How to Make Simnel Cake — The Victorian Way

Traditional cake in the world
311 followers
1 Video View·Oct 9, 2023
Today I'm making a siminal cake. It's a type of light fruit cake, very popular at this time of
year from Mothering Sunday to Easter. It's an ideal tea time cake for the family when
they're entertaining. For this recipe you will need
milk, yeast, flour, butter, cinnamon, nutmeg, sugar, currants, candied peel, eggs, brandy, almond paste
and crystallised fruit. I'm going to start by rubbing the butter into the flour.
This is a very old recipe. I am told that siminals are from a long time ago, back when the churches
would give their congregation something to eat when they gathered at Mother Church,
although we don't know what the recipe was from back then. There are lots of different versions
of siminal cake all over the country. Mr Strutt, Lord and Lady Braybrooke's son-in-law, tells me
that siminal is the Latin word for fine white flour and that he's often eaten them in wafer form.
My great-grandmother told me that traditionally hers were boiled and then baked. They were shiny
on the outside and difficult to cut open. I'm now going to add all my dry ingredients. The sugar,
the candied peel, the currants, a little cinnamon and nutmeg. Just a little.
There are a lot of tall tales about siminals. Annie Chase was telling me one just the other day.
I don't remember all the details but it was that siminal cake was first invented by a man
called Simon and his wife Nellie as they argued over what was the best cake. It was very involved.
There was a chair leg and a pudding. It was all very silly. Now I'm going to make a hole in the middle
and add my yeast which has been in warm milk along with the eggs and a little brandy.
In Wiltshire they make their siminals in the shape of a star and I once met a cook
who always wrapped hers in pastry. Nowadays they are mostly just plain cakes with fruit in them.
I like this one because it has yeast in it. That must mean it's an old recipe because only
old cake recipes have yeast in them. It'll mean that it's more robust which is ideal
because at this time of year the family are often travelling down to their townhouse.
I'm now going to cover this and let it proof for about two hours.
Now that my mix has started to bubble I'm going to put half in the cake tin and then put a layer
of this almond paste which Mary-Anne made for me in the middle and then put on the rest of the mix.
Not all siminal cakes have a layer of almond paste but I quite like it.
Siminals were popular at this time of year as they were used by those who follow Lent
as a weekend off. Mothering Sundays have often been a bit of a feasting time.
I remember making myself quite ill on Frimity when I was a child.
Traditionally though really this time of year is for making a pilgrimage to Mother Church.
No one does that kind of thing much nowadays although the eating traditions have still remained.
I understand in America they have a special day called Mother's Day which is quite different
and not popular here. Siminal cake I suppose has become an Easter cake.
Now this cake will be baked for between two and three hours and I might put some brown paper
around the outside if it looks like it's getting too dark. This is going to go into the oven
for between two and three hours. I will cover the top and perhaps wrap it in brown paper
if it starts to get a little too brown now that it's been baked.
Now my cake is baked and has cooled I've used some of the almond paste to make a ring around it
and then brown it a little with a salamander. Now it's time to decorate it and I'm going to
use some of these candied fruits. You could I suppose use almond paste to make different shapes
or turrets which would look very delightful but not very practical for traveling.
I have seen some with icing in the middle and you could write happy Easter on it.
And there you are Siminal cake ideal for a springtime afternoon tea.
