How old is our Universe actually? Is it 13, 26, or 27 billion years old? I had the pleasure of discussing this fascinating topic with the one and only Joe Rogan. Enjoy this clip from The Joe Rogan Experience!
So this claim of 26 billion years, does it make any sense?
It can make sense in the following context.
Imagine you see a planet, and on that planet there are people,
and they're playing around with these electrified pieces of silicon.
And you'd be like, wait a second, that's really weird.
That planet's only 4 billion years old.
How is it possible that they're not only able to talk on electrified silicon,
but they're also having an internet and space flight?
No, no, no. It takes longer.
In my model of how civilizations form,
it must have taken 8 billion years for that to happen.
So therefore, it's impossible to reconcile with the Earth being 4.3 billion years old.
Therefore, the Earth must be 8 billion years old.
What he said, this guy Gupta said, there are properties of galaxies,
they're rotating, they're appearing too early on in the universe's early history
to have developed into the spiral characteristics
and the population distribution of them.
It's too numerous to have occurred in a universe
that's only, quote unquote, 13 billion years.
And you actually said that. You said, like,
I always thought 13 billion's a pretty big number.
You know, now they're saying 27, so what's the difference?
But there's a big difference, because implicit in that criticism
is that there are flaws and imperfections in how we understand the Big Bang, OK?
When in reality, at best, he could be correct about the formation of galaxies.
But you see, those are two separate things, right?
The formation and the structure of a galaxy
has no bearing on how old the universe is, necessarily.
It tells you something about your models of computer simulations,
is what he's effectively criticizing,
not criticizing the evidence that something like a Big Bang
occurred at a very definite point in the universe's past,
that we believe to about one — to the —
we have equivalent precision for me to say,
I know how old you are exactly,
but if you looked at a 50-year-old person,
you could say, you know the day they were born, plus or minus a week.
Like, that's the precision with which modern astronomers
know the age of the universe.
And one guy is coming up with this idea
that because there are certain galaxies within it that have formed this —
again, imagine if we found, like, a hyper-advanced civilization
that has warp drives and, you know,
does type 3 Dyson civilizations or whatever.
They would not cast doubt on the evolution
and the history of the universe itself.
That would not cause me to question that.
It would cause me to question my models of how people form and —
Right. — aliens form and stuff like that.
But it wouldn't cause me to question the age of the universe.
There's nothing related to it.
When we are studying the age of the universe
and the vastness of space,
is there potentially new technology that would expose more
than we currently can view that would change your model?
In the sense that we are —
John's a scientist, especially me as an experimentalist.
In contrast to people like Brian Cox,
Neil deGrasse Tyson, Eric Weinstein, et cetera,
my job is not to prove theories right.
My job is actually to prove them wrong.
That's really what I get paid to do,
is to narrow and winnow out so much so that what is left is the truth.
There's a quote by Isaac Asimov.
He said, if you think the Earth is flat, you're wrong.
If you think it's a perfect sphere, you're also wrong
because it's not a perfect sphere.
It actually bulges at the equator.
It has properties, you know, because the Earth is spinning.
And the way it formed, it's a little bit like a pear.
Okay. So it's also not —
but it's much less wrong to say it's a sphere
than to say it's flat.
Our job is to find the flaws in the existing paradigms,
shatter those, and refine those.
And there's countless, you know,
examples of that throughout scientific history.
So there are ways that I would be caused to doubt
the formation story of galaxies. Absolutely.
I mean, that's almost like predicting hurricanes.
You know, I just came through a hurricane to see you, right?
There's a big hurricane in San Diego this week,
and it's like an inch of rain, okay?
You know how we drive in Southern California, right?
So even a slick of a trace of rain
causes us to go into total terror.
But we didn't know where it was going to make exact landfall
because climate is an example
not of something that's merely complicated.
It's complex.
The best way to simulate the Earth's climate
is with another Earth.
In other words, there's no irreducible way
to reduce the amount of complexity
to describe a physical system than the system itself.
That's a notion of complexity.
That's a definition of complexity.
So in the context of what you said, absolutely.
And people like Allison and others, Kirkpatrick,
they definitely would be more thrilled than anybody
to discover, well, we didn't understand
there's something wrong with our model of how the universe —
not how the universe formed, but how galaxies form.
So what I'm asking is,
with the levels of detection that we have available,
how significant is the change in what the web is able to do?
And is it possible that — like, when we're looking —
is it whatever levels of detection,
whatever methods of detection we have now,
is it absolute — if you go to 13-point-whatever-billion-years,
is it possible that with new technology
we would get more information, we'd be able to see more,
and then you would remap this idea?
Yes. And the good news is,
that's what the Simons Observatory is trying to do.
The Webb Telescope was never built for,
nor can it say anything about the Big Bang
or what caused the Big Bang or —
It's just galaxy formations.
Not just, by the way.
That's a pretty big deal, but it's absolutely —
Galaxy formation, properties of stars, exoplanets,
the atmospheres, the chemistry, civilizations on exoplanets.
It can do so much cool stuff.