THIS is why it is SO hard to end narcissistic relationships

DoctorRamani
36 followers
Jan 1, 2025
Self-future faking is kind of another word for justification, like we would see in the
trauma-bonded framework, but it involves something that will happen down the line, and it is
almost always coupled with self-blame.
I am being too demanding, they have a tough backstory, or around denial and self-reassurance.
The devil you know is better than the devil you don't.
How many of you use that one to rationalize your narcissistic relationship?
So as always, thank you to all of you who have been sending in these proverbs, and you often
give me ideas to think of ones I didn't even think of before.
This homespun wisdom, as much as it might say, well, why does she even bother?
I'll tell you why I bother, because a lot of these proverbs are sometimes good, but
also can sometimes keep us stuck.
Now, this proverb has a few variations.
Some also say it as, the devil you know is better than the angel you don't.
And the origins of this proverb range from being an Irish proverb, an African proverb,
even a line from a Trollope novel, so any of those places.
But what does this proverb mean?
Basically, that the person who you don't like, or who's tough on you, but you already
know, is better than the one you don't.
And when we use the variation that involves the angel that you don't, that even a bad
person you already know is better than having to take on and learn about someone new, even
if that new person is good.
Now, this proverb captures a main reason that many people get stuck in narcissistic relationships,
and often use as a justification for the relationships.
Basically, familiarity.
Now, let's face it.
The narcissist is the devil you know.
You may know how they will gaslight you, how they will manipulate you, how they will cheat,
lie, invalidate.
You may have your expectations ratcheted down, so even though it doesn't feel good to live
with such low expectations, at least you know the territory.
It all feels terrible, but you get it, and you know how it moves.
I can't tell you how many people in narcissistic relationships will say,
Okay, I know this relationship is absolutely unhealthy and awful, but now what?
If I go out there and start trying to meet someone new, or find a new job, or make new
friends, I am just going to meet more bad people, and at least I already know this bad person.
The idea of having to relive these processes, and make more mistakes, and experience new
hurts and new narcissists, feels too overwhelming for many people.
So they fall back on the devil they know.
Familiarity may be one of the more seductive human experiences out there.
When something is familiar, even if it is bad, we are somewhat drawn to it.
This familiarity dynamic is a key piece of trauma bonding.
When something is familiar, for example, for someone who may have grown up in a family that
was invalidating, rejected, or had an unempathic parent, it can be so easy and almost magnetic
to fall back into one of these patterns, and then justify them or describe them
as a connection you can't understand, but it feels deep.
That familiarity can get us stuck in toxic relationships.
That's the idea of the devil you know.
The devil you know is also a proverb about fear, and fear is a central dynamic
in narcissistic relationships.
The fears for so many people who are thinking of dismantling a narcissistic relationship
include the fear of being alone, the fear of being broke, the fear of not seeing children,
the fear of disapproval, the fear of never meeting new people.
So that fear can get rationalized by this proverb about the devil you know.
For me, this proverb is a chilling cautionary tale about narcissistic abuse because so many
people stay, especially in intimate relationships, because they're so afraid of being alone,
or that the narcissist will move on if they leave, or that they won't meet someone else themselves.
And then there are other variables that people bring into it.
I've talked to numerous people, especially women, who have stayed in long-term narcissistic
marriages and will then feel that if they leave the marriage, they may struggle to find
a new partner and rationalize staying in something that is terrible for their health as the devil
you know.
Another issue that this proverb raises that is so relevant to narcissistic abuse is that
it comes down to basically devil versus devil, right?
The devil you know, that's your existing narcissist, is better than the devil you don't.
And by and large, people often conceptualize that as another person, for example, or a
new person who may be worse.
But for some people, the devil you don't know may be being single or alone or cutting
off from family or leaving a long-term job.
The devil you know is a different and unfamiliar future.
Perhaps the work then is to start recognizing that the devil or the angel that you don't
know may be unfamiliar.
