Exclusive
KYLE BASS: We Are Seeing a Major US-China Financial Decoupling | Focus Talk

China Insights with Jenny
670 followers
51 Video Views·Nov 1, 2023
In recent month, we have seen Chinese Communist Party cracking down on a wide range of Chinese companies and industries from Didi to private tutoring to online gaming. These abrupt actions caused U.S. investors to lose billions of dollars.
In this interview, Kyle Bass, the founder and chief investment officer of Hayman Capital Management, argues that there is no way that one can discount the CCP risk. The U.S. regulators should start to enforce rules on Chinese companies in order to protect U.S investors. He also thinks that what we are seeing is just the beginning of a major US-China financial decoupling.
Hi, welcome to Focus Talk.
In the recent months, we have seen Chinese Communist Party cracking down on a wide range
of Chinese companies and industries, from DD to private tutoring to online gaming.
According to Wall Street Journal, Chinese companies listed on U.S. exchanges lost $400
billion in July alone.
Everyone is asking the same question.
Why is Xi and the CCP cracking down on these companies that are supposed to bring in foreign
Are we seeing the U.S.-China financial decoupling speed up?
Today we invite Kyle Bass, the founder and chief investment officer of Haman Capital
Management, to share with us his views on these questions.
Hi, Kyle.
It's nice to see you.
Thank you for coming on to our show.
Nice to see you too, Jenny.
Great.
So, Kyle, we see that this latest cracking down, and everyone is shocked by it, and it
will still continue.
Just a few days ago, we saw that the CCP announced a five-year blueprint to exert more control
on various industries.
So first, I'd like to hear your view on this.
Why is Xi and the CCP cracking down on these companies that are supposed to be the goose
that lays the golden eggs for the state?
It's really shocking to me the extent to which Xi Jinping and the CCP has gone to cracking
down on these companies.
I understood the dethroning of Jack Ma and the postponement of Ant Financial a lot more
than I understood what they did to Didi, what they've done to online education as well as
the food delivery.
But, you know, now we're seeing them go into even going to healthcare.
It looks like they're just literally going to go through all of the industries and really
crack down.
What I did notice at the same time, and you probably saw, the Hong Kong exchange, which
is now in complete control of the CCP, started talking about relaxing their listing requirements
all around the same time.
So I think Xi's intention is to raise dollars through the Hong Kong exchange and fewer dollars
in the United States, let's say directly on our exchanges, because as you so aptly mentioned
early, that the U.S. regulators are going to likely crack down harder and faster given
the losses that Xi Jinping's crackdown has forced upon U.S. investors.
Yeah, the U.S. investors certainly lost a lot.
They lost billions of dollars on these Chinese companies.
So overall, what is the overall reaction from the U.S. fund managers as far as you can see?
You know, the people that I talked to that were still bullish on China and its prosperity,
its prospects in the future, are very concerned.
Many have sold a number of their Chinese holdings and just gave up because, you know, heretofore,
what you had to do when you were kind of discounting China risk is you were discounting the fact
that you might only own a VIE structure, right, which is just basically a share in a fantasy
football game.
Right.
You don't have any claim to any real assets.
It's just a Cayman Islands subsidiary of, you know, a shell company.
So if I asked you to invest your money in a Cayman Islands shell company that carries
the same name as the Chinese company as a tracking stock, you probably would tell me
I'm crazy.
But for some reason, everybody did it.
So early on, you had to discount the fact that it was a VIE structure, and you also
had to discount the fact that, as you know, Chinese companies don't submit themselves
to call it Western style audits or PCAOB, Public Accounting Oversight Board audits,
which are, of course, controlled by the SEC.
And that changed in the final year of Trump.
However, the change was really just cosmetic because they gave the Chinese companies three
years to comply with submitting themselves to audits basically identical to that of
U.S. companies.
So this might just be Xi starting to move the ball forward on removing Chinese listings
from the U.S. market and moving them to Hong Kong.
I believe that's that's his long term game.
