Il Sistema Sanitario Nazionale (SSN) è davvero al collasso? L' assistenza medica e chirugica ai pazienti è sempre gratuita, adeguata e disponibile in tempo utile? Come far fronte alla fuga di medici specialisti in medicina e chirurgia dall’Italia? La sanità pubblica sta veramente diventando un “business della salute”? Sapevate che in molte aziende ospedaliere la temperatura dei reparti è stata diminuita fino a 2 gradi per ovviare al caro bollette?
A queste domande risponde la Dott.ssa Mirka Cocconcelli, specialista in Ortopedia e Traumatologia, nell’intervista rilasciata a affariitaliani.it (http://affariitaliani.it/), (http://affariitaliani.it/) che leggo e commento in questo video.
Riporta la tua esperienza e dimmi cosa ne pensi nei commenti!
Hai domande su casi personali? Vuoi entrare nella community di scambio informazioni ed esperienze con studenti, specializzandi e tutor di tutta Italia? 👉🏻 https://www.patreon.com/albertomoltenimd
Health in collapse because we are condemned to not take care of the hard truth
Today we will read and comment together this article that you pointed out to me from affariitaliani.it
Why can it be interesting? First of all because an orthopedic colleague is interviewed, Dr. Mirka Cocconcelli
and then because from the subtitle, let's call it whatever we want, being an online artist
I liked the fact that it is said, beyond the we are no longer people but products that will be explored I think in the article
that if people will not do anything, they will be condemned to no longer have a cure
So, compared to the usual catastrophist article, first of all, a doctor who lives the health system every day speaks
and then points the finger directly towards people, that is, instead of saying, ah, the system here, there, up and down, no
he says, if you, we, don't do something, everything will go to prostitutes, let's put it that way
So, let's not waste any more time and let's start
Article by Antonio Amorosi, this is the colleague
Travolti dalla fuga dai medici, soldi buttati e vertici che non pagano mai
Oh, oh, finally it is said, vertici che non pagano mai
Direttori generali sono sempre in linea con gli obiettivi, la dirigenza fa sempre tutto in maniera perfetta
Direttori sono assolutamente i migliori possibili, non potrebbero modificare di una virgola
Let's see, let's see, this article already inspires me
Come stiamo trasformando la sanità italiana in una macchina da soldi che non cura più i pazienti?
Domanda, sono anni che lei parla di collasso della sanità italiana e?
Sono una Cassandra inascoltata
Ti capisco, sorella
Sto assistendo in potenza il crollo, giorno dopo giorno del sistema sanitario e noi sanitari siamo spettatori inermi
Verissimo, c'è proprio questo senso di crollo, è come essere su una nave di cui sei, non so, marinaio
E ti rendi conto che si sta andando contro iceberg sempre più grandi e che si continuano a prendere
Ma il capitano non sterza, non vira
We have seen everything in these years, from the embodiment without sense of departments to the radical cuts of staff
To the reduction of already sufficient services
Yes, absolutely, there are really scandalous departments
But, I mean, one thinks, eh, no, because he doesn't have his own department anymore
No, because putting together certain, so to speak, types of patients is not good
I mean, you can't put a patient with a certain pathology with another
I mean, you learn from elementary school, you don't mix carrots, potatoes and zucchini
And you say, ah, but it's to save money
No, because if you put a patient next to another patient, who may have infected wounds, etc., etc.
How much does it cost you if the patient is also, in quotes, healthy, if he is sick, in terms of antibiotics, lost work time, health, etc., etc., etc.
Then one says to me, no, we have done these calculations and it is fine like this, I take note of it, but it doesn't seem to me that they are done in all cases
However, it has the reduction of already insufficient services
Exactly
In the years, no political decision-maker has even managed to pass a balance sheet law that contrasts dis-economies and waste
Great point this, because it's not just a matter of spending on something
So not only is it cut, but it is not optimized, which is worse, it is a double waste
So, in a world governed by logic, as I would like, the cut should be successive or at least contextual to a reorganization in terms of efficiency
That is, it is not enough to say, ah, we no longer spend 10, we must spend 8, but it should be, we spend 10, but let's see if with these 10 I can do more
Wait a second, is this content useful to you?
