Is the U.S. able to defend Taiwan in a multiple-war situation? 2023-10-22 02:25

Lei's Real Talk
1.5K followers
The Taiwanese have been subject to a "U.S. skepticism theory" from the mainland, which is part of the CCP's cognitive warfare to sow discord between the U.S. and Taiwan. After the Middle Eastern crisis became major news, more people question whether the United States can still defend Taiwan when the Americans are embroiled in multiple battlegrounds. Let's hear two experts' take on this.
1. Is the U.S. able to defend Taiwan if multiple wars break out?
2. How has Israel helped China develop military technologies?
Sign up for my emails: https://leisrealtalk.com/
Donation: https://donorbox.org/support-lei-s-real-talk-support-lei
Ideas/Suggestions: [email protected]
#leisrealtalk #chinataiwan #ccp #israelhamas #uschina #middleeast
okay hi everyone happy Saturday it's l
Satur Saturday Night Live all right
we're going to talk about politics all
right for Saturday night
entertainment um actually I said last
time that uh I have I have saw some very
good experts who you wouldn't see
otherwise because of language barrier
but I want to introduce them to you so
hopefully tonight um you'll find the
time well spent because I have two very
interesting I shouldn't say interesting
interesting isn't a very good word I
have two individuals with fascinating
backgrounds and I think their Insight is
important at this time all right so
let's first talk about um I I heard this
narrative this analogy people use to
describe us China Taiwan relations and I
was so impressed and I think it's so so
true I'm going to tell you that story
first so they say CCP is this abusive
Rogue and obsessive guy who drove the
girl called Taiwan away she ran away and
started home life and got herself
established and made many friends and
one of her most important friends is
called
America and the guys the CCP guy
threaten
to use Force to take her back yelling
you are part of me you are mine and
forbids anyone in the village from
talking to
her um so this guy America lives across
the pond and is very wealthy and strong
so he maintains order in the village and
he doesn't want to see the girl being
hurt
so he told the CCP guy you know leave
her alone I dare you touch her so so
that's what's been happening
now now the CCP guy of course got
mad uh but he's very he's a conniving
guy so he knows that he's trying to
figure out how he could take this girl
back so he figured that he's no match
for the American guy in a physical fight
so he came up with a tactic he thought
to himself well I can't always
say um how great I am you know I can't
you know if I say how great I am to the
girl she's not going to listen to me you
know I mean she hasn't been listening to
me for all these years so I can't say
that um so he came up with a scheme I
cannot make you like me but I can
gradually ruin the trust between you and
the other guy America and I will I will
gradually turn you against him or turn
him against you um I I'll destroy the
trust between you the two of you and I
will break your will so you want to come
back to
me okay so that's an oversimplified
description of us China Taiwan relations
but the last part about the ccp's c um
cognitive Warfare in Taiwan is vividly
Illustrated using the three personas the
CCP knows that if it promotes the
narratives of how great the Manon is or
how great the regime is not many
Taiwanese will listen to them will
believe that stuff and if it openly
attacks the United States that would
cause
backfire so its tactic is it will
gradually spread
suspicions doubts in various sectors of
Taiwan uh Taiwan Taiwanese
Society to make people suspicious of the
American agenda or what the American
government is up to and it will let
experts and K's in Taiwan to discuss
these
issues um a and make them their own
opinions and
Views um while using experts and KS will
make them sound credible and
thought-provoking so after a long time
this CCP Guy believes that it will have
a psychological effect on people and
they will accept it as truth so this is
ccp's cognitive Warfare uh put into put
in a very uh simplified
way CCP cannot build trust but it's very
good at destroying people's
trusts okay so the Taiwanese have been
subject to a US skepticism Theory I
don't know how to you translate that in
English maybe some some people call it
it's like a suspicion suspicious us
Theory or us skepticism
Theory uh it's part of its cognitive
cognitive Warfare now after the Middle
East crisis became major
news there has been this uh discussions
or questions where people wondered if
the United States can still defend
Taiwan um when the Americans are going
