You're watching a feedback session for the Spungella Animation Workshop. Topics that are covered: body mechanics, maya animation.
What experience do I offer? ✔️ Animation Director at Paramount/Nickelodeon, formerly Warner Brothers Animation and Industrial Light & Magic (19 years) ✔️ Teacher at Animation Mentor/Academy of Art University/my workshops (17 years) ► IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1940902/
Need tips and help with your animation at an affordable price? ► Sign up for my Spungella Animation Workshop! $499! No minimum level requirements! From beginner animation up to advanced acting pieces!
You get unlimited planning discussions and 16 video reviews, which can be weekly or every other week or whenever you want/can submit, they never expire! Example reviews are available here on my channel.
All right, here's a shot, let's put this in full, there's no sound and all right, cool.
So for this one, what I would say, this is a good shot you can find online in terms of
reference and I'm curious if that was your starting point, like I would have some reference
in here and this could be one clip, this could be copy paste of multiple clips just to get
the action going in terms of just the complexity of the move.
I do like that you have this little up and down, over, turn into all of this, it's definitely
cool.
I think the main comment that I have would be readability in terms of just how the camera
is placed and the action and the timing of direction changes and the hang time and drop,
especially like a weight issue.
Also what you could do, you mentioned this is just the body mechanics exercise, it doesn't
have to be super polished in terms of characters in the back, other players, maybe they didn't
park, whatever it is, it doesn't really matter.
I'll probably still have it more around here and start him so that the action, like this
is okay because you're moving in this direction but once we're here, A, we're covering character's
face and it's very much two camera where it's very flat, like you don't see any type
of spine, line of action change in all of this.
Whereas imagine the character instead of going like this, even though I like the contrast
from this and having a turn like that, you might benefit from the beginning of him actually
walking this way and then shooting where it's not towards us but it's more like this, we
just kind of turn him around so that he's shooting this way.
So we have a bit more of a change where he might be hunched over, getting ready and then
stretched out to shoot since it's a somewhat of a jump shot, what is this here, tippy toe
but still you can still have a change there and then after that you can still have a turn
into this.
Now that being said, you're mentioning here you got feedback on this shot in the past,
you've been working for a while so this might be too much of a destructive note so feel
free to ignore if you don't want to continue on this.
So to me at the very beginning, it's just the readability because it's so flat to camera,
the big issue in terms of timing and spacing would be as he comes down here you have this
moment where if you track the nose, the neck, top of the head wherever you want, you come
down and it comes to a very harsh stop where you can see it's almost like he has his head
resting on the table and only arms kind of drop, this is all kind of frozen so watch
out for like in your graph it feels like we're something like this, like in your TY it's
only locks and linear key and then it's fairly flat, even the root doesn't do too much but
it's mostly a lock in here.
Then you have a bit of a strong move up that's, it's a hop getting ready, it's not an explosive
jump where you need to be super poppy in terms of a linear key so I would still ease into
this a bit more and same thing with the return if you track his nose, he's kind of stuck
in 2D space so if you track his nose and it's kind of staying put there and then it suddenly
pops up and then up and then suddenly pops downward, this is more your arc as opposed
to easing into this and having a softer return.
Same thing with this, this feels again you have this invisible table surface whatever
that the body hits so again missing that kind of an ease in and ease out of that change
of direction so it feels very blocky and linear even this here as you shoot up you have a
sudden pop to the right that then suddenly locks.
