Arteta's Title-Winning Blueprint? Arsenal 1-0 Manchester City Tactical Analysis

Harvey Gration
11 followers
10 Video Views·Oct 10, 2023
Moves and countermoves by Mikel Arteta and Pep Guardiola, and look, in my opinion, Arsenal's
1-0 victory over Manchester City in the Premier League yesterday was the highest standard
of football we've seen from two sides in a game this season. And look, I'm going to talk
about, in this tactical analysis, about Pep Guardiola's altered in-possession structures,
Arsenal's out-of-possession ascendancy once again, and why Arteta's set-up yesterday is
essentially a blueprint for defeating a still-imperious Manchester City side, and one that was devised
in the summer transfer window. Welcome back to the Harvey Grayson YouTube channel, we've
got that and so much more to cover today, as I give you a tactical deep-dive onto Arsenal's
1-0 win against Manchester City. Let's get on with it.
We're going to start with the first half, and the tactical battles, the chess matches,
the changes in shape from both sides, because Arteta initially went with a very aggressive
man-man press against an altered Manchester City build-up. Pep lined up in this 2-3 build-up
shape, a structure with Diaz and Nathan Ake as centre-backs, Bernardo Silva deepest in
the midfield in that No. 6 role, with Lewis on his right-hand side and Kovacic drifting
deeper on the left. And look, this concentrated midfield 3 for Manchester City, of undoubted
technical quality, looked to compensate for the miss of Rodri, and also it allowed Gavardiol
and Walker to provide the width high and wide in possession. Now, Gavardiol and Walker occupying
these nominal winger roles, let's say, does seem strange, but there was a reason for that.
By crowding the deep midfield, Pep Guardiola wanted to prioritise control of the ball for
his Manchester City team early on. He wanted to suck Arteta's man-man press in and expose
the space in between the lines, playing long to Haaland, with Foden and Alvarez then gobbling
up the second balls. This is a mode of attack that worked so well for City against Arsenal
last April in their 4-1 drubbing of the Gunners at the Etihad, but Gabriel and Saliba in particular
were especially good in the duel, and as Arsenal have been all season, transitionary duels
were won and dominated, and the ball seems to always end up just being recycled. And
this was a large reason why City had the fewest shots that they've had under Pep Guardiola
in the Premier League. Early on though, especially in the first 15 minutes, City did have a bit
of joy against Arteta's man-man press though, with that overload in the build-up, but Arteta
and Arsenal reacted, and out of possession, they were fantastic once again, mixing very
cleverly between their man-man press and also a deeper block, because that hybrid 4-4-2,
4-1-4-1 shape out of possession again was used to a top extent by Arsenal. Rice sat
on Bernardo Silva, and of course was allowed to do this greater marking role because of
his higher set-point in that left-hand side of number 8. The wingers on either side for
Arsenal pressed up against the wide midfielders in Manchester City's midfield 3, remember
in that 2-3 build-up shape? And they used good body angles to compress Man City and
to try and force them to play the ball out to Guardiola and Kovacic's side, which was
definitely a plan pre-game from Arteta, certainly a less dynamic side from Manchester City's
point of view. And although this was risky because White also man-marked Foden in Arsenal's
deeper block, and this at times allowed Guardiola to be free on the overlap, this was something
that Arteta was fine with sacrificing because it completely negates Manchester City's between-the-lines
play certainly. Like I said, with Kovacic more static and Foden marked, and sort of
that space that Foden loves to get on the half-turn-in was really policed very well
across the entire 90 for Arsenal. And it was very similar, Guardiola receiving the ball
in space, in how Akanji did the same in the Community Shield final against Arsenal. And
like I said, Arsenal switched between their more passive shape really, really well, with
that Jorginho and Rice double-pivot, absolutely terrific. The way the pair work together and
marshal space in a very compact shape as always. I think if you combine Jorginho's awareness
of space and how good he's always been off the ball in tight, well-marshaled areas, with
Rice's springiness in defending the half-space in the pockets, City found it very, very difficult
to gain central access. And this is reflected, of course, in their past network. There was
a distinct lack of verticality with Haaland, I think, when they did decide to go long and
mix in playing out from the back with that get-out ball that so many teams, including
Arsenal, utilise now. He struggled to pin and play off the centre-backs, and Foden was
often forced to drift even deeper to receive the ball. And of course, Arsenal in that more
