Spokesperson Matthew Miller leads the Department Press Briefing, at the Department of State, on November 13, 2023.
---------- Under the leadership of the President and Secretary of State, the U.S. Department of State leads America’s foreign policy through diplomacy, advocacy, and assistance by advancing the interests of the American people, their safety and economic prosperity. On behalf of the American people we promote and demonstrate democratic values and advance a free, peaceful, and prosperous world.
The Secretary of State, appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate, is the President's chief foreign affairs adviser. The Secretary carries out the President's foreign policies through the State Department, which includes the Foreign Service, Civil Service and U.S. Agency for International Development.
Good afternoon, everyone.
It seems a little odd today.
Humeyra, do you want to start us off?
Yeah, sure.
Welcome back, Matt.
I just want to ask about some of Prime Minister Netanyahu's comments from last week.
I'm aware that they've evolved and his – and Secretary has also laid out a vision on what
Washington thinks about the future of Gaza, but where we are, it does look like there
is a disagreement with Netanyahu and U.S. on the future of Gaza.
U.S. doesn't want to – any reoccupation.
And while Netanyahu has clarified some of his comments and has made different comments,
it does sound like Israel does want like a security force and with an indefinite period
of time.
So I'm just wondering what the U.S. thinking on that is.
How are you – are you negotiating with the Israelis on that, and how is that going?
So I will say that, yes, as a first item, he has clarified some of his remarks.
But you're right, he has made comments that are different from the vision that Secretary
Blinken laid out, both when we were in the region and then in a speech that he gave in
Tokyo last week.
Let me just reiterate – I know you know them, but just for the record – the principles
that the Secretary laid out, which is that, number one, at the end of this conflict there
can be no forcible displacement of Palestinians from Gaza.
It can't happen now.
While the conflict's happening, it can't happen at the end of the conflict.
Number two, there can be no continued use of Gaza as a platform for terrorism or other
violent attacks, as we saw it used on October 7th.
Number three, no reoccupation of Gaza after the conflict.
And number four, no reduction in the territory of Gaza.
Those are the principles that we believe in.
And when we start to have conversations with people in the region about what the future
of Gaza looks like, those are the principles we're going to lay out that we want to see
adhered to.
And to add to that, central in the question of what happens in Gaza must be Palestinian
voices who have a right to have a voice in their own future.
So we will keep making that clear.
We'll make that clear directly in conversations with Prime Minister Netanyahu and other leaders
of the Government of Israel, as we have publicly.
And you just said, like, no forcible displacement, but we're seeing people from North Gaza
moving to South Gaza because of – I mean, what kind of assurance, if any, is the United
States getting from Israelis that those people will be able to move back?
So they have said publicly that they expect those people to be able to move back at the
end of the conflict.
When we say no forcible displacement, there is a difference between people moving out
of harm's way, which we fully support.
We want to see people move out of harm's way so they avoid being harmed by Israel's
military campaign.
Move out of harm's way inside Gaza and being forcibly expelled from Gaza, which we very
much oppose.
So Israel has said publicly they expect people to be able to return to their homes, to return
to their neighborhoods at the end of the conflict.
Can I quickly go to hostages?
There has been different reports about different kinds of proposals.
I mean, to the extent that you can share, what is the latest?
Do you have some sort of renewed optimism that there could be some progress on that
this week, perhaps?
So on the first question, I'm going to stick to the rule that I've adhered to and that
Secretary Blinken has adhered to pretty rigorously, which is we're not going to talk at all about
either the substance or the status of negotiations to secure the release of hostages, including
the American citizens who we know remain held hostage.
It continues to be a top priority for us.
Secretary Blinken had a call with his Qatari counterpart over the weekend about this.
There are others in the government engaged on this, including, of course, the president
himself.
So in terms of the prospects, it continues to be a top priority.
But again, we're dealing with a brutal, violent terrorist organization who's holding them
hostage.
And I don't think I want to put any kind of percentage on assessing what they may or may
not do.
Matt, can I just, when you talk about there's no forcible displacement, is that what you're
saying?
Yeah, from Gaza.
From Gaza.
Again, I just made the point.
We understand that.
So you're saying, so the Israelis saying basically leave the north and go to the south, or you're
basically getting killed.
