Der bekannte Neurobiologe Dr. Dr. Gerald Hüther spricht über die „Neurobiologischen Grundlagen der Rechthaberei“. Unser Gehirn ist nicht fertig konstruiert, sondern wird durch die Erfahrungen, die wir im Laufe des Lebens machen, strukturiert. "Das Gehirn organisiert sich entlang von Lösungen und Vorstellungen, die sich aus der Erfahrung entwickeln und festigen." Das was im Hirn verankert wird sind daher nicht Probleme, sondern die Lösungen, die wir in unseren Erfahrungen gefunden haben. Das ist auch der Grund, warum wir in dem was wir regelmäßig tun immer besser werden. Manchmal identifizieren Menschen sich doch so stark mit ihren Lösungen und Vorstellungen, dass sie unvereinbar mit anderen werden. Die Menschen könnten sich dann schon verstehen, die jeweiligen Vorstellungen sind jedoch unvereinbar.
Das Symposium der Stiftung zur „Kunst der Wahrheit“ hat das Thema aus vielen verschiedenen Blickrichtungen beleuchtet. Ein Medienwissenschaftler, ein Neurobiologe, ein Richter, ein Kommunikationswissenschaftler und Kontemplationslehrer und eine Pfarrerin und Zen-Meisterin sprachen über die Wahrheitsillusionen, die Funktionsweise unseres Gehirns, Tugendhaftigkeit und darüber, dass Fake News keine Entwicklung unserer Zeit ist.
Yes, ladies and gentlemen, as you can see, I am a bit more cheerful, as they say in Thuringia, when someone is doing well, but unfortunately this test was positive and now I am glad that we were at least able to arrange it that way.
It is special to sit here at a desk in front of the laptop and give a lecture, but I would like to try it and I am glad that we were at least able to do it that way.
It all fits together somehow. Some federal states have just decided that the corona measures should be ended more or less for good reasons and have then of course also called for insights that they believe.
And of course there is our Minister of Health, Mr. Lauterbach, who has a different truth and who also immediately contradicted it.
That means, we already have a nice example of how justice leads to conflicts. One believes this and thinks it is right, the other thinks something else is right.
And then one argues and the strange thing about these arguments is that it is really just an idea that one argues about. And this idea is produced in the brain or is anchored there.
And there again in a region that we call prefrontal cortex. This is a very small region, so if you refer to the total mass of a person, this is an almost negligible amount of cells that are there in this prefrontal cortex.
It is already strange that we are able to influence our whole body with the help of these prefrontal cortex anchored ideas. There are people who have the idea that their life is no longer worth living for some reason.
Ideas that even lead to wars. And that's why it's an interesting question, how these ideas that you always think are absolutely right, actually get into the brain.
I would like to take a closer look at that with you today. And a lot has happened in the field of neurobiology in recent years. I was lucky enough to experience this neurobiology in a phase as an experimental brain researcher,
But this is very difficult for us and we will take a look at why this is so difficult for us today. And of course the one who has a certain idea always holds this idea for the only right one.
What happens to him when he agrees with this idea in some way in the world, then he holds this idea for a part of himself, he identifies with this idea. And that makes the matter very, very problematic.
And this fact that we are on the road as seekers, of course, also inevitably carries the risk that we get lost in it. And that would not be the first time. You know all the people who have run hopelessly with their ideas.
No, no.
It can go in all possible directions if these self-organization processes are not directed and controlled by something in a certain direction.
in which as little energy as possible is used for the maintenance of the relevant system and for its function. This has something to do with the second principle of thermodynamics.
Living systems cannot do anything. You can almost express it as if a living system is a kind of island in a world in which the second principle of thermodynamics determines that everything dissipates.
So that the energy contained in every structure has the tendency to distribute itself evenly in the universe again. And life is a form that matter has found to oppose itself to a certain extent in this second principle of thermodynamics.
That is, under the use of energy, structures are created that can sustain themselves. This is actually breath-taking enough. And of course this applies to every bunch of ants. And this also applies in autumn, for example, to the migration of cranes.
And the flying behind consumes a third less energy. This is a self-organizing structure up there, this V formation. And the criterion according to which it is organized is called energy saving.
And of course this also applies to the brain. The brain organizes the connections of its nerve cells and thus the connections that are built up there according to the principle that connections are sought that require as little energy as possible.
Energy is consumed by nerve cells only when they fire, as we call it, when they build up a potential for excitation and then ions are poured out and they have to be transported back. ATP is used for this. ATP is produced from glucose.