I would like to bring you many others, but to do so, you need a lot of resources, tools, time, video makers, graphics, programs, etc.
What you can do right now is support this project by offering me the equivalent of a coffee at the link you find below or by entering the community
Everything will be used to bring you more and more content
You can also subscribe to the channel, like and share this video
In this way you will make us grow and you will allow us to collaborate with increasingly important realities and therefore bring you new content
So you can do a lot for this project
So let's not necessarily demonize the desire to earn both from the private sector and from the state
I mean, I'm not against this at all
The problem is how to get this, that is, that is the focal point
So it's not a speech against wealth, profit, things, no
It is a much more logical and rational speech, more, if we want, colder, but much more adherent to reality
We are at the point that in the operating rooms colleagues find oriental scalpels that do not cut
I can absolutely confirm it
And this goes back to the reasoning we had done before
That is, the scalpel costs 10, perfect, it's too much, I do the race, the company that provides me with scalpels that cost 7 wins
I, as an administrator, am super cool, I saved 3 for each scalpel, great, I'm a genius
Dear surgeon, hold the scalpel
Eh, but it doesn't work, it doesn't work
Yes, let's think about electric scalpels
The tip that doesn't work, the cable doesn't work, you waste time, look, wait, turn, reset, the column doesn't recognize the tool, all these things here
And then at a certain point, after two times, it doesn't work anymore, you have to change it
Ok, so before it cost 10, now it costs 7, it's a pity that you have to use 2, and then you spend 14
But according to you, someone will say, dear administrator, on paper you saved 3, but in real life you wasted 4
You answer, eh no, eh no, absolutely, I did the band, the race won that, eh, so
The laws, the government, the world impose this to me
But why instead don't you listen to the surgeon?
Eh no, eh no, because the surgeon, you know, can receive the mallet, can receive this, can receive that other, etc, etc
It's not a transparent dynamic
Who knows why, however, in the private, where it is convenient for the private, attention, because this discourse in the sense of the side is dangerous, but it's just to make you understand
On everything that is technological, innovation, etc, you are much faster
And not even having to answer for the question of the business we were talking about before, eh, if you manage the purchases, do something like this, you answer immediately
And then, here, biosimilar drugs are imposed that do not have the same effectiveness as the original
Tell me, what is this?
You are perfectly right, now I made the example of the pistols, but I make practical examples
The patients with a serious heart failure, they said that there is a whole important speech to make, from the pharmacological point of view
But changing a drug compared to another totally changes the outcome
Then this is obviously an extreme speech to make a point clearer
But the fact that really the administrators and the administrators are based only on certain criteria
That then have little discount in the real world and that do not respond substantially never to the damage from inefficiency that create the system
Well, these, sorry, are facts
And I challenge anyone to prove me wrong by bringing me concrete cases
Instead I would be very happy to be slandered, and attention
If someone told me, look, in this hospital this case was made, it was won like this, they realized that, and so it is ...
Well, I say, well, great
And the administrator who is busy taking care of this part, etc., etc., etc.
He answered in the first person, I would say, well, great
But I don't think I've ever read such a thing
She said, there is an emergency ...
By the way, she said where, I would also be curious to hear this colleague, I will begin to follow him
There is a decennial emergency, medicine has become business
We are subject to visit the sick in 10-15 minutes
When a disabled person, an elderly person, a claudicant, a traumatized person
It takes 10 minutes just to reach the operating room door in the bed
Very true, here, this thing, here
Let's get into the experience of the colleague, then maybe I'll make some additional comments on this
It is a classist society in which those who have the money take care of themselves and those who do not have it struggle to take care of themselves
Yes, I partially agree with this
That is, it is objectively true that those who have the money have greater possibilities
I don't push myself to say better care
Surely to be able to choose the healers, absolutely
And certainly to have the privileged paths, this is true
That makes it difficult to heal, the point is probably that it is more difficult to have a linear path, this is clear
A public or accredited specialist can cost less than a pedicure
Here, yes, this is true
The work of the healer who deals daily with patients has become like Chaplin's modern times
Englobed in a chain of editing
Yes, yes, yes
They have to explain to me how I can perform a care centered on the person
Listen to the story of the patient in just 10 minutes
Exact, perfect, linear speech, true
The patient has become an organ
Wait a minute, let's explain this passage a little better
Because in reality the point is the following
That is, let's put it in a bit brutal way, but to make it clear
The hospital buys my time, ok?
