Martin Keown BLASTS PL Panel's Decision that Newcastle United's Goal was Right to Stand 😡🔥

Arsenal Is My DNA
16 followers
17 Video Views·Nov 10, 2023
The back of the times Martin this morning and in other newspapers,
your Chairman at Arsenal, Arteta wrong on VAR call.
Now of course this all hinges on the game on Saturday night at St James' Park
when Anthony Gordon's goal won the match for Newcastle,
but post-match Arteta was livid.
Today the Premier League's independent key match incident panel
quite clearly is reported to have supported the decision to award Anthony Gordon's
controversial winner against Arsenal.
Arteta if you remember was absolutely livid that the goal had been given.
Yeah we have to talk about the result because you have to talk about how the hell
this goal stand up and it's incredible.
I feel embarrassed but I have to be the one now coming here to try to defend the club
and please ask for help because it's an absolute disgrace that this goal is allowed.
It's an absolute disgrace.
Again I feel embarrassed.
I've been more than 20 years in this country and this is nowhere near
the level to describe this as the best league in the world.
I am sorry.
So he felt sick, he was incredibly embarrassed, it was a disgrace etc etc.
The report from the Premier League's independent key match incident panel says
the goal rightly stood.
I'll get to more detail on that in a moment.
We spoke to IFAB.
IFAB, who are IFAB?
They're football's decision makers.
Lawmakers.
They make the rules.
The IFAB chief executive Lucas Brood and he spoke about
without specifically identifying Arteta's outburst
he spoke about some of the hysterical reactions to VAR here in England.
I think people need to be patient that sometimes it takes longer,
sometimes it's more complicated than we think
to make sure we get to the best decision.
But it's difficult to make everyone happy
but we are confident that as I said in the vast vast majority of matches
VAR is almost silent.
You don't see them.
They communicate with the referees.
They help them if we're needed but sometimes things get complicated
and we have to accept that.
Have to accept it.
Lucas, we do accept it and you're doing a good job.
So the Premier League's independent key match incident panel Martin
looked at that Gordon situation, looked at the goal
and obviously cast an eye over Arteta's outburst.
The report states the majority of the five-strong independent panel,
four to one, agreed that the goal should have stood.
They say there was no conclusive evidence to show that the whole of the ball
was over the line, over the whole of the goal line.
The majority agreed the on-field decision of no foul was correct.
There was no foul involving Gabriel
and there was no evidence to show that the goal scorer Gordon
was in an offside position.
That all adds up to one thing, goal given.
So what's your friend Arteta on about?
Well Jim, this is obviously subjective even though it goes to VAR
and I don't agree with the panel.
I would prefer actually, if we're going to name names,
I would prefer to look at three former top referees
who've all looked at this incident very closely.
Firstly, we look at Chris Foy.
He said for him it was a foul.
Dermot Gallagher, top referee, former referee, said it was a foul.
Mark Clattenburg said it was a foul.
So we can all aim at evidence.
I don't even know who the panel is made up of.
Former players.
You say, I'm not sure it can be particularly independent
but I simply don't agree.
As a centre-half in that situation,
immediately I was watching, I was working with the guys at BBC,
we're doing Match of the Day
and everyone's shouting goal, goal, goal
and I'm like no, no, no, that couldn't be a goal
because it must have been a foul.
Watched it back, two hands on his back, Gabriel.
Now people saying he's stooping
and then so people covering that game, Jim,
the Gary Neville's and people, create a narrative.
They put it into people's minds that,
oh why is he stooping for?
He's stooping because he's got two hands on him
and he's stooping because he's off the ground.
He's taking the body weight there of Joe Linton.
So for me, it's a foul all day long.
I don't care what panel you put me in, it's a foul.
I'm not changing my mind.
That's fair enough.
You're not wearing your Arsenal glasses.
Not at all.
Whatever team I was supporting, I'll tell you if that was a goal,
if that was Spurs in a similar situation
and that was a foul on Romero,
I am shouting the same thing.
So do you echo what Arteta's saying?
Are you bitter about it?
Are you...
I think the choice of wording, Jim, was quite strong.
Maybe he could have taken a bit of time out.
You think it was too strong?
Possibly, but I'm not there in that situation.
So you're feeling like you've been cheated.
That's how you feel.
You feel the world is against you.
Yeah, he wouldn't have felt that if Arsenal had gone on to win it 2-1.
It's a huge game.
