8/31/16 Intro to MSE free energy, electrochemistry
Oct 14, 2023
Callister Intro to MSE ch 16 lesson 2:
Gibbs energy of formation, gibbs free energy of reaction, equilibrium, spontaneity, electrochemistry, daniel cell, oxidation, reduction, half-cell, galvanic series, nernst equation,
I'm going to show you how to do the last one.
Okay.
While people are coming in, let me pull up our video for the day, which is one that we
took.
We took ourselves.
This video, since we're going to talk more about electrochemistry, this is something
that we work on in our lab, which are called electrochromic materials.
We have gotten some industry support from Scott Goggles, the snowboard goggle manufacturer,
and we're actually trying to develop some awesome goggles that can change tint in real
time.
So here's our Cluj video that I put together, complete with a vice grip, so you know it's
actual science.
All right.
So there's our electrochromic material.
It's see-through when it's unconnected.
You can see right through it.
What I've built here is a feedback system, so there's a feedback loop.
So you've got the electrochromic material that I'm going to apply a voltage to to make
it change color.
I have lab view running.
Lab view in real time basically allows me to input a desired transparency.
It's not strictly transparency.
That's harder to measure.
Instead, inside of there, there's a little photodiode, and that photodiode is going to
read a value between zero and 100, right?
And so I can set what I want that diode to read.
If I set it down to 40, that's lower than what the room is currently giving it, so that
cell turns on, and within about 30 seconds, you know, faster, even if it's been changed
really quickly, you get this real-time control.
And when it gets to the diode reading 40, then it'll go back over to that, and you'll
see this starts now pulsing.
It's that green light flickering on and off.
So it doesn't have to deliver current constantly.
At that point, it can just pulse, right?
And it's going to reach some state.
This works because of electrochromic...
Electrochromic materials work because of electrochemistry.
You have to understand how applying a voltage to something causes a reversible redox reaction,
reduction oxidation reaction, and that'll be the subject of today.
Rob?
Is that a similar thing or a really fancy adjustment welding element?
That's exactly what that is.
Yeah.
They have them in airplanes.
They have them in really fancy office buildings on the outside.
So how our technology is different than the stuff that's established is that the established
stuff they put on with a high vacuum process, which is very expensive, they do big paints
of it.
It's very, very expensive because you have to pump vacuum down it.
And what we're making is a thin film, like you saw, that I could glue to the outside
of your window in your car or your home or whatever, and it could be a retrofit.
So we're aiming at the retrofit market.
If you don't want to spend $10,000 or $15,000 to get new windows on your home to make it
more energy efficient, what if you could just put an electrochromic material that would
absorb IR radiation and prevent that from getting in your home?
That's the goal of our market.
Aren't you going to have to apply voltage to that to make it transition?
Great question.
We won't cover it in this class.
But if you take, like in the electrical engineering department, Manon has a class on optics, energy
optics.
He'll talk about light-sensitive, that's photochromic.
So if you've seen glasses change on their own, those are photochromic.
This is an electrochromic material, meaning you have to apply a current to get a voltage
across it.
Okay, so there is a second homework.
I will post it after class today.
Homework one is getting turned in, so get that in.
We will do clickers today.
So for your clickers, if you have a physical device, one of these things, you need to turn
it to receiver channel 41, and if you're using Responseware, which I hope you guys are, save
the money, then you go over to it and you put this number in, 174670.
And I will actually start this and you'll see those numbers still when I start it.
So that's channel 41, that's your session ID, so that info should be there.
So today, let me start off with our learning objectives.
Our learning objectives are to learn how to use a standard reduction table to predict
which metal will be oxidized and which one will be reduced when we put them together
in a galvanic cell.
We're then going to predict the voltage of that galvanic cell, and we'll do so as a function
of the salt concentrations of those two ions, and as a function of temperature.
Finally, if we have time, we're going to talk about oxidation rates, which is not the same
as a redox reaction between two different metals, this time oxygen's involved, and we'll
use a formula known as the Pilling-Bedworth Ratio to give some additional insight.
So picking up where we left off last time, last class, let me clarify and correct a few
things I said.
First off, about partial pressure.
Partial pressure has the units of pressure.
So the partial pressure technically has units of pressure, meaning, right here, if you take
the fractional composition and multiply it by the total pressure, you get the partial
pressure.
And there are some great examples, you can see where they do that, where they basically
go through that process.
So that's all linked now in the notes here.
The pressure, however, should be in specific units, it should be in either bars or ATMs.
You can't do it in Pascals and get the same answer.
It needs to be in bars, technically, and ATM is almost the same as a bar, so ATM in this
class is fine.
So if I ask you what the partial pressure is for these reactions where we're looking
at free energy, it would be Pa, where Pa is the fraction of the moles of component A times
the total pressure.
That would give us the partial pressure.