I say, perfect, today dear hospital I give you my knowledge
I do the visits in the operating room for you
And then you give me the visits
Perfect
How long does each visit last?
10 minutes, 15 minutes, 20 minutes, you decide
Ok
So you, hospital, pay my time for, I don't know, 3 hours?
Ok, I do a 3-hour operation
So how many patients can I see?
I shoot
15 patients
Ok
But I have to stay 15 patients in 3 hours
I can't miss
Unless, as happens regularly, I miss at my disadvantage
That is, all the time I spend in the operating room
Is time that I give to myself or to other patients
So I, who am one, who am limited
I can't double myself, I can't do two things
I have to be phenomenal and be able to visit
Finish everything in time
Also because maybe in the operating room I'm not alone
There is also the nurse
Who can easily tell me how often it happens
Not for anything else, but because we may talk about this
It's a slightly different thing
I finish at 4pm
If she manages to finish at 4pm, I'm there
If she finishes after 4pm, I have to timbre, I have to go away
My time is over, it's done
So maybe the operating room that already can't finish at 4pm
For various reasons, patients
I mean, it's not that they have the timer
They go, so even if you try to direct them
To be efficient, to ask targeted questions, etc.
But maybe they can't stay in time
Maybe there are more complex patients
Maybe, as it happens regularly
Patients are added to you
I mean, it happens very often that you go to the club and they call you
While you are visiting
Hey, look, there is this patient who has an emergency
But can't be seen
What do I do?
Do I put it as an extra?
At least put it as an extra
And so you go well beyond your schedule
What does it mean to put it as an extra?
It means that basically
You make a visit, paying the same ticket
You see it more
So you work more
Because if I had to make a visit in that hospital
With what timetable
I would have had to go to Intramenia
Or the free live profession
And so instead of paying the ticket
25 euros, 36 euros, whatever it is
I would have had to pay 150
And doing that, maybe I do a damage to myself
Indeed, without maybe, I do a double damage to myself
One, I finish later
So I use my time even more
To do something that no one pays me for
Two, maybe that patient wanted to see him in Intramenia
That I remember, I made some videos about it
Intramenia is outside of your work schedule
That is, I finish my work schedule
And instead of deciding to go for a walk by the sea
I dedicate my time to an extra ambulatory
So let's also talk about these things
That are important because everyone says
The waiting lists here, the waiting lists there
But the waiting lists are the result of this
That is, that the hospital has requests
But, by the way, about what I was telling you
About the fact that the nurse
Has to go
In addition to the personal choice, which is very right
Because it is correct, sorry
If you realize that you are a worker
And your work goes from 8 to 16
If they constantly told you every day
No, but you finish at 17, 18, 19
What would you say?
You would say, but what an example it is
To be a doctor or a nurse
Or any health profession
It's a mission
So what does it mean?
Your schedule, you are paid from 8 to 16
But it is correct that you stop
At least until all the patients have been seen
Is it correct?
When I have to stay with my family
So when they ask me for rent
To maybe work near the hospital
Where I spend most of my time
I can answer, but I have a vocation
I should stay here for free
And when I come to your store
To buy things, I tell you
Oh well, but I have a vocation
One day you will need me
Or when we are parking
We have to go somewhere
And you are in front of me
In traffic
You let me pass because I have a vocation
Or you leave me the parking
Because at least I optimize the times
I don't like it
But it would be absurd
I mean, we are no longer in the 800
But how absurd
The request to eat, live, sleep, etc.
