Is Korean culture getting so popular that now there are no more Korean only spaces for Korean Americans?
Let's talk about it. Yeah, there was a really viral thread on Asian American reddit titled
No more spaces for Koreans and Korean Americans anymore. This guy goes on to say by the way, he's venting
He's aware that he's venting
He says that Korean Americans we they went through so much from the grandparents generation to the parents generation with the riots and everything
Like that, they're still dealing with a lot of decades of generational trauma
but now in
2023 they're almost considered a privileged Asian because Korean culture has almost reached the heights of
Japanese culture where it's almost like everybody knows that everybody consumes it. Everybody loves it so much
It's so trendy and like cool and chic. So David it went he's saying how it went from rooftop Koreans to
Koreans and that switch has been very stark and almost difficult for him to digest
And then he goes on to say now there's white people explaining what my culture is to other white people who look at us like
We are some rare exotic creature rather than a human
There are no Korean spaces that are not overrun by non Koreans and white people
This was not the case a decade ago Koreans were able to find other Koreans and confide in their hardship at least other Asian Americans
I know I'm sound I'm sounding tribal and exclusive and I know I'm definitely living up to that stereotype about Koreans being unwelcoming
But this is absolutely how I feel in this Andrew post went viral
all right guys
we're gonna delve into is the comment section our own insight because I kind of feel like I've
Seen I know what he's talking about. I've seen this happen
I've seen it myself obviously having been in some Korean spaces for some time
But please hit that like button check out other episodes of the hot pot boys
Um, but also what goes really well with hot pot is smaller sauce. You can go check it out right now smaller sauce calm
We got pre-orders that are finishing up very soon
If you guys want to see more content check out the Instagram page or the shorts that are gonna be on our YouTube channel coming up
Yeah, I mean actually what's interesting about this post Andrew is I was asking
My Korean friends the other day one was 30 one was 20
I was like, what do you guys think about Korean culture becoming so popular?
It's almost reaching like another plateau right now with all the kpop artists doing songs and primarily English
Nugin super shy and or jungkook his last two singles have no Korean and I was like
What do you guys think because these Korean artists are charting higher than ever?
But the product I guess in a way is less Korean than ever and they were kind of lamenting this point
I mean it's somewhat with different details
The dis guy is saying like they're almost witnessing the downside of their culture becoming so ubiquitous and so universally loved at least
Select parts of it
I mean
I'm sure that there was a certain feeling you got when you walked into a Korean space a Korean barbecue a pocha bar
Whatever and like everybody was Korean or at least they if they weren't Korean
They were an insider, you know versus now if you go to a lot of spots in Korea towns
Obviously, it's filled with a lot of non-asians. It's not about people's like first time, right?
They're like, it's not about like the race
But it's just saying like they're not
They're either seeing Korean culture on a very shallow level or they don't even know Korean people and they're coming to these spaces
and that's not wrong because obviously we have business owner friends who are Korean and they overall like it because the market is bigger for
Korean products their economic pie to draw cash flow from is much larger than it ever was
But they also acknowledge they're like, yeah on a given night like, you know
Maybe like 40% are non-asian even you know
I Korean in some select spots and or maybe even 70% of the crowd
Yeah, so so I think that what this guy's saying he's just misses those days. He misses the good old days
Those good old days. Yeah, and I think
That is a sentiment that everybody's feeling if you remember the good old days of anything
Times have changed whether for the better or worse or better for the macro, but maybe worse than a super micro
So, I don't know either way. I kind of see what he's saying because even ten years ago there was like, you know more Korean
exclusive nightclubs in LA in New York that would kind of discriminate against you if you weren't Korean even if you were like Chinese
You know now that's not the case now. It's almost like yeah, I like the Chinese. They always buy like the most bottles
Yeah, that is the way it has changed over the last 15 years. I would say
And maybe not for the Koreaboo aspect, but Chinese are heavily in k-town, but I think that's just because they like
We're gonna get into that later
I think a lot of Chinese they party in k-town, but they don't necessarily
Some of them are but not they're not necessarily Korea booze, right? That's like for the non-asians. Anyway, let's just get into it
Oh man, or a few quick thoughts
Every game plan has pros and cons, right? Like if you run a soft power game plan that really appeals to outside tribes
You know, not just your own because Korea is a small country. They need to export kpop
For example J pop very large domestic market. They don't export it as much for economic reasons or there's no necessity to
Eventually, it reaches this point where other people they start to take I don't want to say ownership of it
But somewhat right because they've consumed so much of it
They start to feel like their kpop or their Korean
Yeah, I got hip-hop spread black American culture to the point where people thought they were part black. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah
no, I think it's uh, it is really interesting that it's reaching that point and I think that the issue here is that because
They're Asian a lot of people a lot of like non-asians are not afraid to maybe sound a little bit
And I don't want to say entitled what's it you're saying that they're not handling their appropriation with the same velvet gloves they might handle
Black hip-hop appropriation. Yeah, essentially, that's what I'm saying. Yeah, that's a good point
Somebody was saying that the rollercoaster ride the Korean culture had in America is insane all the way from the Korean War and obviously
Then I believe that's when North Korea and South Korea split and then boom
It just went through all these crazy ups and downs and for it to be regarded
As the new Japan in terms of like soft power, you know, Japan has been popping for like they had that song
I'm turning Japanese. I'm turning Japanese in what was that?