passive shape didn't get sucked in as they were for Cole Palmer's goal in the Community
Shield, because there was a lot, at times, of central holding of the ball for Manchester
City, but without the same effects on the field tilt, because Arsenal's shape out of
possession proved too compact. And the question for Arsenal has always been, for me, how they
use the ball when they turn it over, a problem I've been very outspoken about this season
in particular. And although they certainly didn't have the optimal set-up to be dangerous
on the break, as I will get on to, Arsenal possessed still immense quality, despite not
having everyone available, and were still very balanced as a side, and that's very
important, very balanced as a side going forward. And something that I've hinted at in previous
videos, but I think have the chance to say now, it also means that even without someone
like Jürgen Timber, Arsenal are not as dependent on Zinchenko inverting from full-back into
midfield, when Rice is in that left eight as a secondary controller, alongside the six,
whether that's Jorginho or Partey. And this yesterday gave Arsenal the closest dynamic
they've ever had to a Xhaka-Partey dynamic, with Jorginho in the six, Partey later on,
and then Rice in that left interior role. And it was very similar as well to the Timber
and Rice partnership in the Community Shield, where Rice dropped deeper and allowed Zinchenko
to roam high and wide, or into the half-space in settled play, and overload that left-hand
side. And this again was seen in the passing network for Arsenal, with Trossard also used
to drift centrally and provide those moments to get out and release there for Jesus on
the right. And this sort of dichotomy between left and right was flipped when Martinelli
came on, of course, in the second half, and Jesus was prioritising doing a more retentive
role. And he did, and look, Jesus did a really good job, I think, the whole game of balancing
his role between retention, and sort of trying to tie together a more separated right-hand
side, and also being that transitionary weapon that we lacked in the first half. And then
also being, again, a more ball-heavy player in that second half. But going back to Rice
in that secondary controller from the left eight, and why it certainly takes the pressure
off always Arteta playing Zinchenko, because it provided that constant, abundant passer,
and staying presence in that left-hand-sided half-space. And also, Rice acting as that
dynamic ball-carrier, and giving us that retention in those very tight spaces. And this is very
important when someone like Martinelli, in the long term, of course, when he comes back
into the side, will be playing on that left-hand side in that wing position, as it plays a
nice foil for his space invading. And this is another dynamic issue that I've aired quite
constantly, and Rice in that left-hand interior definitely provides a solution for that, acting
as that ball-magnet for Martinelli's space invasion. Think of Rice as sort of an anchor
piece, that then pieces move around. And if someone else assumes that space that Rice
has moved into, maybe that is Zinchenko, maybe it's someone else, it gives him then the licence
to box-crash, and I think his combination play certainly attunes itself for that. So
yes, with Rice and Jorginho, or Rice and party, whichever mixture plays there, we have two
natural controllers. And in these real big games, the need for Zinchenko isn't actually
as integral. Jorginho always has, but yesterday in particular, I think he had lovely retention
in deeper areas, and then also had that verticality when we were circulating the ball around the
Manchester City box. And this helped bring in the runs of Jesus in behind, and also White
on the overlap when we switched to that 2-2-6. So of course, Oleksandr Zinchenko is still
uber-important for Arsenal, I'm never going to say he's not, and especially I think now
against deeper defences, when you want always someone occupying that left-hand-sided half-space
and someone in deeper areas. But in these types of big, big occasions, you can in a
way cheat the inverted full-back out of it, potentially play Kivio at left-back and prioritise
the transitionary defence more, and keep that double-pivot always of Rice and Jorginho in
the midfield. So that's just a new sort of dynamic, and something I'll get onto as potentially
a Manchester City blueprint that we will see in the future. And I talked about a balanced
Arsenal side up against Manchester City, because of course, although they missed Saka and Martinelli
undoubtedly, they still had the retention in that first half of Trossard on the left-wing,
and the directness in Jesus. The only thing that you could say they were missing was that
direct, straight-line running power that is so important against Manchester City, and hurting
Man City in the transition, was something Arsenal struggled so much with last season.
