Face the Nation: Sen. Graham, former Defense Secretary Esper and Rep. Fitzpatrick

Face the Nation
17 followers
Oct 2, 2023
We're back now with South Carolina Republican Senator Lindsey Graham. Good to have you here in person Senator
You just voted for a short-term deal that doesn't include a cent for Ukraine nor for the US border, right?
How did you swallow that? We had to keep the government open. We got 45 days to fix both problems
I listened to Kevin closely
They will come out of the Senate soon a bill that will have three legs to it disaster funding
We need more not less
Robust funding for Ukraine to get them through the next fighting season not 24 billion and a major effort to secure our border
I believe there's bipartisan support in the Senate to do both and it will go to the house. Hopefully in the next 30 days
What the speaker was talking about though was a bill HR to regarding the border that?
Senate Democrats will never get on board. There will be a company right so we got to fix asylum
We need border security agent increases we need more detention beds
I think there's Democratic support for major border security reform
But we have to attach it to Ukraine to those who say we need to fix our border
You're right to those who say we need to help Ukraine
You're right to those who say we need to do the border not Ukraine
You're wrong the vast majority of Senate Republicans would support a combination of border security Ukraine funding and disaster aid
Well when it comes to the house
Yeah
And the idea that we got to move swiftly right right the White House
told
Republican leadership that they don't have enough funding for Ukraine to make it through 45 days and the authorities they have are insufficient
Yeah, well, so how much time are you talking about needing you know I've been around of all I'm wearing a pin
Do you think I would leave Ukraine?
Hey, I don't believe that one bit this same White House says we don't need f-16s. We don't need high Mars
We don't need tanks. I've lost confidence in their evaluation what's going on in Ukraine. We've got a bunch of allies
They can help for six weeks
The allies have spent more money in Ukraine than we have and when you hear otherwise, it's just not true
It's been good burden-sharing, but I'm not worried about the next six weeks. I'm worried about next year
We will produce in the United States Senate
Ukraine funding 60 or 70 billion not 24 to get them through next year
We will have a border security measure that is strong and we will have additional
Disaster aid because the nation needs it. We're going to do those three things and I'm hoping our house colleagues will react
Positively to it. I think Kevin is the right guy at the right time
The only way he loses his job is if a handful of Republicans join up with the Democratic Party to fire him
That would be a disaster for the future of the Republican Party. That's not going to happen
Kevin has the
Overwhelming confidence of his membership. He worked to avoid a shutdown
He will help Ukraine, but he's telling everybody in the country including me
You better send something over for the border for me to help Ukraine and he's right to make that demand
understand but your look you're talking about to be clear a
Supplemental bigger than 24 billion dollars for Ukraine and that's a lot bigger in 45 days. Oh, absolutely
You know why because we need it. We haven't lost one soldier in the Ukraine
We spent less than 5% of our military budget 50% of the Russian army's been destroyed by the Ukrainians
They would be at Crimea already if the administration had been so slow and given weapons
And and we dedicate a lot of time to Ukraine on this program
Okay, so we find it important but I want to ask you because leader McConnell had gone into the lunch yesterday telling Senate leaders
That he believed the White House when they said they were running out of funding for Ukraine and then his deputies
Apparently urged him to drop it which is how you ended up with this bill with nothing in it for Ukraine
Is he in control of the caucus?
McConnell's been greater in Ukraine
But he picked a formula to lose votes for Ukraine to expect people like me and others to vote for Ukraine aid without border
Security is unreasonable Mitch made a miscalculation
He's been great on Ukraine. I told him a thousand times the key to Ukraine funding is to deal with a broken border a
Hundred and seven thousand Americans have died from fentanyl poisoning from fentanyl coming across the southern border
We haven't lost one soldier in
Ukraine so
America is being invaded from a broken southern border to my Democratic colleagues. You need to take border security
Seriously. Yeah, are you saying that Ukraine should not be a standalone?
