DISCLAIMER: THIS INFORMATION IS FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE A SUBSTITUTE FOR CLINICAL CARE. PLEASE CONSULT A HEALTH CARE PROVIDER FOR GUIDANCE SPECIFIC TO YOUR CASE. THIS VIDEO DISCUSSES NARCISSISM IN GENERAL.
THE VIDEO DOES NOT REFER TO ANY SPECIFIC PERSON, AND SHOULD NOT BE USED TO REFER TO ANY SPECIFIC PERSON, AS HAVING NARCISSISM. PERMISSION IS NOT GRANTED TO LINK TO OR REPOST THIS VIDEO, ESPECIALLY TO SUPPORT AN ALLEGATION THAT THE MAKERS OF THIS VIDEO BELIEVE, OR SUPPORT A CLAIM, THAT A SPECIFIC PERSON IS A NARCISSIST. THAT WOULD BE AN UNAUTHORIZED MISUSE OF THE VIDEO AND THE INFORMATION FEATURED IN IT.
Hey everyone, it's Dr. Ramani here. So let's talk a little bit about verbal abuse
in childhood and what it does to a kid. Because you might think to yourself, well do you really
need to do research to figure out that verbal abuse is not good for a child? No, but a group
of people did and I think what they found really matters and it really matters for us to understand
how narcissistic parents can affect children. This is a big week for me to read a lot of literature
this week and I was reading a very interesting research study that was conducted by Shanta
Dubey and her colleagues at a place called Wingate University. And in this study they did
something called a meta-analysis and they reviewed lots of studies about childhood verbal abuse,
a child being verbally abused by a parent, caregiver, even a teacher. I was drawn to read
the article because it's such a universal pattern in people who have antagonistic narcissistic
parents in childhood, right? And the authors were really focused on making a very interesting
distinction. They wanted to treat childhood verbal abuse as something that's a part of but distinct
from childhood emotional abuse. And they were clear to point out that childhood emotional
abuse is almost like a much bigger umbrella that takes in more territory, but it includes other
things like the silent treatment, neglect, a child being raised in a home in which they're exposed to
domestic violence, indifference, a parent simply just not caring about them, right? Childhood verbal
abuse is obviously a huge part of that whole larger childhood emotional abuse pie. The screaming,
the humiliating, the use of exploitative language, manipulative language, scapegoating language. Again
enough of you who have narcissistic parents survived this to know what that part of it is.
So the people who did this research find that the long-term effects of this childhood verbal abuse
include depression, anxiety, in some cases PTSD, a greater risk of problematic substance use,
and even suicidal thoughts. So the verbal abuse in childhood they were able to show across these
many many studies can harm a person's mental health well into adulthood. And given the severity
depends on how severe the verbal abuse was some folks may even experience fallout consistent with
complex trauma. Now by and large when people have antagonistic or narcissistic parents
the downstream effect in adulthood is most prominently negative mood states such as anxiety
or depression. Now interestingly according to the research at large they pointed out something that
actually this was actually quite telling to me. They pointed out that the World Health Organization
found that physical and sexual abuse rates have fallen while rates of emotional abuse
have increased. And this is probably a combination of greater enforcement of reporting laws around
abuse, greater consequence for people who abuse children, and more overall awareness.
The realist in me would say that people are still abusing their children and finding a way to do it
that's less easy to pin down and then get reported on. The emotional abuse instead of in ways that
it doesn't leave as many observable scars I would argue that kids are still being abused as much as
they always were. Almost none of this research ever examines though the personalities of the parents.
They will document that a child was abused and understandably focus on the child the well-being
and the outcomes of the child. So we can't make a definitive statement that a certain percent of
people who harm a child also have an antagonistic personality. We know it's multi-determined who
abuses a child with factors contributing to this kind of behavior including stuff like
the parents own history of trauma, the parents own history of being abused by their parents and
caregivers, even cultural norms about parenting, things like alcohol and drug use, social causes
like poverty, and the stresses associated with all of these things, right? All of that said what we
do know about anything is personality is a constant drumbeat that sounds under behavior.