Like the 80s, you know I'm saying for them to go through that arc is insane
and that's what might be causing that feeling of this guy like having
Like the rollercoaster of like how his perception is in the larger culture is it's so crazy
Yeah, I mean put it this way 15 years ago
I think most kids in America didn't really know what South Korea was all about and now 15 years later
They can point at a ton of content media and food
That's Korean, you know. Yeah. Anyway, let's get into the comment section guys
Like we said we are not subject matter experts on this
But yeah
I thought it was an interesting discussion because we noticed it somebody said having a trendy culture is a double-edged sword on one hand
It helps in terms of representation economics and ego on the other hand
The culture gets derived derivatives and exploited the cost of soft power is making the culture consumable and K culture is all about that
The good and bad consequences of inviting white people in are inseparable
Yeah, I don't want to just blame it on white people, but obviously white people being the dominant group in America
I guess that's tends to be the focus
But yeah, I mean I feel like Chinese culture has been through multiple waves in America of kind of trendiness
You know back in the 60s Chinese restaurants were very very trendy, right?
Yeah, my Bruce Lee to 1970s, you know over in the Bay Area
Forgot her name Chang the mother of PFCs the mother of PFCs
But anyways, it's like it's like when your culture gets popular in this society
There's no way it doesn't get commoditized and it there's no way it doesn't get fetishized on some level
It's just every culture that's popular and whether it's Jamaican culture black American hip-hop culture Chinese culture
What even Indian culture on a certain level has gifts to yoga and yeah
Stay, you know, I'm saying it's just bound to happen
And that is I guess kind of the process of being part of America, right?
Cuz you're saying when it's commoditized
It's like if we could visualize culture getting bagged up in a little bags on the shelf and you're almost like in a candy land
What's that called sweet factory and you're like picking mixing matching you're like, oh, yeah. Look at the Korean section
It's really booming at the sweet factory and you're like putting all these into a bag
It's like you when a culture is commoditized you're breaking it into these bite-sized parts that are sort of authentic
But not really because it's the sweet saccharin version of it
Yeah
I mean if you wear a cheap how and you eat a fortune cookie is that is that the most pinnacle like do you understand?
Chinese culture, you know what I mean, right you do some kung fu and yeah
Somebody said all of this makes sense and is valid except that South Korea did this
They were the ones that push Korean soft power Koreans were the ones to originally fetishize Korean culture
You can't reap the benefits of the rise of Korean soft power
If you want to keep non Koreans out of your space, you can be inclusive or exclusive not both
You need to decide this was from Daisy a student a basically an Indian guy. I will tell you this
South Korea, whatever this issue and this rant that this South that's this Korean American feels
I don't think South Korea is worrying about it. You're talking about people in South Korea
I think the all of the
Managers and creators and company heads and CEOs in Korea who are making all these moves
How for example the Samsung board of directors? Yeah, I think they're just happy. They're just like yeah, this is what it is
They're like y'all like, you know, you know Korean culture. They get better and
More people like yeah, we got a chance to like it's just beat Japan like that is what we are
So yeah, it's partially that this guy's this Korean American aka Asian American and this is one of those
So kind of weird spaces for an Asian American where you're like damn. I'm like Asian, but I'm seeing my
Heritage my traditional heritage kind of commoditized
How do I feel about that while Koreans in South Korea are probably like because obviously Koreans from South Korea
They're not worrying about small dwindling enclaves in like large American cities, right?
Cuz they're like, yeah, like they're just gonna move to Powell Park or Fort Lee or a
Locking yada or something a more Korean ethno burb, right?
I know towns have not took the traditional Chinatowns have not been the hub of
Chinese culture I think for a like in a way a decade like we don't want to mean where there's the suburbs
Flushing there's six to six SGV. Those are even more so the hubs. Yeah
I mean doesn't it kind of go to show you as something becomes more popular?
