Les espèces quadrupèdes, dont l’australopithèque et toutes ces prétendus lignées ne sont pas l'ancêtre de l'homme. L'homme a toujours marché verticalement et ses ancêtres ne peuvent pas avoir vécu dans des arbres pour des raisons anatomiques, statiques et logiques. Que ce soit par le Professeur Robin Compton en 1996 ou plus récemment comme nous allons le voir par la chargée de recherche du CNRS Yvette Deloison, spécialiste de la locomotion et de la bipédie, qui avait également été membre de l'équipe du célèbre paléoanthropologue Yves Coppens.
Man walks on two legs, he is bipedal.
According to official theses, he would evolutively come from the primate,
which is quadruped, that is to say that it moves on four limbs.
Today, we will see with the help of scientific studies
why this allegation is false, and why man does not descend from the primate.
The most difficult theoretical leap for the theory of evolution
is this supposed transition of a million years from the quadruped monkey to the bipedal man.
Paleoanthropologists have tried to explain this process through multiple theories.
The most famous theory today is called the savannah theory.
The latter postulates that the size of African forests has drastically reduced
about 4 million years ago due to climate change.
Due to the disappearance of food supply, the population of primates found themselves under pressure,
so that some individuals looked for food outside the forests by venturing into the savannah.
No longer in the trees, but living in the tall grass,
monkeys would have started to stand on their two hind legs to better orient themselves.
At the same time, the spine would have risen, the brain would have enlarged and developed,
and the thick fur would have disappeared.
If today the savannah theory holds an important place in the collective imagination,
it is no longer a consensus.
At the same time, attempts by paleoanthropologists to provide a better explanation
of the passage of the monkey to man have not been conclusive.
The consensus that existed in the past is seen to be shattered by an important question
of the models used in the last 70 years.
In fact, there is now a conglomerate of hypotheses.
The tree posture theory suggests that bipedalism appeared when primates descended from trees.
The theory of food provision emphasizes bipedalism as a means of transporting food over long distances.
The theory of hand release suggests that bipedalism evolved to free hands
and promote the development of complex behavioral tools.
The mosaic theory suggests that human evolution is a combination of environmental,
climatic, behavioral and biological factors.
While more recently, the geological theory postulates that monkeys became bipedal
because they migrated to the rocky and steep reliefs of South and East Africa.
But if all these official theories explain differently the origin of man,
they all have the same view on the fact that the bipedal man would evolutively come from the quadruped primate.
However, we will see why this is false.
First of all, the idea that humans have a mode of locomotion and apprehension of the hand
more adapted to the environment is contradicted by science.
The hands of monkeys are better adapted to their specific needs than that of humans.
The hand of man is not adapted for wildlife.
What makes man superior is above all his intelligence and his ability to create with his meticulous hands.
By the way, for the anecdote, it is funny to note that by comparison,
the hand of man, being able to hold objects finely,
actually shares more resemblance with the gelada,
which is part of the branch of the cynocephalous monkeys,
than that of the chimpanzee with whom we are supposed to have a common ancestor,
and which uses the apprehension of the hand because it cannot hold objects between the index and the thumb.
But we'll talk about that later.
Bipedalism is not an evolutionary advantage,
because the quadruped locomotion mode of monkeys is simpler,
faster and more efficient than the vertical walk of humans.
The skeletons of man and monkey differ radically from each other.
Monkeys live mainly in trees and are quadrupeds.
On the contrary, man distinguishes himself by a vertical walk.
Monkeys have the ability to grasp with their four feet and hands in the same way,
while the morphology of bones and human feet clearly shows
that the foot of man was designed exclusively for locomotion and not to hang in the trees.
How could the bones of men's feet have transformed so fundamentally that they can no longer grasp?
Why, if we descend from the monkey, by adaptation,
the foot developed to grasp has not been modified in such a way as to be able to make
both apprehension and vertical walk possible?
Or is it rather, as we will see, two separate structural characters
without any link or development relationship?
Figured analogies and similarities lead to the affirmative answer to this question.
However, the data speaks clearly against it.
Those who believe in the theory of evolution claim that this type of locomotion
developed from the movement on four legs.