That is no forcible displacement from Gaza.
You're talking about.
I'm talking outside of Gaza, from Gaza out to Egypt or another third party, third country.
Yes.
Okay.
So, so you're okay with like all of the hundreds of thousands of people who were in the north
of Gaza all being.
I would say we support people inside Gaza being moved out of harm's way.
Absolutely.
Okay.
And then when this is over, you say they're going to get to return?
Israel has said that publicly.
Yeah.
To what?
To their homes and to their neighborhoods.
So I will say that one of the.
To their homes and to those homes and neighborhoods still.
So if you saw this, I know you did see because you were there, if you saw what the secretary
said when we were in Tokyo, he said there must be a sustained mechanism for reconstruction
in Gaza.
Because a lot of those homes have been destroyed and there has to be a mechanism for, to rebuild
Gaza, including those neighborhoods and those homes that have been destroyed so people can
return to where they're.
They lived.
Yeah.
But saying, saying, oh, well, once this is all over, you can go back home.
But there isn't anything that's going to be left.
Yeah.
Obviously Gaza is, is this the, the, the location of a, an intense military campaign.
When it's over, we want to see reconstruction of Gaza.
All right.
But paid for by.
We will have conversations with partners in the region about that very question.
I think it's a little, I think it's a little too early to say we're in the middle of the
conflict right now.
We're just having to start having conversations.
But it is not just as easy as saying, oh, okay, well, you're, you're, you're being told
to yourself for your own, own protection, but after, but after that, that, that threat
is over, then you can go back when you have nothing to get back to and no one is going
to be stepping up to pay for reconstruction.
Nothing, nothing about this process.
None of the issues in this process are easy and I did not say they were easy.
All of this is difficult.
Every one of these principles we laid out are, are, will be the subject of, of intense
diplomacy and none of this, I think everyone that's been paying attention to the issues
we've been grappling with and that Israel has been grappling with and that countries
in the region grappling with, no one would tell you that any of these are, are anything
but very, very difficult.
Okay.
Last one for me on, on, on the Shifa, the hospital, do you have any thoughts about what's
going on there?
Let me say a few things.
Number one, you heard Jake Sullivan on, on TV yesterday say that we don't want to see
hospitals be the subject of crossfire.
We want to see the civilians who are sheltering in hospitals, the civilians who are being
treated in hospitals, including babies in hospitals, be protected.
Civilians are, hospitals are legitimate civilian infrastructure.
They should be protected.
At the same time, I would say Hamas continues to use hospitals as locations for its command
posts.
So this is, we talk about difficult issues.
This is a very difficult issue.
We don't want to see civilians caught in the crossfire.
We would love to see Hamas vacate the hospitals that it's using command posts immediately.
We would love to see all the people that are calling for Israel to take steps to protect
hospitals, call for Hamas to vacate the hospitals and stop using civilians as human shields.
We would love to see Hamas take some of the fuel reserves it's sitting on and use that
to supply hospitals in Northern Gaza.
We would love to see Hamas have taken the fuel that Israel offered it yesterday that
they declined for use at al-Shifa hospital.
So it's a very difficult situation.
And I would say as a principle, I'll just restate what I said at the top.
We do not want to see civilians caught in the crossfire.
Okay.
You say, okay, you would love to see everyone call for Hamas to vacate hospitals and get
rid of all the fighters.
Okay.
But if they don't, you're okay with attacks on the hospital?
I did not say that.
I'm not saying you didn't.
I'm asking you.
Sure.
So I am, as we have done all throughout this process, going to decline to comment on specific
places, always because there is a bit-
Right.
Let's just talk about hospitals in general.
We do not want to see hospitals attacked.
Okay.
We want to see hospitals protected.
But if Hamas doesn't remove their people from the hospitals, where they are, where you just
said they are-
Again, there are-
And it's okay for them to be kept?
I am not going to give a general answer on this because there are so many variables.
Are there still wounded?
Are there still civilians in those hospitals?
Have they been evacuated?
There are a number of things you have to consider when you're going to answer that type of question,
which is why we, from thousands of miles away, declined to give past judgment or give
a definitive answer about something where we don't have perfect information about what's
happening on the ground.
Can I follow up on this one, please?
