Comment parler de l’Egypte et ses pyramides sans parler d’Hérodote, surnommé le Père de l’Histoire ? Parmi les auteurs antiques ayant passé du temps sur les vestiges dynastiques de l’Egypte, Hérodote est sans conteste celui qui fait le plus parler.
Peut-être parce qu’il est le plus connu d’entre eux, mais aussi parce qu’il est celui qui mentionna une durée de construction de 20 ans pour la Grande Pyramide de Gizeh, durée autour de laquelle vinrent s’articuler les conversations les plus passionnées depuis plusieurs siècles. C’est d’ailleurs parce qu’il est un des seuls auteurs grecs à entrer dans ce détail qu’on reproche aux archéologues de lui donner tant de crédit. En effet, est souvent amené comme argument que si l’on imagine la quantité d’oeuvres antiques disparues, naturellement ou dans l’incendie de la Bibliothèque d’Alexandrie, il serait un peu cavalier d’imaginer que la vérité réside dans ce que dit UN SEUL auteur parmi tous ceux qui ont pu s’exprimer sur le sujet mais dont les oeuvres sont désormais indisponibles. Argument plutôt valable, mais aujourd’hui nous allons parler d’autre chose.
Vous verrez que c’est un Hérodote approximatif qui transpire de son oeuvre Histoires II. Doit-on lui conférer la crédibilité dont il jouit depuis 2000 ans ? Je vous laisse le soin de vous exprimer à ce sujet au fil du déroulé de la video, mais reconnaissons que même si le surnom de Père de l’Histoire lui colle encore à la peau, l’archéologie a corrigé ses approximations et n’a plus, depuis très longtemps, brandit le moindre de ses écrits comme éventuelle preuve ou confirmation historique.
Hérodote, véritable sens giratoire des hypothèses sur la construction des pyramides, fut l’objet d’un ouvrage du début du 20eme siècle dans lequel son auteur, Camille Sourdille, détaille le séjour de ce dernier en Égypte. Une oeuvre très complète dont j’aimerais aujourd’hui vous livrer les grandes lignes.
Il y a de nombreuses imprécisions ou exagérations des informations transmises par Hérodote, notamment concernant la Grande Pyramide de Gizeh. Il se place en grand spécialiste explorateur de son époque, mais il n'eut pour autant ni libre accès à leurs temples ni à leurs archives. Il n’a fait que répéter, plus ou moins fidèlement, ce que les égyptiens ont bien voulu lui dire ou lui montrer. En fait, Hérodote n'a pas écrit Histoires II au moment même où il menait son enquête en Égypte. Par conséquent la confusion dans ses souvenirs est loin d'être invraisemblable. D’ailleurs, lui-même fait remarquer que sa mémoire a pu être en défaut.
C'est par une semblable confusion qu'on peut rendre compte d'une erreur assez singulière relative à l'une des pyramides. D'après lui, la Grande Pyramide de Kheops, à la différence de celle de Khephren, aurait eu des chambres entourées d'eau, comme une île ; où l'eau y aurait été amenée du fleuve par un canal construit à cet effet.
Que faut-il déduire de cette affirmation ? Que la Pyramide de Kheops était véritablement entourée d’eau ? Oú que les souvenirs d’Hérodote se sont embrouillés mélés à quelques éléments avérés comme la présence d’un canal construit spécifiquement pour la construction des Pyramides ?
How can we talk about Egypt and its pyramids without talking about Herodotus, nicknamed the father of history?
Among the ancient authors who spent time on the dynastic remains of Egypt, Herodotus is without context the one who makes the most talk.
Perhaps because he is the best known of them, but also because he is the one who mentioned a construction period of the Great Pyramid of 20 years,
a period around which the most passionate conversations have been articulated for nearly 2,000 years.
It is also because he is one of the only Greek authors to go into this detail that archaeologists are reproached for giving him so much credit.
Indeed, it is often argued that if we imagine the amount of ancient works disappeared, naturally or in the fire of the Library of Alexandria,
it would be a bit cavalier to imagine that the truth resides in what only one author says, among all those who have been able to express themselves on the subject, but whose works are now unavailable.
This argument is rather valid, but today we are going to talk about something else.
You will see that it is an approximate Herodotus, who perspires from his work History 2.
Should we give him the credibility he has enjoyed for 2,000 years?
I leave you the care to express yourself on this subject throughout the course of the video,
but let us recognize right now that even if his nickname of father of history still sticks to his skin,
archaeology has corrected these approximations and has not for a very long time branded any of his writings as possible historical evidence or confirmation.