So thanks.
I think it was Jimmy that caught me on that one, Jimmy?
So appreciate that.
Then next off, I said that if the reaction quotient is one, and we said reaction quotient
was one in this example up here, we said if this is a solid, that's a solid and your chamber
is completely filled with carbon dioxide, we said what will happen?
Well, we said Q must equal one over one multiplied by this partial pressure CO2, and if that's
just one, then Q, our reaction quotient, equals one, therefore, in our delta G expression,
we have RT natural log of one.
That means this whole term right here went to zero, and so I said the reaction doesn't
go forward.
That is strictly speaking from the experimental standpoint.
We know that the total thing that determines whether a reaction goes forward is delta RG,
which has both a theoretical component and an experimental component.
So I was wrong to state that it doesn't go forward, because it could go forward based
on the theory.
So we're going to do lots of examples of this, because I think there's a little bit of confusion
in the air.
So we have today, and I'm also going to spend, I think, an extra lecture on this on Friday,
so we'll do lots of examples of free energy and electrochemistry where we actually calculate
these things.
So that's correction from last time.
From the experimental part, it would definitely be zero, but the theoretical part could still
dominate to make the reaction go forward or backwards.
So let's start with this one.
We left off last time with this reaction, the sodium, NaH, CO3, can't remember the name
of that, and then NaOH and CO2, right?
That's our reaction, and we're going to assume that we start out with excess CO2, that the
chamber is basically filled with CO2 gas.
So the reaction is going to reach equilibrium when delta RG equals zero.
Delta RG, I'll remind you, is this one on the left, right?
That's the one that takes into account both theory and experiment.
When that equals zero, there's no reaction going forward or backwards, which is really
to say that there's the same amount going forward as there is going backwards, right?
So that is the definition of equilibrium, when delta RG equals zero.
So it would be a fair question to ask, what will be the final pressure of CO2 at equilibrium?
So to solve this problem, you're going to say that delta RG must equal zero with that
equilibrium, and that still equals delta RG naught plus RT natural log of Q, okay?
And you remember that Q in this case just equals the partial pressure of CO2, okay?
So if I've given you this information, we can answer this question.
What do we have to do to answer this question?
This might be a clicker question, so I'm going to start the clicker up here, and I'm going
to get this out of the way because it's harder to read.
Basically it gives you two options, A or B, is the answer negative 77 or positive 77?
And let's work through it together on this first one.
So what's the first step to answering this question and figuring out what will be the
partial pressure?
Or actually, I guess the question asks, excuse me, this one asks what will be delta G formation?
So let me pull this back up.
It says, if delta G formation at room temperature for these things are these three values given
there, what is delta RG naught?
So what is the change in free energy naught, meaning what is, sorry, let me pull it up.
What is this value?
So the first part of the question asks what that is, okay?
How do we solve that based off of this information that I've given you here?
On the clicker, I actually made it easier.
I told you what NaHCO3's value is, it's right here.
Here I haven't told you that, but I've given you this information.
So how do we set this problem up?
Anybody want to take a stab at it, or at least tell us what to do next?
Or how about this?
Tell your neighbor what you think you should do next.
Okay, so let me pick on Polly.
What do you think?
How could we start this?
Using the equation that we have for delta G in our notes.
So G equals, sorry, H minus TS, right?
So I've given you H and S, and we know that since this is F naught, that that's happening
at 298 Kelvin, right?
Yeah, so we'd use that to calculate for the sodium in the bottom of my hand.
Yeah, so we'd say negative 950.8 kilojoules per mole minus 298 Kelvin times, now watch
the units here, this is tricky.
The first one was in kilojoules per mole, this one's in joules per mole, so turn that
into kilojoules to save yourself the headache, 0.102 kilojoules, and that's per Kelvin mole.
So when we do that, our Kelvins cancel, and we're going to get an answer in kilojoules
per mole, okay?
Which is what we want, right?
So somebody give me that value, and let's hope that it's the same as, where'd this thing
go?
Let's hope it's negative 851.
Okay, somebody have that yet?
Huh, something's wrong, it should become more negative.
Wonder if I've got a wrong value here.
Let's use the value in this one just so you can do the quicker question, right?
Let's assume that it comes up to negative 851, and by next class I'll figure out what
the problem is there.
I probably just typed something out wrong.
So that's the approach, though.
Any questions on the approach at least, that you do G minus HTS, or yeah, G equals H minus
TS?
So let's assume that it's negative 851, what is happening?
Negative 851 kilojoules per mole.
Now that we have that for an individual compound, how do we figure out delta RG naught, which
is what this question's asking for?
Yeah, it's gonna be products minus reactants.
So in this case, our products are the NaOH and the CO2, right?
So delta RG naught will be equal to negative 379.484 plus negative 394.35, that value minus
this negative 851.