to be EMB boiled in multiple
battlegrounds
so this is what we're going to focus on
tonight so we will first talk about is
the US able to defend Taiwan if multiple
Wars break out we'll hear that from two
experts and then last but not least I
feel it's very important because it's
discussed by uh one of the
experts we'll talk about how Israel has
helped China develop military military
Technologies and I think that's a good
lesson to be learned by everyone so
let's talk about first things first so
Beijing has been using its influence in
many Taiwanese media as well as social
media um to spread this us skepticism
theory for the past several years it
started during the US China trade war
and then after the outbreak of the Russo
Ukrainian war in
2022 uh it has immediately launched this
us abandonment of Taiwan Theory right it
it it BAS basically it's saying that oh
the US will abandon Taiwan and the
expression today's Ukraine is tomorrow's
Taiwan is developed to um to to to
instigate fear fear of War among the
Taiwanese now after the Middle East
crisis broke out um another narrative is
spreading that this time it's what the
US is not going to defend Taiwan because
it's incapable of being involved in
multiple Wars or or the US doesn't want
to defend Ty one anymore because it's
tied up um I don't think many people
really doubt the US government's
determination in defending Taiwan should
the CCP attacks the island but there are
many people who have the question if the
US is still able to um if multiple
Regional conflicts break out so let's um
hear that from our first expert uh let
me introduce you Tony who
where is he let me make add this to the
St stop stop stop let me start from the
very
beginning okay start okay let me um tell
you a little bit who he is Tony who
immigrated to the us at the age of 16
with his parents and joined the US Air
Force in
1977 he is a grandon of a Taiwanese Air
Force General he dreamed of becoming a
pilot but wasn't able to due to an
eyesight uh problem he in 2004 he
retired from the Air Force but continued
to work at the Pentagon as a senior
analyst I think he became the first um
seni Pentagon country uh what what do
you call that
country manager or country uh like the
the contact person officer um in charge
of of Taiwan so he became um pentagon
first manager uh of Taiwan Affairs I
think that's in
[Music]
2004 maybe 2004 I may have the dates
wrong but anyways he returned to Taiwan
to serve as the deputy Science and
Technology officer at the uh American
Institute in Taiwan you know that's the
de facto ambassy u in Taiwan because
there's no diplomatic relations they
have these cultural Affairs or economic
Affairs
office uh his I found his experience
with American military services and and
with the Pentagon as well his knowledge
of Taiwan because he's he was born in
Taiwan um make his opinion something not
to be missed so in the next piece he
explained the US strategy how the how
the United States plans to fight
multiple
Wars um I found it f fascinating so I
will play the the clip I have people
come telling me that they don't they
listen to my uh podcast so so I'll play
so they when I when I just play the
audio without voice over they don't know
what's being said so after I play the
video I'll quickly tell you you know um
again what he what he said so here's the
video manage major
regional now
wi hold
winoc
Force follow on
Force original
interop ability
inter
okay so he elaborated on the um specific
situation now uh the the Russia Ukraine
war and the possible Taiwan straight
conflicts pertaining to how the US
allocates military resources in Europe
and Asia in the next clip
so start from oh yeah maybe I should um
help those people who didn't hear the
clip um so he basically said the US
strategy has always been able to manage
two Regional ma two major regional
contingencies and win both it doesn't
mean winning two Wars simultaneously
it's a win hold win so focus on the
first war while holding the second one
after winning the first war move the
focus on the second and win the second
war so it's not winning
simultaneously and that would be rather
difficult for the US military right now
of course uh American Military presence
uh in Asia Europe is superior to 90% of
the countries but facing a formidable
enemy like China and Russia uh troops
from the US Mainland would be needed and
American troops stationed in other
regions have no problem of holding a war
but to win follow on forces from the
mainland is required and so the follow
on forces uh will win wi the
wars in succession not simultaneously
but one after another so he said that's
the original concept but in the past 20
years the US has been helping allies and
