Did you miss the latest Ramsey Show episode? Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered! Get all the highlights you missed plus some of the best moments from the show. Watch entertaining calls, Dave Rants, guest interviews, and more!
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
Katie is with us in Concord, New Hampshire.
Hi, Katie.
Welcome to the Ramsey Show.
Hi.
Oh, God.
This is actually happening.
Whew.
Okay.
Breathe, Katie.
It's going to be good.
Holy moly.
What's up?
How can we help?
I'm overwhelmed with gratitude.
This is crazy.
Okay.
Whew.
First, I need to thank you for everything.
Thank you.
How can we help?
Okay, Dave.
You have to promise not to yell at me.
My boyfriend and I have combined all of our debt and our bank accounts, and we are genzell
intense on our debt.
We have about $89,000 left.
We have smashed out all the credit cards.
There's no more credit card debt, which is very freeing.
Now we're working on student loan and auto loan.
My question is, my family and I have recently joined a church that my children and I were
baptized in.
Every month, we have our budget meeting.
I'm the planner, and he gets to change my plan, which I don't really like very much.
My question is, month after month after month, the church column is a bunch of zero, because
I feel like I don't really have anything to give, and I want to be able to give the 10%
of our income.
When are you getting married?
Ask him.
I've actually had this conversation with him.
I've actually been married twice before.
How long have you been dating?
We've been dating for over a year.
If you're willing to completely combine your finances, you should never do that unless
you're married, and then you should do it immediately.
This is very dangerous for you, very vulnerable.
Either take your finances back apart or get married.
What was his response when you brought it up to him, marriage?
We talk about it.
We want to get married.
His thing is he wants to be able to provide picture perfect for me.
Sorry, that's not an option.
There's no such thing.
I got a hunch here real quick.
Katie, what does he make income-wise, and what do you make?
Separate those.
Okay.
I make $4,000 a month, give or take, and he makes about $5,500, roughly.
I actually have more debt than he does.
Number one, let's just back up, back the bus up here.
Either get married in the next 30 days or separate your finances.
This is very dangerous for you.
I'm scared for you.
You should not be paying his debt.
He should not be paying your debt when you're not married.
You are going to get ... It's going to put a strain on the relationship, something's
going to blow up, and one of you is going to get left at an unfair disadvantage due
to this broken system that you should not be using.
I'm not yelling at you.
I just want good for you.
I love you.
I want you to win.
Then once you've made the decision to either separate your finances or combine them because
you're getting married immediately, not next year, then this is not something you need
to plan for two years, paint or get off the ladder.
Once you've decided all that, then we can come to your question.
How do we put ... You've just started attending church, how do you put church in the budget?
Well, you don't put church in the budget.
You put God and generosity in the budget.
For those of us that are evangelical Christians, the first stage of baseline generosity is
a tenth of our income going to the local church, but that is an act of worship.
That's an act of not trying to buy God's favor.
He doesn't need your money.
He says to do this because he wants to turn you into a generous person because generous
people are much better children, and you and I are better children of God when we are generous.
He's trying to turn us into that, and that's what the tithe was established for.
It's not established as a rule.
It's not established as a shaming mechanism by religious zealots.
It's established as a method of teaching us the power of generosity when it's a regular
rhythm in our lives.
Were I you, I would live on 90% of my income and be giving a tenth of my income to my local
church if I'm a person of faith.
That's not a condemnation, but it's what I have done for 40 years, and it's worked really,
really well for me.
There's no guarantee you're not going to have bad times.
There's no guarantee of anything.
It's just an act of generosity, and it's teaching us the rhythm of generosity, a baseline start.
I was in a church when I was going bankrupt, Katie, in my 20s as a baby Christian, and
there were people there that would say things like, well, you know, God protects you if
you tithe, and I went, uh, missed that part, went bankrupt.
I missed that.
Well, and then I had one old blue-haired lady say, well, you just didn't have enough faith,
and I said, honey, I didn't have anything left but faith.
They took everything else.
So I mean, come on.
So broken doctrine, broken theology, and so you can get twisted up in all that toxic garbage,
or you can just say, hey, I'm going to live life with an open hand, and I'm going to be
a generous person because generous people smile more.
Generous people are less often depressed.
Generous people are better at relationships because who wants to be in a relationship
with a selfish person?
No one, right?
And so the act of generosity becomes a character quality, and it changes your whole life.
And so, yeah, I'm going to put that at the top of my list of things to do, absolutely,
but not as a legalism rule.
Yeah, absolutely right.
That is really scary doctrine, and it's what drives a lot of people away from the faith.
If you think you got to give God money to get something good from Him, that is a recipe
for frustration and desperation.
Yeah, as if He needs your permission to bless you, you know, and as if His blessing is dependent
upon you giving Him a nickel, good gracious.
If He wanted your money, He'd take it to a big greasy spot where you were sitting.
I mean, He's God.
I mean, come on.
He doesn't need your money.
That's not the point.
The point, and so don't be shamed by it, Katie, and don't be going, because I heard the guilt,
oh, every month I feel bad because there's nothing in the church column.
Put something in there, but don't do it out of shame.
Do it out of, hey, I want to learn a different way of living that includes generosity, and
it includes a smile, and it includes being married to this guy you've fallen in love
with and combining your whole life, not just your money, and let's do the whole deal.
Let's go game on, but don't pay someone's debts ever, and don't let someone pay your
debts that you're not married to.
You're going to get yourself in a pinch.
I've been doing this a long time, and I never see good of it.
It ends, as Deloney says all the time, this ends in ash.
Ooh, that's a pretty harsh statement, but it does.
It just, the thing burns to the ground, so I want you to win, kiddo.
We love you, and I'm happy that you're and your family are in a good church, and it sounds
like you're starting your journey there or resetting your journey there.
That's awesome.
I'm happy for any of that.
I'm cheering you on.
Ken's cheering you on.
We want you to win, and no, we're not yelling at you.
That's not what we do.
We yell at concepts, not people, but yeah, don't, you know, those of you that are shacking
up and aren't getting married, you can do that if you want to do it.
I won't be mad at you.
I'm not going to yell at you, but don't combine your money.
Don't combine your money because you're going to get burned.
Don't buy a house with somebody you're not married to.
You're going to get burned.
I get it all the time in here.
It's all the time, and you're just setting yourself up.
You make dumb decisions like that.
You get yourself burned.
We don't want that for you.