Okay?
So when we plug that in, which one is it?
Let's see.
In fact, let's just do this all, I'll start the quicker question now.
You can actually be putting the answers in right now, I think.
So you should be able to enter A or B.
Let me get this out of the way for you.
If you don't have a calculator to lead over and work with a friend, that's fine and glass.
Probably that number up top there, that 174670.
If you've registered, then...
Okay, another two minutes, get that answer in.
Maybe one minute, you should probably have this by now.
In fact, is anybody still working on it?
Can we move on?
Okay, I'm gonna hit next.
So this one, wherever my button went.
So we stopped this one and yeah, the great majority of you guys got that it was a positive 77.
So if you got it wrong, make sure that you were actually doing products minus reactants.
Okay?
So that said, the next question is, is this reaction as it's written spontaneous?
Okay, 30 seconds, get your answers in.
Okay, gonna end the poll.
And people think that, yeah, this is not spontaneous because delta G was positive.
If delta G was negative, it would be spontaneous.
So that said, what will happen to this?
Wow, too many things open.
It means it's gonna go backwards, right?
Instead of spontaneously forming more CO2 gas,
since the chamber was full of CO2 gas when we started,
it's actually gonna start going backwards.
Some of that CO2 gas and this NaOH are gonna react to form some of our,
what we had written as our reactants.
So those products are gonna go back to being reactants, right?
So the question then is, what will be the final pressure?
Well, now we can finish this question, right?
So now that we know what delta RG is, and we've set this equal to zero,
all you do is you plug in the temperature this is happening at.
We're gonna say room temperature, I think, on this one.
Room temperature.
And you just solve for PCO2, which is just equal to Q.
So go ahead and do that.
What is R equal to?
R is the gas constant.
You'll remember from chemistry it's 8.3144 joules per mole.
Per mole kelvin?
Per mole kelvin, right?
It's gotta be.
Yeah, it is.
Joules per mole kelvin.
Okay?
So if you plug in room temperature, 298 K,
you should be able to solve for the partial pressure.
Let's give ourselves a little more room.
Remember that this is in kilojoules.
Let me go to the next question.
Okay.
And the next question is asking for this.
So which one of these is our answer?
What will be the final partial pressure of CO2?
Sorry, which window is valuable?
Here?
Okay.
So get your answers in.
We'll do two minutes on this.
Good?
The question is asking what will be the partial pressure of CO2 at equilibrium?
So the question is asking what will be the partial pressure of CO2 at equilibrium?
So it's this equation right here.
You're just finishing the calculation.
One thing to watch for is that this is in kilojoules,
and R right now is written in joules.
And R right now is written in joules.
Okay.
One more minute.
Okay.
Get your final answers in.
Most people responded.
Okay, I'm going to end the poll.
A or B.
People think it is...
What?
People think it's A, right?
So that's good.
So any questions on this type of problem?
Yeah, Kyle.
I only have questions I can answer.
I was the guy who said the same thing.
Should I recap the whole thing?
Let me recap the whole thing, okay?
Can you actually calculate it out?
Can I calculate it out?
Sure.
So PCO2 is going to be equal to exponent of negative 77.
Let's write this in joules.
200.
That's joules per mole.
Divided by 298K times 8.3144 joules per mole K.
Right?
That gives us...
By my calculation, I got...
Oh, I left off at 2.
Let me add it real quick.
Yeah, I get 3.18E to the negative 14.
So roughly 3 to the negative 14.
So how do we factor in the concentration of the sodium hydroxide?
How do we factor in the concentration of the sodium hydroxide?
So in this case, why could we write Q as just the partial pressure of CO2?
Because if you look at our reaction, the only gas that's present is the CO2.
These are both solids.
If those were gases, then we'd need to know what their values were to solve this question.
If they were aqueous, then you'd have to deal with their concentration.
We'll talk about that later today when we talk about batteries.
Okay.
So let's recap this question.
This whole concept.
We introduced free energy.
Free energy takes into account both enthalpy and entropy.
Since those both matter, we need them both.
Free energy is G.
And then free energy itself has two components.
If we're looking at a reaction, we want to know what delta RG is.
That says does it go forward or does it go backwards, right?
At equilibrium, it's equal to zero.
If it's positive, it goes backwards.
Forward, it goes negative.
Or negative goes forward.
But delta RG itself depends on both the equation as it's written on paper.
We'll call it the theory value.
That doesn't know anything about what's in the chamber where the reaction's actually happening.
And then there's the experimental value.
And that doesn't care what the theory value is.
It just says reactants versus products.
How much of these are there, right?
What's that value?
Okay?
So delta RG needs both of those factors.
In this question, I gave you the reaction as written on paper.
So as it's written on paper, you'd be able to figure out delta RG-naught.
That's the theory value at room temperature as it's written on paper.
