals in place that
would be different but the system
defaults to any excess cash flow to
going into a taxable account all right
so savings rate that is a big piece of
what I'm looking at all right so after
that let's start looking at the cash
flows all right so this is like a nice
uh nice visual right here it just breaks
everything down down for the current
year as far as their cash flow goes so
like salary so total inflow is 200 Grand
and then we see where it goes so their
living expenses all right then we have
their goals so the goals this is the
$5,000 vacation goal we have their tax
payments federal state FICA we have
their planned savings so we have the
401K and the 529 plan and then we have
the net cash flow that we're saving in
that taxable brokerage account that
4,281 and for their living expenses we
can see how it's broken down all right
we have the $7,000 a month living
expenses that we put in there then we
have their housing expense which is
their mortgage the principal interest
the taxes and insurance and then we have
that $8,000 credit card bill that they
need to wipe out of there all right so
this gives a current year and then here
we could scroll forward to Future years
which is pretty cool but I really do
love using this summary table all right
so this gives us all years into the
future and it lets us uh really look out
and get a good idea
of what's going on all right so we can
see each age right so we're starting
because we're at the end of 2023 right
now we're starting with 2024 so they'll
both be 21 I'm I'm sorry they'll both be
41 they have $200,000 of income we could
see their expenses right so it's all
that other data just in the tabular form
here tax payments the plan savings total
outflow so we can see this is the net
cash that's left over so for these net
flows we'd have to have a discussion you
know do they actually see these net
flows in their bank accounts are they
actually saving that money each year or
are we just off on the monthly expenses
that we're estimating so a very
important piece to creating these plans
is you have to have tight numbers with
your expenses because you could be off
you know life is crazy right and one
month to the next your expenses change
so it's very hard to really dial in on
that like I love using software right
Capital itself has a great budget tool
that I personally use other apps out
there like mint recently is uh you know
they were taken over and now mint is
going away which kind of sucks uh
personal Capital has a budget tool um I
think there are a couple other ones that
are becoming popular Monarch money I
believe is another one I haven't checked
it out but um but I love using apps and
Technology to be able to track my
spending so I know exactly how much life
costs me every month all right but you
want to have that number as close as
possible because it makes a huge
difference right if we were off if they
really spend $88,000 a month and we put
$7,000 in there then this number would
be negative right they'd have negative
cash flow this year that basically would
wipe out the cash flow in each of these
years if we were $1,000 a month off on
their expenses so that part of it is
very important all right so as we go
through here we can see their goals and
how it changes in the future so in 2028
that's when their Sun starts going to
college right and then this distribution
this is coming out of the 529 plan all
right so they have a goal for vacation
in here and then the rest of the goal is
um is college so if I click on this
we'll see it right we got education and
then we got the vacation goal so this
24,000
237 that is being distributed from their
529 plan all right so this is a net
worth tab so we could look at net worth
throughout the future into the future
years you can see I mean the net worth
it Dr it grows you know dramatically
over time um even with their primary
residence right we can see their
mortgage it gets paid off here in
2042 is the last year that they have
their mortgage um you have to remember
you know inflation plays a big part of
this so in 2042 basically 20 years from
now the cost of living you know it's
probably going to be double what it is
today if we have a you know a 4%
inflation rate than um the cost of
living it's going to be much higher than
it is right
now all right so back to the summary
overall so as we scroll through we could
see that they have positive cash flow
going all the way through right they're
income is good their income is growing
everything's going uh the way that they
want it to their expenses are staying
you know significantly under their
income with everything even with you
know the high taxes that they're paying
their goals um their plan savings right
there's still cash flow positive in
these years to the tune of40 plus th000
per year that they could go ahead and
Save in different types of accounts and
then retirement year so this $60,000
right they both turned 62 they both
retire 2045 this $60,000 right here that
is Karen's pension so that's the only
income that they have right there right
so their net flows they're big time
negative right so they need to pull
money from their investment Accounts at
this point while they're building a
bridge to Social Security right before
before they are able to start taking
social security but at this point in
2045 if they continue to save the way
that they are right we could take a look
at 2045 you know what let's actually do
which one would we write let's go
accounts so in
2045 they would have saved over
$700,000 in a taxable brokerage account
just from that excess cash flow being
saved every year and between the 401K
and the 403b it would grow to $3.8
million so now is that realistic right
it is if they continue to save at that
clip they leave their money invested for
growth all right because we're using a
pretty aggressive allocation with them
so probably using an average rate of
return right around 8% for these
retirement accounts you know and like I
said before as they get older we're
using lower and lower rates of return
but all the way leading up to retirement
we're probably using in the range of an
8% return maybe dialing it down to about
7% when we get to this point so they
have $3.8 million in these retirement
accounts and they have
$777,000 in their taxable brokerage
account so this is the year
245 so in that year right where they're