Herodotus, a true spin-off of the hypotheses on the construction of the Egyptian pyramids,
was the subject of a work from the early 20th century in which his author, Camille Sourdille, details the stay of the latter in Egypt.
A very complete work, which I would like to deliver you the main lines today.
And if you want me to go deeper into these 272 pages in a future video, do not hesitate to tell me in the comments.
All this to say that there is a lot to say about this subject.
There are, for example, many inaccuracies or exaggerations of the information transmitted by Herodotus,
especially concerning the Great Pyramid.
This is what we can generally blame him for.
He places himself as a great exploring specialist of his time, but he had neither free access to their temples nor to their archives.
He only repeated, more or less faithfully, what the Egyptians wanted to tell him or show him.
In fact, Herodotus did not write History 2 at the very moment he was conducting his investigation in Egypt.
As a result, the confusion in his memories is far from unlikely.
Moreover, he himself points out in the book that his memory may have been defective.
By a semblable confusion, we can realize a rather singular error relative to one of the pyramids.
According to him, the Great Pyramid of Cheops, unlike that of Khefren,
would have had chambers surrounded by water, a bit like an island.
Water would have been brought from the river by a canal built to this effect.
What should we deduce from this statement?
That the Pyramid of Cheops was truly surrounded by water?
Or that Herodotus' memories simply got a little confused to come up with a semi-blubi-bulga,
finding its salvation in some revealed elements, such as the presence of a canal built specifically for the construction of the pyramids?
We will rather opt, in my opinion, for the second option, don't you think?
Speaking of memories, we will all create new ones together and which will remain engraved in your memory for a long time, believe me.
I am of course talking about the next Egyptian trip, on which there are still a few places.
So if you want to join me and if you want to join us on the adventure and register,
you will find the information in the description of the video or by clicking directly on the little i that appears on the screen.
But the pyramids of Giza that Herodotus spoke of are not the only ones to have been mentioned.
On the west bank of the Nile, from Arbu Rawash to Meidum, passing through Dahshur and Saqqara,
over an area of about 70 km, we can count more than 80.
If those of Giza have their underground part indisputably out of reach of the infiltration of the waters of the Phreatic Ditch still present today,
it is not the same for all the others.
For example, when Gaston Maspero, former director of the Egyptian Antiquities Service,
undertook in 1883, it goes back, to open one of the two pyramids of Lisht,
pyramid where we find by the way the remains of construction ramps,
well, water spills under the work of the workers of the time.
Or when Flinders Petrie was able to enter the chambers of the pyramid of Awara,
belonging to the famous labyrinth mentioned by Herodotus,
well he found his rooms filled with mud and water.
However, we do not ignore in the region of Memphis or the labyrinth the peculiarities of this genre,
because most of the pyramids, even at the time of Herodotus, were pillaged from the pharaonic Antiquity.
If Herodotus has only described the pyramids of Giza, it is that they are the most considerable,
that he saw them up close, and that they are attached, at least we believe, to the legends he has reported.
But he has surely been able to see a large number of other pyramids, which it is impossible not to see.
Indeed, from the plateau of Giza, it is easy to see the alignment of the pyramids of Abusir, Saqqara and Ashur.
Yet he does not talk about it at all.
Even more astonishing, when he writes his work, there is a confusion in his mind.
He reports to the pyramid of Cheops what he had vaguely heard about other pyramids.
As for the construction over 20 years, however, whether it directly concerns Cheops or not,
it is a duration that has now become standard, presenting, or not once again, its limits,
whatever the pyramid to which we relate this duration of construction.
Besides, it is important to note that the chapter in which Herodotus tells us about water,
clearly shows us that the canal and the water surrounding the island he had mentioned was underground,
therefore invisible.
Herodotus therefore speaks here of something he has not seen, which makes the confusion even more probable.
We could perhaps attribute this confusion, but less likely it seems, to Herodotus' informants.
The description made by the latter of the site of Memphis, an ancient Egyptian capital,
allows us to understand that Herodotus knew this city during the cruises of the Nile,
and only during the cruises of the Nile.
However, as we have just mentioned, Memphis was the capital of Egypt,
and it is from these priests, still active then, that he most often invokes the testimony.
And it is from his old temple of Hephaestus that he knows the best the detail.
It is to this temple that a large part of the story he told is linked.
It is for Memphis, which is true, the date it provides for the beginning of the cruises of the Nile,
and it is for Memphis as well that the indication of the height of the waters is valid.
In short, it is to Memphis that he drew the greatest number of these information,
which he may have extrapolated and applied to other sites, including Giza.