And that's why in every region where many neurons fire very strongly, glucose consumption is particularly high.
And nerve cells do this by inhibiting other nerve cells that then pass on such strong stimuli to them. And in this way, every nerve cell can ensure that its energy consumption does not shoot up to infinity.
We as humans have intuitively grasped where the whole thing wants to organize itself again and again and have therefore also found such wonderful terms for the states where everything really fits. So you can call it heaven or nirvana or paradise.
And the problem with all these states is that if it would really fit, you are no longer alive. That is, you reach this wonderful state of complete coherence only when you have died. Then nothing else is useful to you.
That is what we do with our brain all our lives. We try to save energy. And now you understand why thinking or even solving problems is not one of the people's favorite occupations.
We prefer to sit on the sofa and let ourselves be scurried away by something. That consumes less energy. But we keep finding out that you can't do that all the time.
If you then expose yourself to life, especially to living together with other people, then this once found equilibrium, this once found coherent state is constantly disturbed again.
The nerve cells try to put it back in order by activating connections that reduce the energy consumption that every single nerve cell experiences under these conditions.
if you then succeed in solving a problem that has to do with this high energy consumption, then this high energy consuming incoherent state is transferred to a less energy consuming, more coherent state.
That's what it's all about. And what happens then is that you find a solution for the problem. And the networks that have enabled you to solve this problem are then attached and strengthened.
And that has something to do with the fact that whenever you succeed in transferring an incoherent state to a coherent state in the brain, you can say that energy is released because not so much is consumed anymore.
So it's essentially about catecholamines, dopamine and endogenous opiates. And they activate other networks on their part, which then also activate certain body states that we find pleasant.
So this aha experience, after weeks of trying to figure out and solve something, is a wonderful experience.
And the interesting thing is that these nutrients that are released also have an effect that we call a neuroplastic effect.
This means that these are substances that activate receptors that are partly on nerve cells, but above all on glial cells and which cause these affected cells to emit so-called nerve growth factors.
And in this way, the relevant network is strengthened or this relevant circuitry pattern is strengthened, which you have just used to activate the relevant solution.
And now you have understood, and I think this is extremely important, that what is anchored in the brain is not the problems that we all have, but the solutions that we have found for these problems.
You have to think a little longer about what that really means.
these are these neuroplastic substances and they ensure that exactly the networks that I have just used to solve the problem are also strengthened and anchored.
And this now explains that in what we do, when we then use such solutions, we also get better very quickly.
And that goes from learning how to ride a bike to such phenomena that you, like me, for example, have become better and better in the course of life to give such lectures.
And in the case of such ideas that you make your own in the course of your life, that would be the prefrontal cortex in which these relevant networks are then strengthened and anchored.
Look at how deep the problem is, what I'm trying to get at, because it then leads to people getting into conflicts with each other because they have certain ideas. Actually, the ideas are inseparable, people could understand each other.
And now let's take another look at how I or how you came up with certain ideas. And then it is clear that we brought them into the world, they were first anchored in the brain during our life.
And the ideas that we build up are always ideas that help us to make an incoherent state a little more coherent.
And the strongest incoherence that we can ever experience in the course of our life in the brain, we always experience when we are made an object by other people.
So when we are not seen in our subjectivity, when we are not accepted as we are, but when we grow into a world of adults and try to find our way around there.
Where these adults with their ideas cause us a problem, because they would like us to think like them.
That means we are all the time, the first three years of life at least, all on the road in our whole subjectivity. We are the constructors of our own learning process.
We learn through playful experimentation, what works and what doesn't work. It starts with our own body and everyone who has accompanied children throughout their lives knows how much these children are constantly experimenting with what works.
Until they try to put the big C in their mouth. These are the physical processes where they try out what works. Then, of course, they try out what works with objects. And these are the decisive learning processes.
This is how learning takes place, by trying out what works and learning what works. This is anchored, this is the solution. And what doesn't work, is not tried out further and is left behind. And so it goes on and on.
And this is a wonderful state, if you can still remember how you, through playful experimentation in the kitchen of your mother, from all the kitchenware, then built such a sailor ship.
And you can already guess where the problem is, namely that the mother is not always just happy about what her children try out with this unwavering desire to design and all the joy of discovery that they bring with them to the world.
In school, some things are also learned, but primarily not what is taught there, but what is then anchored in new insights in school through playful experimentation.