Can I-
Matt, are you-
Yeah.
Go ahead.
Now, you speak with certainty that Hamas is using al-Shifa Hospital as a-
I did not speak to al-Shifa.
You spoke perfectly.
I said hospitals.
Just to be clear, Saeed.
About the Shifa Hospital.
Yeah.
You know for certain.
The United States of America, the intelligence community knows for certain that Hamas is
using that as a command center.
So I am going to use my own words because you just misstated what I said.
I'm not-
No, no.
Let me just-
You did.
So let me just-
I'm not-
Let me just-
Let me be clear what I said.
I am not going to comment on any specific hospital.
To do so would require me to get into intelligence matters, which I'm not going to do from the
podium.
I will say, as a general matter, yes.
We do know that Hamas is using al-Shifa Hospital as a command center.
I will say, as a general matter, yes.
We do know that Hamas is using al-Shifa Hospital as a command center.
completely out of service right now. So let me just, if you indulge me, a few more questions
on this particular issue, on this very issue. So why don't you rely, I mean, there are Norwegian
doctors that served in that hospital that came out and said, you know, European doctors
didn't say this is nonsense, there's no command post and so on. Why don't you send them, you
know, a commission or the Red Cross or ask anyone to go and see, because that's what
they said, come and see it, come and see it and see if it's being used as a command post.
Why don't you do that? I think that would, you know. So I would just say we feel fairly
confident in the judgment we've passed. We would welcome truly independent observers
going. I think that's a little unrealistic to ask for in the middle of a conflict, Said.
But they are willing. The Red Cross said they are willing to do that. I think it's, we have
seen, we have seen Hamas at times break its agreements that it's had with the Red Cross
and other interests. I think it's a little bit much to ask for someone to go make an
assessment like that. You talk about the fuel, you know, you're saying that Israel offered
Gaza, like, offered the hospital something like 200, 300 liters of fuel, and they requested
that it be, somebody would come in the middle of the night and pick it up at two in the
morning and so on. They said, do it through the Red Cross, do it through the agencies.
Why wouldn't they do that? Why wouldn't they have Hamas people go and pick it up in the
middle of the night at two o'clock in the morning? Isn't that a bit cynical?
I don't think so. I'm not going to, first of all, the idea would not be that Hamas people
would come pick it up, but hold on, but the people, hold on, Said, just let me finish
my answers, that people from the hospital would come and pick it up. I would say that
they should have accepted the offer. I will let Israel speak to the exact specifics of
it, but if they clearly, if they need fuel, which they clearly do, they should have taken
the offer from the government of Israel. But to the larger point, Hamas is sitting on fuel
reserves in northern Gaza. Hamas is using fuel reserves to ventilate its tunnels. If
Hamas truly cared for the people in al-Shifa and in other hospitals in the north, it could
take the fuel that it's using to protect its fighters and send it to the hospitals so the
hospitals could protect patients. They are not doing that.
So you think that by this continued assault and so on, that Israel will achieve its goal
of, let's say, providing care for those who need it, and at the same time disarm the hospital?
I mean, what is the end? What is the vision as far as the hospital?
So I'm going to let Israel speak to, I'm going to let Israel speak to its exact campaign.
I will speak to U.S. principals. They can speak to their campaign.
There has been, you know, since, we don't know what happens after Friday, after Saturday,
the Shifa hospital quit counting. They don't have the means to do it anymore. But until then,
there were about 11,400 Palestinians who have died. That's about one in 200. Doctors, lawyers,
teachers, mothers, fathers, babies. You know, we have, every 10 minutes we have a child killed
in Gaza. So what is the end game? How do you see this thing ending? Or must the slaughter go on?
So, Saeed, let me start by just reminding you what the secretary said on Friday,
which is that far too many Palestinian civilians have been killed as a part of this conflict.
We want to see the government of Israel take steps to minimize civilian harm. We would love
to see Hamas stop using civilians as human shields, which they very cynically do. They're
the ones that continue to put civilians in harm's way. They obviously have shown no sign of changing
that longstanding abhorrent practice of theirs. And we want to continue to get civilians out of
harm's way into places where they can be safe from harm. And we want to continue to get them
humanitarian assistance. That has been, if you were paying attention to the secretary's trips
around the region, as was true about his first trip to Israel and other countries in the region,
that has been our primary focus from top to bottom. And let me get, last question.