And the confusion and loss of confidence and loss of self-esteem that often come out of
narcissistic relationships means that many people may feel that they can't make it on
their own or be on their own or do on their own.
But let me promise you this, any day without a narcissist, even if it is a day alone, is
much better than a day with them.
We are sold so many narratives about how being in a relationship is better, that being with
family is great, that old friends are worth keeping.
Sometimes, sure.
And sometimes, maybe not.
A key focus of healing that I hold for people who have experienced narcissistic abuse is
to get good with your solitude and recognize that not being invalidated or manipulated
or gaslighted, there is nothing that feels better than that.
So while the Irish or African or whatever origin of this proverb remains unclear, whoever
wrote this or thought this unwittingly was writing about trauma bonds and fear.
The idea that I have to stay with the devil I know to avoid the devil I don't.
At a minimum, you know this.
After being in a narcissistic relationship and surviving it, you know that you have the
ability to survive it again.
So staying with the devil you know may be familiar, but familiarity is a sucker bet
when it comes to toxic relationships.
Yes, the devil you don't know may be scary, but sometimes that devil or angel you don't
know may be your salvation, whether it is a new person or better yet, just you.
That fear of being alone keeps so many people trapped.
And honestly, I think more often than not, in so many cases of narcissistic relationship,
that that devil you don't know is that idea of being with just you.
And the awakening and the healing and the recovery from narcissistic abuse is that it's
not about just you.
Being with you, that is the prize.
Now we know future faking when the narcissistic folks do it.
They say, I'm going to change, I'm going to therapy, we're going to have kids after
this or that happens, that you're going to get your raise once we get this new contract
or next Thanksgiving, we're not going to invite your uncle, don't worry.
And you know the drill, they don't go to therapy, they don't change, they stall things
that matter to you.
You never see the raise and the abusive uncle is right there front and center at the next
Thanksgiving.
But a key part of trauma bonding is when we future fake ourselves.
It's a way to hold on to hope and stay in the relationship.
It's a way to deny and ignore and not have to deal with the mess in front of us and pin
our hopes on a future day.
So what does self future faking look like?
Well, one version of it is when we do it about the narcissistic person or the narcissistic
relationship.
So we'll say things like, oh, they're going through a tough time at work.
Once this deadline passes, everything's going to be so much better.
Or I know they're working lots of late nights so we can buy a home one day.
As a way, and you say that to yourself, as a way not only to talk yourself out of their
inappropriate and shady behavior, but also connect it to the future fake.
You get two for the price of one there.
Or you might say to yourself, you know, they said they're looking for a therapist and I
know that once they work through their trauma, it's all going to be so much better.
I just need to be patient.
And I'm really a cold, horrible person if I don't give them the time they need to work
through their stuff.
So you get the double fun of self blame on that self future fake.
Or another one could be, I know that next year's summer vacation is going to be different.
I am sure it's going to be so much better.
So that's one set of future faking about the relationship.
But then there's the future faking that we do that also involves ourselves.
So we may say things to ourselves like, once I get myself some therapy, this relationship
is going to be so much better because I'm too anxious and I need to work on that.
So you get self blame plus future faking.
Or another could be, you know, I've got to do the work.
I've got to plan more date nights for us.
I just need to be more affectionate to him and just express more gratitude and then things
are going to get so much better.
Now, in this case, you are putting the future hopes for the relationship on the changes
you will make in yourself.
Now, I am confident you can make those changes.
I really am.
The problem is that those changes are not going to result in the change you hope to
see in the relationship.
Change in you is not going to change the narcissistic relationship.
But you link your changes, which are also going to take a minute as changes do, to what
you think will happen because of the self blame as well.
And that results in that type of self future faking that focuses on the change that you
make that you believe can change the relationship down the line.
It just doesn't work that way in the narcissistic relationship.
Self future faking is kind of another word for justification like we would see in the
trauma bonded framework.
But it involves something that will happen down the line and it is almost always coupled
with self blame.