retired it's not that big of a deal for
them to pull this money from their
taxable brokerage account they don't
even need to take distributions from the
retirement Accounts at that point and
then at 67 is when they turn social
security on so now if we click on income
in the year
2050 right we have social security
between the two of them
$122,000 and the $60,000 pension and
then at age 75 when they're required to
take money from those tax deferred
accounts right this is the ticking tax
bomb that we were talking about before
they're rmd they're required minimum
distribution
$321,000 that they have to take and they
don't really need the money right so you
can see how much they owe in taxes that
year and really every year going forward
because they're going to have to
continue taking these required
distributions from the 401K and the the
403b but now they have all this net cash
flow that they're basically just going
to reinvest in taxable brokerage
accounts all right so as we go and look
through this you know I know right away
that they are on a very solid Financial
footing right is there anything that
could really blow them up in this type
of plan and I really don't see it you
know like if Rich loses his job that
could be one thing that could really
blow them up um but Karen is a teacher
so her job is very secure right not much
risk of her losing her job maybe she'll
want to retire earlier than planned but
as we looked before that very well could
be a possibility so overall everything
is looking great um I'll show you the
education tab real quick and then I'll
just talk about recommendations we'll
wrap wrap this thing up but we could
look at 529 you know the savings for
each of them so like their son he
currently has a balance of $43,000 in
the 529 and they're adding $3,000 a year
as well so with that the education cost
right 27,9 40 per year that they want to
to um that they want him to go to a
state school right who knows if that's
how it will play out and they're going
to be paying about $20,000 a year so we
could actually look at the details of
that so if we go for Education cost for
sun right here is the actual cost each
year there Sun borrowing some money the
net cost of what they're going to be
contributing we could look at the
529 so they continue to add right
they're assuming a rate of return on
there where the portfolio is growing and
then we have the withdrawals here so
they actually have you know have it in
here where they're contributing um a
little bit too long which would be fine
because they would be able to just
change the beneficiary on this and move
it into one of the girls 529 plans so
it's easy using the software to also
plan for college all right so let's go
back to the profile and we'll wrap this
up so as far as recommendations go off
the top of my head for them right
emergency fund so any excess cash that
they have right now we need to just plow
away in an emergency fund and let's have
a goal of getting that to $30,000 all
right you set it you you send it
somewhere and you don't worry about it
anymore you open up a high yield savings
account an online bank a place like I
personally use wealth front or
betterment is another good one Sofi
Capital One all of those are popular
online banks that have competitive
interest rates right now in the money
safe and secure FDIC insured and it just
sits there for when you have the
emergency another thing that I would
love to see them do and I would probably
prioritize this over the taxable
brokerage account and that would be both
of them doing Roth
each year so they're under the income
limitations where they could both
contribute and max out Roth IRAs so that
would be a big priority for me I would
love to see them start saving for
retirement through Roth accounts and
they're not in a very high tax bracket
right so even doing Roth 401k
contributions is something that I would
have a conversation with Rich around if
that makes sense and I think it would
right because right now they have a lot
of money in those pre-tax buckets we got
to start building that Roth bucket out
out so those would be my big
recommendations you know as far as the
insurance stuff we didn't jump too deep
into that but Rich he had a nice big
Term Policy Karen she might not she
might not have enough and it might be
good to get a private policy on top of
that so maybe a 20y year 15year term
somewhere in that range would be good
maybe in the to the tune of
$750,000 or so in case God forbid
something happened to her at least Rich
would get a million bucks and be able to
uh you know take some time off work
whatever it is he needs to do be able to
kids pay for the kids College maybe pay
off the mortgage and not have to stress
about money at that point so that would
be an important piece to it to just make
sure that they both have enough
insurance but as far as the game plan
goes you know they're doing everything
great I would just love to see them
emergency fund taxable brokerage account
Roth account and start you know piling
money away in those we didn't talk about
an HSA at all in this video I think
they're under Karen's health insurance
through the school district which is
very good and they don't have an HSA
option so they're just sticking with a
regular po type of plan and not
contributing to to an HSA but um I know
I went through a lot in this video and I
went fast so uh so I don't know if this
is one that you could watch on one and a
half speed cuz I was talking faster the
whole way through but I just wanted to
bang through a lot of stuff hopefully
you found this one helpful um if you
want me to do a case study based on your
general information I don't want to know
specifics um but your general
information you know email me we could
even set up like an outline this is what
I used to do with people i' send them a
little outline to fill in and then we go
ahead and plug it in and I don't use
your real names or anything like that um
and then uh you know we do like a a
little case study on it again obviously
none of it is financial advice right I'm
just going off general information just
for educational purposes only but I hope
you found this one helpful and um and
yeah I'm going to get back to doing
these hopefully you know once every two
weeks or so is the plan right now and
kind of mix them in with my weekly video
as well so all right I will see you
again in the next one thanks