My last one, please. When the secretary says far too many Palestinians have died,
does that mean enough is enough by now? Is that the end?
It means exactly what it says. It means that far too many have died. We want to see
fewer civilian casualties. We want to see the government of Israel take steps to minimize
civilian casualties. And we have direct conversations with them all the time about that.
And we want to do all these other things I just talked about to get civilians out of harm's way
and get them the humanitarian assistance they need. Because it's been a few, let me go to someone else.
Just to pick up on what you left off, is it your understanding that Israel is trying to
minimize civilian casualties? Is it your assessment?
It is. It's our understanding that they do attempt to minimize civilian casualties. They've
talked about that publicly. We think there are additional steps that they can take. The
secretary communicated that to them very clearly when he was in Israel, and we've had continued,
ongoing conversations with them about that.
If hospitals are indeed sanctuaries for Hamas, which Israel says it is,
is there any active discussion over creating field hospitals and potentially U.S. involvement?
Not U.S. involvement inside Gaza, but yes, there has been conversations with our allies and
partners about setting up additional field hospitals. There's been conversations about
setting up additional facilities where people either in southern Gaza or people who have moved
to southern Gaza from the north can seek medical care. As you, as I think you probably know,
there are wounded Palestinians from northern Gaza who have been evacuated and left through
Rafah Gate to seek medical care. So yes, that is something we continue to work on.
Thank you. Please come back to me when you're clear, Ashraf.
Just one more on this hospital issue. Given what you just said, what Jake Sullivan has
said, and what the Secretary said about this far too many Palestinians killed,
we've asked you this question in previous weeks. But in light of all of these new developments
and the targeting of the hospitals, is there any intent at this department or the administration
to take a look at, in a formal way, whether Israel has followed the rules of war?
Again, we are monitoring the situation very closely, as we always monitor conflicts.
But I don't – I'm not going to provide any update on internal deliberations.
I should not be interpreting that, the internal deliberation part, as
there is an internal deliberation on this?
You should interpret it exactly the same way you should have interpreted it two weeks ago,
when I gave the same answer, which is I'm not going to comment on internal deliberations.
But you're saying there is no change in the thinking in light of the recent developments?
I am saying what I just said, not what you are claiming I said. What I'm saying – so I will
use my own words. And what I said is we're monitoring, of course. We monitor this situation
as we monitor any conflict. But in terms of our internal decision-making process and internal
deliberations, I'm not going to – I'm not going to – I'm not going to speak to those.
But you're asking – I mean, you understand why I'm asking this, right? Because you're saying
there are additional steps that they can take that they don't seem to be taking them right now,
and all of this is unfolding with the hospitals. So I'm wondering if there is any change in the
administration's thinking on that. I'm just not going to – I'm just
not going to talk about internal matters. Go ahead, Michel.
I have a couple of questions, Matt. First, are you on the same page with Israel regarding how
to deal with Hezbollah? Did you ask or did the administration ask the Israeli Government
not to escalate the situation with Hezbollah and drag the U.S. to a new war or broader war?
So I'm not going to get into internal conversations with the Government of Israel. I will say that you
have heard us say publicly a number of times one of our primary objectives is to keep this
conflict from widening, and that means to keep it from widening both in terms of preventing
additional conflict in the north of Israel with Hezbollah and to prevent conflict widening to
other countries in the region. Are you aware of the reports that Israel
targeted journalists in south Lebanon today? And do you have any comment on that?
I'm not aware of those reports today. If it just came in the last bit while I was coming out here,
I haven't seen it. And finally,
in the supplemental package request, the OMB stated that the crisis in Gaza could result
in displacement across borders and higher regional humanitarian needs, and funding
may be used to meet evolving programming requirements outside of Gaza, including Israel,
West Bank, Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, and Egypt. What does the administration mean by that?
So I think you should take it that we are doing prudent planning, as we always do in
these situations. It's not a prediction about what might happen or what will happen in the future.
As I said a moment ago, we've made very clear that Palestine should not be displaced from Gaza.
