Gartenarchäologie im Schatten des Bauhauses – Der Garten des Hohenhofs in Hagen

LWL-Archäologie für Westfalen
1 Abonnent
03.10.2023
Mirjam Kötter ist Leiterin der Abteilung Denkmalschutz und Stadtarchäologie in Hagen.
Eva Cichy ist wissenschaftliche Referentin bei der Außenstelle Olpe der LWL-Archäologie für Westfalen.
In ihrem Vortrag stellen die Archäologinnen gartendenkmalpflegerische Untersuchungen vor, auf deren Grundlage die historische Gartenanlage des 1907 errichteten Hohehofs in Hagen wiederhergestellt werden soll.
Hello, my name is Miriam Kötter from Hagen.
We would like to talk about the project at the Hohenhof together.
First of all, it will be a little bit of building,
to give you a brief idea of what the Hohenhof is,
what kind of object it is.
Here is a historical recording.
This is part of the construction work that is currently taking place.
What role does the monument care at the Hohenhof play at the moment?
On the one hand, this is the support of the construction workers
on the part of the construction monument care.
So we have a building monument and the garden is part of it.
So we have to be on site for construction meetings on a regular basis.
Then materials have to be adjusted on a regular basis,
restoration questions have to be clarified
and, of course, last but not least,
the reaction to the ground monument care,
which is then shaped, especially here in this case,
by the finding of wall remains.
And why is all this?
The big goal is IGA 2027.
Yes, very briefly a little bit about the history of the Hohenhof.
The Hohenhof has a very varied history
as the original residence of Karl-Ernst Osthaus and his family.
The multiple use of the Hohenhof,
but also the different actors in the garden
have left their mark.
And there is the use as a women's clinic
with chief physician's office in the former men's room of Karl-Ernst Osthaus
and as a location for the Pedagogische Hochschule in the 60s to 70s.
So they only form a very small part of many conversions over time.
While the main architect Henry van de Velde for Osthaus
mainly styled the villa as a total work of art
through the design of the cutlery
up to the clothing of Osthaus' wife,
the garden architect Leberecht Miege
worked on the design of the garden from 1913 onwards,
especially here in the southern part of the property.
You can see a small section here, a plan by Leberecht Miege,
and he mainly worked on the southern part.
You can still see it quite well in the area,
at least we believe we have recognized it,
where van de Velde's planning also ends and Miege's starts.
The transition from van de Velde's planning to Miege
can still be traced back to the sources
that have to be studied regularly during the course of the project
and also in the area.
With regard to the international significance of the Hohenhof
for the history of art and culture,
but above all as one of the most important monuments in Hagen,
it was a bit of a surprise, at least for me,
that the Hohenhof Samtgarten was not included
in the list of monuments of the city of Hagen until 2010.
But it was already noticed that the significance of the Hohenhof
as a total work of art was already recognized quite early.
So it was always treated as a monument
and yet, of course, all these revocations
also left their mark.
After Hagen decided to apply for the Hohenhof
for the International Garden Exhibition in 2027,
it was first commissioned by the garden architect Susanne Weißer in 2018
to create a garden monument care development concept.
Here we also see a rough plan in the left part.
This has become even more detailed in the execution planning afterwards.
She was working on the garden
and also made some archaeological assumptions
by looking with a shovel or a spade
to see if she could find any road fortifications or walls.
So she first created a development concept
and that should later be the basis for the further occupation of the IGA.
At the heart of the IGA project is the restoration of the garden
according to a historical model.
On the day of the open monument in 2019,
the resonance with around 2,000 visitors was only at the Hohenhof,
so not on that day itself, but only at the Hohenhof,
as high as never before.
On that day, the first archaeological examinations were also carried out,
which were then carried out by the external excavation in the southern garden.
The so-called Buddha pit, which you can see here in the lower picture,
was one of the most important structural remains in the southern part of the Hohenhof
that should be restored in their substance.
Everything else that is now being restored in the garden
is purely reconstruction work.
We do have a few photos that we can refer to,
but that's a lot of speculation.
Sometimes the angles of view are not the ones we need,
but we are missing the last hint on the right edge of the picture.
So it's mostly reconstruction,
but the Buddha pit is actually one of the parts
that could really be reconstructed in its essence.