The thesis saying that man has always walked vertically and that his ancestors
cannot have lived in trees for anatomical, static and logical reasons
has been supported in the meantime.
Whether by Professor Robin Cropton in 1996 or more recently, as we will see,
by the CNRS research officer Yvette Deloison, locomotion and bipedal specialist
who had also been a member of the team of the famous paleoanthropologist Yves Coppens.
According to her, the quadrupedal arboreal species, including Australopithecus
and all its so-called lineage, are not and cannot be the ancestor of man.
The following excerpt is key in understanding the evolutionary impossibility
between the monkey and man.
I quote the excerpt in his book
Man does not come down from an arboreal primate, an unknown evidence.
Quote beginning
The hypothesis of anthropologists, as it was developed, among others, by Howells and Wasborn
in 1953 and 1978, and which continues to make law,
considers that man evolved from an arboreal primate
and that his regrowth would be made in the trees before going down to the ground.
In other words, that the foot of the current man would derive from a foot of an arboreal primate.
One of the first to have put forward this idea is Huxley in 1868.
Since then, all anthropologists continue to reason on these a priori
which have not really been the subject of scientific demonstrations.
Passed to the creeps of compared anatomy, this hypothesis does not resist.
In principle, no scientific hypothesis must be preserved if it is not compatible with the facts.
As for the human origin, these facts are of a paleontological and anatomical order.
Primates, like other animals, place themselves on paths that their specialization has made irreversible,
whether they are tarsiers or simians, even anthropomorphs.
For example, the tarsius has very long posterior limbs adapted to jumps.
Anthropomorphs, gorillas, chimpanzees, orangutans,
have limbs adapted to suspension and the grip of branches, both by hands and feet.
There is a direct relationship between the proportions of the limbs and the locomotion.
The values of the intermembral index of large apes are interesting to compare to that of man.
Yvette de Loison then explains that
there is a muscular-tendon system facilitating suspension,
with the impossibility of extending the fingers when the anterior limb is stretched,
and among other features, curved phalanges.
This curvature of the phalanges also exists in the feet,
which has the ability to oppose the first toe to the lateral toes,
thanks to its possibility of adduction of the luxury.
If man had borrowed one of the ways in which the hand has a role in the locomotion,
he would never have been able to return to his current state,
because the anatomical specialization never regresses.
A horse cannot recover the lost fingers during its evolution,
no more than an orangutan will want to push back its atrophied thumbs.
In the current adult man, the hand has retained an undifferentiated anatomy,
that is to say, unspecialized, neither for suspension nor for locomotion.
The foot, on the other hand, is highly specialized in human-type biped locomotion.
It can even be said that the hand is isotropic while the foot is anisotropic,
that is to say that it does not have the same properties following the same directions.
The foot of man does not have any of the characteristics of arboriculism
that we observe in large apes,
such as the regression and abduction of the first toe
joined to long and strongly convex lateral toes.
This confirms that in Australopithecus,
the arboriculistic character has developed,
while I think that man has never been arboriculistic.
For me, this is an evidence for years,
but I studied the foot of South Africa without preconceived ideas.
An arboriculist cannot give a biped, it is impossible.
In the end, current research suggests that there was no evolutionary specialization
under the form of development of specific extremities conditioned by functionality.
As in many fields,
we accept concepts and ideas that seem sensible to us
by giving us the real and practical possibility of the feasibility of these concepts.
Quadripedia and bipedia are two radically different states of nature.
De Loison underlines that the vestibular system,
responsible for the sense of balance in arboreal monkeys,
is adapted to their specific way of life
where they have to face rapid and complex movements in the trees.
This implies rotation and twisting of the head
to maintain balance on unstable branches.
On the other hand, in humans, the vestibular system is made for bipedal, terrestrial locomotion,
where stability during walking is paramount.
Sensory mechanisms and anatomical adaptations
related to balance in humans, such as vision and proprioception,
which implies the perception of the position of the different parts of the body,
differ from that of monkeys.
Likewise, the suspension of the skull is distinguished in humans and monkeys in a fundamental way
and testifies to at least two separate evolutionary lines.
The transformation of the position of the body would also require deep transformations of the entire skull,
because with the vertical walk, the center of gravity of the cranial fixation
would also have to change gradually,
passing from the edge of the monkey's skull to the center of that of man.