But as part of our planning, we're planning for any number of scenarios. We want to keep
this conflict from widening, but we have to be prudent and plan for any potential
humanitarian scenarios should they emerge. Matt, is it correct – staying on the supplemental,
is it correct that the supplemental – and this came out, I guess, while we were gone – but
removes all congressional oversight from arms transfers to Israel?
No, that's not exactly correct.
That proposed waiver that's in the supplemental makes zero changes to how arms sales would be
notified to Congress and made public. The notification of sales, whether it's through
government-to-government, foreign military sales, FMS, or licensed commercial sales,
would be the same under the supplemental, as they have been for decades. What this provision,
I think you're asking about, would do would be to allow us to waive the congressional
notification requirement for supplemental foreign assistance funds, not for arms sales.
So foreign assistance, like ESF?
I don't know the exact program. I'd have to look into that and get back to you.
Economic support funds.
Yeah, it may be. I'd have to look for it and get back to you.
But not for FMF, not for foreign military –
Again, I would have to dive into it and get back to you. I think the story,
from my understanding, conflated funding notifications and arms sales notification,
but beyond any details, I'll have to gauge after.
My last one is, when you talked about the hospitals and Hamas using them to operate,
you said that you were fairly confident of that assessment.
Fairly?
Fairly confident.
We are very confident of that assessment.
Very?
Very. Confident.
Fairly?
Confident.
Well, I just want to make –
We are confident.
Okay, so if you're confident that that's the case, then you presumably then don't have any
issue with Israel going out, if they give people ample warning to leave.
It is a very complicated question. Not everyone who's in a hospital can leave.
There are questions of whether ambulances can get there and transport them out.
It is what makes this issue so difficult. And while I'm declining to pronounce
specific factual judgments on difficult situations when facts are evolving all the time.
Right. But then you put yourself in a position, or you leave yourself open
to never having a position on it at all.
I think we've made clear what our overall position is. Again,
we lay out our general principles, but I'm thousands of miles away from Israel right now.
We get conflicting information. You hear – we get conflicting information in press reports.
You get conflicting information from people on the ground.
It is difficult to pass a definitive judgment about what has happened, what should happen.
So I'll decline to do that, other than go beyond what our principles are
regarding civilian protections.
On the civilian casualties – and I will have one more. You said – you have been
calling on Israel for quite a long time to minimize harm to civilians.
But I just wanted to make sure, like, do you really think that Israel is doing everything it
can to minimize harm to civilians? And what are the other steps that Israel can take?
MR PRICE So we do, as I said,
think there are additional steps that they can take. What those additional steps are,
we've had very direct conversations with them about that, but I will keep those conversations
private.
QUESTION Okay. One more, please. During the
Arab-Islamic summit in Saudi Arabia this weekend, Turkish President Erdogan said that
the Israeli minister's remarks about a nuclear strike on Gaza revealed the existence of Israel's
nuclear weapons and called on an international investigation on that.
What is the U.S. position on this call for an international investigation? And do you – I mean,
is the U.S. aware of any potential nuclear weapons owned by Israel?
MR PRICE I don't have any comment on an investigation
or the underlying question. I will say that the remarks by that minister were completely
unacceptable, and we are glad they were immediately repudiated by the prime minister.
QUESTION But you don't support any investigation on that?
MR PRICE I'm just not going to comment on that at all.
QUESTION Thanks so much. There is a dissent – internal
dissent memo that's saying the administration's spreading misinformation. I know you won't comment
on the actual memo.
MR PRICE Correct.
QUESTION But you have protesters out here on Thursday yelling shame at employees as they walk
out the building saying, quit your job. I mean, how is morale in this – inside this building,
and how is it affected by all of the kind of –
MR PRICE So I would say that the State Department, like every organization, not just in government
but around the world, contains people with a diversity of views. And one of the things that
we think is one of our strengths – you've heard me talk to this before, you've heard Vedant talk to
this last week, I think you've heard the Secretary talk to this at times – one of our strengths as
an organization is that we have that diversity of views and that we welcome people to make those
views known. The Secretary has met with a number of people from all ranks of the department,
from different bureaus in the department, to hear exactly what they think about our policy,
both with respect to Israel and its conflict with Hamas and with respect to other matters,
including very controversial matters. And he encourages people to provide feedback,
he encourages people to speak up if they disagree. It doesn't mean that we're going to
change our policy based on their disagreements. He is going to take their recommendations and make
ultimately what he thinks is the best judgment and make his recommendations to the President
about what we ought to do. So I would just say that with – it goes to this question of morale.
