Lecture 06

IIT Kanpur July 201
20 followers
Oct 23, 2023
Hello, everyone. So, today we will talk about Value Theory, and the very introduction to
it. I am not using a text today, but a free thinking session both for me and for you about
what is value theory and what is it to value. So, we have been talking about ethics and
values in the introductory sessions earlier. So, now, let us stick to what do we understand
by value theory, and what is it to value. We as human beings or human persons have this
peculiar ability to value things. So, in a typical argument, if you look at a logical
argument, there is a premise, and then from there, we reach a conclusion, right. And,
this process is the logic of the argument. So, if the logic of the argument is valid,
then the conclusion follows from the premise. And, if the premise is true, and the logic
is valid, then the conclusion reached is not just true, but also the entire argument
is sound. But, that is the logical basis of it.
Now, why are we talking about this here. We are talking about this here, because it is
this premise, which is the core of value, right. That, the weight assigned to the premise
comes from the value one holds. So, let us make it simpler, and start from basics. So,
what is particular about human beings, is that we
value. We value between different entities, that we come across in life, between concepts,
between preferences. So, we make these preferences, and we make these values. And, these
values, which is again a separate question, how exactly do we do that. But, for now, let
us focus on the fact, that human beings do value
things. And, when we study about, or theorize on
these values, we come out to be doing value theory. Now, let us start with seeing, where
do we value, these examples of valuations, right.
Money is an example of valuation. We value, price is supposed to be a value of an commodity
in the market, right. So, how is the price of a
commodity determined in the market. It is determined by many factors, that economists
and financial experts would analyze in terms of.
So, I have come across, I have listed down a few examples of valuations, and how it takes
place in different disciplines. So, we have cases of valuations, that take place in different
disciplines or different knowledge bodies. So, to value, is to make a preference. And,
we make preferences, in the entire gamut of knowledge, that we come across, the world
we inhabit, the world that we live through. So, let me start with fundamental, what kind
of valuations we do. Valuation is a word used in
various disciplines. It is used in Mathematics, it is used in Finance, it is used in Architecture.
And, my argument here is, that valuation is something, which is intrinsic to all knowledge
claims, that we make. Because, the premise, that we hold over here, this premise, is what
core of the value, that we come across. So, we make a value choice, we make a value decision,
when we look at the premise. So, let us try to abstract it, from the way, we go across
it, in different disciplines or fields of life, that we come across.
Let us say, starting with the most fundamental, or not the most fundamental, but the most
obvious, is when, in the domain of Ethics. In the domain of Ethics, we have valuations as
intrinsic, or extrinsic, also known as instrumental. And, here typically, this is the apparatus,
with which we make sense of the world, the conceptual apparatus, with which we make sense
of the world. So, to be intrinsic, we make a value choice, between intrinsic, and instrumental,
or extrinsic. Intrinsic, meaning things, which are valuable in itself. And, extrinsic,
or instrumental, is things, which are valuable, for what they bring along.
So, for example, when we go ahead, and read about Ethics, we will look as intrinsic moral
theories, as examples of Deontological theories, and instrumentals, as examples of
Consequentialist theories. But, that is for another day. But, this is just a word, that we
come across. So, whether we look at, we value things in itself, or whether we value things,
from what they bring about. Let me flesh it out, in an example, that perhaps, is easier to make
sense in. Let us say, a politician, who is making a speech, to win votes, or to declare his or her
position to the people. Now, when the politician appeals to rights, to something, which is
intrinsically valuable, well, the politician is appealing to, an intrinsic sense of Ethics.
When, the politician promises development, that well, we look at, we will build dams,
bridges, and infrastructure, that will bring about, a development, and flourishing overall,
the politician is looking at, or promising extrinsic rewards, that it promises to do
some things, for the consequences, that it brings along. So, this is an example of,
where, that value choice is being made, by a politician, between, intrinsic and extrinsic.