Therefore, it is not the teaching that allows us to structure our brain, but it is the self-made experiences. And these experiences that we make, that's something different from knowing what you are suitable for.
You can say that there are people who, when they experience as children that they are made into an object, very quickly get the idea to make those who make them into an object, also into an object.
You all know that. The little girl gets told by her mother to finally put on her shoes, and the little girl bends down and says to herself, more or less loudly, stupid mom. Mom made the child into an object, the child makes mom into an object.
So this is a difficult situation, because in a certain way it also makes it clear that this strategy to teach other people, to evaluate them, to justify them according to their own ideas, to want to change them as you would like,
this idea can only come from someone who has not found the possibility in his childhood and later life to have the feeling and to have the experience that he is loved for his self-will and may belong to it.
And then you make that your own, that becomes an idea, that is, I have then anchored the fixed idea in my brain that it depends on behaving in such a way that other people like me.
And if you follow this idea, then you will be liked by me, then you may belong to it. Therefore, children are suitable for the idea of adults.
then this leads to the fact that this idea is increasingly embodied and that you can hardly move outside of this idea and that you even identify with this idea.
And everyone who then comes and says, are you still at Toast and there are other ways to look at the world and deal with this problem, then this is viewed by me as an attack on my personality, on my self-image.
because their own ideas no longer work with which they have been on the road so far.
There is a second solution, which you all know, which is probably even more difficult for the person concerned.
Then you make yourself an object, your own assessment.
but somehow that now leads to me explaining myself to be too stupid for math.
And then it means I am too stupid for math or I am not lovable or I am not beautiful enough.
And then you write that to yourself, so to speak.
And at the moment when I have talked to myself long enough that I can't do math and then also confirm it by saying that my mother or my parents are also too stupid for math and that is probably genetic, then it's over.
Then I can't get out of the number at all.
This then leads to the fact that you of course also fulfill the prophecies of these people who made you the object of their assessment.
But it doesn't hurt anymore.
If I first say I'm too stupid for math, then the math teacher can give me any assessment.
That doesn't matter to me anymore, because I'm too stupid for math.
And that is then this solution that you make yourself the object of your own assessment.
This is of course highly fatal, because in the end you can no longer guide yourself.
So you make yourself the object, although you get along in the world, but you don't like yourself anymore, because you really don't want to be like that.
And it's not that easy to let go of this idea later in life.
But that can happen to you.
And the happy message is that it can happen to us all the time.
We are running in search of how life goes and how to find solutions for the problems that life has in store for us.
You can get lost again and again.
This can also lead to the formation of ideas that are so firmly anchored in the brain that they determine the whole life and the coexistence with others.
And the worse it gets, the more successfully you use this relevant pattern of solutions over the years.
It can all happen.
But, and now comes the happy message from neurobiology, the brain is time-living plastic.
Up to old age, it is basically possible that you let go of this idea again.
You can also, if you want to, engage in new experiences.
And these new experiences that you can then have can lead to questioning the old ideas you had.
And that you now suddenly form a new idea of how living together can be done constructively, for example.
You can form a new idea for yourself, what kind of person you want to be and how you want to shape your life.
Who you want to believe in and what you want to believe in.
These are wonderful possibilities and they function brain-technically until the last breath.
The brain could already rebuild itself, but we don't like to do that.
Because it is of course more comfortable, and now you know why I talked so much about thermodynamics at the beginning,
it is of course much more comfortable to hide a pattern of solutions once found in the old,
than to expose yourself to the un-image of an uncertain future.
People prefer to be stuck in the swamp of their own ideas.
That is energy-saving, because you can operate there.
You know how to do it, you are familiar with it.
It doesn't confuse you all too much.
It is not a beautiful life, but the suggestion to just crawl out of this swamp and stand on the shore,
seems very strange to you, because it could be that it is raining, that it is windy,
that there is an abyss behind the shore,
and that is why people are more inclined,
although they could theoretically rebuild the connections in their brain,
people are more inclined to hold on to their once-won convictions and once-won ideas.
Yes, and that makes the whole problem difficult.
And that is why it would be good, now let's look at how it could work,
it would be good if we could all at first reassure each other about it,
and also strengthen each other in that one of the stupidest ideas we all run around with,
is that we could change another person.
That would be great.
What we can do, we can change another person with the help of conditioning techniques,
of rewards and punishments.
So we can train him.
We can make him behave the way we want him to,
but that is why he hasn't changed.