We see the diversity of opinions as a source of strength of this department, not as a source
of weakness. Mr. Miller, my name is Jacob Milton. I'm working for Weekly Bangladeshi and
a publication called We Are the People and Nagri TV. As you know that Bangladesh and Dhaka is
another hot place like Gaza. It will become a Gaza Strip very soon if free and fair election
is not going to take place. Bangladesh is a sovereign country where 90 to 95 percent of the
people are in favor of democracy and free, fair, participatory, and inclusive election.
Citizens of Bangladesh become very optimistic once America starts playing a role concerning
human rights and democratic process. All major political parties except Omlig are working with
His Excellency Peter Haas and other diplomats from other nations. Why must the U.S. government
discuss the Bangladesh issue with India? Does it not indicate that our country has already been
sold to India by the current regime of Bangladesh? Does the U.S. need India's concurrence do anything
in Bangladesh? Let me just say what I've said many times, which is we support free and fair
elections in Bangladesh. We think the future of the Bangladeshi government should be determined
by its people full stop. I have one. You asked three and one there. I'm going to go. Go ahead.
Thank you, Matt. Assistant Secretary Donald Lue has sent a letter with urging for dialogue between
the ruling party and the opposition. But how can there be any dialogue when most of the opposition
political leaders are in prison? And I'm wondering who received letter from the opposition as
government cracked down opposition and going on and government workers, you know,
been killed at least five. So what is your comment? How can be a dialogue within this scenario?
So again, I welcome the attempts by various reporters to draw me into internal
Bangladeshi political matters, and I'm going to continue to refrain from doing so. The United
States does not take a side in Bangladeshi elections. We do not support one political
party over the other. We support free and fair elections, period. I'm going to.
Okay. I wonder, sir, how can Palestinians accept the offer of full Israeli offer for them?
You know, the people who leave the patient who left the hospitals targeted and killed by Israeli
soldiers and as well Red Cross, they said they declared it's very difficult to them to do their
duty. And also, they lost 99 of their employees. So it's difficult to accept this offer as well.
My question. Let me just say something first. So I think your question goes to what I was
saying. No, no, no, no, no, no. Sorry. Let me. The point you just made. I will definitely come
back to your question. The point you just made, I think, gets to the difficulty I was
speaking to a minute ago about finding definitive judgments when facts
are so hard to ascertain. You mentioned reports that the Israelis were firing on
people near the hospital or relief workers. There are reports that Hamas fighters are firing on
Israeli soldiers from inside the hospital. So that you. So, so, so my point being that in such
a difficult situation, it's why I'm declining to pass judgment. But I would say in general,
if it is so important for this hospital to have fuel, which it obviously is,
I would think that they would, I would hope that they would take the government of Israel up on
its offer to provide fuel, as well as, of course, as I said earlier, that Hamas would just start
turning over some of its own. Now go ahead with your question. Israel planning to build a buffer
zone north of Gaza, the north part of Gaza and Gaza cities. There is reports talk about that,
that Israel planning to build a buffer zone to take and make a buffer zone in the northern part
of Gaza. So are you sure or guarantee people, civilian people who left their homes in Gaza,
northern part of Gaza and Gaza city to after the war is end, they will go back to their homes?
Are you guaranteeing that? So what I can guarantee is what United States policy is. And what United
States policy is, is that there should be no reduction in the territory of Gaza. And that's
a matter that we will continue to make clear to the government of Israel and to other partners
in the region as we start to have these conversations about the future of Gaza.
Thanks, Matt. I know you won't comment on the reported cable or memo or the many reported
memos of dissent, but is the Secretary aware of dissent, particularly on this issue? And would
you say that this issue has drawn dissent like perhaps others haven't in his tenure here?
So I'm not going to characterize this issue versus other issues. There are, of course,
a number of controversial issues that we deal with. And at any time on a big controversial
issue, of course, not everyone in the department agrees with the given policy that we decide to
pursue at any one point. So comparing this issue to others, I don't think I'm able to do.