However, you might question, that well, both these are important. And, as we have earlier
discussed, value questions are rarely between, the desirable and the undesirable, or in Ethics,
between right and wrong. And, rather, they are choices between, what is desirable and
more desirable, or between two competing rights, in Ethics. So, when we are looking at, two
competing rights, or two competing desirable goals, that is where, Value Theory and Decision
Making takes place. That is the tough part of, Value Theory and Decision Making.
So, for example, let us say, another one, that I have listed, is between, when we talk
about Politics, whether we focus on, Freedom or Equality, that completely. Now, both of
these concepts, are very important values, in Political Rhetory, and Political Positioning.
But, what is chosen, over the other, almost determines, the political spectrum, that you
belong to. Simplistically putting, arguments, political arguments, that choose, Freedom
over Equality, both of them are desirable goals. But, when Freedom is chosen, over Equality,
this seems to be, the right side of the political spectrum. And, when Equality is chosen, over
Freedom, that is generally, the left side of the political spectrum, the right and left,
in Politics, that you may have heard of. So, Politics has this value choice, that you
come across.
Now, let us look at, some more choices. And, the point of this exercise, is that, we are
doing here now, is that, when you look at the world out there, you should be able to
spot these value debates, in the world, that you come across, in whichever field, that
you are, we always make choices. Let us say, come to the rather drab field of Finance,
or may be exciting for many, but well incomprehensible also for many. So, here, I would say, a classical
dichotomy between, value and growth. So, how does one invest, whether one invests, to preserve
value, or one invest to make growth. Now, both of these are desirables. But, the character
of a financial decision, and thereby, the decision maker, and thereby, the corporation
making the decision, is determined by this value position, taken by the person, or the
company, or the organization. So, value and growth, are the two equally desirable values.
But, one needs to focus on either of them, to bring a character, or bring a direction
taken. Now, let us look at say, I thought of another example, Vehicles. Something, much
more down to real life, and lived experience. So, and here, I find the two variables, or
two of the many dichotomies possible, is right quality, and control. Now, many of you, who
would be vehicle enthusiast, or any of you, who is purchased a vehicle, and you would
like to make a rational decision, on purchasing a vehicle, or choosing a vehicle, you will
have to debate on, well, what criteria do you value more. And, why, and the simplistic
question that, why cannot a manufacturer make a vehicle, putting in all the good qualities
of all the vehicles out there, why is that just not possible. That is just not possible,
and here, I will share, that why, design as a discipline, or design as a study, is a very
crucial value decision making exercise. Now, let me put that, flesh this example out.
Now, if I make a vehicle, if I make a vehicle, let me talk about, let us say, the tyres. The
thicker the tyres are, right, that means, the more, the distance between the rim, and the road,
is lesser. The lesser the thickness, that is the thickness, I am talking about, the more control,
that the steering gives to the road. So, if you have typically seen, racing cars, they have,
their rims are almost, touching the ground, at the very thin wheel between, that may be wide,
but the thickness between the rim, and the road, is much lesser. Now, if you look at,
more road going cars, or commercial use cars, you will find them having a much thicker gap,
and that works as a, comforting suspension, to the car in general, and that gives it a better
ride quality. So, when a manufacturer, or when a designer has to design a product,
when a manufacturer has to make a vehicle, one cannot have all the extremes, because,
the value theory part of it, is to make, to decide the equilibrium between, equally competing
desirables, right. Ideally, a vehicle should have excellent ride quality, and excellent control.
The steering should be well connected, and well responsive to the road. But, that is sadly not
feasible, because one comes at the cost of the other. Manufacturers do try to bring out the
golden equilibrium, or try to have both of them. But, design decisions are always between these
two, desirable, but contrasting, values and extremes. So, to get, say a comfortable passenger
car, would sacrifice a little bit of control, for a plusher ride quality. A car designed,
for the enthusiast, will sacrifice a little bit of comfort, to get better road grip and control.