That is why he is still the same inside as he was before,
and if we stop with the rewards, or if the punishments are suddenly no longer carried out so consistently,
then he will be exactly the same as he was before.
So the attempt to change the behavior of people through derogatory methods,
is very popular, especially in the Anglo-Saxon countries, in the USA,
they are still very much on this conditioning track,
but that is probably a mistake, that is not how it works.
We cannot change other people,
because what determines their behavior is these inner attitudes.
I like to call it an attitude,
and it is always bound to certain ideas, to a certain self-image,
and what determines the behavior is the inner attitude created and anchored in these people through experiences.
You cannot change that,
at least not with the methods we try to do all the time.
You cannot change another person,
the only one who can change is this other person.
And they will only do that if they want to.
If they don't want to, they won't do it.
And they will only be able to do it,
if what comes to their mind after such a change,
what they believe will happen,
appears much more attractive than what they have at the moment.
They would have to bring another person,
to get them out of the swamp of their own ideas,
because they find the shore so beautiful,
where they can unfold themselves again in the free wind.
And that is why the motto is,
if you really like another person,
and are interested in him,
you will come out of entanglements and such ideas,
which rob him of his whole vitality,
which almost bring him into a state,
where he no longer has any contact with his body,
with his basic needs,
where all the joy of discovery and the desire for design is gone,
where he behaves like a hamster wheel,
where it only depends on whether everything works well and is perfectly wrapped.
And if there is a person who has entangled himself in this way,
then they can do nothing but invite him,
encourage him, inspire him,
to want to have a new experience,
from which they assume that if he would have this experience,
then he would also change the idea he had so far.
And now guess why I say this,
because we are very bad,
we are pretty good at styling and hairdressing,
but we are very bad when it comes to inviting other people.
And the reason is,
yes, it is also relatively banal,
you can only invite another person if you like him.
I can't invite someone I don't like.
And we all haven't learned how it should work,
that I should suddenly like a person I can't stand at all.
I sometimes try this with management staff,
who then complain about the employees,
who don't do everything the way they want.
And then I say,
if you have Mr. Müller in front of you,
and he constantly gets on your nerves,
then you could also,
instead of constantly making fun of him
and giving him your evaluations,
and telling him what to do,
you could also try
to find something in him that you like.
And then they look at you in a strange way,
and then I say,
you have to take a different approach.
You could ask him after the weekend
what he did on the weekend,
before you criticize him again
for not doing something right in the company.
And this could happen,
that this employee tells you
that he would have fed his bees on the weekend.
And then you realize
that you have a beekeeper in your department.
And this in a time when there are hardly any beekeepers left.
Where all the bees die,
and you have someone who takes care
that these bees continue to live.
And in the name of heaven,
then please invite this beekeeper
and not the whole Mr. Müller.
And that works.
And then you can
focus your attention
on this part in Mr. Müller,
which you like.
And the strange thing that happens
is that the whole Mr. Müller follows.
He's on it.
And since Mr. Müller has mostly experienced
that he is always criticized,
he even likes to follow,
when he finally meets someone
who sees him,
who likes something about him.
So you can only invite people,
encourage and inspire
when you are really ready
to go into a relationship
with these people,
which is not an object relationship,
but when you are ready
to meet these other people.
And you will only do that
if you have something
about these other people,
and find what you like.
And then you can invite him.
And then it can happen
that Mr. Müller
tries it out
and finds out
that he can let go
of this stupid idea
that he has
and that he thinks
is the only right thing
to do.
This is a wonderful process.
I always say
that this is
the unique chance
in the life of a person
to free himself
from the entanglement
in which he is trapped.
And in German it means
that when I free myself
from the entanglement
in which I am trapped,
it means development.
And these development processes...
We have to finish slowly, Dr.
I know,
I'm already looking at the clock,
but these development processes
try to free themselves
from the entangled ideas
that they had in their heads
because it was not possible
to free themselves back then.
Because what they had in their heads
and what they were
dealing with for a while
becomes more and more hindering.
It also hinders them
from developing
and makes life
not really alive anymore.
They function,
but not really alive.
And that means
that we could all help each other
to free ourselves
from these too narrow
ideas,
but not by teaching each other
and making our ideas
and teachings
and assessments,
but by inviting each other
to rediscover this magic
of this world
and our own possibilities
but from my point of view
this is the only chance we have
to survive on this planet.
Otherwise we will be entangled
until we all die in the end.
Thank you very much for your attention.