It has to be it will not be a standalone when I go to South Carolina
I openly talk about helping Ukraine. If you let Putin get away with this you have a bigger war. Well, what about our border?
I promise people in South Carolina. I'm gonna do two things
I'm gonna help secure our border and keep the fight going in Ukraine to make sure that Putin doesn't get away with this
Have you asked?
Donald Trump your friend to come out and publicly support more aid to Ukraine and to push some of these skeptical members of the Republican
Conference, I'll leave it up to him to what to do, but he wanted to get out of Afghanistan
Vladimir Putin has been praising him for his comments about president Trump
He did not pull the plug on Afghanistan
Even though he wanted to the biggest mistake we've made since the war on terror is withdrawing from Afghanistan
To President Trump and anybody else if we pull the plug on Ukraine, that's ten times worse than Afghanistan
There goes Taiwan to stop funding Ukraine is a death sentence for Taiwan
Putin will keep going you missed all the World War two if you don't know how this
Movie ends to the Republicans who say Ukraine doesn't matter to us. You're wrong
Respectfully, you're wrong. The war gets bigger not smaller
There goes Taiwan if Ukraine can beat Russia China's less likely to invade Taiwan and Putin gets stopped
I need to take a break here, but we have more to talk about with you senator
You will
Senator Graham's gonna stay with us and we're gonna talk about the legacy as well of Senator Dianne Feinstein on the other side of that
Break, we'll be right back
Welcome back to face the nation. We turn now to the life and the legacy of California Senator Dianne Feinstein who died late last week
Women are seen as spear throwers of change
It were not the same thing repeating itself
Then Senate candidate Dianne Feinstein first appeared on face the nation in 1992 miss Feinstein
Is is gender a plus or a minus for you?
There's so many men back there and we don't see anything happening
The Californian was a pioneer winning her seat in the year of the woman
The Senate went from two female lawmakers to six
Feinstein said it was the first time she felt her gender wasn't a negative for voters
When she was elected to the San Francisco Board of Supervisors in 1969, there weren't many women in public office
Feinstein became the first female mayor of the city following the assassination of two of her colleagues
both mayor Moscone and
Supervisor Harvey milk have been shot and killed
She never forgot that experience and championed gun laws including the 1994 assault weapons ban when she reached the Senate
I am quite familiar with firearms. I became mayor as a product of assassination
I'm aware of found my assassinated colleague and put a finger through a bullet hole though
It expired ten years later her passionate campaign continued. Let me talk about rights for a minute
Does a child have a right to be safe in school?
Does a law client when it goes that he goes into a law firm have a right to believe he's safe
Does a shopper in a mall have a right to believe that she's safe?
I think so that position put her at odds with conservatives
but she became a deal-making centrist an
Increasingly rare breed in Washington and at times challenged her own party
This is not what Americans do as the first woman to head the powerful intelligence committee
She sparred with the CIA director and accused the agency of trying to cover up its past abuse of terror suspects
We're supposed to be better than that that we don't have to torture people
America she argued is big enough to admit when it is wrong and should be confident enough to learn from its mistakes
Being a pioneer wasn't easy as she told Bob Schieffer in 2009
We women have had to fight for everything we've gotten in the public arena
We weren't given the right to vote we had to fight for it today women make up a quarter of the Senate
following a path she helped to forge
Senator Graham was one of the Republicans as you saw there in that piece who worked with Senator Feinstein actually quite closely
Yeah, the Judiciary Committee. She was great when I first got to the Senate somebody told me now
Protect their their name here
If you want to get anything done
See if you can get Ted Kennedy and or Dianne Feinstein to help you because if they got on your bill or your idea
The people in the Democratic Caucus would listen if Ted was the lion. She's the lioness she could move votes
She knew how to get to yes on controversial things. She was always kind. She was always prepared. She was a defense hawk
She was socially liberal. She was my friend
I miss her and if you're looking for a role model in politics as young man or woman look to her life
You know, there is also that image of her embracing you after a very contentious hearing
Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett and she was criticized from within her own party for praising how you conducted yourself
How do you think about that now? Well that says more about the current state of affairs than Diane
Diane was saying nice things
We had a like a five-second hug and because she wanted to say something nice about me
They thought she had to be off the committee. That's what's wrong with Diane wasn't the problem
She was the solution and there are people on my side. It goes both ways. So let's just do this
Let's reflect on a well-loved life. America's better for Dianne Feinstein having served our country
California's better for it and we lost a lot. We just didn't lose a person
We lost an idea and I want to read my contribution is to try to read
Reinvigorate the idea. It's okay to be tough and kind
It's okay to be liberal or conservative, but it's even more okay to work for America. And that's what she did
We've lost a lot with Diane. So the rest of us we're gonna have to up our game
Before I let you go. I want to quickly ask you she was also an outspoken proponent of abortion access
She was are you going to reintroduce your bill limiting it to 15 weeks of access?