I sincerely hope someone does the research. This is not easy research to do to think about
parental personality but I would guess if someone did do the research that a significant proportion
if not the majority of parents and caregivers who chronically abuse children likely do have
some form of antagonistic personality, dysregulated, entitled, unempathic, exploitative, manipulative,
blame-shifting. It tracks and if that's the case it also makes the case that having an
antagonistic parent would not be good for a child's health because antagonistic parents, yes,
narcissistic parents are far more likely to verbally abuse their children and that means the
long-term effects in those children as they come into adulthood that these researchers were finding
in their exploration of this all of these studies. Now where the article sort of lost me and I
understand from a science perspective why they have to say this because they have to be able to
the work has to apply into other situations is to take what they have learned about childhood
childhood verbal abuse, this thing that it's a thing and it's not good for children and ultimately
not good for those children when they become adults, and one thing that these authors
say is like we have to address primary prevention. We have to stop verbal abuse from happening in
the first place and that means that the adults, the parents, the caregivers need to stop yelling
at the kids. Can that realistically happen? One could argue well hey the rates of other forms of
abuse drop so why not? Well it's complicated to figure out why the rates of those other forms
of abuse dropped and the other emotional abuse increased but again abusers are going to abuse
especially when they're antagonistic. That's not going to change and emotional abuse and
verbal abuse are all but impossible to legally punish. If the definition of child abuse were
expanded to include verbal and emotional abuse the courts, law enforcement, child services, and social
services would literally have to hire thousands and thousands more people to manage what would
come their way. It's not realistic and it's never going to happen. Certainly a subset of parents who
may not be antagonistic could be trained and taught to dial down the emotional abuse if they were less
stressed, had more support, more resources, more help. Where the hell those resources are going to come
from? That's never going to happen so let's keep it real. There's really no pathway here. Some people
talk about parent training, teaching parents that yelling at their kids is not okay, and teaching
the parents other responses. That might help in some percentage of cases but you got to get those
parents into the training. But when we sift out to the narcissistic and antagonistic parents
there's no training, there are no resources, there are no supports other than someone else coming
along and fully taking responsibility for raising the children that will fix it. We know that these
personality styles are very resistant to change. They're also very reactive when the person is
stressed and it may simply be that the consequence of other forms of abuse like for example being
punished and all those other things would happen if a parent engaged in physical violence but those
antagonistic parents are still engaging in the emotional and verbal violence which carry the
harms of all abuse and violence. And that's the rub. Antagonism and parenting do not mix.
The requirements of parenting, eternal patience, self-sacrifice, chronically putting another
person's needs before your own, constant compromise, and very high levels of self-regulation
are literally impossible for a narcissistic person. I really commend the researchers on this
article. It was a very important one. It's one that I am going to keep as a reference and we'll put a
link to a summary of it in the video notes if it's something you want to read further and learn more
about. If you're a therapist this article should be required reading and teasing out the separate
effects of verbal abuse is important. Emotional abuse is in fact a very big umbrella that takes in
a lot of territory but when it comes down to it we cannot talk about verbal abuse and frankly
any form of abuse of children without talking about antagonism or narcissism
because it is often a reason why so many of the family violence prevention interventions
may not always work especially when it comes to emotional abuse. Simply attempting to teach
antagonistic and narcissistic parents to better regulate their emotions is not something that
is ever going to happen at a population scale. Antagonistic narcissistic parents fully overtake
and overwhelm their children. They view their kids as either someone that should never inconvenience
them or make them look good or that is there to attend to the parents needs and when that child
ever expresses their own needs, wants, hopes, interests, true selves, the narcissistic parent
will either shut it down or respond to it variably. For example, show interest and then pull away when
they can't be bothered or they may say things that will leave the child feeling as though that
they're the one, the child themselves is the one who's entitled and demanding and out of line.
The verbal abuse is a subsection of the larger landscape of what happens to children in these
sorts of personality environments and the lifetime of self-doubt, self-blame, confusion that follow
all of this. It's part of that too and keep in mind that the parents don't just
have no effect just because you got older. Narcissistic parents may keep up with their
problematic behavior for a lifetime and while you have different options in recourse when you're an
adult, inside all of us as a child when we do encounter an invalidating parent, no matter what
age we are. And that verbal abuse that scared us as kids still bruises us as adults. We hold it in
our bodies and magnifies the likelihood of lots of poor outcomes. Listen, this research in many ways
is telling many, most of us something we probably already knew, especially if you survived a childhood
like this. But the more research that gets done on this, each day we may get a little bit closer
to an attempt to try to address these things at a larger level. But it also will have to, it also
means that we have to have the will to also account for the impacts of personality on these findings
and to me that's really the next innovative horizon in this kind of work. And that's another
science moment on this channel. I'll keep the science coming. I'm sort of doing some research
and really digging into it. A lot of it really is worth sharing. And one last thing I wanted to let
you know something exciting. I have a new book coming out in February called It's Not You.
Very relevant even what was talked about in this video. If you grew up with a narcissistic parent,
it's available for pre-order now. Click the link in the video description to check it out.
It takes on all kinds of narcissistic relationship. And this book is about healing. Thanks again.