I am being too demanding.
They have a tough backstory or around denial and self reassurance.
This just has to get better.
It's going to get better.
It has to get better.
Cognitive dissonance would be raised if you decided to stay in something that is never
going to get better, right?
Oh, I'm going to stay in a relationship where I want children but my partner doesn't.
Or Thanksgiving with my family always means my abusive uncle is there.
Those statements are uncomfortable.
So in order to make these relationships work, you level up the dissonance by making it about
the future.
Next year is going to be different.
But by now, you know it won't be.
To make the pieces fit in a narcissistic relationship, you make a bet about the future.
And since you cannot predict the future and hope can really muddy the waters of really
thinking accurately in terms of probability, well then what you have is that you keep making
these promises to yourself.
Once they get the promotion.
Once the kids move out.
Once we move to a bigger house.
Once your sister moves out.
Once they go to therapy.
Once they end their affair.
Once the summer is over.
Then the challenge here is that not only are you living in the future instead of now, you
still are living in a future that's never going to happen.
Yeah, I don't disagree.
Some things may change if a person gets a promotion or you have a child or whatever
the shift may be.
Circumstantial things will change.
Maybe there'll be more money.
Maybe there'll be less money, but also potentially more stress.
For example, the arrival of a new baby, miraculous as it may be, is stressful as hell unless
you are a rich person who isn't having to deal with the messiness and the sleepless
nights and it is an unfathomable level of stress if you are not well resourced and you're
doing this with a narcissistic co-parent.
So yes, elements of life can change.
Certain things will happen, can happen, but what will not change are the patterns inherent
in a narcissistic relationship.
Gaslighting, manipulation, blame shifting, rage, or difficulties with frustration, lack
of empathy, entitlement, arrogance, all of that is not going to change.
As always, if you remain in one of these relationships, you have to remain with the recognition,
not easy, but that right there is radical acceptance, or you get out, not easy, but
that right there, that's the fear of the unknown.
But please, try not to future fake yourself, because when you do that, you end up blaming
yourself more.
I'm so stupid because I believed they would change.
You are human, you love someone, you want to believe in them, in all of it, but if you
want to assess a relationship, look at it now, today, because that's the that, not on
what you think it could look like one day, because there's no evidence of that happening.
If the fundamentals suck today, then that needs to be the basis of the decision, and
odds are, the fundamentals will suck down the line as well.
Yeah, you just may be living in a different house, or have more or less money, or have
kids or not, but the fundamentals of a narcissistic relationship will remain the same over time.
You can count on the narcissistic folks future faking you.
Don't make it more difficult by doing it to yourself.
So let's talk about the fear of being alone.
Fear is one of those things that explains a lot about narcissistic relationships.
The fear of being alone, interestingly, is a key part of what a survivor of narcissistic
abuse goes through.
Being in a relationship with a narcissist is such a mind-twisting experience that you
stop trusting yourself.
In addition, relationships with narcissists can be so controlling that you can slowly
lose confidence in your own abilities.
Control in relationships with narcissists is something that is an often observed thing.
The narcissists themselves are sort of obsessed with control, and their control means that
over time, obviously, they have to run the show and you may get robbed of the opportunity
to make decisions in your own life, and there's a whole video in this series on indecision.
So at one level, the fear of being alone may reflect some of the sort of dependency that
the narcissistic relationship can bring up and a false sense of inadequacy that without
this relationship, you wouldn't be able to take care of yourself.
So despite knowing that you are being treated horribly and recognizing the need for a change
and wishing that all of this was different, the fear created by years of invalidation,
gaslighting, dismissiveness, and just generally being diminished can leave you believing that
you cannot function without the narcissist, and that's a rhetoric that the narcissist
often shares that you wouldn't be able to make it without them and they'll push that
in your face.
People experiencing narcissistic abuse, although there may be a sense of relief when it's done
of not having to endure their narcissistic abuse anymore, there's also often the fear
that after the relationship, you will be alone forever, that you will not be able to find
another partner or another companion.