Yes, complete reconstruction of paths, walls, trees,
flower beds and other plants.
So the goal is IGA.
Of course, it's about planting and flowers,
but also insects, everything that has to do with the environment.
And you still follow the plans of Pfandl, Felde and Miege.
Ms. Weißer's garden conservation development concept
was to be the basis for all subsequent planning in the Hohenhof garden.
In the next step, funding was applied,
the spending of which is closely linked to the requirements of environmental and species protection.
In addition to the conservation and archaeological questions,
aspects of the reproduction of a sustainable, ecological,
rich garden system were very quickly in the foreground.
In 2021, the planning office ERIK carried out the implementation planning.
And in April 2022, it actually started archaeologically correctly.
With the construction works, shortly before the first excavators rolled,
the last preliminary investigations were carried out by the Außenstelle Olpe
in the area of the suspected playground.
In this project, the spirits in Hagen are dividing.
Some see it as a great opportunity to finally give the Hohenhof the attention it deserves.
Others see it as an excess of a million projects,
including a large part of the trees that have now become very old
and have had to suffer.
So it was a huge discussion,
because, of course, trees have grown that were never planned by Rostaus.
And the dispute over the old tree stand,
which can be seen as part of the garden,
but which was never planned by Rostaus in this form,
will probably go down in history.
So we're still discussing that today.
Yes, then there were preliminary investigations by the archaeologists
before the construction began, but they were not the last.
Of course, this had to be reacted to in the course of the construction works.
In May, a few weeks after the start of the work,
the city of archaeology was called to the Hohenhof for the first time
at the edge of the Westgaten.
Then, at regular intervals,
further construction-accompanying documentation work was carried out
by the Außenstelle and partly also by the city of archaeology.
Yes, and a significant contribution to the research of the structural remains in the garden
was carried out in advance of the construction works.
And of course, they could be integrated into the later planning.
Then I'll take over now.
Older park and garden facilities of castles and monasteries
are often objects of archaeological excavation.
In Westphalia, for example, the baroque garden facilities
at Körtlinghausen Castle in Rüthen,
the Friedrichsthaler Baroque Garden in the Freilichtmuseum Detmold
or Schloss Berge in Gelsenkirchen-Bur.
Or, as we will hear in a moment, the investigations of the garden in Chorweil.
Or a completely different example,
parts of the water art in the Banyo park facility of a water garden in Burgsteinfurt
with a flowering period between 1765 and 1820.
However, the research of facilities of the 20th century is rather rare.
An example is the investigation of the garden created between 1925 and 1930
on the Dessauer Bauhaus site.
As with the garden of the Hohenhof,
the question of the realization of designs
and the materials used in the focus was also there.
While, above all, the house-like garden areas of the Hohenhof
are more or less well documented based on historical recordings,
the areas further away,
for example the playground, which we have just heard about,
or paths in the dark forest,
you will see in a moment what that is,
it is unclear how the planning was implemented at all.
So we started in March 2019 with our investigations.
And we actually did about 30 small surveys until April 2022.
Here you can see only the most important of them,
not, for example, the surveys in the so-called dark forest.
That would be this area here,
and many other smaller stories.
We proceeded differently.
At the very beginning of the spring, we did small surveys by hand
and also hand-examined this beehive.
In the summer of 2019, we got a small excavator
and did larger surveys around the house.
And then, as we have just heard,
in 2022, we investigated the landscape-building work
and especially in the western garden, in the so-called utility garden area.
And you can see the example of this wall
that limits the utility garden to the path.
And we found it very nicely in the foundations.
And as Mirjam said earlier,
at the beginning of the focus was mainly on the so-called Buddha pit,
a small, recessed seating area
from which we know from a letter of a reader from Karl Witt,
the head of the Osthaus Museum and a good friend of Osthaus,
that he fell victim to vandalism
a few years after the death of Karl-Ernst Osthaus.
The design of this garden element actually comes from Osthaus himself.
So, after Vandefelde overplanned the garden,
he thought about it himself and wanted to have this seating area built,
which he did before Miggel was added in 1913
and re-designed it.
On the base, which we see on the left,
was, as we know from Witt,
a Japanese god statue from the collection of Osthaus.