The occipital hole, where the spine attaches to the skull,
would therefore have to migrate almost along the skull,
because the skull of a chimpanzee literally hangs at the end of the spine
with a cartilaginous system very specific to it,
while the human skull rests on the rest of its body in a vertical way.
This notable anatomical difference cannot proceed by pure chance.
None of the many intermediate stages necessary for a successful reposition of the monkey
could be highlighted in the fossils.
So far, we have only demonstrated the presence of one of these two skull fixation modalities,
but none that is located between them and constitutes a type of transition.
De Loison notes that the muscles responsible for this function in arboreal monkeys
are adapted to suspension from branches and require a strong jaw
and very specific neck muscles.
In humans, these adaptations are not present,
because the suspension of the skull is not an essential function in their bipedal lifestyle.
De Loison also emphasizes other anatomical differences between humans and monkeys,
such as the position of the spine, the shape of the thoracic cage and the structure of the limbs.
These characteristics are in agreement with the adaptation to the biped in humans
and cannot be explained by a direct ascendancy from an arboreal and quadruped monkey.
Thus, by studying the radical differences between monkeys and humans
through the study of locomotion, apprehension, anatomy, sense of balance,
skull expansion and other factors,
we understand that primates and humans have been specialized in their environment separately from each other
and that it is impossible for us to come from them.
Because as De Loison recalls, anatomical specializations never regress during evolution.
A regression of an anatomical specialization to a previous ancestral state
is considered improbable due to evolutionary constraints and functional constraints.
Anatomical specializations do not regress during evolution
due to the principles of natural selection and adaptation.
Natural selection favors traits that give an adaptive advantage in a given environment,
while less advantageous traits tend to be progressively eliminated over the generations.
This is the famous example of the orang-outang, whose atrophied thumbs can never grow back.
Likewise, monkeys, which are quadruped species specialized in their environment,
will not be able to become bipeds, or rather to become them again.
Because according to Yvette De Loison, quadrupedy would rather come from bipedalism,
that is to say that primates that walk on four legs would have evolved from bipedal ancestors.
She explains this evolution by basing herself on several arguments.
First of all, she emphasizes that the anterior members of primates and humans
are adapted to manipulative and apprehensive functions.
They are equipped with joints and muscles that allow complex and precise movements.
On the other hand, the posterior members are more adapted to the function of support and propulsion during bipedal walking.
According to De Loison, this asymmetry in the structure of the limbs suggests an evolution from bipedalism to quadrupedy.
The author also states that the posterior members of primates are naturally more powerful
and more adapted to propulsion when they are used to move on four legs.
This observation is based on the observation of current primates and their motor capacity.
Quadrupedy offers greater stability and better balance compared to bipedalism.
The use of the four limbs allows a more balanced distribution of body weight,
thus reducing the risk of falling.
In addition, the anterior and posterior limbs can be used in a coordinated way to maintain stability during movement.
Quadrupedy also offers advantages in terms of speed, movement and energy efficiency.
By moving on four legs, primates can use the anterior and posterior limbs in a more synchronized way,
which allows them to propel more efficiently and move more quickly over short distances.
According to De Loison, these anatomical arguments indicate that quadrupedy is an evolution of bipedalism in primates,
rather than a primitive form from which bipedalism would have emerged.
Quadrupedy is more specialized, more advantageous and more evolved than bipedalism for the needs of primates.
Thus, it supports the idea that the ancestors of primates evolved from a bipedal form,
to then develop quadrupedy in response to specific locomotor needs.
Evolutionary theorists also know these anatomical differences,
but they are taken for granted by Darwinist preconceptions that still dictate the way to follow.
We understand this because in the absence of rational explanations,
discussions that would not fail to take place about their conception would be harmful rather than useful
and would show the flaws of the theory of evolution.
In addition, the evolution of the primate to the human would have required a transformation of the entire biological system
which cannot be linked to simple factors of natural selection, environment, climate, migration or mix,
because the question of locomotion involves domains too often forgotten and yet necessary.
The misleading image of a monkey that gradually gets up on its two legs does not take into account any scientific reality
and is seen to be highly criticized by paleoanthropologists themselves.