And this fear can get magnified in people who believe that as they get older, that they
will be less attractive as a partner, less desirable, etc.
And that fear can leave some people just staying in their narcissistic relationship, or if
they end up leaving or their narcissistic partner should leave them, they may feel a
sense of panic, anxiety, and euphoric recall.
I should have never left that relationship.
It really wasn't that bad, that kind of thing.
If you are from a narcissistic family, the fear of being alone may be pronounced in scapegoats
who always felt they were teetering on the edge of being cast out, but also a byproduct
of the conditional love that is the narcissistic family.
When it is conditional, it stands to reason that if you don't play by the narcissistic
family rule book or playbook, they might let you go.
They may not literally put you out on the street, but they may withdraw, withhold, and
definitely psychologically abandon you.
There can be a precarious sense that always floats around when you are in a narcissistic
family system, a sense that your narcissistic parents could cast you out at any time.
And because you never know exactly what they want or how to be enough, it can be a pattern
of narcissistic abuse that trails you into adulthood.
This fear of being alone can be something that predates the narcissistic relationship,
but in most cases, this fear is exacerbated by the narcissistic relationship or this fear
comes up through you being in a narcissistic relationship.
Many people have said to me that they were independent and strong, happy people, and
then they got into this relationship and years of manipulation, control, gaslighting, all
of it turned them from a cheerful, self-reliant, independent person into a person who slowly
felt more and more dependent on a partner who was unempathic and dismissive.
The toxic combination of control, gaslighting, and devaluation can take you into a space
in which you start to wonder if you can actually take care of yourself.
Because in a narcissistic relationship, they are so good at fooling your friends and families,
not in all cases, not in all cases, but in, you know, not a small majority.
The idea of leaving a relationship from a narcissist and striking out on your own can
also feel potentially isolating and ramp up that fear of being alone because everyone
wonders why you are leaving and don't quite understand it when you tell them it's because
of narcissistic abuse or gaslighting.
So what do you do if you have this fear of being alone secondary to narcissistic abuse?
First, practice being alone and that may be difficult because of your living arrangement
or your partner's sense of control and obviously because of the nature of the world these days.
But if there's any chance for you to just be alone and see how it feels, then give it a try.
But some of this can also sort of be done inside your head.
Play it out in your head.
What would it be like to come home to an empty house?
To eat dinner alone?
To watch TV alone?
Imagine someday in the future having to go to events alone, sit at a friend's wedding alone,
go to a party alone.
There may be some feelings of anxiety but go deeper now.
Think about what it would feel like to not be criticized during dinner or not be invalidated
while you watch TV or having to watch your partner either showing off at the party while
they continue to invalidate you or complaining about the party.
Think that part through too.
If you can envision that life of some sense of serenity and peace being alone,
then you may be able to push back on that fear and remember you may not be alone forever.
Number two is my tried and true favorite.
I'm going to suggest therapy.
Chip away at the core in therapy of what is fueling your fear of being alone.
Years of being in a relationship in which someone is telling you that you are incompetent
and who has invalidated and gaslighted you have left you so confused
that you start to believe they're true.
They're not but you start to believe what they're doing and saying is true.
If your choice is a manipulative relationship or being alone, I'm going to tell you right now
that's a no-brainer from a mental health perspective alone is always going to win.
Number three, I want you to consider support groups online or otherwise.
And someday maybe in person but to bolster support and spend time with other like-minded people.
Number four, I want you to start doing something you enjoy and ideally something that gives you
and fills you with meaning and purpose and this can include hobbies, volunteering,
maybe trying to take on some new maybe even more advanced responsibilities at a job,
going to school or going back to school.
The greater the sense of efficacy which is a word this feeling of I feel like I can do this,
I can accomplish this.
That gives you a little more strength to push back on this fear of being alone.
In essence, it gives you resilience.