If we add that, because of the geographical situation of the city,
he had to, after leaving it, necessarily go back there again,
during his journey to the south, to Upper Egypt,
we will be persuaded, the description remaining always exact,
that it is especially during the period of the cruises of the Nile that he stayed in the valley.
Thus, the data provided by Herodotus on the city of Memphis,
its site, its monuments, its gods, its history, its surroundings, are of extreme wealth.
On no other locality, he provided us with such varied details,
in none he has collected information so numerous.
During his trip to Egypt, it is therefore surely in the capital that he also made the longest stay.
Herodotus was not content to visit the only city of Memphis.
He wanted to document himself carefully on its surroundings.
He went to the pyramids, and along the way, he admired the ground
by which the materials had been brought at the foot of the work, and noted the dimensions.
He spoke quite a long time about the Great Pyramid,
and mentioned the three small ones located in front,
one of which, the one in the middle, would have been built by the daughter of the same pharaoh.
For my part, I had also made a video a few years ago
where I made you discover the interior of one of these three secondary pyramids,
in front of that of Cheops.
Here too, I put the link in the description for those who would like to see this rather exclusive immersion.
Herodotus also described the Pyramid of Khefren and that of Mycerinos,
but what is very surprising is that he did not speak at all about the Great Sphinx.
Some explain this anomaly, in quotation marks, by the fact that the Sphinx was then sanded,
as it had been often during ancient times, and as it has been many times since.
But even sanded, the Sphinx remains the Sphinx,
and this head protruding from the sand gives it an even more mystical aura
than since it was entirely sanded.
We don't really know why he made the impasse on this lion with a man's head,
except that maybe, again, he is talking about things he has not seen with his own eyes.
Even more surprising, if Herodotus does not mention this unmissable Sphinx,
he does speak, however, and several times, of limestone quarries
from which stones had been extracted for the construction of these huge buildings
and which had not ceased to be exploited.
Amazing, isn't it?
The accuracy in the evaluation of distances depends on both
the more or less great habit we have of this perspective
and the idea that we make of the size of the objects.
Under this double relationship, Herodotus had to be led to exaggeration.
Not only, as we said, his trip to Egypt was quite short,
but it was at the beginning of his stay in the Nile Valley that he began to visit the South.
At that time, according to all likelihood,
his eye was not yet sufficiently adapted to the special optics of this country
and in a way confused by an imperfect experience
and at that time, we can understand it, Herodotus was getting lost in random approximations.
There is an example that I like to give to illustrate the fact
that it is very difficult to estimate these monuments without having experience or knowledge.
During the trips to Iceland that I organize, I use a drone
and in 2021, I remember having almost lost sight of the drone which was 75 meters above me,
really perpendicular.
When I resumed visual contact at the time,
I told myself that it seemed a lot higher than 75 meters.
And yet, 75 meters is only half the height of the Great Pyramid.
It shows that these dimensions are properly dizzying,
even if we do not necessarily realize it when we are far away and we contemplate the plateau of Giza.
Or conversely, submerged by this gigantism,
we would tend to see even larger dimensions than they really are.
The tendency to exaggeration must have been all the more strong
because to this default usually added to Herodotus,
a high idea of the size of the objects, pyramids or other monuments seen from afar
and which he had to judge according to those who had been able to approach it a little closer.
It is indeed the grandiose, gigantic character of the constructions that struck him.
He stated that the pyramids are of a magnitude that exceeds any expression
and that each of them can enter in parallel with the largest monuments in Greece.
We really agree on that.
He took care to detail the incredible work they required,
but he also showed that the pyramids themselves were surpassed by the labyrinth of Awara,
himself less surprising, according to his words, than the lake of Moeris.
A construction hierarchy that in my eyes is at least unusual, not to say improbable.
We therefore understand that Herodotus, convinced to this point of the gigantic character of the Egyptian constructions,
which would not be, being the absence of precise landmarks,
or precise visualizations or ground experience,
fantasized their mass to the enormity reported in his writings.
It is therefore an approximate Herodotus who perspires from his work History 2.
Should we give him the credibility he has enjoyed for 2,000 years?
I leave you the care to express yourself now that the video is coming to an end,
but let us recognize, however, that even if the nickname of father of history still sticks to his skin,
archaeology, I mentioned it at the beginning of the video and we mention it once again to clarify things,
archaeology has for a long time corrected the approximations of the author
and has not for a very long time branded any of his writings as possible historical evidence.
Hoping you enjoyed this video, friends,
I give you an appointment on the channel for the next publication very soon,
and until then, as always, be well and above all, do not forget to keep the passion.
Ciao Ciao!