To do that, you need to know delta GF-naught values for all the compounds.
I gave it to you for two of them.
And for the third one, I gave you H and S so we could calculate it.
Okay?
Now we know delta G-naught.
Delta RG-naught, excuse me.
Delta RG-naught, which is does the reaction happen according to theory,
knowing nothing about what's in the chamber?
Then we had to take into account experiment.
There, I told you to start with that the reaction chamber was full of CO2.
And since that's the only gas that's present,
our reaction quotient was just Q equals partial pressure of CO2
because the solids are just equal to one.
Since we know that, we can say RT natural log Q.
We can figure out whether from an experimental perspective,
this one goes forward, right?
And we found out that it doesn't.
So when we plug in everything, we find out that the overall delta GR
for this reaction is positive, meaning it goes in reverse.
So then the question was, how far in reverse?
When will it stop going in reverse?
To answer that question, we had to set delta RG to zero.
That's the equilibrium position, right?
That's the definition for equilibrium.
And when we do that, I just brought this delta RG-naught,
which doesn't change from before, to the other side of the equation,
and we ended up with that negative 77 this time,
equals RT natural log of Q, which is just partial pressure of CO2,
solving for partial pressure of CO2.
Any questions left on that?
Sophia?
Wait, Sophia?
Well, it told us at room temperature, right?
Room temperature, by definition, you can use 300 Kelvin,
but the actual value that everyone uses in chemistry is 298 Kelvin.
So what end of the problem will this be?
Sorry, which one is at room temperature?
Like, how do we know it's used at room temperature?
I would have had to say in the question, at room temperature.
So I just told you guys.
On a test question, I'll say this is happening at room temperature.
Okay.
Yeah, for sure.
Good point.
Shannon?
What's the units on the answer that we found?
What are the units?
Okay, great question.
So up here, in my verification from last class,
we said that when you do pressure in these reaction quotients,
it needs to be technically in bars, but ATM is almost the same thing as bars.
So that would have the units of bars technically, but ATM is fine.
So basically, it's going to be a very, very small number.
Okay.
Yeah?
Since we gave us the delta H and delta S as a standard temperature and pressure,
can we assume that it's 298 K because it's standard temperature and pressure?
Can we assume that it's correct?
Yeah.
Now, on the homework, let me pull it up real quick
and show you guys what the homework will be.
I know.
By the way, karma is real.
You guys, who stayed up late last night working on the homework?
Raise your hands.
A lot of you.
Karma is real.
Karma got me.
My five-year-old came in my room at like 3 in the morning with a bloody nose
after having dripped blood throughout the house.
So we were all up last night.
I got what was coming to me.
So homework two, I'm going to give you an example of delta G naught values,
but not just at room temperature.
Right?
I give it to you at room temperature, and I also give it for these two compounds
at elevated temperatures.
Okay?
So when you do something at elevated temperatures in a reaction,
let's say the one that we just did, this salt, right, the sodium NaHCO3,
if you were going to recalculate this and say,
does it still happen at 1,000 degrees Kelvin,
you can't simply change out 1,000 Kelvin right here in the temperature.
You would also have to modify your delta RG not to be not just at room
temperature but now at 1,000 K.
So I'd have to give you values like these at 1,000 K to figure that out.
And you'll have an example to do that on this homework.
Okay?
Any questions left on this?
Kyle.
So just a quick conceptually.
So delta RG is the free energy that tells you what direction it goes, right?
That's the change in free energy for the reaction as written.
And if the energy goes down, we know that the whole universe,
if it's spontaneous, it wants to go down in energy,
it wants to lower its energy.
So if that value, the change in energy, is negative,
then it went down in energy.
And that's why it happens as written.
If it's a positive value, that means for that reaction to go forward
as written, it's got to go up in energy.
So it won't happen.
It's going to go backwards.
Okay.
So then the change in free energy for formation basically tells us,
like, how much energy is needed or how much energy is used for the form?
If you were to only consider, as it's written on paper,
ignoring how much of the different quantities are available.
Okay.
And so that's just what the second part accommodates for,
the error you have in your calculation.
Not error necessarily.
That's maybe not the right way to phrase it.
But it takes into account real world conditions.
What's in the crucible or the beaker or the test tube where this is
actually happening at?
On paper, it's fine to say that gasoline joins with oxygen.
It combusts and forms CO2 and H2O.
But if you have no gasoline to start with, that reaction can't go forward.
Or if there's no oxygen in the chamber, it can't go forward.
That's all that's saying.
Okay.
So that's why you use that because it depends on your temperature
and your pressure essentially, like how realistic your calculation will be.
And so that's why you use that to kind of, I want to say,
like, you know, just fix it basically.
Yeah.
I mean, maybe the right way to think of this is like in chemistry,
we learn about these reactions.