On top of the fact that, as we know, companies like or people like Jack Ma, companies like
Didi, companies like the online education companies, these are all different rationale
for a crackdown.
Ant Financial was that I think Jack Ma became more world famous than Xi and maybe even more
powerful and started to talk down, as you probably remember, to the CCP.
Didi is interesting.
They were worried that the Chinese cybersecurity arm of the government was very much worried
about their Western intelligence agencies being able to tap in to Didi's network and
see where Chinese people were being taken to and from.
And so they were really worried about that.
And then when you get to education and gaming, those are those are major ways to influence
the population of China that the CCP keeps under basically lock and key and under their
own purview.
So I think many different reasons for why why they're doing it all simultaneously is
just she's showing how powerful he is and maybe even kowtowing to the elders in the
party who think capitalism has become a little bit of a disease over there.
Yeah, I saw a Wall Street Journal editorial.
They gave a good reason.
I think they said this is, in essence, a way to increase the political control the CCP
has on the society.
I mean, on the surface, there are different reasons, but in essence, it's about control.
But you're an insider, and I always wanted to ask this question.
Why did the U.S. regulators allow Chinese companies to bypass the rules that other corporations
need to follow in the first place?
Yeah.
So I've gone back and read that it was a 2013 MOU that was signed by the head of the CSRC,
the Chinese securities regulators, and the heads of the PCAOB here in the United States.
So it was basically the administration at the time in the U.S. wanted to give China
the benefit of the doubt to list their companies here.
And I think their thinking was that they would eventually comply with U.S. securities laws,
even though in the MOU, China states that all of the data of all Chinese companies is
part of national security and is a national secret, and that it can't be shared ever with
the West or Western auditors.
So if you read the MOU, it's really silly.
And why we would ever give China the pass when every other company based anywhere else
in the world has to comply with U.S. securities laws, just like U.S. companies do.
And so you and I can both imagine how much fraud there actually is under the covers of
Chinese companies.
So I don't think they'll ever comply with submitting to Western-style audits.
So at some point in time, I think she's got to just move them to another exchange.
And I think this is the beginning.
So now SEC finally said that they would require more disclosures from Chinese companies.
I guess they temporarily halt the new IPOs of Chinese companies.
But do you feel this measure comes too late, too little?
Yeah, I mean, one could say $400 billion is a little late.
So the answer is yes.
I think that forcing compliance with U.S. securities laws should happen immediately.
I think the SEC Chairman Gensler should force Chinese company audit compliance with U.S.
standards immediately.
I think their job is to protect investors.
And clearly, investor protections haven't been happening, given that $400 billion has
been lost just because of a Chinese crackdown.
And then there are the losses like Luckin Coffee, right?
There's the Sinophores.
There are so many examples of collapses in oversight that could have potentially been
avoided if they were submitting themselves to audits.
So I really think that all of these things should be immediately enforced.
Yeah, I see that the committee on the present danger China, of which you're one of the co-founders,
right, sent a letter to President Biden urging him to revoke China's ability to avoid audits.
Has there been any response?
We don't have a response yet, to my knowledge.
As you know, I was one of the two signatories on that letter.
And that is very important for the SEC to protect U.S. investors from Chinese fraud
and accounting fraud.
But do you foresee the U.S. government and regulators taking more swift and proactive
measures to protect U.S. investors?
I think it's right around the corner, Jenny.
I think it's coming.
I think that this has been an eye-opening experience finally.
Now, at the same time, you probably noticed this in the last two days, the chief investment
officer of BlackRock decided that China is no longer an emerging market.
It's a developed market.
And therefore, they're recommending that investors triple their investments in China.
Wow.
Truly remarkable.
I don't know.
I don't know if you saw this.
But under the cover of Afghanistan happening, we saw a major increase from a major investor
saying these things.
So I saw something similar by Jamie Dimon.
I think he's recently said that this turmoil happened lately.
It's just life in the fast lane.