So, even for vehicle manufacturers, they have to make a decision there, and that is what defines
the character of that vehicle, or that particular brand of vehicle. Then, let me come with, say
companies. Now, if you look at companies, now, they also need to make this value decision here,
whether they are going to be high volume, low margin, low profit margin, or low volume,
and a niche product with high profit margin, right. Now, this is also examples that we have
seen. So, mass manufacturers will always go in for cutting down their margins, not just because
they have competition, but they plan to sell a big volume of products. Whereas, niche manufacturers
will have limited editions, and which will have few units to be sold, but will have very high
margins. So, now, the company itself has to make that value decisions, are they niche enough to
go in for a low volume, high profit margin scenario, or they would rather, they have the
scalability advantage, to go in for a high volume, and low profit margins scenario.
Now, these are dichotomies, that I am presenting, rather simplistically, for you to get a knack of,
what are the value decisions being made in different parts, or in different arenas of
life. Then, let us say, if these were two very practical examples. Now, if I come to
theorizing. Now, even theorizing is not free of values, and it is in a sense value laden. So,
as a theorist, you are a reductionist, or a non-reductionist. And, in a moment,
I will explain reductionist, or holist. Now, what is the difference here. Now,
even as a theoretician, you have a value position, you are taking a position,
that what are you looking for, in terms of fundamental answer, right. And here,
I will put in another example, that I had, which will perhaps also fit in here, is ontology,
which is process, or product, okay. These two can go into the same bracket, because this is
largely about theorizing, about thinking, about how the value laden conceptual apparatus, can
influence also, theorizing, thinking, and conceptualization. So, for a reductionist,
a reductionist would claim, that well, one phenomena can be explained, completely in
terms of another, more basic phenomena, without any loss of meaning. For the non-reductionist,
or the holist, one would like to see, that well, for the non-reductionist, one could see,
that we find, that one phenomena, cannot be fully explained, in terms of another phenomena.
There are connections, between two levels of phenomena, and reality. But, it is also,
not reducible. Let me think of an example, that will perhaps make sense of this.
Let us say, a reductionist, okay. Let us take a classical philosophical example,
about the mind-brain reductionism. So, for a reductionist, or a physicalist, who is a
reductionist, the mind can be reduced to the brain. So, that means, the mental thoughts,
and activities, that one is having, can be understood, totally in terms of the
physical and chemical processes, electrical processes, that are going on, in the brain.
So, if that is totally explicable, then you are a reductionist. The non-reductionist would say,
that well, there may be connections, and correlations, but it is not fully explainable,
in those terms. So, depending on, what is an approach, of the thinker, or the theoretician,
the theory is likely to take an orientation, like that. Now, look at Ontology. Ontology,
also has the distinction, between process and product. So, when we look at process,
process meaning, that when we look at, say, a wave, a wave of something, is like a process
happening. Whereas, product is, when we look at, in terms of fundamental entities.
So, let me think of a simpler example. Let us say, when we look at, or the Buddhist example,
perhaps, that can make sense of it, the Buddhist and the Upanishadic example. So,
for the Upanishadic example, the self is a product, or is an entity, right. This will be,
the Upanishadic example. And, this will be the Buddhist example, where the self is merely a
process, a process of cognitions, that are happening, repeatedly, one after the other.
So, Ontology means, the minimum level of, minimum existence, that a system postulates. So,
process or product, right. So, Ontologists also, or thinkers, have to make a choice,
between process and product. Now, let me come back to something, a little more interesting.
Let us say, architecture. That is also, where an architect, or a designer, has to make a
classical choice, between form and function, right. So, I am presenting them as binaries.