It's not always good for like every single group in the diaspora in every single way
For example Andrew, I know some Taiwanese Americans as the six to six night market grew and spread around the country
They were like they stopped serving sink to stinky tofu because that was turning off a lot of the demographics
But the Taiwanese were like, but yeah, yeah
Yeah, that's what makes that like six to six night market Taiwanese. It's the tofu, right?
But they had to take it away right for the marketability. Of course, Andrew
There was a bunch of people posting saying like I'm Korean. I agree. Somebody said let's be honest guys
It was the Chinese the Chinese and Thai people. They were the ones who took the spaces
How true is this man a lot of Chinese patrons?
There's a lot of Chinese people who like Korean culture at least eat in Koreatown. I think they like the vibes
Like you know what? I mean even more like I do think Chinese taste buds
They'd rather eat choir over go to John with a shinjang cumin on it
But like they I think Koreans the way they interpersonally ping and create like fun venues Chinese
They can't do it. All right, so that's why they consume there and they spend the money
Somebody said as a nerdy Southeast in South East Asian male. I got it pretty bad
This is my vent that ever as everybody has said that Asians have come up as a nerdy Southeast Asian guy
I got nothing. So that's my vent
How much is this interesting Andrew that everybody is saying like in this whole macro?
Representation of like kpop coming up or Asian culture coming up in CRA
There are groups or specific subgroups sub subgroups within groups. They got left out
Yeah, no, definitely a lot of groups benefited more than others. I still think it is
Still better for him in general. I think it's still better for every single Asian a little bit
I just think that the impact might not be as significant and as game-changing for sure, right?
You're saying it was a rising tide
But the tide was not because the more people who understand what even Asian is even if even if this guy's like
let's just say like Lao or Cambodian right one of the lesser-known Asian groups like
Like people still interested in Asians more period. You know, I mean, yeah
It might not be Korean or Chinese or whatever one of the big ones
But I don't I mean especially I think as a nerdy Southeast Asian guy from what I've seen in the Southeast Asian world
The nerdy play like the gamer, you know top-level pro gamer vibe doesn't work as well
Even as it would in the East Asian. Yeah, that's true
No one how that world works
This guy said this girl said I'm Chinese and I feel like white people who are into Asian culture
They rank each Asian culture in terms of coolness
Then they pit us against each other and then we buy into their hierarchy of how they rank us and then somebody said yep
Chinese are the most hated low-key in America right now easily because we don't have anything cool and modern that people would want
I'm like Japanese or Koreans and then somebody said don't forget about us Muslim daisies to like Muslim South Asians Bangladeshis
They were saying that uh, yep, we get hated too. Yeah, you know what I'd say about Chinese being the most hated
I feel like in the macro the Chinese is the most feared
But on an individual basis, there's still so many Chinese people embedded in like every city
It's hard to say that they're hated all the time. You know what I mean? Yeah, people still going to eat
Traditional Chinese hot pot all the time that is straight from China. People are still consuming Chinese
Products all the time. Yeah, but in a coolness sense. I see what they're saying
I know what you're saying in an overall cuz it's almost like yeah
It's hard to basically ascribe a movement to what's happening to Chinese people because there's so many
25 25 25 25 splits. It's safe to say Koreans are the coolest right now, though
Yeah in the cool worlds like if somebody says yo, I got a new DJ that's Chinese
People are not gonna be as interested to hear. Oh, I got a new DJ. That's Korean
Everybody. Oh, let me give it a listen at least see what check it out
Um, somebody said I'm Korean and I feel like all the success that we've been having is actually building up some resentment within other Asians
Because they have started to call us racist and rude with their anecdotes
Amen, I think the races and rude anecdotes have been around for a while
Like yeah, I mean, I think it's better now. Yeah, the relationships are better now
I would say to be honest as far as just like
Relationships with Korean people go there's some of the most love I've ever gotten was from Korean people
But some of the most unwarranted like hateful spite definitely was also from Korean people
I just feel like they're very like up and down. That's my general opinion knowing like a thousand of them
Um, somebody said I'm so sick of the judgment from within my own community as a Korean
That's my vent basically saying that like as the whole Korean wave has taken place some Korean Americans. They don't even fit with it
Yeah, that's true not all Korean Americans fit into this kpop kdrama look this girl said I'm Vietnamese
My husband is Japanese and everybody views us so differently when they perceive us through the lens of our culture
For example our white friends
They always want to ask him about the bullet trains and all these movies that they've seen about Japan
But when I bring up anything about Vietnam, they complete the conversation with the white families completely go silent
And then she said on the flip side when we went to the Japan Festival in our town San Jose
There was only like seven Japanese people who showed up out of 300 and then we went to the Viet cultural festival
And that was about 95% Viet which gave me peace. So she's saying basically it's just the pros and the cons of it all
Yo, that was a really really interesting comment and last but not least Andrew this Korean guy said to this Korean poster the original OP
And said what you're describing is essentially Han the feeling of sorrow and resentment that you cannot entirely put your finger on and I guess
The feeling of Han is a very Korean sort of morose thing driven by I guess
Centuries of ups and downs but mostly downs
Yeah, apparently, you know
My overall takeaway is my message to people like him who kind of resent the Korean wave
Not that I think he would turn the hands of time backwards, but you're saying he wouldn't hit the reversal
But you would still take it because it's a net positive, of course, but it's just not the most comfortable
It's like it's like when something good happens to you, but it's not like entirely good, but it's overall good. You'll take it
You know, it's like yeah, it's like if you got promoted at work you make more money you got promoted
You got a higher position, but then you got way more responsibilities and you got to work more hours. It's like
You'd take it though. How much of it is just individual positioning though?