Look, Jamie Dimon and really Wall Street in general, if you look at what they've earned
from Chinese IPO underwriting fees and their Chinese businesses, it represents one of the
highest growth sectors of any Wall Street investment bank.
And it represents anywhere between, call it 10 and 12 percent of revenues in these banks.
So China's become functionally important, very important to Wall Street.
And so Jamie's saying, I don't really worry about it.
It's life in the fast lane.
Easy come, easy go.
Tell that to the people that lost 400 billion dollars.
Jamie's still very wealthy and so are the heads of all the Wall Street firms.
And again, I've said this publicly in the past, if the United States left its foreign
policy up to people like Jamie Dimon and Wall Street, we'll all be speaking Chinese tomorrow.
Right.
So there's got to be a separation between financial investment and the protection of
investors, as well as U.S. national security.
And that's got to come from leadership and the presidential cabinet.
And I hope that's coming.
Why do you think they are so confident on the long term growth prospect of Chinese economy?
I mean, for a lot of people who read into China's politics and economy every day, they
see a lot of problems.
Yeah.
Look, the Chinese banking system has had pretty significant problems over the last couple
of years.
A number of banks have fallen into pretty significant financial straits.
And now you've got one of the largest property developers in the world, Evergrande.
And Evergrande is circling the drain.
They just removed the CEO.
That has a major impact.
The leverage that's been afforded Evergrande itself is enormous.
And the unwind is really going to put holes in some of the largest banks in China's balance
sheets.
And so, you know, I think if you look at the financial performance of stocks in China over
the last 10 years, it's very close to being like, call it plus 2 percent or plus 3 percent
annualized for a 10 year period when the S&P is north of 15 percent.
Why people clamor to invest in China, given the risks we already talked about discounting,
and now you have to figure out how to discount Xi Jinping risk.
Oh, yeah.
I don't think anybody can show me a model for discounting Xi Jinping risk.
So how can anyone pay many, many, many multiples of revenue or many, many multiples of earnings
when you have to discount all of those risks?
And there's no way to do it.
It makes no sense to me.
But you know, economists like Wei Li at BlackRock are saying it's time to triple up on China
at a time in which you should be divesting yourself of anything Chinese in your portfolio.
It's mind boggling to me.
It is.
So overall, what do you think is the impact on the relationship between Wall Street and
the CCP with the latest developments, especially, I think, that the China stocks, they're not
doing well at all, even as we speak.
That's exactly right.
And I think, you know what, we all knew this was going to happen, Jenny.
You knew it.
I knew it.
We didn't know when, but we knew frauds would come to surface at some point in time.
We knew that, you know, that the model of call it Western rule of law, capitalism and
property rights and human rights is simply incompatible with a communistic regime that
tramples human rights and rules by law.
There's over time that fundamental incompatibility or clash of ideologies can't coexist.
And so I believe this is the beginning of the great decoupling between the US and China.
And I think investors are just starting to realize that the risks far outweigh any potential
rewards and that no one's going to be tripling up on China, despite what BlackRock says.
Yeah.
Talking about decoupling, I think it's something that really happens right now because the
Chinese Communist Party and the US government are doing the same thing.
They're pushing the Chinese companies off the US exchanges.
I don't know where they're going.
So, but in your view, how is this decoupling, is this financial decoupling really happening
and will it speed up down the road?
Yeah.
Again, I think this is the beginning of the financial decoupling.
I think it will speed up down the road.
I think China will have to move its US listings to Hong Kong and move it to a place where
there are much less stringent requirements on listing and on audit compliance.
And so I think it's super important for people to understand this is just the beginning of
a major decoupling.
And by the way, China's militaristic belligerence with Taiwan is next.
You've probably seen in the last few days that China is restricting the outbound flow
of passengers from Hong Kong and they're limiting people's ability to even leave.
They're limiting people's ability to transfer their assets.
So Hong Kong's basically become a Chinese police state and a trap or a prison to those
that have enjoyed democracy and freedoms for so long.
And now you really have China start talking about Taiwan.
And I think that's the next big, call it global hotspot.