We calculate delta G.
But as engineers, we actually use these in real world scenarios, right?
So you have to take into account both what's actually happening
and what it should be on paper.
Okay.
Any other questions on this?
We will do a bunch of more examples.
This is very typical of a type of question I'll put on your midterm coming up.
Okay.
So chapter 16 officially picks up here.
They skipped all that thermodynamic goodness.
I don't know why, but they did.
Now chapter 16 picks up.
You should be responsible for reading section 16.1, 16.2, and 16.10
in the third edition board.
I imagine it's probably the same in the other editions.
There's some of this chapter that we're not going to test you on,
things like the rates of these electrochemical reactions
we're not going to test you on.
It's just the basics.
So let's talk about electrochemistry.
Electrochemistry is an electrochemical reaction
that combines both an oxidation and a reduction half reactions.
We're going to come back to that over and over and over,
and that makes our life a lot easier,
that it always has one of the oxidation type and one of the reduction.
So let's talk about one of the classic examples is zinc metal
in an acidic solution.
Okay.
So you've got two beakers.
You've got your voltmeter that you're reading across them.
You put a piece of zinc in one.
You put a salt bridge.
A salt bridge is literally you can use a straw from McDonald's
that you pack with, like, filter paper that is soaked in salt water.
We'll talk about why you have to have that in a minute,
but it has to be there.
And then on this side, you've got hydrogen gas
and a piece of platinum wire or something as a catalyst,
and you're going to have this reaction taking place.
You're going to have zinc metal being dissolved.
Over time, this zinc piece of metal is going to be shrinking.
It'll be disappearing.
And on the other side, you'll see little bubbles forming over here
in this little beaker thing that they've got drawn here,
and that means that hydrogen gas is being evolved.
Right?
So what are the oxidation and reduction reactions?
Remember oil rig.
Oxidation is loss.
Reduction is gain.
So tell me which of these two things, the hydrogen or the zinc,
is losing electrons.
Zinc.
How do we know that zinc is losing electrons?
Yeah, it's going from zinc metal over here to zinc 2+.
So it's lost two electrons.
So we can write that reaction.
This is going to be a half reaction.
We're going to say that zinc goes to zinc 2+,
plus two electrons.
Screen flashing.
Sorry for that.
I'm always doing that.
Okay.
Zinc goes to zinc 2+, plus two electrons.
This is oxidation.
Okay.
Any questions on that?
That's clear?
So what is being reduced?
The hydrogen.
As written right here, we've got two H-plus molecules,
or ions I guess we should say, in solution.
That's coming from the acid.
We had to put this in acid for that reason.
Right?
Acid dissociates into H-plus and whatever the conjugate is for the acid.
It's going to pick up.
So it's going to, what's wrong here?
So there's a problem here.
These are both written as reductions, aren't they?
Right?
So that's not right.
Right?
Because we know that for a redox reaction,
we have to have both reduction and oxidation.
Right?
So we need to rewrite this.
We need to say H2.
Oh, that equation is wrong.
That equation is wrong.
The Internet lied to us.
We've learned a valuable lesson today, everyone.
The Internet lies to us.
That is not right.
Let's get rid of that.
H-plus, sorry, that's not two, that's H-plus.
Say two of these plus two electrons goes to H2 gas.
That is a reduction.
We know it's a reduction because it gains electrons.
It started out as an ion.
It picked up some electrons.
It became H2 gas.
That's why it bubbles.
So the Internet lied to us.
Apologize for that.
Okay.
So when you combine these together,
we can add these two reactions and we get two H-plus plus zinc metal plus two electrons yields zinc ions,
zinc two plus, plus hydrogen gas plus two electrons.
The electrons cancel on both sides, and they should.
If they don't, then you haven't balanced it right.
The electrons need to cancel out.
Okay?
So that's our reaction.
Our reactants are hydrogen ions and zinc metal, and our products are zinc ions and hydrogen gas.
Okay?
Fair enough?
That is the basis of what are called reduction tables.
They always use this curious setup of flowing hydrogen gas with a platinum electrode at room temperature on one side,
and on the other side, they always have some metal sticking into it.
And by doing that, they can measure what voltage is produced when this reaction either spontaneously occurs,
or if they have to drive it with a voltage, they can measure what that voltage is.
And from that, they generate these standard reduction potentials.
So by definition, since everything is compared to hydrogen, they make hydrogen values equal to zero.
Right?
They say hydrogen ion picking up electrons to form hydrogen gas, we're going to call that potential zero.
Right?
The only reason they can do that is because they're comparing everything to it.
Okay?
It's the basis for all these comparisons.
So these tables, that's always in the middle.
Now, things above that table, things up here, we're going to say are less reactive.
What does that mean?
It means that these reactions, as written, are favorable and spontaneous.
So spontaneous reactions, as written.