Let's pretend you even ease into this move as you're initiating a move like this the
momentum you have to change direction and it takes time to change especially since
there is not a leg on this side that will push him back this way this would be like
pure the balance regaining balance maybe through arms like shifting arms over core muscles
for him to change direction so this feels just a bit too rough and linear and like I
said this section through there and then same thing here so you turn go down this feels
a bit better you're starting to ease into this a bit more but then we're a bit locked
so you come down a bit locked through there and then suddenly we have this one frame you
can see this here bam one frame popped down and then suddenly changing direction and again
this is there's enough speed for him to move where meaning that as he changes direction
this leg has to push this way it's going to take a while by while yeah three four frames
depending on the style in your case three four five frames to go and turn and in this
case we have this again this wall here you can see this how the body just hits this and
bounces off basically this is either there's a wall that the character bounces off there's
another character that that kicks the guy get out of here so it doesn't feel like the
way is observed in terms of a way change it takes a while to change direction and to push
off with this leg my example for students is always not that you're you know a student
i know you know your background and you've worked but imagine you have a car which is
floating clearly but imagine a character is pushing and car's pretty heavy it takes a
while for the car to move now imagine after a while that car that car is moving and now
your character is running around the car to push against it so a car comes to a stop and
goes the other way this is so heavy that the car will go slowly move and then you push
against push against oh it stops it stops and you push push push and it slowly moves
over clearly the car is heavy heavy but it's the idea of you have an object that goes to
the right or left whatever but it goes in one direction depending on the mass and the
weight and the momentum and all of this to change direction it has to come to a stop
and then the force against it to turn now finger wiggles for instance right there's
nothing you can wiggle your fingers really fast hands a bit slower arms again a bit slower
head again a bit slower and then the root you can't wiggle as fast as your fingers so
this is one of those cases where imagine this is a small car that moves and someone is now
pushing the other way so it's going to take a couple frames for that car as in the root
here to stop and change direction hope that makes sense but that's what i would look at
same thing here spacing wise where you can see we can track the head goes over there
and then bam where is it here in this frame hits a wall again and then it's has even like
even a pivot off of here where you're moving this way and you're countering the head this
way giving us a bit of a pivot as opposed to coming in here and then you start and ease
in and then it would ease into here to then go up so imagine your arc like this and you're
easing into this stop and an explosive out again all that is a bit missing where it feels
they hit this wall and even this here it feels like a really strong linear pop in your roots
that suddenly goes up now it can be more explosive here i don't mind too much it could be here
the next frame maybe here and then here where you start that push and then bam explosiveness
but right now it feels just a bit too linear and the same thing here so you're up there
and i'm seeing a lot of changes in spacing where you're starting to have an arc and then
up here we suddenly pop down pop really down to the left but then we're suddenly going
almost up again but suddenly pops to the left and then it slows down a lot after all of
this move this spacing is too small here and then we lock again in this space it doesn't
there's no forward momentum anymore and then suddenly we drop down into that as opposed
again the an arc i know it's tricky because you're having the mechanics of a jump and then
you hang on so it is going to stop a bit right your root is going to stop and do this that i
understand but there's an overall momentum to the left that's going to continue so even if you're
here on that next frame you're going to have your shoulders that are being pulled up so your body
from this to this the head would be lower shoulders would be lower this would be fully
stretched the fingers might be just at the edge of the rim you want to feel that extension and
that pull gravity wise and then it's going to have a swing to go forward but it's going to be
something like this you go you jump the rim stops this swing forward into a drop and not what you
have here where we're doing this stop and then suddenly drop through there so watch out for that
and then same thing here we're having a very strong linear pop or we don't feel the compression
just yet this wouldn't pop forward so quickly you would have first a compression with the
with his leg and then he might even still be leaning back a bit and then as you come down
he will compress into this but then we're also resting here so if you look at the overall
momentum when he jumps it would be landing even let's pretend this is an arc that goes backwards
like this right we're tracking this all correctly this would be your final arc to come down it feels
more like come forward maybe one more step here it feels like we have so much movement forward here
especially with this sudden rotation forward that for him to suddenly stop and get up is again too
much of a loss of energy where we're suddenly changing direction and resting as opposed to
that leg is going to take a step forward and it's going to end up more here and then we cut out
so to me that's the biggest issue there are some other things like clarity of posing where i would
have that leg up here um just for silhouette reasons that gets a bit better then you have a
bit of a tangent where the the shins are aligned you have a tangent here and here there's some
stuff in terms of posing but that to me is is not as important just looking at the body mechanics
it's just too rough in place in terms of spacing and weight and direction change and yeah that's
what i have there let me if that makes sense i would start with that you mentioned that you want
to do acting shots in the future so you can also just not keep working on this and just keep those
notes in mind as you move on with the new shot but that's solely up to you that's how the workshop is
structured and that is that for me and that's it thanks all right there's an email you can sign up
you can start whenever you want you can submit whatever you want you get 16 submissions either
way a like and subscribe would be awesome all right thank you