Fear of being alone is something that may have plagued you before,
long before this narcissistic relationship.
In fact, your fear of being alone may be why you got into the relationship
despite all the red flags and why you stayed in it despite all of the red flags.
But it may also be a byproduct of the narcissistic abuse in the relationship.
You may have gone from independent to reliant and dependent
simply within the context of this narcissistic relationship
and don't view the end of your narcissistic relationship
or maybe even distancing yourself from your family as a sentence to always being alone.
There's many people out there who believe my friends are more family to me than my family is.
There are people out there who say,
Oh my goodness, I don't think I'm ever going to meet anyone again.
I'll never be able to trust again.
And lo and behold, they meet that person who compliments them
and they recognize that there's a huge difference
between being in a narcissistic relationship and in a loving relationship.
But as I said, there is a lot of, there's almost a lot of single shaming in our culture.
Oh, you're alone.
What's wrong with you?
There ain't nothing wrong with you.
You're good.
You are not withering in a narcissistic relationship.
That already puts you ahead of the curve for overall.
But the fact is, is that for a lot of people being alone feels like a failure.
It feels like an abandonment.
It triggers a lot of old fears and all of this, this fear of being alone
very, very much gets magnified within the context of narcissistic abuse.
Lifetime history of trauma is a vulnerability factor
for a whole host of issues in life, including mental health issues,
physical health issues, decision-making.
And sadly, we know that a history of trauma is often predictive
of future vulnerability to trauma.
There are many reasons for this.
We know that trauma directly impacts the brain
and how we process information, memory, and emotion.
We know that trauma is stressful
and impacts neuroendocrine systems in our body
that affect immune function and a whole host of other health issues.
We also know that trauma happens in traumatic environments.
And a person who is in such an environment, having endured one trauma,
it's probable that they will experience more.
Now, trauma is also found to impact decision-making
and can result in more risky decision-making
that can place a person at risk for harm.
Often, this can happen because of difficulties in processing fear-based stimuli
and of issues that may be associated with post-traumatic stress.
And these might be patterns such as having what we call
a sense of a foreshortened future,
meaning that you almost think that you're not going to live a very long time
or other existential sorts of threats,
a sort of fatalistic, why bother?
Bad things are going to happen to me.
A subset of people who experience trauma may go on to develop symptoms
that comprise post-traumatic stress disorder,
which includes patterns such as avoidance,
vigilance or constantly monitoring your environment for threats,
arousal or feeling sort of anxiously on edge all the time,
re-experiencing and often thinking about,
nightmaring about or flashing back to the traumatic memory.
And above all else, lots of anxiety and also things like social withdrawal.
So in a word, trauma, not good.
And trauma can do a real number on a person's psyche.
Trauma rarely occurs in a vacuum, especially childhood trauma.
Now, while in some cases there may just be one traumatic event,
and other than that, other things in that child's life are safe,
in general, trauma for children occurs in trauma settings
that can be characterized by family violence, community violence,
neglect or societal or cultural violence.
And this can include wartime, civil unrest, discrimination, prejudice and racism.
So what does this have to do with being a narcissist magnet?
Trauma, we know it results in devaluing yourself,
especially when it occurs in childhood.
Sadly and tragically, so many people blame themselves for their own trauma,
especially their childhood trauma.
And this is work that must be addressed in trauma focused therapy.
But if a person doesn't get that help, and even in some cases when they do,
it's not uncommon for a person to continue to blame themselves
for bad things that happen in their lives,
whether as children and even as adults.
So that combination of self-devaluation, self-blame,
and a possibility of risky decision-making
makes it pretty clear why people with histories of trauma
may be more vulnerable to narcissistic people in their lives
and in turn to narcissistic abuse.
Now from the jump, a person who's experienced
chronic childhood neglect or trauma
may very well have had narcissistic and high conflict,
antagonistic and dysregulated people in their lives.
So as we said earlier in this series,
people who emerge from narcissistic family systems
are kind of already primed to be narcissist magnets.