Which has kind of become a litmus test for a lot of these presidential candidates. Yeah, Donald Trump has not signed on
He said he didn't like 15 weeks. My bill has exceptions for rape incest life of the mother
47 or 50 European nation of 50 European nations limit abortions from 12 to 15 weeks
15 weeks the baby can suck its thumb and feel pain. I will introduce that bill
I want America to be like the civilized world not China or North Korea
It's a debate worthy of a great country to have this debate and we will have it senator Graham. Thank you for your time
We'll be back in a moment
We turn now to the former Secretary of Defense under President Trump and author of a sacred oath Mark Esper
Good to have you back with us today
You know, we are
We are having conversations about just how politically difficult
basic matters of governance are in
Washington
And I wonder what sign you think that sends to our adversaries around the world
Well, thank you Martha Margaret for having me on this morning first, let me also salute
Dianne Feinstein as we mourn her passing. She was a real leader in the Senate, you know time
She would buck her party. She could reach across the aisle. She was a real leader
from my time on Capitol Hill and
We're gonna miss her and we need more people like her. So again, my condolences my salute out to her
Look on your question with regard to what our allies see
Vladimir Putin sits in Russia today and he looks across the landscape and he sees United States America, which is
Unwilling to spend what it needs to on defense. It is now pulling back spending for Ukraine
We've seen successive Republican votes where more and more Republicans vote against funding for Ukraine
He sees coups in Africa. They're pushing Western militaries out. He has a pro-sympathetic
or sympathetic
Serbia that's massing troops on the border of Kosovo
We had a vote today in Slovakia a NATO ally in Central Europe that just picked a prime minister who is pro-Russian
And has promised to cut spending for Ukraine
Look from his vantage point the West is fracturing and he's going to continue to wait out the clock and maybe hope that Donald
Trump returns to the presidency
I want to ask you specifically about that because in your book you write extensively about your frustration with
Getting then-president Trump to support aid to Ukraine and that was before the full-scale invasion
That was when Russian troops were just in the east of that country
He still to this day is not coming out in support of aid to Ukraine
And as we just talked about Vladimir Putin has said some of the comments he's made make him happy
What does that mean in terms of what we should expect and if there is a second Trump presidency?
Well, I suspect that he will do what he says and that is he will come to office
He will somehow attempt to negotiate a deal between Russia and Ukraine and that won't fly
There's only one person that can get end this conflict in Ukraine and that's Vladimir Putin and he's not about to do that anytime soon
So I suspect Trump will quickly move to end funding for Ukraine. And then at some point he's also going to move to
Withdraw funding for NATO and maybe even pull out of NATO, which would be disastrous for United States national security
So for all those reasons that concerns me and then of course we could talk about our allies and partners in
Asia as well who will equally be concerned about these type of events
So, I mean you're clear you're not supporting the former president's bid to return to office
But you know the governor of Florida also presidential candidate has has raised his personal objections to you know
Limitless checks as well. So do you like any of the Republican candidates right now?