Incidentally, Arsenal had 60% possession in that game.
Everyone talking about one shot.
Newcastle only had two shots themselves.
Yeah.
So the game could have gone either way,
quite like the Man City-Arsenal game went either way.
But moments go for you and moments go against you
because this same panel said, do you know something?
Havert should have been red-carded and he wasn't.
So Arsenal got a break in that one.
Well, again, I don't...
Do you think he should have been red-carded?
No, I don't.
I think he should have been if he'd made contact.
He didn't make contact.
He comes in and it's the trailing leg that he catches.
But you're definitely looking at this through Arsenal glasses, are you not?
I think Havert was really on the edge there
and I wouldn't advise him to make that kind of tackle.
But I can see the common sense in why he wasn't sent off.
But, Jim, when you look at that time and time again,
were they really looking at the foul?
This is where, these are the areas when
you've heard you're Mike Deans having to go up Paul Mercer
and you don't know the rules.
What we do know, actually,
we do know when people have been fouled.
We do know when people are trying to cheat.
We do know when they're trying to take advantage of the rules, yeah?
That's something we can offer.
But the former players in this panel looked at it and said,
no, the whole sequence building up to that goal
means it should have been a goal and it was a goal
and the goal was given.
So it was the right decision.
I've just told you the three former top referees
and maybe that's the issue.
Maybe that's the issue.
The actual on the field referee.
But you're always going on about former players
should be more involved in the game.
They are.
They're on this bloody independent key match incident panel.
Well, Premier League panel?
The Premier League's independent key match incident panel.
I do not agree with their decisions, Jim.
The former players.
What do you want me to change my mind?
I believe in what I saw.
Would you be...
It's a foul.
And if I was in that panel,
I would have brought it to their attention
to explain why the player cannot get off the ground.
I did it today with our producer.
I said to him, look, okay, I've got two hands on your back.
Can you lift off the ground?
No, you can't even leave the floor, Jim.
Be honest with me here.
I'm being honest now.
If this has happened at the other end of the pitch,
it's in James's park and it was Arsenal's goal.
If it's stroked off, I then accept and understand it.
I just had to...
Because at the end of the day, Jim,
I'm actually an advocate of fair play.
I might not look like that when I was on the pitch,
but it doesn't mean I can't sit here and actually say that, yeah?
Oh, yeah, this righteous, virtuous individual.
I'm not that.
I'm saying to you, that is a foul on a central defender.
Why can't you accept authority and the decisions that they arrive at?
What is it about football and some of the people within it
who say even after it's been shown...
It's because they're looking at it in the cold light of day, almost.
They're getting a second chance to get this right.
And when they get it wrong, it's a double hit.
But they didn't get it wrong.
In my opinion, they got it wrong.
They didn't get it wrong.
And I'm not alone in that opinion, by the way.
You might not be alone in it, but you're in the minority.
No, I don't think so.
I think you're just making...
To suit your narrative, that's what you're throwing at me.
To suit your narrative, you're saying...
Look, I'd love to go...
Maybe I should sit in on the panel.
Do you know?
Well, maybe you should.
Have we got a number for the Premier League's
independent key match incident panel?
Would they be able to accommodate Martin Keown?
Could the five-man panel become a six-man panel?
Yeah, let's do it.
We'll ask.
Are you serious about that?
I'd love to go along, but Jim, I wouldn't get that opportunity.
Because I might bring some common sense to the table
and that's not going to happen, is it?
Martin, they applied common sense.
They looked at it.
How could four of them agree and one disagree,
but that's a majority decision that it was right to give the floor?
Why don't they talk to the former referees then?
If we're not allowed, why don't we get former referees in the room?
That same panel.
Yeah, I know there might be a couple in there,
but get them all in there.
They are all in there.
Well, is Classenburg in there?
Is Dermot Gallagher in there?
We have former referees and former players
on the Premier League's independent key match incident panel.
Let's name them.
Who are these individuals?
They're not naming them.
They choose not to name them,
but they insist former refs and former players are on it.
But if you want to add yourself to that list, why not jump in?
I don't have to agree with them, Jim.
I'm not going to, I simply don't agree with them.
They missed something.
It's Jim White and conspiracy theorist Martin Keown
and we're live on TalkSport.
Jim White and Simon Jordan.
Monday to Friday mornings from 10 on AM
on either TalkSport app and on your smart speaker.
TalkSport.
