Charles Barry and A.W.N. Pugin, Palace of Westminster (Houses of Parliament)

Charles Barry
6 followers
Oct 4, 2023
We're looking across the River Thames at the Houses of Parliament in London.
It's tempting to think that this was built hundreds of years earlier than it was.
It was built in the early Victorian era.
There was a great fire in 1834 and it burned down the old palace that had been here.
And there was a competition that was held for designs for a new building.
The competition had the stipulation that the new structure had to be designed
in one of two historical styles.
It had to either be Gothic or it could be Elizabethan.
That is, from the time of Shakespeare.
There were something like 97 entries to the competition
and the vast majority were in the Gothic style.
So that's why this looks like it was built hundreds of years before.
It's in the style of the Gothic, which dates from the late medieval period.
The competition was won by an architect whose name is Charles Barry
with the assistance of Augustus Pugin,
who was responsible for the interior designs as well as the stained glass
and some of the exterior decorative forms.
Pugin was known for his love of the Gothic,
for his belief in the Gothic as the right and true moral style of architecture
and also a style of architecture that was associated with Englishness.
This is why the competition stipulated it needed to be Elizabethan or Gothic.
We think about the Gothic as French,
but in England in the 19th century, the Gothic was English.
I think it raises the issue,
why was the 19th century so fascinated with reviving older architectural styles?
What was that about?
And of course the reason has to do with industrialization,
with the new modern world and the way that that unsettled people.
Well, the modern era seemed ugly,
a period of factories and steam engines.
It seemed like there was nothing beautiful about it.
When they looked at the past,
they saw the beautiful architecture of the Gothic period.
They looked at the classical past and they saw beauty.
But when they looked around them, they didn't see beauty.
They saw the industrial world.
This was now a period when you could buy cheaply made goods for the first time
and the old systems of handicraft had been replaced.
People had moved from the country
where people had learned through apprenticeship traditions of making things,
but now things were being produced by factories
and it was an unsettling period.
So I think it's natural that people looked back to historical styles,
especially a building like this,
which was meant to be the seat of government.
And is still today the seat of government.
This is where the House of Commons meets.
This is where the House of Lords meets.
This building represents the parliamentary system.
So you're right, it had to really speak of tradition.
But it really speaks of a kind of falsehood.
This is not the Gothic.
It is a modern invention.
In fact, the building itself uses quite a number of modern innovations
in its constructive techniques.
It's an enormous building on a concrete bed,
certainly not a medieval tradition.
Concerned with ventilation, in fact,
the central tower was added to the design
in order to help support ventilation in the building.
And so this building really is a product of the 19th century.
Architectural historians call this the Gothic Revival.
And the Gothic really did stand for a kind of Victorian fantasy,
a 19th century fantasy of medieval artisan craftsmanship,
of a time of really taking care in making things by hand.
And so we look at this and we just see an architectural style.
But it's a style that's really associated with very specific values
that the Victorians were trying to return to.
And in fact, Pugin, one of the two architects who worked on this building,
published a book called Contrasts,
which paired the modern and the medieval worlds.
And the modern world did not come out well.
It was a deeply moralizing book
that looked at the way in which medieval society
was full of moral virtue,
but the modern society had squandered that.
So, for example, there was one famous plate
that showed the modern city,
where the skyline was dominated by factories and smokestacks,
versus the medieval city,
where the landscape was dominated by church steeples.
That is, by a reverence for God, a kind of moral center.
The comparison between a world guided by faith,
that he imagined was the medieval Gothic world,
and a world guided by a hunger for money.
And he's drawing very stark contrasts.
But the Victorians loved to do that.
They loved to compare the old medieval world of faith
with the new modern quest for money and fortune.
And so it's important for us to understand a building like this
within that Victorian context.
Let's get back to the building itself.
We see this magnificent exterior
that just spans the edge of the River Thames.
And we can see this reference back to the medieval style
of the perpendicular Gothic.
And in fact, it was very self-consciously
based on the Chapel of Henry VII
in this late Gothic style that we know as the perpendicular.
It's just at the east end of Westminster Abbey,
which is a building that is just behind this one.
And here we can see these large windows,
an emphasis on the rectilinear,
vertical, and tracery and lace work.
We can see that each window has at its top
tracery work that divides the glass up,
almost like a filigree effect.
The architect is really maximizing the window space.
And this is a feature of the high Gothic.
Barry had traveled extensively
and really loved the classical tradition,
even though he's building here in this faux Gothic.
But if you look closely,
you can see Barry's interest in the classical.
Look at the regularity of this facade.
Look at the sense of rhythm and balance.
And it's really only the exterior decorative forms
that refer to the Gothic style,
because the building as a whole
is laid out with a kind of symmetry, regularity,
that is really at odds,
even with the conception of the Gothic
from the 18th and 19th centuries,
where the idea of the picturesque,
the idea of the organic,
the idea of the asymmetrical was so important.
So we could say that this is, in some ways,
a classical building with a Gothic skin on it.
Nevertheless, or perhaps because of this,
the Houses of Parliament is just such an extraordinary example
of the 19th century's concern for historical style.
And an interest in avoiding confronting the modern.