For free
It is also absurd
To use this vocation
And say, you are paid to do a certain type of work
But you have to do double, triple, quadruple, quintuple
And I know it is hard to digest
But this is the reality
And I was telling you that
The bullshit
Is that the doctor is a medical director
So basically
If I have to finish the things I have to finish
I stop 6, 7, 8, 10 hours more
It doesn't matter to anyone
While for the nurses, who are not
And they have to stamp
They have to justify if they stop more
And this is a genius trick
To be able to say
Doctors basically don't have schedules
I'm a bit more rushed
Because otherwise we would never finish the article
But I have to say, great
It touches on some really interesting points
The patient has become an organ
The doctor, the nurse, the social worker
Will be replaced by telemedicine
Yes, no, I don't think so
In the immediate future
But in this way we are condemning entire generations
True
To manage the patients we need above all empathy
A feeling that can be timed
As you can manage it with severe or terminal patients
The answer is
You can't do the things I told you before
Always go beyond, etc, etc
But this, with time
I assure you that it is wearisome
Very wearisome
And so we explain the burnout, etc, etc
The truth is that health
Has never been at the center of the political agenda
Of the various governments
Very true, very true
No one has ever said whatever it takes
We will make it effective
At any cost
No one, never
We will make it impossible to treat people
Politicians have understood
That we have to deal with humans
And not with serial numbers
I visit the patient, I don't have the disease
But now there is the PNRR
Yes, but in reality they understood it very well
And that
How to say it
They fully exploit it
They understood very well that it has to do with human beings
And that you are human
And therefore to want to be logical
You should say
Dear patients, I finished my shift
You go home
And get ready
If you want, there is a free profession
If you want, there is another
I don't go on, have a good day
Stimbro, ping
So it should be
In a logical world
But you see
There is this total discrepancy
Between what we should do
That we know we should do
To be able to change things
And the impossibility of doing it
For the good of the patient
But this is a very astute vicious circle
That is
There are things that do not go
Things are not done to change them
Because we have maximum respect for the patient
We do everything for the patient
Who should change things
Is aware of this
Things go wrong, but they are not changed
PNRR therefore
That dedicates very little to health
During the pandemic
PNRR
In fact, I wonder who allowed
That the health quota was only
8% of the PNRR
Then now here, ballet of figures
But the concept is
Good that you make the comparison
22%
For digitization
Which can go well
Doing charity is wrong in these cases
But you have to be
Rational
That is, if you arrange
And manage to organize a system that
In perspective costs you more than everyone else
You have solved the law of Pareto
It should be banal, but not
In her I feel a deep bitterness
He is right, there is no point in fighting
We are fired
Because the productivity of a health care worker should be
Evaluated on the quality of the care provided
And on the results obtained
Not on the number of patients visited per unit of time
He is right, however
For example, she is orthopedic
The free profession can do a lot
Let's do the math
Ok, I'm orthopedic
Very well
I'm going to do a course at my expense
To treat patients better
Be more efficient
Etc.
I save a lot at the hospital
I'll tell you how it works
You have to get to know the course
So if you do it on time
And it is something optional
You have a maximum of 8 days
8 days per year
To be able to train
Ok
Of these 8 days
It depends a little on the company
But in general you really need to fill up kilos of paper
And what you usually do is
You take the holidays
I take the holidays to train
Okay, I invest in myself
Perfect
But who earns us?
I?
If then this
The free profession
If instead
The hospital
In terms of efficiency
Efficiency, quality, etc.
Do you think the hospital recognizes me?
But it depends
If I have a primary school that is spent for me
It could make me recognize career advances
Etc.
But they are infinite compared to how much I save at the hospital
And compared to how much
I invested in the first person
Therefore often
In the public
It is not worth training
Because you go and do your things
You're done
Why do I have to do
Look, I'm looking at it right now
Courses
Take 4, 6, 8 months
Instead of going to the sea
I have to invest to go
Move
And for the hospital
It does not count a tube
Or to make it count
That usually a course
Even 1 or 2 days
Quietly are 4, 6, even 10,000 euros
That is
I invest 4 months of my salary
For what? Yes, I can also invest them
But I have to see a prospect
And if this prospect is not there
It is useless to upgrade
The patient in the center says the slogan
Of every government we have had in recent years
Yes, in the middle of a disease of services
Heavy
When a hospital company
Will cut bills that cost him three times
What he paid a year ago
What do you think he will cut?