But it's something we may have solved now. This is something you'll guess I will inevitably
touch on, Martinelli as that wide, free man on the left-hand side, left-hand, deliberately
separated from the out-balling target man. And that's part of these new attacking dynamics
Arteta has introduced this season. And look, Pep also pressed Arsenal in that first half,
in a man-man style, and this shows how tactically there is so little to split the two sides.
And the parts and the moments that these games are won, are really in the fine margins. Whether
that is having depth, or the experience across a season, or when we're talking about individual
games, winning those key battles and moments. And this can be done through athletic superiority,
which both sides really have in abundance. And it created a sort of dogfight out there,
and was such an interesting watch. It also, you can gain that edge with how unpredictable you can
be, or most frequently now, how you dominate the transition. And it's why I've been so particular
with my criticisms on Arsenal this season, with how we use the ball in the transition,
when we force that turnover. Because we have the physicality and aggressiveness to win that ball
back, but the maturity in how we use it hasn't been there until yesterday. And this was the
blueprint to win those sort of moments and gain those fine margins, when the teams are so hard
to separate. I think in terms of criticisms for both sides yesterday, it was hard to find,
but I'm going to offer one for either side. I think for City and for Pep Guardiola,
you can see the reasoning behind the prioritisation of that deeper control, over playing a natural
winger, if so. So I think that's something you could criticise them for. I think for Arsenal,
how we use the ball at times in the first half against City's press, I really wanted us to lure
their press in and bait the press slightly more. Play the ball into sort of Rice and Martin
Odegaard's pockets, and then bounce it in and out wide and sort of break and breach that press.
Because Kovacic, Lewis, Alvarez and Foden, I think, pressing against Jorginho, Rice,
Odegaard, those Arsenal three should really come out on top. And I think the only reason we didn't
do this as much, especially as not much as I would have liked down that right-hand side,
away from Walker's sort of side, the only reason we didn't do this as much was because we didn't
want to get pressed into a corner by Man City. And although Raya is very fine going long,
and Nketiah did his best as he always does as that outlet, with his sort of natural relentlessness,
even if he does have a lack of height, let's say, we still didn't have that natural outboard. I
think Arsenal were conscious of that and not getting pressed into a corner and just turning
the ball over and affording Manchester City dominance of the play. And on a side note,
I absolutely love David Raya's performance. I think the one difference between him and Ramsdale
in the goalkeeper's position right now, I said this on Dalida Guna's channel,
is not quality. Quality isn't the issue, it's just confidence. And don't listen to the comments
that some people are saying on Raya's jitteriness, because if you can criticise him at all yesterday,
it was anything but, it was actually the opposite, maybe he was too composed.
So yeah, the difference is confidence in Raya and Ramsdale, and that transmission to the defence
and team is something that Raya gives Arsenal right now. But now let's go to the second half,
and really the definitive moments in the game. There were more tactical tweaks that the coaches
had to react to, but you also see the formation of Arteta's City template, City blueprint.
From my point of view, as soon as the game was 0-0 at half-time, that double combination of
Martinelli and Havertz was screaming to come on, as I'll get on to. And it was one of those
opportunities for me that opened up the game and made it a sort of must-win for Arsenal,
as strange as that sound. And I think Arteta definitely saw it that way. Of course, Martinelli
on at half-time, and Jesus as well, as Arsenal wingers, they were much more aggressive in their
positioning, pushing City's centre-backs in Ake and Diaz, who were obviously split by
Nketiah pressing Ederson in the middle. And they also shadow-man-marked Walker and Guardiola to
try and force City to turn over the ball. But, once more, Pep Guardiola reacted to this, and
he opted to switch the play for Manchester City much more regularly. And this shift of approach,
shift in directness, and in a way giving up that sort of central control that they wanted to in
the first half, was exemplified in Guardiola's set of substitutions, because Docu, Nunez and
Stones came on for Alvarez, Kovacic and Lewis. Docu, of course, suddenly became that wide 1v1
and the ability to play on either side was reacted to by Mikel from Tomiasu.