As written.
Okay?
And below it, these things are going to be more reactive metals.
Or in other words, the reaction is not spontaneous.
As written.
Reaction not spontaneous.
Yeah.
They react easier.
So they just react spontaneously.
The metal is less reactive.
Like, think of the noble gases, and they also call them noble metals, like gold.
Does gold tarnish easily?
No.
It's pretty unreactive.
Right?
Platinum, same thing.
Silver.
That's why we make jewelry out of them.
If you made jewelry out of, like, sodium, it would turn into sodium oxide, like, right away.
It would be a bad idea.
Right?
So these are more reactive metals.
We're going to talk more about that.
That's a fair question.
One question you guys should all be wondering is, wait a minute, the voltage here is positive,
and you're saying that a positive voltage is spontaneous, as written, and here negative
is not spontaneous, as written.
It's the opposite of delta G.
Sorry, I didn't come up with it.
You can blame chemists, Faraday, or nerds, whoever came up with this.
It's just opposite.
I'll come back to that in a minute.
Let's go back to do another example, and we'll talk about this more.
All right.
So we showed you the penny battery last time.
A penny battery, you saw that we were able to light up an LED just by stacking stainless
steel washer, piece of salt bridge, right?
Just filter paper soaked in salt water, and then zinc.
And then we did stainless steel, filter paper, zinc.
Stainless steel, filter paper, zinc.
We stacked up, like, six of these, and then we were able to light up an LED.
What was actually happening, what was happening is we just had a controlled redox reaction
that produced a spontaneous reaction, and therefore it had a voltage that it just spontaneously
created.
Okay?
And that's the voltage we used to light up our LED.
So if you were to put copper and zinc into two solutions, and in the solution you had
copper ions with the copper metal, and zinc ions with the zinc metal, right?
And you hook these up, you put the salt bridge on, you make them electrically in connection,
which one's going to corrode, and which one's going to have material, ions from the solution
build onto it, electroplate onto it, right?
Which one will dissolve and which one will precipitate from the solution is the question.
Well, we can answer this question, and this is what you guys are in this class because
you care about, dealing with corrosion when you design your bridges and your cars and
whatever devices you're making.
You would look at your standard reduction potential table, right?
And you'd find zinc and you'd find copper.
Copper is right here.
Copper picking up two electrons, copper ions picking up two electrons to form copper metal.
And then zinc is down here.
Zinc, two plus ions picking up two electrons to form zinc metal, right?
So which one is going to do the reaction as shown here, right?
That's a fair question.
So the one that is, should I say this correctly, reactions on the top of the reduction temple,
so ones that are higher up on this table, are spontaneous.
So as written, copper two plus ions are going to come out of solution and form copper metal.
So it's going to plate onto the outside of the copper.
And the other one needs to be reversed, which means zinc metal is going to dissolve into
a mixture of two electrons and two plus ions, right?
So that's always the case.
I can give you a table like this, and I do it on the homework.
I'll do it on the first midterm.
You'll have a table like this.
I'll give you two pairs.
Whichever one's higher up proceeds as written.
The other one must be reversed, okay?
We'll do an example of this.
So let's write it for the copper and zinc.
And have you noticed the truth?
So if you put together copper and zinc, we know that zinc is dissolved, right?
The states are right here.
And copper is precipitated.
But if we use iron and copper, now the iron is dissolved and copper is precipitated,
same as before.
But if we use iron and zinc, all of a sudden the zinc is dissolved
and iron is precipitated, right?
So we can change whether or not iron is dissolved or iron is precipitated.
We can make sense of that by looking at our table.
Let's look at iron and copper first.
Well, where is iron and copper at on this table?
Here's iron, right?
Iron and copper, copper is above it, which means iron is going to dissolve
because it's lower on the table.
It's going to be the one that switches, and iron metal will turn into iron ions, right?
But iron versus zinc, all of a sudden iron is higher,
so it will actually play it out.
It's going to precipitate as opposed to dissolve.
Why are there two iron values?
That's an excellent question.
Why are there two different iron values?
Because they're different reactions.
In one case, you've got iron 2+, picking up two electrons to form iron metal,
and here you've got iron 3-plus ions turning into iron 2-plus ions,
and they have different voltages associated with them.
Yeah, Rob?
Would you like us to familiarize ourselves with this table,
or would you give us something?
I would give you this on a test.
In fact, so all my homeworks are just old test questions,
and the homework for this week coming up, of course I already closed it.
Pull it up again.
I give you a table like, maybe it was open.
It's right here, right?
I gave you this, and I asked you to answer questions based off of that.
Okay.
So any questions on this?
Someone?
So you have like iron 3-plus going to iron 0.
Are the values additive?
Are they additive?
Let me get back to you.
I think the answer is yes, but I don't want to confirm that just yet.
