Edu's Successor: Analyzing the Best Fits for Arsenal's Ambitions

Deluded Gooner
9 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 4, 2024
With Edu Gaspar leaving Arsenal, Arsenal need to appoint a new sporting director. The newspapers
have linked us with several names but the question is who is the best man for the job?
I don't have a clue but together we're going to take a deep dive into the profiles of people
who have been linked with the job. Let's go, don't forget to hit the like button,
comment and tell me who you believe would be the best based on what information I've presented.
At number 1, perhaps the most recognisable name on the list is the Portugueseman Luis Campos,
who's well experienced and a highly respected football sporting director slash football
executive. He's widely regarded as one of the most astute talent scouts and directors in the
modern game. As you know, he's built a reputation for building competitive squads with a limited
budget, discovering talent that can develop to a world-class platform and revolutionising football
recruitment strategies. I mean, his impact on modern football has been immense and you could
argue he's set a gold standard for squad building, influencing how clubs across Europe approach
talent acquisition and also recruitment. You look at his work at Monaco and Lyon in particular,
they demonstrate scouting excellence and also show strategic planning on both a financial and
sporting aspect and also show successes in that regard. Campos remains one of the most highly
sought after figures in football and his methods continue to inspire directors and clubs worldwide.
Now, at the time of making this video, his contract at PSG is winding down and there are
simultaneous rumours with PSG trying to get him to commit his future. So, is it a case where
Arsenal are genuinely looking at him, genuinely exploring the opportunity to bring an experienced
man who's going to leave his job on paper or is it a case of creative journalism for those very
same reasons? I'm not too sure. I've always said I do like the unique approach Arsenal took where
you've got young professionals relatively on a playing field and non-playing field all growing
together. But I do believe we need an experienced head and another experienced football head. I am
not comparing Mikel Arteta to Arsene Wenger or Campos to David Deane. They're very different.
But for those who are old enough to remember, there's a thin line between being a genius and
being insane. And I think David Deane was able to pull Arsene Wenger back from that.
Where you look at some of the signings that haven't universally been agreed,
Mikel Arteta, rightly or wrongly, has got his way. If we've got a more experienced man that
could better utilise our resources and is given the licence to do that from the cronkies, then
maybe we don't necessarily spend 65 million on Kai Havertz that's spent to a more traditional
striker. Take nothing away from Kai Havertz, just as an example. Where you look at the signings of
Aaron Ramsdale actually replacing Ramsdale with Rayo, Califuri and Kai Havertz and you just scroll
through the athletic or something of that ilk, it shows you that it wasn't a universal popular
decision by Arsenal to do that. Mikel Arteta pushed for it and he got his way, which probably
shows you the cronkies probably need to give more power to the next sporting director.
But I digress, people. Where you look at his philosophy and approach, Mr Campos' talent
identification is world-renowned. He's known for finding young players before they become
well-known entities. Next on the list, at 43 years of age, in his early 40s,
like Edu, we have Thiago Scuro, who has over two decades of experience. Naturally,
his career began in his homeland in Brazil. He worked at various clubs and in regional leagues
before making his way to the European game and finding himself at Monaco as their sporting
director in 2023 after joining from RB Leipzig. He is known as a strategic planner with strategic
adaptability. And if you're going to work at a club like Monaco, you need a keen eye for emerging
talent, which he has shown. These qualities could make him a fitting candidate where you look at
Arsenal as we seek, above all, a sporting director who is a visionary, capable of driving the
football club forward. He has worked at RB Leipzig. He has worked at RB Borgandante. No, forgive me
if I'm wrong. He actually might have went there before he went to Monaco. He did eventually
replace Paul Mitchell, who's English and known for, in his own way, how he operates as a sporting
director. You can see on screen the various players that he's brought into the club over the
last couple of years, seeing their trajectory. And you can see that they're all kind of indirectly
emerging talent, or very few of them are the finished articles, which obviously has adaptability
where Arsenal's concerned. What's interesting to me, apparently his philosophy is centred around
human relations, fostering a sense of belonging, organisation, and he's known as being a tough
negotiator. Now, some fans kind of criticised Edu for such people, if I'm honest with you.