I will say, as I said before, that this is a difficult issue where people have very strong
feelings for very good reasons. That is not true just at the State Department. You look at the
protests that have happened around the country, the protests that are going to happen in Washington
this week. You look at the very strong feelings that this issue has aroused in the United States
and around the world. Of course, that extends to inside the State Department where people have
very strong opinions. I'll just reiterate that the Secretary wants to hear from those employees.
He wants to hear what their opinions are. I won't comment on any dissent memos, but he has spoken
in the past about how he welcomes the dissent channel and thinks it's a very valuable channel
and that he likes to get feedback through it, and he hopes that people will use it,
and he hopes that it continues to be protected. One of the reasons we generally don't talk about
it is we want people to feel that they can use that channel confidentially without fear
that somehow their participation in that channel would be used against them with respect to
employment or promotion decisions down the road. It's a channel that the Secretary finds
very valuable as he finds valuable his meetings with employees, as I said, at all ranks to talk
about their opinions on this issue and many others. Beyond the channel, has he on this issue
spoken to employees or diplomats or anybody at State who have raised disagreements with how the
U.S. is conducting foreign policy on this issue? Of course he has. He's talked with people inside
the building who very much support the policies that we have undertaken, as well as people that
disagree, and what he does in those meetings is explain how he came to the decisions that he's
come to, explains our conversations with the government of Israel, outlines our entire policy,
which is not just support for Israel's right to continue to hold accountable the terrorists that
attacked it on October 7th and continue to attack it, but also all of our work to protect
civilians and to get humanitarian assistance to civilians, our work calling for humanitarian pauses.
I think one of the things he makes clear in any time he has a conversation about these issues is
it is the United States of America, not any other country, that was able to secure an agreement
to get humanitarian assistance into Gaza. It was the United States of America that was able to secure
an agreement to get humanitarian pauses so people could move through these humanitarian quarters
that have now been set up to move from north to south. So he will continue to make that clear in
all of his conversations. Has it changed his decision-making at all? I'm not going to speak to
impact on his decision-making, but he is someone who wants to have his opinions challenged,
wants to have his positions challenged, wants to engage in a good faith back and forth because
he believes that that strengthens his ability to make good decisions on behalf of the American
people. Yes, this is a question about the APEC summit this week. How – do you expect there
could be a trilateral space to talk about fentanyl in APEC, considering that the leaders of Mexico,
China, and the U.S. are in the city of San Francisco? Today the major of San Francisco
said she would like to hear some progress on this issue. So I won't speak to any specific meetings
that we haven't yet announced, but I will say that curbing the trafficking of fentanyl and the
devastating impact it's had on American citizens is something that the Secretary raises in his
meetings with officials from the Government of China. It's certainly something that was on the
agenda when we've met with officials from the Government of Mexico. You can very much expect
that it will be on the agenda for a number of his meetings at APEC. Go ahead. You framed your
response earlier that it was the U.S. who was able to bring – get humanitarian aid into Gaza. The
U.S. – Broker an agreement is what I meant, yeah. And who was able to get these three to – or four
to five-hour pauses. So how much responsibility do you take then for the 11,100 lives that have
been lost, if you are in a position to stop that today? I would reject the premise of that. The
Government of Israel conducts its military campaigns. We talk to them about how to minimize
civilian casualties. We talk to them about what they can do to protect civilians and how to get
them out of harm's way. We do everything that we can to broker agreements to get humanitarian
assistance in, but ultimately this is a campaign that's being conducted by the Government of
Israel. We will continue to make our policies clear to them. We will continue to offer our
best advice to them, as you've seen the President do, and we will continue to work to get humanitarian
assistance in. Thank you, Matt. Ukraine, Russia, if you don't mind. Secretary –
Can I just – one thing on this? Are you saying that without the United States
there would be no humanitarian aid going into Gaza?
So it's a – you never know what a counterfactual is. Had we not brokered that agreement,
you have no idea whether someone else would have come. Hold on, hold on. Let me finish.
You have no idea whether someone else would have come in and brokered an agreement. What I'm saying
is what did happen is that it was the United States that brokered that agreement that allowed
humanitarian assistance to come in. Okay. Well, was there anyone else that
you were aware of who was in a position to be able to broker an agreement?