And what the US just did with our botched exit policy from Afghanistan just showed China
and Russia that the US looks weak.
I tell you, we're not weak.
That was just a that was just a sequencing issue that went horribly awry.
But I think China might be emboldened and empowered to move on Taiwan sooner rather
than later.
And I think that's that's a real risk to financial markets.
You think about what the US would likely do from an economic perspective.
I think we would immediately sanction all of the SOE banks and the joint stock banks
in China, which would basically take them off the SWIFT system and make their interoperability
and their ability to move dollars around the world, it would stop overnight.
And we'd basically be we'd declare economic war on China if they ever moved militaristically
on Taiwan.
You think that will happen soon or like any minute?
I don't know about any.
I mean, it can happen any minute.
But my guess is China was really wanting to have the global legitimacy of hosting the
Winter Olympics in 2022.
I think there are many calls coming from congressmen and congresswomen and senators in the US to
boycott the Beijing Olympics due to the genocide in Xinjiang and Tibet and Mongolia and the
Chinese population by the CCP is something the world can't stand for.
So I think I actually think the Chinese government was waiting to host the Beijing Olympics next
year.
And then I think all bets are off if if if they start to understand that the world will
actually boycott those Olympics, then I think all bets are off sooner.
Do you think China can afford to financially decouple with the US?
I mean, can they afford to lose the US dollar?
What they're going to use their digital currency to survive?
That's their hope, right?
Their hope is they're going to roll out the digital currency in 2022, almost concurrently
with the with the happening in the Olympics.
And their hope is they can force the adoption of its own digital currency with the Belt
and Road countries and with anyone that engages in trade or investment with China.
So if they do that and it's successful that, you know, right now they still have a closed
capital account.
The RMB only settles about 1.8 percent of all global cross-border transactions.
And that 1.8 percent, almost 95 percent of that happens in Hong Kong.
So they're trading with themselves.
So when you really look at the RMB and you look at the Chinese currency, nobody accepts
it as legal tender for anything other than the Chinese people, because they have to.
So if their digital RMB is forced upon, again, the Belt and Road countries and the countries
that trade and invest with China and they force settlement in digital RMB, then literally
overnight they won't become a reserve currency and they won't supplant the hegemonic position
of the dollar.
However, they will go from virtually no market share to somewhere around, I don't know, 10
or 12 percent market share, which is a quantum leap in the global economy.
The question is, is how would people spend that digital RMB if they couldn't spend it
in the U.S.?
So I think the U.S. will end up banning the digital RMB.
I believe that it is the Chinese tech stack, right?
It's a digital Trojan horse.
And we can't allow that in our economy.
So hopefully our authorities at the Fed and the Treasury end up banning the digital RMB.
Yeah.
I think there are a lot of changes that happen really fast, but on the U.S. side, I think
one of the key things is to protect U.S. investors.
So do you think the SEC will make concrete steps in terms of IPOs, in terms of audits?
Because right now what they're asking is, they're asking the Chinese companies to disclose
the risks, disclose the offshore structure.
But I don't think these companies can really accurately predict or even quantify the risks
that they face when it comes, you know, in association with the state governments.
Right.
I mean, no one can discount Xi Jinping risk.
And so there's no way to put a discount model up.
I mean, you can put a disclaimer in your S-1, right, in your public filing and say, we have
no idea what Xi Jinping is going to do.
These securities could become immediately worthless with one stroke of Xi Jinping's
pen.
I mean, they could put the catch-all warning in there, but that doesn't protect U.S. investors.
We, meaning the SEC, should move to protect U.S. investors immediately and bring regulatory
challenges to China's belligerence.
Yeah.
Talking about these investors or financiers who are still bullish about Chinese market
and even encourage people to double down or triple down on China market, that's a bit
dangerous for U.S. investors.
So with all your experience and your insights, what kind of role do you think the financiers
at Wall Street played in making China what it is today?
Yeah.
I mean, I think that Wall Street is the blood that grows the CCP tumor, right?
That's how you think about this.