Friends build up their combat
capabilities and it's a concept called
interoperability uh meaning that we can
use each other's weapons and fight
together um and when he said when our
capabilities are combined no enemies in
the world can
um can
handle the US and its allies so let me
play the second
clip I think he he he he talks more
specifically concept two reg major
regional
contingencies forces designed for that
St
group always keep in mind major regional
contingency so
strateg okay
so uh let me just quickly give you a a
uh know a paraphrase of what he said he
said American forces stayed in Europe
and the Pacific can at least hold hold a
war if not winning winning it he said
the two major regional contingency
concept should work and the US forces
are designed for that he said um two
American Carrier strike groups are on
their way to the Mediterranean region
for the purpose of deter deterrence and
they don't affect um the the force in
Asia which has one carer group in South
Korea right now um and then in San Diego
four carrier strike groups are standing
by and can take off at any time if
something happens in Asia um and he
said he said the munition Arsenal in
Europe is for Ukraine and the Ukraine
War uh didn't touch the Arsenal prepared
for Asia and he said this strategy
provides a solid base to avoid the
situation um
that um that that you can't to to avoid
the situation that you cannot handle um
two Wars so Tony's bilingual and
bicultural background makes him very
interesting now let me introduce the
second
guest who also has bilingual um
bilingual
bicultural background and he is Japanese
journalist Akio uh my translation the
name I think it's y yayita yayita y
yayita he was born in tenin China in and
to a Japanese father and a Chinese
mother that was during the cultural
revolution a few years after the
cultural revolution his n native
language he grew up in China until he
was 15 so he he uh and his family
returned to Japan when he was 15 so
Chinese is his native language he served
as the Beijing correspondent for the
Japanese uh s shimbo newspaper between
2007 and
2017 um and he's now based in taib and
is the papers taib branch chief with his
native Chinese knowledge Japanese
background and Taiwan experience he
offers a unique geopolitical
perspective into this the doubts and
suspicions that that CCP is promoting
uh that challenges um us determination
in protecting
Taiwan um so he he's basically arguing
that the current Middle East crisis
isn't a new war for the United States
and that the US will not give up uh
defending Taiwan so let me play this
clip uh which one I get confused oh I
think it's the this one sorry
let me see it's this
one start from the beginning start from
the
beginning
for
for
fore
okay so he does say that this this don't
underestimate this um this this Theory
even though we know it's ccp's
narratives but in Taiwan it does have
like he like um like Akio said it does
have quite a following yeah there are
people who believe that um so don't
underestimate
that um now what I want to say is this
despite the amount of support Ukraine
received worldwide the Russian Ukraine
war is still ongoing after 20 months
without beijing's economic and Military
Support Russia would not be able to
fight Ukraine for so long without
beijing's backing North Korea and Iran
wouldn't openly support Russia without
the ccp's interference Saudi um the
Saudi
Israel peace agreement wouldn't have
been disrupted by the Hamas attack
meanwhile the CCP is becoming more
aggressive in the South China Sea in the
Taiwan straight and in the United States
backyard it's collaborating with Kuba
right in addition to uh trying to
control Brazil and large amounts of
undercovered terrorists and questionable
Chinese are entering the us through our
defenseless borders didn't we see uh
four Iranian terrorists I mean four
Iranians whose names are were on the
list of were on the terrorist list were
detained at the borders
so I
mean the only the only reason CCP is
able to do that is because it has money
but who has provided the money
the wealthy Democratic nations in the
past three
decades right so the Chinese didn't
benefit much from the economic reforms
but the CCP is using its economic
influence to or is using its Eon its e
economic resources to buy influence
corrupt corrupt people acquire assets
infiltrating our society so without
money it's not able to do anything uh
the country that has learned a big
lesson in this is Israel because Israel
has been actively doing business with
China including um large defense
contracts right or or or business
selling arms to China or selling
military Technologies to to