And this meant that Docu wouldn't have gone up against Zinchenko on the right-hand side 1v1,
and he actually remained on Ben White's side. Of course, when Arteta saw that Tomiasu wasn't up
against Docu 1v1, and it would have been Walker again, he actually allowed Tomiasu to drift
forward, almost playing a second striker role, acting as another outball alongside Kai Havertz.
But back to Pep Guardiola's change in mentality in the game in substitutions, because Nunez also
came on for Kovacic and provided greater legs in midfield to try and break the lines in a different
fashion. I think Kovacic yesterday often struggled with the pace of the game. I'm not going to get
onto the red card, although I was fuming with the decisions at the time, and I'm not going to get
onto that. But Nunez, I think, added that athleticism alongside Stones in his replacement
for Rico Lewis to try and go toe-to-toe with Arsenal in the transition. That was Pep's and
Arteta's plan, ultimately, as the game wore on. And it made the game incredible, because it was
completely there for the taking for either side. There was nothing splitting the sides, and that's
why I say it was a bit of a dogfight. These athletic monsters going toe-to-toe in the duel
after a real nullified tactical battle between the two managers. One manager adapting and making a
new sort of tactical tweak, the other one reacting to that. And it was something that Arteta has
definitely learned from that fretful day in April in Manchester last season, when Pep moved from a
4-2 build-up shape to a 4-3 and completely overloaded Arsenal, and in a way, confounded
Arteta as to what to do. But why did Arsenal become so threatening in the transition, and why
was I so happy that that was the case? Because here came Mikel Arteta's changes, and Havertz
and Martinelli were my dream substitutions. Like I said, I was calling throughout the whole game.
We infused that straight-line running power, which is the last sort of thing in our attacking
dynamics we were waiting for. And even without Havertz, I think, because obviously Martinelli
came on at half-time. Jesus still did a tremendous job of being that outlet, off the right at times,
taking balls down, over his head, pinning Guardiola back. And even though, at times,
his sort of decision-making can be improved, he generally retained possession very, very well
when Martinelli came on. And you guys know I've loved Jesus as a winger, and I've wanted to see
him there so much more often from Mikel Arteta. But back to Arsenal in the transition, and back
to their big-space set-up. Remember, this out-ball and this central clustering, often around the right-hand
side that Arsenal are using, and then to separate Martinelli as that wide, free man on the left,
bypassing the second phase of play, is something Arteta has introduced this season, and something
I've been very, again, outspoken on. And Havertz, of course, became that out-ball when he came on,
something I've been exhaustive of, of how, when he signed, in the long run, he will be moved as that
centre-forward, or that ram-deuter type, against low blocks in that 3-1-6 shape. And Jesus and
Oerdegaard clustered around Havertz in that inside right channel, to gobble up those second balls,
and I think combine this with Jorginho in possession, then pulling away more to that
right-hand side. It left Martinelli as that wide, free man, and look, him and Doku for Guardiola
and Arteta are two sides of the same coin. And this is a structure for this Arsenal, this staggered
structure, this big space set-up, is one that damages any side, and this is one that has been
implemented for the big nights in the Champions League, for the Manchester City affairs, for the
technical and physical games. It enables instant progression up the pitch, and more time playing
in City's half. You know, it was a real shift from the first half to the second half, now it was about
overloading the right-hand side, winning the knockdown, giving Martinelli the space to run
and be released. And it's typical that the game came from playing long to Havertz, something
Partey's verticality, actually, will be super for, and it's great to see the team not just using
long balls to sort of make that more direct approach, but also taking a more diverse approach
in attacking the smaller spaces, and going long to Havertz, not just from out-balls. And it's something
that we need to improve on in our game, maybe Partey can give it, but also something that we need