And, you know, when you have someone like Wei Li at BlackRock, China has infiltrated,
the CCP has infiltrated the ranks of Wall Street, the banks, the broker-dealers.
They've infiltrated the think tanks, the universities in the United States.
We know that the CCP is everywhere, and it's because of the U.S. openness, right?
But when people like Wei Li at BlackRock, who's their chief investment strategist, you
have a Chinese chief investment strategist at BlackRock saying it's time to triple down
on China when every single indicator is telling you that as a fiduciary, you have to run
the other way.
There's no way to quantify these risks, and it's reckless, right?
And it's willful misconduct to suggest that to investors.
So I think that the CCP has infiltrated so many places around the United States, and
what we've got to do is start to really understand how deep they've pushed and what their agendas are.
And clearly, you asked about Wall Street's relationship with funding the CCP.
They've put in pipes for these passive indices where you have not only do you have China's
major additions to passive indices, but you have them now being added to bond indices,
which is even larger than stocks.
So we're talking hundreds and hundreds of billions of dollars automatically flowing
to China, and they desperately need that money.
So I think we should stop that literally overnight.
Yeah, unbelievable.
I mean, it seems like some people only care about profit, and that reminds me of one thing.
I don't know if you want to comment on that, but Vladimir Lenin once said, the capitalists
will sell us the rope with which we will hand them.
Now, do you think this is an inherent problem of capitalism, or is it just human nature?
Well, the U.S. built its foundation on, you know, first the Declaration of Independence
and then the Bill of Rights.
And most importantly, I believe the U.S. functions and is known globally as the safest place
in the world and best place in the world to invest because we have something called
the rule of law, and we live by laws.
And it's why there is such confidence in our markets.
So when I think about Lenin saying we're going to give the capitalists rope to hang themselves,
he is playing on, call it, the human proclivities of, call it, greed and avarice and all of
the things that people have with their desire for money and power, but mostly money.
And so do I think that there are going to be huge income and wealth disparities?
Absolutely.
If you just look at how capitalism is defined, that's how it works.
You have to work hard to get to the top.
I think those wealth disparities have been accentuated by central banks printing so much
money.
So I just believe in the long run capitalism clearly will survive and flourish.
And as you probably know, the story ends poorly for communism every time.
There's not one instance in world history where socialism and communism promoted meaningful
economic growth and sustainable, let's say, individual human rights.
And so it's failed every time.
And it will fail again.
And China will be the world's next example of a miserable failure of communism at some
point in time.
Yeah, I just think that in the midst of all this, it ultimately falls on each individual's
conscience and moral values to counter the CCP temptations and threats.
What do you think?
That's exactly right.
Exactly right.
Okay.
Well, thank you so much, Kyle, for sharing your insights with us today.
I think we continue to see more actions to control the economy by the CCP.
You know, Xi Jinping on Tuesday said he wants to redistribute wealth, basically.
So it may have serious consequences on the Chinese economy.
Yeah, without a doubt.
And you know, the irony of him saying that is our intelligence agencies, right, the CIA,
they believe two of the richest people in the world are Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.
But I think what the hardliners in the CCP are saying to Xi, and Xi himself is saying,
is this wealth gap between the super wealthy and the average Chinese person is so obvious
and it's easy to see.
And it forces the average Chinese person to question this model of socialism and communism.
And so wealth distribution is probably a core tenant of the plan to kind of dethrone all
of these billionaires in China and spread their money around amongst some of the political
elite as well as the people.
So we'll see.
We'll see what comes.
But you sure wouldn't want to be a Chinese billionaire running a Chinese company today.
They're going to be running in short supply at some point in time.
Yeah.
And the money that they ripped, I don't think it's going to go to the poor, right?
Right.
It's going to go to the standing committee of the Politburo.
Unbelievable.
Well, thank you again, Kyle.
It's a very insightful conversation.
Hope to see you again.
My pleasure, Jenny.
Thank you.
Well, thank you for watching Focus Talk.
We'll see you next time.