The answer is easy
The services already collapsed
But in your opinion
Can they lower the temperature by half a degree
In the intensive care unit
Or in the operating room
The emergency situation is already dramatic
With waiting days
Even in big cities
Let's see what he says
I worked 15 years as an emergency doctor
There are no funding
No means, but only massacring shifts
Lack of specialized staff
Unpleasant holidays
Lack of gratification
Would you be cured by a doctor
Who has been working incessantly for 24 hours?
I don't think so
All directors should try this experience
Only to understand what it means to struggle
Not to work
But to struggle
The place often narrow
With chronic services
To get adequate assistance
That's it
That's the real world
Do you only talk about the negative of this world?
No
This is the reality
If we want to talk about unicorns
Vocation
We all agree
Of course this is the job I chose
The job I want to do
But not talking about these problems
Is a damage
That I do to the patient
This effort to talk about it
To spread it
Is fundamental
And we shouldn't do it in a hurry
It should be something
That the national media do
There are no more doctors for hasty choices
Made in the past
Doctors now escape depressed
Frustrated and without motivation
Because there is not even the hope of a small change
Recently I had a news
That was awarded by directors
Look, I hadn't read it
I said it at the beginning
Recently I had a news
That was awarded by directors
With about 30.000 euros
For the achievement of the goals
Goals that
In addition to the 150.000
Of fixed salary
You see when you want
The money is found
Probably the goals
Are goals that have put themselves
And this is the absurd thing
That the goals if they choose them
It's crazy
It's madness
But I wonder, these awards are linked
To the recent escape of 11 doctors
From the PS of Reggio Emilia
Or maybe they are linked to the 11 units
Escaped from the PS of Rimini
Or maybe for the PS of Rimini
It went recently in tilt
As reported by the local daily
Here, this is fundamental
I mean, you director, you should explain me
Why there is a bleeding of doctors
From your departments
This you should explain me
Other than giving them the bonuses of this food
Eh?
Because with 30.000 euros of bonuses
Give them to the doctors who work
Give them to the staff
Who works
Or, I absolutely agree
In giving bonuses
To those who manage
And manages to make me save
But beware, they make you save
As I told you before
I mean, I buy something
Instead of 10
But that thing is worth 4
And they answer, no, they don't answer at all
So, dear director
Explain me why nobody wants to come
To work in the structure you manage
Maybe because that structure sucks
For those who work there
Eh, but it's a structure of excellence, etc, etc
Yes, but if it wants so much excellence
That the doctors have a very high turnover
And why do they have a very high turnover?
Because they arrive, they see, they understand
That it's not possible to live there
They make sacrifices for a few months, a few years
In order to bring home some information
And then they say to you
Hello, hello, greetings
Here, explain me that
Will he have known about the assumption of Cuban doctors in Calabria?
Will it happen also in other regions?
Yes, it will happen
With Argentinian, Albanian doctors
In the autumnal silence of the government
Of the minister Esperanza and of the various parties
Maybe parties, yes
But for the Augustan fairs
Great, mamma mia, great
I propose to replace everything
In the health management
Or
I propose to replace everything
In the health management
Obviously not at the level of management tasks
With general directors
Cuban, Albanian and Argentinian
Health managers
Non-contracted
Well, understandable
Doctors run away from hospitals
Because they are enslaved by chosen choices
Very good, mamma mia
This health transhumanity
Will involve wage dumping
So what should we do?