I'll have to get back on next class.
In general, using these tables are very, very easy.
They're called galvanic series, is another word for them.
In your book, it has like a galvanic series,
and it's a very, very useful thing when you're trying to figure out
sacrificial anodes.
Anybody heard that word before, sacrificial anodes, that phrase?
Allie's heard of it.
She's the only one, I think.
Sacrificial anodes, if you have a water heater,
you put a sacrificial anode on it.
Why?
Because your water heater, if whatever component in it is that's
susceptible to corrosion goes bad, you're going to get water flooding
in your house, and you don't want that.
So whatever that component is, probably a valve somewhere.
I don't know what it is.
It's probably a valve.
You don't want that to corrode, even if you have it connecting to other
things or whatever, and it might normally be corroding.
So instead, you hook up what's called a sacrificial anode to it,
and that will intentionally be corroded instead of the valve
until whatever your sacrificial anode is is completely gone,
and then when it's gone, maybe your valve will start to corrode.
But the idea behind these is that you put in something that you know
will corrode.
So looking at this table, how would I pick a good material
for a sacrificial anode?
What am I looking for?
Yeah.
So something higher on the table means that the reaction as written
is spontaneous.
The reaction as written means you're going from ions,
and you're plating out, you're precipitating.
For our anode, we want it to be the exact opposite.
We want our valve, which we don't want to go bad,
we want it to plate out, if anything.
We don't want it to dissolve because that will cause leaking
and ruined carpet or whatever.
So we want something that will be spontaneous in reverse.
We want, for example, zinc metal to spontaneously turn into zinc ions
and electrons.
So you actually pick things lower down as your sacrificial anodes.
Can you go too low?
Yeah, you betcha.
If you put potassium and sodium, these things are extremely reactive.
They're going to burn up way too fast.
Just in air, they're going to react with air, actually, and oxidize.
So that's not going to be valuable for you.
So you want to pick things like, I know they use magnesium.
I know they use zinc.
I bet they don't use aluminum for a reason.
I'll talk about why.
But those are your good candidates for sacrificial anodes.
You connect it up preferentially so that that will be the thing
that undergoes the oxidation half reaction.
So your material that you don't want to corrode has the reduction reaction
occurring.
Any questions on this?
Yeah, Rob?
So like you were talking about the potassium and the sodium,
can you use those as compounds with other stuff, or do they have to be?
Oh, they use them all the time.
Sure.
Like we use these in our labs.
If you use sodium metal, like we work on batteries,
and some of the things we work on are sodium.
Like you're all aware of lithium batteries.
We're working on sodium batteries in my lab.
And if you're working with sodium metal, you can, but you can't do it in air
because it will immediately, if you scrape off the surface,
I'm sure we can watch a YouTube video on it.
We'll find it for next time.
If you scrape the surface off with some sandpaper and just watch it,
you'll see a new oxide coat form.
So in these situations of these experiments,
do they need to be pure metal for this reaction to occur successfully?
As written, these are pure metals.
In the real world, we work with alloys.
And so the table in your book, you have this table,
and like two pages later you have a galvanic series table,
which is actual metals that are engineering materials.
So aluminum, 1100, steel, 316.
Those things are listed in terms of the potential involved
when they have reactions, right?
So things that are most likely to oxidize
are things that are going to be dissolving.
So that's the galvanic series.
Sorry, this is flickering now.
What's going on?
Okay, any questions on this?
I'm going to give you a table.
Which one gets oxidized?
The one that's lower down on the standard reduction potential table.
If this was an oxidation potential table,
which sometimes people report,
that's obnoxious, I'm sorry that's happening.
I don't need the table.
Then it would be just opposite, right?
So let's dig into this a little bit more.
Let's write this out.
Let's do it for the iron and zinc couple, right?
So let's first write out the reduction potentials.
We'll say that iron, 2+, picks up two electrons to form iron metal.
Zinc, 2+, picks up two electrons to form zinc metal.
What are the voltages associated with those?
The voltages are written right here.
They call those V0s, right?
So iron is negative 0.44.
Voltage 0 equals negative 0.44 volts.
Meanwhile, for zinc, the voltage is negative 0.763.
V0 equals negative 0.763 volts.
So we know that they can't both be reduced.
One has to be reduced and one has to be oxidized.
And we remember that the one that's lower on the table is the one that gets oxidized.
So what do we need to do to the reaction for zinc,
since it's the one getting oxidized?
What do we have to do to it?
Yeah, we flip it.
So we're going to scratch this out and say,
that one's getting oxidized.
Let's rewrite it as zinc metal turning into zinc ions,
plus two electrons.
Really, really obnoxious.
I'm sorry that's happening.
It's like not in on the way.
Okay, zinc 2 plus plus two electrons.
Our voltage is now going to be positive 0.763 volts.