to add is those half-space crosses and balls into the box from outside the opposition blocks and in
those half spaces. And it's such an effective way of attacking and bypassing an opponent's block,
especially if they don't have a real physical back line. And it's something, by the way, that we've
never done reliably under Michel Arteta. Xhaka was our biggest player of those sort of crosses
last season, but obviously he's left now, and I think Odegaard has to be the player that steps up
and takes the mantle, in a way, for those types of crosses. Interestingly, Martin Odegaard this
season has 0.74 crosses per 90 minutes, which is super, super low, especially when you compare it
Kevin De Bruyne in Manchester City last season, who had 6.42 crosses per 90. Of course it helps
that he can over and underlap more than Odegaard, but those back-space, back-post crosses, particularly
to Kai Havertz, is something that needs to be introduced to Arsenal, otherwise we won't be as
complete as an attacking unit as we can be. So of course Havertz allows us to bypass the second phase
and skip over the toil of breaking aside as good as Manchester City down, if you will.
And he can be, at 6 foot 4, he can be such a pain to any defences. His aerial numbers as well,
success rate, are staggering. And it's about dominating the in-box action in those key
moments. I think for Havertz it's about simplifying his role now, now that he has been transitioned to
the Arsenal team. Utilise his link-up play exclusively with his back-to-goal in between
the lines. Invade space created for by others, and be in the right place at the right time, like a
typical Ram Deuter would be. Not that added pressure of being sort of the bigger toucher
of the ball, and joining the team through the thirds in that left interior role, where even as
he's playing as a shadow striker, at times that lack of second phase presence is either put on
Martin Oerdegaard, when it doesn't have to be. But like I said, this, I think for Arteta,
is the City blueprint. But I also don't think it changes anything from Pep Guardiola's point
of view, because there's so little to separate the teams tactically. These fine margins can
ultimately go against you, and it was such a close game, and it was a deflected goal that
won it for Arsenal. I think now touching on Arsenal long-term, again something I've aired
previously, and how the team is set up for the biggest occasions, it's flexible whether we
actually have to invert a full-back or not. And I think Timber gives us this optimally,
from his unpredictability of not just inverting from the left to right,
but playing as that outside, more conservative wide centre-back on the left or right.
And moving away from the midfield dynamics and how we control games,
Havertz of course in the centre-forward, Martinelli as that instant transitionary
weapon off the left. And it gives us, reliably, six players in the build-up,
plus the goalkeeper if you want, and of course that's the newest tactical implementation into
the league this season. The goalkeeper acts as a plus one in the build-up, as a left or right
centre-back. And this also gives us, again without the need to invert a full-back,
having four quasi-centre-backs on the pitch, and four weapons in attack at all times,
able to play a 3-1-6 or a 3-2-5 in settled play with that perfect balance in either shape.
And it's why I've been telling you, and you guys will know, telling you to hold off
in judging Havertz as a left interior. He can play that shadow striker role of course against
deeper blocks. But as I've said, without Partey and Declan Rice available in these bigger games,
with that being the closest Jaka-Partey dynamic we have, let's see where Havertz plays then.
And I think it was a really encouraging little cameo from him in the centre-forward,
as his best minutes for Arsenal have come so far. But that's the video. I know it was a long one,
really in-depth, and I loved making it. And I hope you guys loved watching it,
because if you're still watching now, I asked you to like, comment, subscribe,
I only asked you right at the end, because hopefully that means you've enjoyed the video,
taken something from it, if you're still watching by now. But that's all from me.
Thank you so much for watching. A great win for Arsenal, but one that will certainly not deter
Pep Guardiola's Manchester City. That's all from me, I'll catch you in the next one. See you later.
