Es gibt ein großes Problem mit Japan Interviews auf YouTube und den YouTubern, die diese machen! Warum sie einem nichts über Japan beibringen, erzähle ich euch genauer in diesem Video!
(*) Wenn ihr über diesen Link einkauft, dann erhalte ich eine kleine Provision von Amazon. Für euch wird der Einkauf dadurch keinen Cent teurer, aber ihr könnt mich und das Projekt "NihonGo" dadurch automatisch unterstützen, wenn ihr etwas bei Amazon kauft. ────────────────────────────────────
The big problem with Japan interviews on YouTube.
You probably know the YouTubers who wander through the cities in Japan
and ask the most different Japanese people about the most different topics.
A few days ago, at the time of this recording,
a video went viral on X, the original Twitter,
of this Takeshi from Japan, or whatever his name is.
He's a Japanese YouTuber who makes videos and street interviews with Japanese people for English-speaking people all over the world,
but I think especially the US market.
This video that went viral is a short he made on YouTube
and someone posted it on Twitter and then it exploded
and now it got over 16 million views, a lot.
There were also some newspaper articles in the USA about it.
And in this video, he asked Japanese women if they believe that fūsokke is a foreign gene.
First of all, you have to know that he translated fūsokke with prostitution in the video,
but it's difficult to translate that directly with prostitution,
because there is so much that falls under fūsokke in Japan
that it's not just prostitution, but a whole lot of other things.
And that's why it's hard to say what a Japanese person thinks about it,
if you ask him now, what do you think about fūsokke?
Does he immediately think, yo, here, sex with a prostitute,
or a little softer stories where it's not about sex at all, and what, I don't know everything.
So there is really a range of services in Japan, of sex services that can be used there,
so that it's a bit problematic to translate that directly as prostitution.
And the person, the English-speaking American or maybe also German, who saw the video,
thinks to himself, oh, okay, so the women, which many said in this interview,
think it's okay if a man goes to a prostitute, they don't think it's a foreign gene.
Because the women in the video said, oh no, fūsokke, I don't necessarily think it's a foreign gene,
if the man has a reason for it, or yes, I think it's better than if he somehow emotionally
chats with a woman and then meets somewhere in a hotel, I think that's better,
then he should rather do that, those were a bit the statements from the video.
And that also caused a lot of criticism, because people said,
hey, wait a minute, especially foreigners who live in Japan, wait a minute,
you can't just translate that as prostitute or prostitution.
And the way he represents it in the video, or the way the women say it,
that definitely doesn't apply to all women in Japan.
And it's definitely not the case that you can go abroad as a man and the woman says,
oh yeah, do it, it's okay if you go to a prostitute, that's not the case.
And that's why it caused a lot of discussion, and I thought I'd make a little video about it too,
because this problem that came up there is one that I have always mentioned in live streams,
and which is also the reason why I don't do street interviews with Japanese people here.
You see, I never do these interviews, you never see any street interviews here.
The only thing I do is interviews with individual Japanese people,
because I always find that very interesting, like the priest from Tsurugi-san there,
we had a very long, over an hour, an interesting interview about the mountain and what not,
or just generally the individual opinion of Japanese people in the interview,
but then it's also clear that it's an individual opinion,
and you can also ask a little deeper, you learn a little bit about the person,
and just know, okay, that's an experience report.
But that's not always the case with these videos, with the street interviews,
especially when the title says, cheating culture in Japan,
so the dating culture or the foreign culture in Japan,
and you ask Japanese people, how do you think?
Then the viewer who doesn't know much about Japan thinks.
I used to think that too, because I was also someone who didn't know anything about Japan,
and at that time there were already these street interviews,
and I watched them during my university time too,
then of course you think, okay,
the Japanese say they would rather do something with a foreigner or not,
then you think, is that really so?
But you have the feeling, okay, these are Japanese people who say that,
these are Japanese women who say that,
there has to be something to it, if he asks them and they say that,
then that's probably the case in Japan.
And unfortunately that's not the case,
because the problem with these interviews is that they are very selectively asked.
Also this Takeshi from Japan, he asked people in the evening,
and if I look at the Japanese women he asked in this short,
then they are mostly young,
they are people who like to party, at least that's what it looks like,
and of course they are not the Japanese women
who meet with their girlfriends for lunch somewhere in the shopping mall at noon.
That's a completely different clientele,
but that is not made clear in this video,
and he doesn't say that either,
and most YouTubers who do such street interviews don't say that,
that they ask a certain clientele there,
and of course a certain clientele also gives certain answers.
So to give another example,
the good Mr. Nippon recently made a video from the beach,
where he also asked about the dating culture,
and the people he asked there,
they were just a bit,
so from a Japanese point of view you would say,
yo, these are not necessarily the smartest people there,
it's a bit, a lot of alcohol and partying and stuff,
these are maybe a bit the stupid ones,
who you ask there.