Well first let me say there should not be any blank checks for Ukraine, right and and every all of everything
We provide should be audited and accounted for that's just good
But look on the on the bigger question
Look, I'm disappointed in in in some of my party who are not picking up that the mantle of Ronald Reagan
I consider myself a Reagan Republican Ronald Reagan would definitely support these young fledgling democracies, whether it's Ukraine in
Europe which is being invaded by its larger bigger
Dictatorial neighbor or Taiwan in in Asia that's being intimidated and threatened by China. That's what Ronald Reagan stands for
I look I think they're that said I think there are a few Republicans in the debates right now who I could support
Who are better certainly than Trump and who could beat President Biden and I think for Republicans
We got to quickly find that person rally around them and then bring the party together and run a strong candidate
You want to give me a name?
Look, I think we've seen some good performances from Chris Christie Nikki Haley
DeSantis Tim Scott, I think there are three or four or five, but the Republican voters need to decide who that is
It's not Donald Trump, but I think there are a number of good candidates out there
I mean you've made clear you see President Trump as a threat to democracy
Not just a flawed candidate a threat to democracy. You've said
Upon his retirement last week general Mark Milley an ally of yours during your time in office
Appeared to refer to him in his farewell speech as a wannabe dictator. Is that overstating things a dictatorship?
Well, look if you go back the week prior
Donald Trump said that Milley for his behavior, whatever he thought that was was was
Should be punished and he he talked about execution
Which was completely unfair Mark Milley served this country honorably for 40 plus years in war and peace
Moved dragged his family around 20 plus times. He deserves our respect and admiration and not that type of talk
No less coming from the commander-in-chief the former commander-in-chief. So so look I have a lot of concerns about Donald Trump
I have said that he's a threat to democracy
I think the last year certainly the last few months of Donald Trump's presidency
Will look like the first few months of the next one if that were to occur
There are a number of stalled military promotions in the Senate, you know talking about problems with democracy right now
Are you disappointed that even in Congress Republican leadership hasn't been able to?
Clear that hurdle and get the caucus in line to say that you know
Some of the highest ranking military officers in our country should get the jobs that they've been nominated for
Yeah, look I'm concerned on a few levels look first of all, I think
Senator Tuberville's serious and about his concerns over the policy issues
He's had a chance to bring him up for a vote and declined to do that
And I think it's unfair to hold military nominees over 300 now
Hostage if you will over a policy issue for which that's not their responsibility. That's a civilian responsibility
And so my view is that they that should not happen
It's happened in the past by both parties and I've called on recently Senator Schumer to start moving
Nominations which he has because otherwise it looks like both parties are politicizing the military
That's my institutional concern and then Margaret if you step back you ask yourself
Look, the Chinese government doesn't shut down the Chinese government doesn't do continuing resolutions and they certainly don't hold up their admirals and generals
When they need them as they prepare for potential conflict with the United States
We just look really dysfunctional and we're harming our own readiness in the process
When we look across the international environment
Mark Esper, thank you for your analysis today
We'll be right back
We're joined now by the co-chairs of the problem solvers caucus, Pennsylvania Republican Brian Fitzpatrick and New Jersey Democrat
Josh Gottheimer good to have you both with us and we got a lot of problems that you do need to solve
I want to start on what we just learned in the course of this program
Which was speaker McCarthy coming out and seeming to link
Some movement on the border to his willingness to move a Ukraine funding bill
Then you heard Lindsey Graham say how that would go down or he wants it to go down in the Senate
He called it a three-legged stool
Would you get on board with what Graham proposed? I would I think we have a lot of challenges
I think we need to address all of them. It's actually consistent with the problem-solver framework that we introduced last week
It addressed keeping our government open and address Ukraine. It addressed our border and expiring authorities
We dealt with several of them in the continuing resolution that passed thankfully yesterday
But there are remaining items that are unaddressed the border in Ukraine being two of them, but the border
Proposal that has passed the HR to that speaker McCarthy talked about would not go anywhere in the Democratic Senate
That's not going anywhere
I mean
But I but I think to Brian's point
We have to address both and I think it's a false choice to say we're gonna do one or the other
Right, but clearly we know that we've we can make it the next 45 days
To support Ukraine make sure we stand up to Putin and to China and Iran
Which is critical to our national security and to our allies
But also we need to make sure that we deal with and and deal with the challenges
At the border and border security and live up to our values there
All right, what Graham laid out though was not just funding for Ukraine
It was I mean almost a year's worth of funding for Ukraine. Can you get that done in 45 days?