If you flip the reaction, you flip the sign.
Just like with free energy where you had to flip it,
same thing here, okay?
So when we write the overall reaction,
we're going to have zinc metal plus iron ions
forming zinc 2 plus ions plus iron metal.
And the overall, they call it delta V naught,
is you just add those two voltages up.
And in our case, it's going to be positive 0.323,
positive 0.323 volts.
Since that voltage is positive, that means that it's spontaneous.
Remember, this is the exact opposite of free energy.
If it was a negative free energy for the reaction,
then it's spontaneous.
For voltages, it's positive.
And I did not choose that.
That is just how it is, right?
In the back, was there a question?
Yeah.
So are we assuming we're putting like two pieces of zinc
and a piece of iron in a mixture of both?
What you have to have for this to work...
Two different beakers.
Yeah, for this to work, what you have to have,
they could be in the same beaker,
but you have to have the appropriate ions in those beakers, right?
So if, in our case, what is our, it's iron,
is that what we're doing here?
Iron is going from iron ions to iron metal.
So wherever the iron is, you have to have iron ions also present.
They can be in the same beaker.
So if you look up, I don't know if I can Google it,
if they'll have it.
I'll show a picture soon.
Actually, maybe I have the notes.
I don't.
I did a project for Kennecott.
What does Kennecott make?
They make a whole lot of copper, right?
They mine it out of the ground.
They take it from being in an oxide or a carbonate state
into a metal state.
But that metal has lots of things like bismuth and other stuff in it.
So as they refine it, they do an electrodeposition refining process,
where over here they have a big steel plate that has copper on it
because they've dipped it into molten copper, right?
And then on the other side, oh, sorry, they have pure copper.
Excuse me.
They have the molten iron, molten copper with, like, the impurities.
They make a big sheet of it, and they put it in an electrolytic solution.
Over here they put a steel plate,
and by driving a voltage between those two things,
as long as it's a large enough voltage,
these copper ions will dissolve in the solution
and then plate out onto the steel.
But the bismuth and the mercury and the things that you don't want in your copper
just fall out.
If they went to a large enough voltage, they would all plate,
but if they control the voltage carefully, they can just get copper.
If they do this over and over a few times,
all of a sudden you have very, very pure copper.
So we'll talk more about that.
You'll have homework problems where you're going to do that as well.
Any questions on how we got to here, right?
That you add the voltages.
It's just like with free energy reactions, that you add them together.
Okay?
Okay, and like I said, there are lots and lots of tables out there.
You can look up what would be reactions for different things.
This one's really nice because it says for materials that you might actually use,
you know, bronze, brass, lead, these different lead alloys,
if you pair it up with any of these other things, which are the same things,
it tells you whether the metal of the top row gets attacked
or the metal of the side row gets attacked.
So for example, if you put copper together with stainless steel,
it's a red, it's a value that says 320, that's millivolts, 320 millivolts,
and since it's red, we know it's the side row,
it's the copper that gets reacted against.
When you put steel and copper together, copper is going to be dissolved, right?
And it actually gives you a value, right?
Now these values are approximations,
because you need to know what the concentrations are,
but this is actually a pretty valuable table.
So why did it take Emily six or so of her zinc and steel washers to light up an LED?
Well, let's look at it.
She had zinc. Zinc is, where's zinc at?
Zinc is down here, right?
So here's our row, and what column do we want to compare it to?
Well, that's our row.
We look up here now for steel.
It's probably a stainless steel alloy, right?
So maybe this one, I don't know.
It says 400 millivolts, and it's the zinc that's being corroded.
So for every one of those couples that we put together,
this rough table says you should get about 400 millivolts.
She had to stack eight of those, so that's 3.2 volts overall.
And what's the voltage on those blue LEDs?
Probably something like three volts.
Yeah, a blue LED usually takes about three volts.
It's more than a red or a yellow, right?
So that's why she had to stack eight of those things to get it to work.
If you stop at four, you're only at, what, 1.6 volts.
You're not there yet.
So you've got to keep on stacking these together, okay?
So there's great tables.
A table like this is a great tool for you to use.
It's very practical.
If you graduate from this class, you know, you take this class,
you'll at least be able to look at a table like this and say,
all right, we have a nickel,
and we're going to bolt it up to a piece of titanium.
What's going to happen, right?
Nothing or something.
It says the titanium, it's a positive value of 90.
It's a very small voltage, which means it's a very small driving force,
meaning that reaction's not going to be severe.
It will corrode, but probably slowly.
Whereas if you took nickel and paired it up with something clear over here,
like whatever that is, magnesium, yeah, you betcha, magnesium's toast.
Magnesium reacts like crazy.
Okay?
Any questions on this?
Okay.
We're out of time, so we'll pick up here next time.
We'll do one more lecture on this.