And of course they give other answers,
than if you ask the housewives,
who, as I said, have lunch together in the Takashimaya mall at noon.
I mean, imagine that, if you were on the baller man,
Mallorca baller man,
you would now ask Germans about the dating culture,
and then someone uploads a video about it,
would you think,
oh okay, what the people say in the video,
that is standard or representative for the dating culture in Germany,
probably not,
but you would say,
oh, he asked a baller man,
he asked the stupidest of the stupidest,
who just let themselves go,
so very over the top,
don't take it too seriously,
but you would never get the idea to say,
okay, the interview of the baller man,
that somehow represents all Germans,
and how the Germans would date or something.
So you really have to make yourself clear,
these interview videos do not say anything about Japan,
and the topic they want to say something about.
If the street interview about the dating culture says,
the chance that something really useful comes out of it,
is super super low,
because it's always just individual opinions,
the youtubers are not trained at all,
to take people from different layers of society,
from different age groups,
that's not even their goal to do that,
so they don't go with a scientific approach behind it,
okay, I really want to find out something about the dating culture in Japan,
but they go with the idea,
okay, dating culture in Japan,
that interests many people abroad,
I'm just going to ask a few Japanese people about it,
and I'm going to cut the answers in the end,
that were really good or something,
that are a bit, how should I say,
that are interesting for the people,
and I just want to entertain them in the end,
and of course I want to generate a lot of clicks in the end,
with the content I make there,
that means the people who do these interviews,
they rather think about what interests foreigners,
how could I make a video that is interesting for foreigners,
that might go viral,
where the people say,
what, there is a dating culture in Japan,
that's okay, the people share that,
that's the way of thinking,
how YouTubers approach this story,
that means you should free yourself from the thought,
that you learn something about Japan there,
and that the YouTubers have in mind,
that they want to convey something about Japan,
really substantial knowledge,
that's usually not the case,
because these videos can't do that at all,
so you should see it completely as entertainment,
that's how I do it for example,
I watch these videos sometimes,
I just see it as entertainment,
sometimes I laugh a bit,
in the Mr. Nippon video for example,
I could laugh a bit,
because I thought,
what are they answering,
what's wrong with them,
so you should see it as entertainment,
you can of course also learn a bit of Japanese,
natural Japanese, everyday Japanese,
you can hear a bit of that,
that's also a good opportunity I would say,
but you shouldn't expect,
that you can learn something from these videos,
or something meaningful,
because if you watch this video of Takeshi from Japan,
then you might think,
okay, going abroad is not a big deal,
but it is a big deal,
and I wouldn't do it,
and I wouldn't recommend it to you,
that you think,
if you have a relationship in Japan,
you can go to this or that shop,
that can cost you the whole relationship,
marriage or something else,
that's not a good idea,
but through these videos,
unfortunately something else is suggested a bit,
and they fire these clichés a bit,
and I personally think that's a shame,
because I try to dissolve these clichés,
and to convey a as realistic picture of Japan as possible,
and then people come with these street interviews,
that click well of course,
because people want to see something like that,
and it's a bit of entertainment,
and better entertainment probably,
than Kevin sitting here,
and trying to explain something,
how it really is,
that's of course not so exciting,
that's clear to me too,
but then these clichés are fired,
and then people,
I get messages, emails,
or also in the live streams,
where people say,
Kevin, is that actually true?
No, of course that's not true,
that's just a video,
made for entertainment,
which is supposed to convey a certain cliché,
or which is supposed to make you look,
and to share,
and to think,
is that really so?
And then you ask other people,
and that's how the video spreads at the end.
That's my opinion,
that's the reason,
why I don't make these videos,
because I just want to convey things to you,
with which you can also start something in Japan,
that means if you watch my videos,
then you know a bit more about Japan,
and if you are in Japan at some point,
then you can also start something with this knowledge,
that's at least a bit of the goal I have,
I certainly don't always achieve that with every video,
and not always as well as I would like to,
but that's the thought I have,
and that's why I don't make these street interviews,
even if I've been suggested them for ages,
by different people,
yes, but with that you can increase your reach and so on,
it's more important to me to convey the right information,
than to increase the reach,
because at the end of the day you also notice,
whether someone is talking nonsense or not.
That's it, guys,
I hope you liked it,
I hope you were able to take something with you from the video,
how do you find these street interviews,
how have you watched them so far,
have you also always thought about it,
okay, I'm not really learning anything about Japan here,
but it's just an entertainment video,
or how have you seen the whole thing so far,
I would be very interested.
So, go into the comments with it,
feel free to take a look in the video description,
there are still a lot of links,
especially discount links to my online courses,
and then I hope to see you again next time.
See you!