I think we can't keep we know that we can get through the next 45 days
But it's a matter of days and weeks and
not months and years in terms of what we have available to make sure that we
Ukraine has what they need to stand up to Putin in the dictatorial March
So I think we have to make sure that we get some legislation to the floor quickly
I know the the speaker is open to that. He signaled that he's open to that
I think that's key and but we also we have other challenges and we can do more than one thing at once
And I do think the Ukraine funding should be for a longer period of time. It should be for a year
It sends the right message Ukraine sends the right message to Russia
And it's it's perhaps I think the best solution inside our chamber to get that done
And the border security language just you know in our framework was a bipartisan bill
I was curious and cinnamon Tom Tillis his bill in the Senate myself Jared Golden in the house is a two-party solution of the border
It's it represents the intersection of where the two parties agree and you think you can get the speaker on board to consider work hard
Yep
You also heard today the call a motion to vacate to oust speaker McCarthy
from leadership
He says he can survive
Can he?
Yes to me this what's going to be put on the floor is a choice
Are we going to reward bipartisan bills being put on the floor or are we going to punish them? That is a choice
Substitute out Kevin McCarthy's name for Hakeem Jeffries or anyone else if the situation were reversed and and the squad try to do the same
Do Hakeem Jeffries should he be speaker at some point?
I can tell you what I would do on the first and hundredth vote. I would vote to table it
Because I don't think that sends the right message
I think I think what we need to do is encourage bipartisanship and courage to party solutions to be brought to the floor
That's what we need
And to do the opposite would really be rewarding this Hatfield versus McCoy brand of brand of politics
That's destroying our nation got Gates says he's gonna keep coming and he can't right
He only one vote needed for a motion to be and that may require and change in the rules package
I mean this cannot be the trajectory for the remainder of the Congress to stop one person from correct
I mean that was so keep in mind that was how speaker McCarthy got to the leadership
That was one of the promises that was that was well
That was one of the changes that was made
But we were given assurances that that was never going to be used that it was a matter of principle that it be remained at
one so you can't have it both ways and I can
90% plus of the American public does not want us to be
Voting on a motion to vacate every day for the rest of the term
Is he gonna get Democrats like Brian was up to Hakeem there? I don't know
But our Democrats going to join Gates, you know, he needs to get 218 votes the way I look at this
You've got a civil war raging in the Republican caucus and and as it has been since the beginning right with extremists trying to take
Out common sense and they keep doing it time and again, and so I'll leave that to Brian, you know
That's their caucus and I'm from Jersey. We don't mess with other people's families
And so I'll leave it to them but but I'll tell you what we're very open to from a policy front
We continue to do this as you saw yesterday as you saw the debt ceiling when if there's bipartisan ideas brought to the table
We're always gonna be at that table and negotiating good faith. That's what the problems harvest caucus does
It's how we got yesterday done, right?
If you remember that's how yesterday happened you had every Democrat plus one help cover for the 91 Republicans
They lost we all came together for the good of the country to stop a government shutdown and make sure we help people and help
Families that's the kind of stuff
We should be sitting at a table about negotiating good faith and we'll continue to do that
Republicans have shown they can't govern on their own there
I've seen the only way these things are getting done is with Democrats, right?
So in bipartisan governing and that's good for the country the people want us to put the country over party
So can you say we won't be back in the same place November 17th talking about a possible government shutdown?