He's known for his willingness also to connect all aspects of the club and build relationships
with key stakeholders, in which Arsenal talk about collaboration all the time. He's also,
through working at the Red Bull Network, has a structure in place in terms of the multi-club
network kind of stuff, and that is something I would think is a long-term option for Arsenal,
and it needs to be people. Again, he went from being CEO to sporting director, he kind of played
a key part in the organisational reshuffle at Monaco, and Monaco are doing quite well. They're
not quite doing what they did when they pipped PSG to a league title, but they're doing quite well.
And also, on the topic of the Red Bull Network, where you look at him indirectly and directly
working for New York Red Bulls, Salzburg, and also Leipzig, this shows he has an integration
of clubs worldwide, and above all, must have the competency of emerging talents, where to look,
how to look, how to get deals done, and also keeps an eye on the future, people.
This experience has given him a unique perspective of managing football across
different markets and cultures, which evidently is going to benefit Arsenal.
His strategy is often emphasising, once again, identifying and nurturing young players throughout
the academy, and obviously leveraging club scouting networks, people. When you read online,
it says he's data-driven, he makes data-driven apologies decisions, apparently he's a strong
advocate for using data analytics to guide decisions from player recruitment to tactical
approaches. Obviously, the eye test is also going to be known. He's also known for his
approach around sustainability. He prioritises creating a self-sustaining football model,
ensuring clubs can thrive financially while being competitive on the pitch.
Now, does that not sound like Arsenal to you lot, people? Where you look at global collaboration,
he has the ability to bridge local and global football philosophies, and that makes him a
valuable asset in organisations with strong ambitions, which I hope Arsenal is. Above all,
he's proven himself to be an astute operator who does his due diligence when identifying players
and making sure they're the right profile of the team, getting them in for the right price,
and he's also been known to do some shrewd signings in the summer, which doesn't always mean
bad. So, I like what he can bring on paper. As you know, Arsenal have also been linked with,
and you're going to have to give me for mispronunciation of his name, Simon Ruhle.
Some of you lot will remember him from his playing days. Obviously, he's a former Leverkusen player,
ironically, and German footballer, and has vastly become a very well-respected
football executive in that right. As said, currently he's working as the sporting director
of Leverkusen. He's known for his leadership and intelligence and data analytical approach
off the field, as well as his strategic squad building, focusing on, again, like some,
assembling a balanced team with youth experience and technical quality, which every sporting
director should do. Every team should want experienced players and young players. You know,
variety is the spice of life. Based on reports, he's seen as one of the brightest minds currently
in football management, or higher executive football management, and his approach serves
as a model for clubs aiming to combine competitive ambition with financial prudence, people. He's
helped to recruit the likes of Bonaface, Frim, Ponglin, Mundo, Hinckley, Florian,
Verts, Tatsuoba, Granit Xhaka. These are players of different profiles from different nations
who are at different periods in their career, who have all simultaneously helped Leverkusen
to achieve what they've gone on to do, which is picking up a few trophies and, like Arsenal,
going invincible. I mean, being invincible is also something that is obviously a good thing.
They pipped Bayern to the title, which is no mean feat. And again, like you've seen with Edu,
took a chance on an inexperienced manager in Xabi Alonso. He's also been linked with Liverpool
and Roma. Again, rumours are rumours. Oh, you could also throw Moussa Diaby into that as well.
You have to look at Leverkusen's recent success. There's not just a stroke of luck. Luck happens
when preparation is done. And that has to be a result of Leverkusen's team and Simon Rool's
deliberate and strategic planning. And it'd be fair to say currently there's a proven track
record that it seems to be working, where you look at sourcing young players, stars of tomorrow,
trying to compete against a juggernaut in Bayern Munich. In our case, it would be City.
It makes sense to have him on the shortlist. I think you guys have had enough of me butchering
names, so I mean no disrespect. But another man that has been on the list is Mr. Tim of West Ham.
He's known as a sophisticated and meticulous operator who embraces a data-led approach.
His initial arrival at West Ham was seen as a coop. He's someone that seems, based on reports,
that likes to be ahead of the curve. Obviously, at the moment, with the manager Luka Tegi and
obviously the signings not really doing much for West Ham, it looks like it was a bit of an issue,
we'll put it, in the transfer market. But they were praised for how the players they signed.