China uh especially during the early
days of China's economic reforms so I
want to play you this clip in which Tony
described um in from his perspective
from somebody who has worked at the
Pentagon described the collaboration
between Israel and China and I thought
it's eye openening so I want to play
that clip here we
go hold on start from the
beginning all right here we
go
control
L
VII uh L
cancel sign Python
3
UAV UAV har har
for w
upgrade
so okay all right um I'll I'll provide
you the link to the to the actual video
uh to the actual TV program it's it's
like an hour long so these are just uh
clips of them so um in addition to what
he mentioned in 1984 Israel provided the
Chinese with tank thermal sheath
technology which can ensure that the
tank gun will not lose accuracy under
different uh under different
temperatures and China didn't know that
uh and also China didn't know the
technical process specifications and
software operation initially in the
defense industry and Israel provided
help um to get the Chinese up to up to
speed Israel also upgraded the mean
class submarines and trained many
Special Forces Personnel for
China uh I saw one article that talk
about why would the Israelis do that
well
money uh the Chinese often offer
lucrative deals that's too hard to
refuse so how many people can resist
ccp's money I don't think there are a
lot and um that's why that's why we're
in this trouble today so people should
remember that any economic strength
CCP obtains will be translated into
military and political expansion and
aggression so I hope that people you
know
remember remember that and remember the
lesson that Israel learned okay that's
all for today um it's only 30 minutes
wow it's good I feel good to do maybe I
should do shorter presentations in in
the future so I just you know just want
to share share with you these um I think
experts great analysis there's a lot
more information that I found they're
very very
insightful um these four Clips already
took me a good part of today me and my
editors to translate and uh create the
subtitles for you so um so yeah I hope
that they're helpful let me see if
people have questions for
me um oh I didn't I didn't give people a
a quick summary of what he said in the
last piece I'm sorry for those people
who listen to me on on
podcast uh oh that's okay I I I already
I already wrapped up so I'll take
questions this is this is hard to do
trying to repeat every
person okay uh let me see if people have
questions for me um
just John S lay thanks for a weekend
show
oh yeah well this is my um this is my
birthday weekend
so so I uh I skipped my birthday
celebration to uh to do this program but
it's it's it's a good time well spent
anyways let's
see
um let me see
uh from Master G big leay don't you
remember me describing Taiwan as a woman
that has
a jell ex jealous ex-boyfriend who feels
that if I can't have you then nobody
can um was that you I don't I I have I
read it from several sources and I
probably also heard it on my channel
yeah that analogy is used
widely okay all right um well thank you
let's
see all right uh well not a lot of
questions for
me somebody asked me if I feel left out
when people are actively talking among
themselves no I don't feel as long as
you guys um have a great time you know
um sharing ideas with each other I'm all
good okay um suan okay Nick furry
question can China citizens be
considered innocent especially if they
if they implicitly explicitly support
CCP
um and making paa
weapons I I think it depends the type of
job they do I mean they if that's their
job if they work in a factory that makes
bombs what can they do I mean they
cannot quit that job I
think um I don't think you can't hold
them accountable for that right but the
decision makers at the top I think
should be held accountable but the mass
majority of Chinese people I mean that's
I think they I I don't think we can hold
them
accountable and we shouldn't shouldn't
hold them
accountable all right let me see David
Lan do you think that the CCP
involvement primarily xiin ping should
face trial at the he for
Global uh something act
violation not just the terms of is not
just in terms of Israel but especially
Ukraine
um but but then you're saying that will
should the CCP be tried for
their undercover support to Russia for
Invasion into Ukraine uh if there's
evidence if there's evidence concrete
evidence then yeah they should be they
should be held
accountable and I don't think the
evidence is so hard to
find I think the Western countries have
evidence they're just they haven't made
up their mind what to do with the
evidence yet I think they they're saying
to themselves let's not annoy CCP
