Can you simply heat silver to remove tarnish? Example of thermodynamic free energy calculation
1 Video View·Oct 11, 2023
Silver forms silver oxide tarnish, Ag2O, at room temperature. Is it possible to remove this tarnish by simply heating it up and reversing the tarnish reaction? We carry out a simple thermodynamic calculation of the change in Gibbs free energy in order to make the determination.
Here is another question that we can use to do a thermodynamics example. You are probably
familiar with metals oxidizing, right? When metals get oxides on them it makes them pretty
bad looking. Sometimes we do it artistically because it looks a lot better. For example
in this metal working rose they torch it and by torching it, heating it up, probably your
experience tells you that when metal gets hot like under a torch it starts to oxidize
and that is what gives it this bluish color. Eventually it would turn a blackish color.
That is because the oxide, iron oxide in this case, is forming along the surface. So the
question we have is this. Will silver oxidize into silver oxide in air at room temperature?
So if you have silver spoons, will they automatically form what is called tarnish, silver tarnish,
which is just the oxide forming? Will that happen automatically at room temperature,
in air, and then what about at 500 Kelvin? So to do this the first thing we need to do
is write out the equation for silver oxidizing. So that is going to be two silvers, those
are going to be in the solid form, plus one half of an O2 molecule, that is going to be
a gas, forming Ag2O and that is also going to be a solid. Okay, next we can write the
reaction quotient for this, Q. So Q is going to be equal to, again it is products over
reactants, and then you raise that to the number of moles there are. So it is going
to be the activity of a solid, activity of Ag2O, over the activity of Ag, and that is
going to be squared, multiplied by, this time since it is a gas we are going to use the
partial pressure, the partial pressure of O2 gas, and since there is half a mole we
raise that to the one half power. Now we learned that in this class we are going to
assume that all solids and liquids have an activity of one. Again that is an assumption
we are making in this class, not always justified. We are going to do it in this class. But it
makes this a lot easier. That makes this thing all simplified to the square root of the partial
pressure of the O2 gas. Okay, so that is our reaction quotient. Next up we know what the
partial pressure of oxygen is. In air this is always going to be equal to one over the
square root of 0.21. Air is 21% oxygen, so it's partial pressure is going to be 21%,
and so out of one atmosphere there is going to be 0.21 atmospheres. Okay, so we know what
Q is. Now we are going to say at 298 Kelvin, that is room temperature for this class, we
will always use 298 Kelvin for room temperature. We are going to solve for delta G. So what
will delta G be? Delta G is going to be equal to delta G-naught plus RT natural log of Q.
So delta G-naught plus RT natural log of Q. So what is delta G-naught? Well for this reaction
that we have written right here, we have something in its elemental state plus something in its
elemental state turning into a new compound. So if we figure out delta G-naught, delta
G-naught is just again the sum of the products minus the sum of the reactants of the formation
energies. But since these are both zero, all we need to know is the formation energy of
silver oxide and it's going to be equal to it. So it's going to be negative 1456 at room
temperature, right? Negative 1456 kilojoules per mole at 298 K. And at 500 K it will be
a different value, okay? 2.06 kilojoules per mole. So let's try it at room temperature
first. So at room temperature, delta G is going to be equal to negative 1456 kilojoules
per mole. And then we're going to add to that plus RT natural log of Q. So plus R. Remember
R is 8.3144 joules per mole Kelvin. But here we have this unit in kilojoules per mole,
so let's convert that into kilojoules. We're going to do 8.314 e to the negative 3, now
that's in kilojoules per mole degree Kelvin. We're going to multiply this by 298 Kelvin's
so that the Kelvins cancel out and we're just left with kilojoules per mole. And then we're
going to multiply this by the natural log of 1 over the square root of 0.21. Okay? When
I plug all those into my calculator, I get that the value is equal to negative 9.3 kilojoules
per mole. In other words, the change in the free energy for this reaction of forming tarnish
at room temperature is very negative. Therefore, it's very likely. And that's why this happens.
In your grandma's silverware door, these things get covered in tarnish because it's thermodynamically
favorable. Now, will that happen at high temperature? Because we just said that, at least with iron,
when you heat it up, this happens very quickly. So it must be favorable. Is that the case
with silver? Let's find it out. Okay? We said that the new delta G naught is going to be
protosomatic reactance, but now we're going to use the values at 500 Kelvin, so it's going
to be 2.06. So we're going to do the exact same calculation here, except we're going
to swap out this value for delta G naught, right? The delta G naught value is going to
be different, and we're going to use a different temperature. But otherwise, this is the exact
same setup. So this time, delta G equals delta G naught, just like before, plus RT natural
log Q. And since this is still happening in air, then Q is the same. Okay? So this time
it equals, it's positive 2.06 kilojoules, okay? 2.06 kilojoules per mole, plus 8.314
e to the negative 3 kilojoules per mole Kelvin. We're going to multiply this by 500 Kelvin
this time, and then multiply it by natural log of 1 over the square root of 0.21. When
I plug all that into my calculator, I get that it's equal to 5.3 kilojoules per mole.
Or in other words, by heating this reaction up to 500 Kelvin, which is not even that crazy
hot, all of a sudden, the reaction is no longer very favorable. It is not favorable. In fact,
whenever you see a positive value this mean, that means that it would be favorable to go
the other way. So this silver tarnish would actually start to decompose back into silver
and oxygen. So you could go back to your nice silver spoons without having to clean
it with a tarnish, which is pretty slick.