They were praised for installing Luka Tegi. And it makes sense, people. Again, a fellow German,
someone that's worked at a couple of clubs, that knows what he's doing. It's well known
he did not necessarily see eye-to-eye with David Moyes. Luka Tegi himself said on the first day
these two individuals, him and obviously Tim, had a disagreement about recruitment.
So is he a bit of a confrontational figure? Does it give you shades of mislintat at Arsenal?
I don't think Arsenal are too keen on him, people. But what I can't do is sit here and downplay his
work. There were some good signings at West Ham. He was instrumental in them signing, ironically,
former Arsenal man Mavro Parnos. He's done very well to help them get Kudus. He's probably better
known for his work where he worked with Simon Roos, as mentioned earlier, at Leverkusen and
Bremen, people. Which, again, this is going to put you in good regards. Now, personally, I don't
think he scores that high up the list at Arsenal. But who am I? I don't work for Arsenal. I don't
know anything. But I do like what I see from him. Gregory Lorenzi. As of 2024, he remains currently
a prominent figure at Brest, contributing to their efforts to maintain their competitiveness
in France's top footballing league, or Ligue 1. Under him, they've actually, for the first time
in their 74 history, competed and qualified for the Champions League. Which, to be honest, when
you're fighting the likes of Monaco, Marseille, PSG and the budgets that they have, that is not
an easy feat and something that should be applauded. He's played a pivotal role in shaping
the club's squad through strategic signings. Looking online, his approach seems to focus on
balancing young talents with experienced players, while obviously maintaining Brest's financial
constraints with the greatest of respect as a mid-tier league club. He's done a lot of notable
things, people. He's helped them get into the Champions League. This summer, he signed a number
of competent individuals who have brought something to their squad. They maintain a focus
on outsmarting the market and nurturing young talent that they bring in, all that comes through
their academy. Of course, there is an element of having to sell players on to maintain competitiveness
and look after the balance sheet. They've punched well above their weight in Ligue 1. They've
secured key signers that have aligned with the club's strategic goals and ensured, once again,
financial stability. So this shows his competencies. Once again, they shocked the whole of probably the
but more so France people when they did qualify for the Champions League. And as a sporting
director, naturally, you need to make difficult decisions. If there's one thing you can praise
for Edu, it would be his willingness to take a chance on the inexperienced and still inexperienced
five or so years into his role, Mikel Arteta. The same rings true for Mr Lorenzi, as he convinced
Eric Roy to return to coaching, which some would say was a stroke of genius, people. He led them
to third in the league, which is their best ever league finish. And as I've said a couple of times,
Champions League qualification, they did very well in the last summer to stretch their budget to the
extent they did. They carefully, craftily finessed a well-rounded squad, people. And they're laughing
at that. When you look at Lorenzi, I think he demonstrates the importance of clearly determining
the profile of player that you want, scouting structure and manager people. You know, when they
look to replace Moet and Straciano, I can't pronounce his name. They've done well in that
regard. They're the kind of club that have the replacements for the replacements on top of
obviously bringing in good names as suggested. And there seems to, he could be someone that could
angle for a move to Arsenal. He's been linked with clubs in France prior. He's also actually
technically been linked with Roma as well as Arsenal. So he could be someone to take a chance
on and obviously Arsenal love a French connection. Roberto Alabi, he's a Spanish football sporting
director currently serving as the director of football at Sociedad. He has gathered a lot of
significant respect within the footballing world for his expertise, his strategic and clear vision
and his leadership qualities, and also being instrumental into Sociedad's recent success people
and remaining competitive in Ligue 1. He's had a couple of stints at Sociedad before, but he
returned to the club in 2018 as the director of football. Naturally, key responsibilities will be
building the squad and shaping the football club's philosophy while sticking to their principles. As
we know, Sociedad and Bilbao, they're very keen on local talent and players that reflect the fan
base off the field. And ironically, you know, he is Spanish like Mikel Arteta from the same region.