It was the United States that did it. I don't know what you're referring to. I'm sure you have a –
No, I just – I'm just – I mean, you're taking credit for all of – it's just like his question.
I mean, if you're taking credit for the, quote-unquote, good, that means some aid getting
in to Gaza. We take responsibility for the things that we do, correct.
Okay. But if you're – but if you're claiming – if you're claiming that you have influence
enough to get the aid in, then – So what I –
Then you're saying that you don't have any responsibility for anything else?
No. No. I think that you were on the last – you were on both of the last trips. I think it's very
clear that while we are able to make our opinions known to the Government of Israel and we are able
to move them, there are issues on which we have disagreements. We started this briefing off about
some of the disagreements that we have with them about – with respect to what – where Gaza will
come. Okay. Well, let's just say you're taking credit for doing this, but you're not taking
responsibility for – I'm taking credits for things that – where we have had a direct impact,
where the United States Government – Well, you're referring to something,
quote-unquote, positive. And there are other areas that we continue to work – there are
other areas we continue to work on. Those aren't our fault.
There are other areas we continue to work on. Okay. Go ahead. Go ahead.
Thanks. Thanks so much. Max. I was hoping you could fill us in on this morning's
meeting with Ukraine, the Secretary-General of his delegation. Did he assure the Ukrainian side
that the topic of Ukraine will be on top of his queue despite the challenges abroad and at home?
We, in all of our conversations with the Ukrainian Government, make clear that we
will continue to stand by them, that we will continue to back them. And you don't have to
just look to our private conversations. You've heard the President of the United States speak
to the American people about exactly this question when he laid out in an Oval Office address our
request to Congress to provide supplemental assistance to Ukraine so we can continue to
back Ukraine. In addition to that, the Secretary talked with Mr. Yarmak this morning about steps
we can take together with Ukraine to harden its infrastructure for the upcoming winter.
We, of course, in the last winter saw Russia trying to take down energy sites in Ukraine.
They may very well do that again, so we talked to them about steps that they can take
to prepare for and respond to that. As I understand, you also guys are
talking to the Russians as part of APEC talks. There's a discussion between Ambassador
Matt Murray and his Russian counterpart. Is Ukraine being discussed without Ukraine on the table?
Ukraine is not being discussed without Ukraine on the table. I mean, if you mean the final
disposition of the conflict, we have made clear that we will never make any decisions or we're
not in a place to make any decisions without Ukraine. Of course, we will talk about the
Ukraine – the war in Ukraine and we will talk about how we can best defend Ukraine. We always
do that in partners. The Secretary has talked a number of times about how he's constantly in
meetings with foreign counterparts looking for ways that other countries can assist Ukraine.
We will certainly do that.
But who is a non-sanctioned Russian deputy prime minister that will represent —
I'm sorry, what was the —
Non-sanctioned Russian deputy prime minister will represent Russia at APEC. Who is he or she?
I'll have to get back to you on that. I don't —
Have you guys invited Ukrainians as well to the summit?
I'll have to get back to you on that as well. I'm just – I'm not aware.
There are rumors that —
I just – I don't know, Alex. I'll have to take it back.
Let's talk about Iran, if you don't mind.
Yeah.
There are speculations on social media that U.S. is about to waive
some – issue a new waiver on Iran that will allow Iran to access $10 billion.
Why, when, how? Anything you can tell us?
I think you certainly shouldn't expect me to comment on speculation on social
media, and I will decline to do so. Go ahead, and then we'll wrap it up.
Is it true?
Thank you.
Yeah, I think I just answered it, or declined to answer.
Thank you, Matt. Can you please give us a sense, if anything, discussed
in New Delhi 2 plus 2 meeting on particularly Bangladesh upcoming election? Indian press and
Bangladeshi press described that they had a good meeting on Bangladesh upcoming election,
and we saw the Indian statement, as well as the Chinese statement,
charming as internal affairs. So can you please give us a sense?
I'm just not going to talk to the – hold on. As I said, this would be the last – I'm not
going to talk to the specifics of the meeting other than what we put out in our readout that
the Secretary said in his statement while we were in India. Thanks, everyone.