because they found it's already a
handful
handle um
pal G Gia 69 lay will the natural
disaster in the three gorgeous Dam
destroy the ccp's
power it will but it will also kill so
many innocent people if the three
gorgeous Dam collapse in China you know
how many people would die um the the the
the flood will go all the way down I
think even cities like Shan
High uh which is at the ve it's at the
very end it's basically where the yansi
river meets the ocean gets into the
ocean even Shanghai will be flooded so
so
many I cannot imagine all the regions
along the yzi river you know people
would die we're we're talking about tens
of
millions and even more and these are the
highly populated very dense area so I I
certainly wouldn't want that to happen
even though it will destroy the
regime
so all right
um let's
see happy birthday thank you thank
you uh Darren D do you think the Middle
East attacks on us vessels will escalate
World
conflicts I think if that were to happen
yes it would but I do not think they
they would have that will
happen um I think a lot of it is just
you know I think there it's a show you
know it's CCP is very good at put on a
performance to deceive people so CCP is
the director behind the scene and then
then you have these actors acting but do
they really want
to uh turn turn The the scene you know
into a seriously you know a dead a
deadly scene I don't think so because
they understand the consequences if if
that were to happen so I don't think
that will that will happen Jeff Ramos
thank you resist CCP
money good point thank you all right um
from ma Ming Martin Martin is that an
English name Martin or a Chinese name
Martin
thank you Le you said Israeli
intelligence might be infiltrated and
may be this is the reason they missed
attack what kind of infiltration I can't
imagine army officers turning against
their
country yes it's hard to imagine but it
is happening uh because I'm not saying
that they're doing
this
willingly uh consciously in the
beginning
oftentimes these people are invited to
go to
China and you know on on a friendly trip
and these Chinese are extremely nice to
them uh but the the Chinese have already
studied everything about them what they
like what they don't like and they'll
set up something to trap you you know if
you like money they will they will offer
you some money they will make you do
something that that at the first sight
seemed okay but if you really think
about it's a violation of
your you know ethics right or they will
you know set you up with with a Chinese
woman who could be a spy or you know
they will have evidence something
against you so once they have you have
the evidence you know either you work
with them or you run the risk of losing
something precious to you um so
oftentimes these
people become hostage and then and then
they will also make you know on one hand
you will lose everything because you
know they got you on the other hand they
will make working with them looks so
easy and not risky you know what they
will ask you to do in the beginning it's
just so easy like nothing not a big deal
not like serious violation it comes in
it comes in waves it's baby steps you
know is a small thing a small favor
that's harmless one thing and then they
gradually were ask you to do more and
more serious thing bigger things more
serious um violations so that's how it
happens I'm not saying these people you
know willingly Say Hey I want to spy for
I want to spy on my country I want to
turn against my country no CCP uses
human weakness and then so I think a lot
of these
spies you know become the hostage become
ccp's hostage they do that involuntarily
and then at some point they can't help
themselves so it's very sad that's how
it
happens thank you
Martin all right
um
okay Brian Smith Lay marvelous hair is
again trying to steal the show haha
marvelous hair no it's not it's it's
going in all directions I don't think
it's marvelous I don't know what
happened to that hair it's not marvelous
thank
you all right sorry I got distracted
okay no more questions wow I did so
well okay is that it that's all for
me okay so we'll end it
here okay so Charles uh Denman Denon
I'll just read a comment so many
Taiwanese in Taiwan have fallen into
being fooled by the united front Works
Department there are many that haven't
bought the thought bought the thought
control of the CCP thought control yeah
you're right there are a lot of
Taiwanese who have fallen into
that Lei do you think CI what does that
mean um all right um I'm not sure what
what that means okay that's all thank
you very much for joining me and um
enjoy the rest of your weekend I
certainly will and I'll see you next
week
bye-bye