We see a growing Spanish influence at all levels at Arsenal. Could this be something? In fact,
he actually signed Mikel Arteta once upon a time. And naturally, because of Arsenal's dealings in
recent years for Quirin Tini, for Nacho Monreal, for Mikel Mourinho across the summer, and maybe
a couple of other examples, he's someone that might, while he's been on the outside, might have
a working insight as to how Arsenal like to operate. Despite his contract being until 2026, he
has actually told Sociedad that he would like to depart the football club. And I mean, his time at
Sociedad is going to be remembered fondly. He helped establish or re-establish Sociedad as one
of the leading clubs in Spain. They ended their 30-year drought, people, when they won the 2021
Copa del Rey. He's also credited with assembling a squad that, again, balances youth development
with strategic signings. You look at Ozzy Arabal promoting Martin Zupermandi, the same could be
said for Azarabal, and Ander Borussia, I cannot pronounce his name, forgive me for mispronunciation,
but it shows there's a key remit to promote academy talent. He obviously got Martin Odegaard
on loan, which probably played a role in Arsenal indirectly once upon a time signing him. You look
at the signing of Alexander Izak, they bought him for 10 million and sold him for 70. What a profit
that is. They obviously got David Silva when they needed it and Kubo to ensure the team's
competitiveness. When you look at the acquisition of Mikel Mourinho when he was pried away from his
club, he quickly established himself as a member of Sociedad's midfield and the heartbeat of such
people. His value skyrocketed, look at how he was looked at in the footballing world, to obviously
him being signed by Arsenal for a lot of money. So it shows he can find trash and turn it into
treasure, forgive me for referring to these players as that people. You look at what he's
implemented, the philosophy focuses on long-term stability, people. It leverages the academy,
it makes astute moves in the market and players that fit the system and the dynamic and remains
competitive. They've obviously consistently competed in European competitions, which is
music to the cronkies ears, being more recently in the Champions League prior to the Europa League.
So they're doing what needs to be done, youth development, balance squad building,
club identity. It makes sense and it makes sense as to why Mr Roberto Alobi has established himself
as one of the most effective sporting directors, not just in Spanish football,
but in world football. His work at Sociedad is a model for clubs looking to compete at the highest
level while having financial sustainability and a strong identity, if I'm completely honest with
you. As I said, people, for me, he would be someone that I'd be keen on because maybe he
could help Zoubamedie, bring Zoubamedie with you and convince him to leave. He's not only from
Spain but from the same similar region as Arteta. He's clearly significantly experienced at his
role where Arsenal need that. Youth Academy and promoting the youth and making sure they kick on
is something that's central to him. Outsmarting the market, you could argue Arsenal need to start
doing that. And most importantly, having a clear identity. Now, of course, you know, in the modern
day, budget management, financial operations, all of these sort of things go into being a sporting
director in part, people. So it makes sense for me. So yeah, people, I'm no expert on, you know,
the inner dealings that these directors have done. But I do think I've done my best to give
you a very recent overview. Who would you take as a sporting director? For me, it's either gotta be
Olabe or Sossiedad or Luis Campos. I just think because they've got a proven track record of what
we want to do. When you think of Olabe, we'll be here all day talking about what he's done at
Sossiedad. When you think Luis Campos, you think, you know, what he did in his own way at Monaco
and Lille. I want that. I want an experienced head to kind of guide Mikel Arteta because I do
think we're in a unique place that Mikel Arteta at present is the only footballing brain in the
structure of Arsenal Football Club. So yeah, man, it wouldn't surprise me if no doubt none of these
names end up being the sporting director. I'm keen to see what it looks like. We've obviously
been linked with Murtazaka, Ryzycki and people of that ilk. Personally, I want somebody a bit
better, if I'm honest with you. I should say a bit more experienced. But you can't rule out
another young, young sort of individual, youngest individual because there's some young ones on the
list that obviously have done what they need to do. You know, over the international break,
we've evidently heard that the executives and the decision makers and Mikel Arteta flew to LA
to speak with the Cronkies about all things Arsenal. You'd imagine this is on the agenda.
You'd imagine Arsenal, apologies, started planning for this way before it became clear that Edu was
leaving because they must have got wind for it. Even going back into the summer, people,
Edu was linked with a move away from Arsenal. I do think the sporting director needs to be
given an equal kind of voice to Mikel Arteta because for all of Edu's faults,
I don't think he was allowed to kind of project himself, if I'm completely honest.
But that's my thoughts. Don't forget to like, comment and subscribe. Make sure you leave
a name as to who you want. Appreciative to you lot tuning in.