And we found out
that there were probably tiles on a floor from Estria.
On the top left, you can see an example of this construction brick,
so that we had a tile floor.
And in these recesses, which you can see at the top and bottom of this Buddha pit,
there were probably seats in the past.
We found mortar remains of this at about half the height.
Witt also mentions a water basin, which was supposed to have been there.
The idea is that in the middle of these steps,
this rectangular recess with mortar remains
might have been the place where this water basin was located,
which had already been lost in the 1920s.
Then it was very important to find out how these paths in the forest were originally built.
On the left, you can see an example from the plan by Leberecht Miggel,
how these paths were actually designed and laid out.
We also found the last remains of a split surface,
and below that a heterogeneous stone layer
made of gray slag, construction debris, brick and a little slag.
And we were able to prove that the whole thing
was framed with these large polygonal bricks on the sides.
A special focus was then mainly on the area of the South Garden.
This is where the exact location of the Serenite,
a sculpture by Aristide Bayolle, was to be found,
which you can also see in the photo,
and the design of Henry Vandevelde as closely as possible.
We can also see that in this picture,
which shows this exact time frame,
i.e. the design of Henry Vandevelde.
Unfortunately, we were unable to find the traces of the bed surfaces.
Vandevelde probably used simple metal bands
that could not be identified.
But we found something else.
A large rectangular foundation was discovered,
here marked with 1, made of large polygonal brick,
in black-gray mortar with a lime deposit in the so-called blue concrete.
And because of the size, the positioning and the shape,
we assume that we have actually found the foundation
for this foundation base here.
Then, to be seen in the picture under the 2,
we found a narrow, leading to it from the north,
a foundation base.
And we got this special layout
provided by Ms. Weiss,
which you can see on the right in the picture.
This special layout, these are additional plans
that Leberecht-Migge made for the garden
and which, by chance, only a few years ago
reappeared in Switzerland, to our luck.
And we now assume
that this special layout was actually implemented.
And after the research,
a photo was published, which you can see on the top right,
which actually shows the implementation of this special layout.
However, around this rectangular small space,
we see a buxbaum hedge insertion in the photo.
And what we found, called the 3,
is something different instead.
Namely, an insertion with stones
placed in concrete.
And this whole inserted area
does not correspond to the plans that we have,
but is a bit larger and longer.
And what was not part of the known plans
is what you see under 4,
namely a step located on the south edge.
So we have actually rediscovered a redesign of this space,
of which we do not know when it took place and by whom.
We know that this sculpture on the pedestal
was already sold in 1927.
So since then, the pedestal has been empty, so to speak.
And of course, we then thought
whether we might have reused this space with the free pedestal again.
And of course, the first thing that comes to mind
is the use of the site as a gauleiter school.
Maybe something else was put on this pedestal
and made it beautiful again.
That's the idea we have.
We can see a small find at the bottom right,
namely this fragment of a uniformed crew
from that time.
But we are actually missing photos or plans
that would really help us.
We then started a call in the press
to get more information.
Unfortunately, we have not yet received a response.
It remains to be seen that it has been assumed for a long time
that Henry Vandefelde has made his plans
especially in the house-like area.
So there is a change of letter between Osthaus and Vandefelde
and Osthaus and Lebrecht-Migge,
from which it is very clear
that Henry Vandefelde did not like it at all,
that someone was fooling around in his work
and tried to influence Osthaus vehemently
that it shouldn't be like that.
But we were able to prove that it happened very well,
namely that the Migge special planning was used.
We then found other elements,
which I did not present in detail,
such as bed insertion or this step and the like,
where we have to assume
that this is related to gauleiter re-planning from a younger time,
but where we also don't have any plans and the like.
We looked for things that we didn't find,
such as the already mentioned playground
and also the paths in the dark forest that we were looking for,
so this forest area that Lebrecht-Migge also designed.
So we found a bit of something,
we didn't find a lot,
some of it is now being implemented
and you can see the whole thing on the picture on the right,
how the whole thing will be presented to the public in 2027.
And of course we hope that the whole thing will receive as much attention and interest
as it did on the day of the Open Monument in 2019,
when we were really overrun by interested parties.
Thank you very much.