Let's say for example
There's a family of Korean people or a group of Korean friends and everybody won a million dollars in the lottery and you won
50,000 technically you're still up 50,000 from zero, which is a significant sum
But everybody else won a million wouldn't there would be some humanistic feeling of like dang
They got that and I got this, you know, like dude, honestly, and I'm not saying is I don't know who this OP is
But like what if he is on the more like introverted like lonely Korean guy side?
And then he's seeing all these more social like cool Korean guys
Benefiting like five times as much from this wave bring it all these people to the Korean spots and having fun and he's feeling a
Little left out of it because he can't benefit from it as much
I guess my recommendation is try to benefit from it more because any Korean person who's selling a Korean product or is
Considered a cool Korean. I'll be honest. They have to be considered a cool Korean and there's usually two types of cool Koreans, right?
There's the one that looks like kind of like more fobby fobby kpop kdrama and then the more like broed out one
Yeah, but whatever it is if you're trying to sell something that's from your culture right now now is a great time
But he again he may not have anything in the works like that. You know what I mean? Right, right, right
I guess I can feel his pain. You know, I see what he's saying
I think I seen it happen in the past 10 years every observation
He had is a hundred percent right logical and probably there's some statistics if we could get this
And then also throw on the fact that we're Asian so people are not afraid to
Explain our culture to us. You know what? I mean? They're a little bit more liberal with the
Commodification. Oh, yeah. Well, you know I spent two weeks in Seoul and then and then you're like, yeah, I'm Korean
I get it, you know
But then also they don't see you as a Korean American as representing Korea because maybe in a way you don't technically right because that's like
Somebody that's like a oh it what if I mean there's white people out there who know Chinese way better than me who have probably
studied Chinese culture
More than me to like the history. So it's like what if they're explaining something to me?
Am I supposed to take that with offense depends on how they're saying it? Yeah, I mean last but not least Andrew
Let's just bring it back to Chinese. What do you think about the comments? Because this was a long thread
We didn't even get to everything where they were like, yeah
Guys, I could see the pros and cons of that soft power approach because everybody wants in now like the Japanese
But it's better than everybody just thinking you're too updated and uncool
Yeah, or the geopolitical enemy. Yeah. Yeah. I mean like we said guys
I'm not saying everybody got to consider like everybody else's situation
You know, it's sort of like the Vietnamese and the Japanese couple that was like in the comment section
It's all man
Everybody born into a tribe the tribe made certain decisions or maybe their indecision was it's still a decision and that's how the cultural game
plan for that diasporic wave
Took place. Yeah, I feel like it's people needing they people need to lean hard into a lane to
Be distinctive. So what I mean by that is like if you're for example a Chinese person who?
can appear to be part of the
like part of Chinese the Chinese government and you act like it a lot of people are gonna view you as part of the
Chinese government so then you're gonna suffer from that imagery but like you get the box
Yeah, but I don't think people confuse me for being part of the Chinese government
Right because I'm so Americanized and I'm maybe act different or look different or whatever dress different, right?
Same with being Korean like if you're on the edge, you're gonna feel really uncomfortable
But you were if you were on the extreme end of looking like a kpop guy or being some cool Korean person
Sending having a opening up a business that can benefit from it. Then then you're gonna like it. Yeah
I mean long story short. I think that's a good way to ending it in terms of just a functional
Strategic move is like I noticed that as video games became more popular
Everybody's like is looking at life like video game
Archetypes and like you said when you shoot a gap a little bit harder and it's more discernible to your average normie person
They can fit you in that archetype and hopefully it's a positive one that vibes with the context
So anyway guys, let us know what you think in the comment section below
Viral thread from reddit a lot of interesting discussions valid points on all sides debate in the comment section
Keep it civil until next time we'd hop out boys. We out. Peace