It is not easy
There is a manifesto of political management incapacity
At every level
Meanwhile, we must instill hope
In health workers and patients
Things can change
But if we continue to invest billions
In desert cathedrals
Like the 1,430 houses of the community
435 community hospitals
611 territorial operating centers
Full of new electromedical devices
Of high technology
Without the staff
That makes them work
We go in the opposite direction
The president of Agenas said
That 30,000 nurses and 10,000 doctors are missing
While in the last three years
The SSN has lost
About 21,000 medical specialists
And from 2019 to 2021
They abandoned the hospital
8,000 white shirts for voluntary admissions
To which 12,665 pensions are added
So
Look at the numbers
Of those who left
21,000 people
Who say
Hello, stay here
Because I can't take it anymore
What to do then?
Rethink the system
And take care of people
Not only diseases
Because the patient is a unicum
We take care of men and women
Not objects and inanimate objects
At the decision-making peaks
It is essential to hire
Competent leaders
And not appendages of local politicians
And if these directors
Are not adequate
They must be sent home
Good
Say it, write it
They must be sent home
People must fight for this
For a health as a fundamental right
Of the individual and interest of the community
Article 32 of the Constitution
Ok
Not for the latest iPhone model
Otherwise you will be condemned to have two health
One of series A for the rich
And one of series B for the poor
Are you happy?
I don't, the same goes for the governors
And the health ministers
Too...
Good, good, until now
I removed the first part, it is impractical
The second, I completely agree
Too interested in doing propaganda
Occupying the media to hide
Their own management
If I had seen one who said
I was not able to do this
One, I swear
Even if there was the most incapable
I would vote for it
No, let's not exaggerate now
But you understand
Show us the real numbers and not the propaganda
Or let's say
We want to see the numbers
The real numbers
Not the one I spent
7 instead of 10
I don't want to spend 7
It takes me a long time to spend 14
Gioppini
They are smart
And they are eating us
They are the ones who are eating us
It would be necessary to transform the negative realities
Of suffering, stress and pain into positive
Enhancing the health organ
Returning to that passion with the capital P
Exactly, not vocation
Good, good, good
Not vocation, but passion
For the profession
Which is the same initial
Because being a doctor is not a vocation
It is a profession
For the profession, the cure
There was a time
I don't agree
It is right to go forward
It is right to modify certain things
Today the patient
Is not like a time
When he is hospitalized for 20 days
To do everything
You also have to think about efficiency
Efficiency
And efficiency
But
Health should not be
The slave of business
The point is
It is fine to do business
About health
I am not against
The principle
But the business
Should not be at the expense of health
They are two things that can go in parallel
Health can win
But never the business
About health
For the profession, the cure
There is still a lot of time
Listening time, anamnesis,
Consultation time, is the time of cure
Let's say it
The time of anamnesis, of consultation
Is the time of cure
And it should not be timed
This is a bit extreme
It can't be that a visit can last
Even 5 hours
No
There must be the right compromise
Even just to delay the waiting times
In the IPS, you could introduce
Volunteer staff
Who illustrates who is doing what
I made the video
On this by the Caring Nurse
You can find it on the channel
Who is doing what
Even just to alleviate the useless suffering
To the family patient
If the health care workers are few and demotivated
Who is able to adequately listen
To the needs of the patients
The care worker is part of the care
And without listening, the care becomes a chimera
The hospital has become a place of suffering
Frustration and pain
Not only for the patients waiting
But also for the health care workers
Who work and as soon as possible
They will be fired
Because they consider the situation
Unchangeable and unmanageable
These are holy words
And it is a real picture
Of the Italian situation
From north to south
We have to hire smart people
And give them orders
It doesn't make sense
We have to hire smart people
So that they can tell us what to do
As Steve Jobs used to say
This is also a very literal thing
It's not that if they hire me in a place
I go and say
Dear CEO, you have to do this
No, it doesn't work exactly like this
But this point is correct
And what is written
In these lines
Unfortunately
I use it as a
Closure of the article
Because it is the reality
A little sad, a little very sad
Indeed it should scare us
But we don't care
Because we have other problems
This is one of the main problems
But in my opinion
Spreading awareness
Is a fundamental thing
I thank you for your attention
I remind you of the importance of subscribing to the channel
Like, share this video
In groups, chats, etc.
And look in the description
How you can join the community and support the project
I thank you for your attention
And I'll see you in the next video
Bye