Well, we're two out of 435
So we're not in a position to make that prediction what we can say
Like we said last Sunday on a show that Josh and I appear together
We will do whatever it takes to keep the government open. We made that pledge
We were prepared to take drastic action yesterday had that not passed the floor. We will do well
There are a number of mechanisms where we could force a floor vote on our two-party solution
Okay, there are options for us to do it. We were prepared to do it. Thankfully, that's one of many
Thankfully, we didn't have to go there
But we will do what it takes to make make sure the lights are on in the United States government for sure
I think the point is we're gonna work around the clock these next 45 days
But this cycle of insanity has to stop and this what Brian I believe why we need long-term solutions
We can't keep doing this and wasting our time. We have real challenges in the country and this includes the debt ceiling as well
We cannot be constantly on the on the on the 11th hour of brinksmanship while we were behind that deal
It's not even the debt ceiling the FAA
You haven't passed into law a defense bill. These are the most
Extremists how we got here these ultra right-wing extremists keep fighting against reasonableness in common sense
They refuse to vote for the debt for the defense bill right multiple times. They kept trying to take it down
Yeah, and that's the point
That's why you need bipartisan solutions right now in this Congress is the only way we're gonna be able to govern the extremist
Are the problem in this country? It's the bipartisan moderates that are the solution
That's what we believe in and you have a proposal to get all of 100%
We introduced our bill last Friday. Yeah, it's a it's the only bipartisan bill. It's equal
co-sponsors Democrat Republican
Represents where the intersection of the United States of America is and that's what our country wants
They want us to approach government the same way we approach our personal relationships
But then you heard I mean as we were talking with Senator Graham, I mean, I asked him about Donald Trump
He still won't come out and support Ukraine aid. You have other presidential candidates wavering. He called for the government to shut down. So
President Trump. Yes, right
So if people are governing by popularity polls and not by the mandate that you say you feel you have how do you solve that?
I mean these I can tell you the overwhelming majority of it Congress
I can tell you the overwhelming majority of Americans support the approach that Josh and I take you approach government the same way you approach
Your personal relationships. You don't allow the perfect to be the enemy the good you take 80% of something rather than 100% of nothing
You come to the center you build consensus and you move forward. That's how all of us operate our lives
It's this loud noisy fringe the Hatfield vs. McCoy saber-rattlers. They get all the attention, but that's not where most of the American people are
That's why Josh get attacked from the left and the right
Do you think speaker McCarthy learned the lesson that you 100% and I think yes
I mean yesterday was exhibit a and I hope I hope that's a breaking point. We have a five-seat majority
It's all they have the only way we're gonna get stuff done for the country's by what's working together
That's the only way as we're seeing
Gentlemen, thank you that we'll be back in a moment
There's a big birthday celebration in Georgia this weekend for our 39th president. Mark Strassman has the details
They're celebrating a birthday in tiny Plains, Georgia
Jimmy Carter's birthplace
99 years ago today get down there and hang out as a family, you know
Just be a really small private event
He can't party like he used to for his 99th birthday. So none of us can't right? None of us can that's exactly right
Americans celebrate with him the famous and happy birthday president Carter and the everyday a
Jimmy Carter peanut gallery of well-wishers the White House wouldn't cake
39 candles for the 39th president
It's some salute considering most Americans alive today were born after Jimmy Carter left the White House in 1981
I moved back here to Plains. He's like the father of the town. He's the heart of the town and
we just
Celebrate him every day when Carter entered hospice back in February. His family thought he had days to live
Seven months later. He's earned all this birthday fuss. He's modest and
But you know, he smiles. He likes the attention. He's proud of it. He's very proud of it
Jimmy and Rosalynn Carter now married
77 years will celebrate the day as true Southerners with family fried chicken and
Caramel cake his favorite they've gotten to experience this outpouring of support over these last several months that has really been gratifying
And we also want to wish President Carter a happy birthday from all of us here at face the nation
Until next week for face the nation. I'm Margaret Brennan
