Analysis - Into My Own by Robert Frost

Robert Frost
3 followers
What doesn't kill us makes us stronger.
Sometimes the first poem of a collection is like the thesis statement for the rest of the book.
This is certainly true of Robert Frost's collections.
Usually they're prefaced with a short poem called The Pasture, which is like an introduction into Frost's world.
But in his first collection, A Boy's Will, it was this poem, Into My Own.
This is a really important poem in the Frost canon, and I think it's probably underappreciated now.
Simply because it was the first poem in his first collection, and it goes,
Into my own.
One of my wishes is that those dark trees, so old and firm they scarcely know the breeze,
were not, as t'were, the merest mask of gloom, but stretched away into the edge of doom.
I should not be withheld, but that some day, into their vastness, I should steal away,
fearless of ever finding upon land or highway where the slow wheel pours the sand.
I do not see why I should e'er turn back, or those should not set forth upon my track and overtake me.
Who should miss me here, and long to know if I still hold them dear?
They would not find me changed from him they knew, only more sure of all I thought was true.
The first thing that we should take note of in this poem is the name itself,
Into My Own.
This is a theme of the poem, but it's also what's happening in it.
The narrator, Frost, is retreating into himself, by retreating into the wilderness, those dark trees.
Those trees, the rough wilderness, is near, and we can see them, and it's a really, really grim place,
so old and firm or strong that it scarcely shows the breeze blowing against it.
The narrator is saying that he wants this dark place to not just have the mask of gloom,
but he wants it to be the gloomiest place he can find and vanish into.
And it be everlasting, until the edge of doom, a quotation from one of Shakespeare's sonnets,
basically meaning until the end of time.
He then says he should not be withheld, but it's intentionally unclear if this is withheld by himself or by others,
because he wants to steal away into the vastness of this gloomy wilderness.
Steal away is quite an interesting use of words. It isn't just to fit the rhyme scheme.
Steal is quite an emotional, almost violent word in this context.
This is a poem of bitterness and misery.
There's a story behind this poem, and it's talked about in Robert Frost, A Life by Jay Parini, a really good biography of the poet.
In that book, around the page 50 mark,
it's said that this poem was inspired by a time when Frost thought his future wife was going to go with another man.
Frost was young, and being emotionally went out ten miles into a woody swampland, literally called the Dismal Swamp, to kill himself.
Obviously, he didn't do that. But this is where this gloomy atmosphere is coming from.
But there's more to the mood than just this backstory.
I do not see why I should e'er turn back, or those should not set forth upon my track to overtake me.
Who should miss me here and long to know if I still hold them dear?
This sounds like a really deep depression, which I'm sure everybody can relate to in their own way.
We probably all had a really dark moment like this.
But the poem ends on a twist.
They would not find me changed from him they knew, only more sure of all I thought was true.
Instead of choosing gloom and misery, Frost has decided to allow this dark wilderness to renew him.
Here, Frost's taking a sort of, what does not kill me makes me stronger sort of attitude, based on the philosophy, not of Nietzsche,
but of tough self-reliance espoused by Emerson, and especially William James, who Frost studied in University at Harvard, and who,
like Frost, was wracked by religious doubts and self-doubts,
but always had faith in the nature of things and in the universe.
The suicidal thoughts and the moment that inspired this poem are transformed into something else.
This isn't a defeat.
This is a retreat from the world to regather strength and regroup before getting back out there and being yourself.
It's really interesting when we compare this poem to the last poem in Frost's last collection,
a collection called In the Clearing. That poem is untitled,
but it's usually referred to by its first line,
In winter in the woods alone, and the final stanza of that poem is,
I say for nature no defeat in one tree's overthrow, or for myself in my retreat for yet another blow.
Nature is never defeated, just like Frost was never defeated by the darkness of the world.
Frost's poetry is often an exploration of that darkness,
and so when looking at his books only, not his magazine publications,
it's really interesting that his last poem is an echo of his very first.
The setting and the theme are essentially the same, and this is a theme, or a
habit, that has always been there, all the way through his life and work.
The darkness of the world is often explored by Frost in different ways,
and it's really, really interesting to see how his attitudes and thoughts on it develop throughout his life and in his body of work.
But the main message of Into My Own is actually really, really encouraging, and kind of nice.
It's that you really shouldn't let yourself be defeated by the darkness of the world.
Instead, you should retreat from it, and come back stronger, and fight the world anew.