Because, even though they are contiguous, one has to make a choice, between going one way,
or the other. So, when we look at form, when architect has to decide, whether the form is
going to be, the primary function, primary object. That means, the beauty of the building,
that comes forward, is designed, or how it plays a role. And, you can see this, causing a hell
and heaven of difference, between different models of architecture. Sometimes, function
is sacrificed, to preserve form. Sometimes, form is sacrificed, making really ugly buildings,
but very functional buildings. So, somewhere, the architect, the planner, has to make a choice,
between, calibrate, between these two extremes of form and function. Of course, they are contiguous,
that I mentioned. Because, it is not that, one is in isolation of the other. But,
how one calibrates the equilibrium, between these two extreme, is an example of, how value
theory takes place, right. So, looking at these examples, now, I want to urge you to think,
of where you find, in the day-to-day world of existence, you find, these value debates embedded,
right. So, you can look around, and think of situations, where value decisions are taken.
Say, if you look at, look at the epics, okay. So, Vibhishan has to make a choice, between justice
and loyalty, right. Or, the classical choice, between loyalty and honesty. Now, both of them
are equally, or both of them are cherished values. But, one sometimes, has to make a choice between
the two, whether to be on the right side, or to be loyal to one's own, kith and kin. So,
this is an example, that plays out in real life, very often. A businessman, a manufacturer,
a teacher, all of them have to make, say, impact versus sustenance. So, to have, these are again,
two variables, that you can come across, that well, making an impactful learning session,
vis-a-vis, making a more sustainable learning session, that has a higher retention rate.
So, the world can be seen, in terms of classical binaries, and dichotomies, of which, we need,
our value decision apparatus, to arrive at an equilibrium. And, that basically,
defines the character, of the decision being taken. So, when we look at, any decision made,
or any organization, or any collective, we can understand, and back calculate, the kind of value
thinking, that has taken place in its background. Let us say, look at the Indian Constitution.
The Constitution plays significant emphasis, on fraternity and community. So, if I may,
propose an analysis, that the Indian Constitution, comes across from the Indian ethos,
of communitarian, of celebrating communities, and therefore, tries to incorporate, or preserve,
the communal role of individuals also, vis-a-vis, say, a constitution, that may celebrate the
individual liberty, over any community association. So, and that defines, the kind of Constitution,
it is. So, value thinking, or value theory, takes place in every domain of life. And,
the point of doing this course, or engaging with this, is to first and foremost, identify,
where you see, a value choice has been made. If you look at a policy anywhere, the policy also,
reveals a value choice, that has gone behind, in building that particular kind of policy.
So, I leave you now, with this thinking, and urged to explore, look around your human world,
and inhabited world, and find, where you find value debates, or identify value debates,
that have taken place, and have resulted in policies, or characters, and organizations.
Of course, this can also be an introspective exercise. Because, we ourselves, as individuals,
are value making, conceptual value making apparatuses, we define our personality,
our character, comes into being, by the kind of value equilibrium, we choose to be in. So,
we choose to be patient, or we choose to be impatient, we choose to be, whatever the
extremities of human behaviour. And, it is not necessarily, always a binary, between two
characters. But, it is a game of multiple values, of which we choose an equilibrium. And,
that equilibrium, in that way, defines the kind of person, that we are. The same thing,
would also apply to organizations. And, we also, revise these over time.
So, the first exercise, for a moral philosopher, is to identify, where are the value debates,
around. And, what is the value thinking, that has taken place, to analyse retrospectively,
the value debate, that may have taken place, in any policy, or any institution, or any
organization, that one comes across. So, to sum up, let us look at, value theory, as something,
which talks about values. Values, which is something, very peculiar, or foundational,
to human beings. And, valuation exists, in different disciplines. Right. Stock market,
also makes a valuation. A valuation, is assessing the qualities of an, say, a share, or a stock. So,
valuation, is something, that takes place, in a lot of disciplines. It is a center, of how,
we weigh in the premises, in an argument. Right. So, please go ahead, and try to identify,
value debates, value thinking, and value theories, that come across, that you may have come across.
Thank you.