The likelihood of self-devaluation and not enoughness
that is so endemic in people who are survivors of trauma
is exactly where a narcissistic individual
can easily manipulate, gaslight, and devalue.
Narcissistic abuse in many ways parallels the invalidation of trauma
and it becomes a sticky dance,
particularly for a trauma survivor who doesn't know about narcissism.
It can literally replay a toxic script from the past,
making it very difficult to see the red flags.
And a person who is a trauma survivor
can experience classical toxic dynamics.
When they experience that, like gaslighting,
they will blame themselves
and then be more vulnerable to ongoing manipulation.
In addition, trauma survivors may be more likely
to isolate themselves from other people
and that can make the control dynamics of the narcissistic relationship
even more potentially dangerous.
I have always held that one of the primary reasons
that people do enter narcissistic relationships
is because they do not understand these patterns
or what they're about
and that they also don't understand
that these patterns are very unlikely to change
and that they're manipulative
and can play upon earlier trauma dynamics.
Armed with that knowledge,
many survivors of trauma can learn that these patterns are real
and learn how to identify and hopefully protect themselves
when they arise in their lives.
But there's also the added need of trauma-focused therapy.
All the education in the world will not make an impact
unless a person can do a deeper dive
to understand how their trauma is impacting them into adulthood.
To impact all of that
and to also be enlightened about the dynamics of narcissism
are key issues that can be protective.
The reflexive self-devaluation often observed in trauma survivors
is a key ingredient in how there is a vulnerability
for what I call the suck-and-stuck dynamic
of initially getting sucked into the dynamics
of a narcissistic relationship
and then for getting stuck
even when the red flags are popping up everywhere.
And far beyond anyone who has experienced trauma,
let's face it,
one of the greatest vulnerabilities anyone has,
one of our most magnity elements,
is that too many of us feel as though we are not enough
and need to earn the love or the regard of another person.
That damaged inner script is what keeps people stuck
and that script is often multiplied
in people who have survived trauma.
In this particular case, therapy is critical.
While education helps,
understanding your experience and placing it into a context is essential.
Now when we talk about trauma,
we often talk about pain and loss and negative effects,
but never lose sight of what is also termed post-traumatic growth.
The psychological growth that comes from being able to see
that you are not defined by your trauma
and to build out all of the healthy parts of yourself.
I do not believe trauma is destiny
and that while trauma may place a person at risk,
it is a cycle that can be ended.
When we talk about trauma,
another question that does sometimes come up
is what qualifies as trauma?
Usually when we talk about trauma,
we talk about an event or an incident
that is beyond that of a normal human experience
and that places the person at harm
or places someone who's close to that person at harm.
So for example, a child watching a parent get beaten up would be a trauma.
The child may not be getting beaten up,
but they're watching someone they love get harmed.
But trauma would qualify as anything from physical abuse,
sexual abuse, ongoing psychological abuse,
neglect, witnessing violence,
all of these things qualify.
And so in that way,
many times people think trauma has a much more narrow definition,
but it takes in more territory than you think.
And I have to say in my years of doing therapy,
many people come in and as they sort of unveil
and slowly lift the layers of their history,
they may not even recognize
that their early history was riddled with trauma.
And as we get to the core of that,
it also helps them often understand
how they keep getting into toxic relationships.
Obviously, this is a magnetic pattern, as you will,
that has much more of a relationship to other mental health issues.
But nonetheless, it's one where I think it's why it's critical
that anyone who does have any history of trauma
absolutely needs to do the deep dive in trauma-oriented therapy.
But it also highlights why therapy is such a useful tool for so many people.
Everyone goes and gets physical exams every year,
many people do.
Getting some kind of therapy checkup isn't a bad idea either
because it may open your eyes to dynamics in your life
that may continue to put you at risk.
Thanks again for tuning in.
Please hit that subscribe button so you can join this channel
and also hit that bell to get notifications.
Thanks again for tuning in.
