Join Jared, Ryan, and Duta for their weekly spaceflight discussion. SpaceX’s Starship is once again back in its fully stacked configuration. NASA’s OSIRIS-REx mission has delivered samples from asteroid Bennu. A government shutdown in the US almost closed NASA. The Psyche mission has its launch delayed a month. RocketLab has suffered a launch failure. Stoke Space has made a successful hop! Plus general chaos in todays live show!
we're all clearly ready
3 thirds is not a rule
in check for what we're supposed to be doing today
but we are going to
go ahead and start off with you Ryan
because we have had a very busy week
with SpaceX as
always and you know
always good to touch on them at the start
so Ryan what have we
had from our dearest ex
this week
they've put
big ship on big booster again
as you can see
it's kind of
I wouldn't say
confusing but
mildly unexpected
I think is probably the best way to put this because
they don't have a launch license
the flight
termination system hasn't been armed
so they're physically and regulatory
wise both not ready to
launch despite what a certain CEO
likes to say on
his social media platform so they're not
ready to launch but
they're putting the ship back on the
booster for a configuration which is
from the outside looks like they're ready
to launch even though they're not
they very
smoothly go back so
it is kind of confusing
to look at but
this could be an indication that SpaceX
has actually decided that they want to do some full
stack testing such as a full stack
wet dress rehearsal to prepare
for launch whilst they have to wait
I'll say longer than expected for regulatory
things to go through maybe
SpaceX thought that they'd already have a launch
license by now turns out that they don't
so they're like oh we've got extra time we might as well
do extra testing maybe that's
just what they've decided to do at the end of the day
nobody apart
from SpaceX themselves really know what they're
doing at least for now
we have a full stack that we can take
pretty pictures of and share
with everyone on the internet so
maybe full stack testing is on the way
but to make it even more confusing there
aren't any road closures indicating
that a full stack test would be underway
we typically see overpressure notices
as well to residents of the village
if that's something that they're wanting to do
because big oxygen and big methane
put together uncontrollably
would not be a good day
so there's no
indications that they're going to do it so
it's just quite confusing
gotcha so things are
I don't want to necessarily say
in regulatory limbo because
we definitely know that the
EPA and others are moving
as fast as the
mechanisms of bureaucracy can allow
them to do so like these are not
groups that are
out to get anybody
if you will they're simply there to assure
the safety of the public but it is also
like we got some extra stuff
to do with them there
so it's a bit of a
a bit of a slog
to get through all of that but
it is what they're working
so yeah
I guess in the meantime might as well
do what you can
yeah and
hopefully that's what we see testing because
everyone likes a bit of testing but
as I said there's no indications
at the moment that they are going to be testing
and maybe they'll spring
a surprise on us and close the road and
issue an overpressure notice but we haven't seen
anything like that yet yeah Mr. Huggie
is saying that you know all ready to go
hopefully they do a couple a few wet
dress rehearsals while waiting and
I agree with that it would be
pretty good for them to
do that you know kind of get
all of the ducks in a row while
they have all of this down time
I'd say it would probably
look a little bit silly
if they had all this down time
and then we come up to the launch and they
end up finding a whole bunch of problems
before the launch in the
technical side so hopefully they can
hopefully they can if they aren't
already taking the time now
to not follow that out
yeah
so boy it sounds like everybody's in
agreement here so tough
tough crowd to work with today on
the tomorrow show with that
so also
SpaceX with their Falcon 9's just
continuing on as well because let's not forget
about the fact that SpaceX is a launch
company they're not just a build big
test vehicle company
they're first and foremost a launch
provider so
that's still going along Falcon 9's
chugging along there and I'm hearing
that we're accelerating
a little bit so it's beginning to look like
possibly a hundred launches
this year maybe very very
very very very close to it
I need to
I don't have the exact number
in my head right now but I do
know for the month of September they did conduct
ten launches which is a record
for a single month however
I'm not sure if
let's say they do twenty
ten in October
ten in November and ten in December
that's only in air quotes
big air quotes only thirty more launches
so they need to be at seventy launches
by now if they want to
hit a hundred by the end of the year if they
stick at this current cadence and I think
they may just be shy of seventy
so they could get close to a hundred at this cadence
but I'm not sure if they will hit
a hundred precisely I think
they may be in the sixties somewhere potentially
at the moment
but we know they're definitely going to be setting a record
for this year
yeah they're setting a record I think they've already surpassed their
twenty twenty two
cadence so the record
has already been set they just
have a goal of a hundred and they may or
may not reach it
currently it looks like they probably won't
yeah and I'm sure someone
in the chat room will definitely be able to find
a precise number for us because that's
just how our amazing chat
room here at tomorrow works
and also
Adam Baker letting us know
that they have a new
water tank
as well on the ground with everything that needs to
happen there so there's also a lot of ground systems
ground support equipment, GSE
still needs to be tested for Starship
Andy Law letting us know
that they are just at seventy Falcon
nines so Ryan
I've just found
the numbers and it's seventy launches in total
sixty six Falcon nine three heavy
one Starship so if they're
sticking with Falcon nine cadence
or just for Falcon nine they have
sixty nine launches for Falcon nine and heavy
put together so at the current
rate of Falcon nine
and heavy cadence they would literally be
one launch
short of hitting a hundred by the end of
the year yeah well
I will say Adam has my
favorite comment of the show so far which
is just seventy
yeah just seventy
just seventy
from one provider
one provider
I think it's even
so
there's often the case made that
SpaceX is their own best customer
with Starlink and other things like
that but I would feel
I think even with commercial launches
it's still
they're still
the reigning champions so even
if you were to just count
non Starlink launches it's still
for non Starlink launches
they've done twenty seven flights
yeah it wasn't
ten years ago where we were
raving about having eighty launches
in a year yeah
and that was in
eighty launches and that was talking about
the entire world too
so
in the entire world
everybody putting everything
in the sky, eighty launches
in one year
that was less than ten years ago
and SpaceX is doing
targeting a hundred this year
seeing seven or
eight launches from the United
States in a year was like amazing
like holy moly
yeah and at the moment
up to this point in 2023
the United States have
as a country launched
85 orbital flights, 80 of which have been
successful but that includes
Tesla launches such as Starship
Relativity, also
it includes Electron launches
which actually launch out of Mahia in New Zealand
so my opinion even though they're
a US company it counts for New Zealand because it launches
from New Zealand but that's a whole other
rabbit hole you can dive down
and throw your opinions out about
that but yeah China has
launched 45 orbital attempts
44 have been successful
so in terms of
if you discount Starlink
launches, SpaceX is behind China
but if you include Starlink launches
because in my opinion they're completely valid
they're just their own customer
they are nearly twice
2X
ahead of China in terms of
launches which is just kind of
one private entity
is beating an entire nation
in terms of orbital capability
yeah I was about to say Arvail has a great
statistic here which is that
in 2012 the United
States had 13
launches total
so
and we had
more than 3 quarters of that
just in September
just from one launch provider
that was it
so I believe the United States
had 11 total
in September because we have to include
ULA's
Atlas 5 lofty and silent
Barker for that if I'm
remembering all of our stuff correctly
yeah so
wowee! Dutta if you want to take my
screen share quickly I have a chart from the
Wikipedia page for 2023 in spaceflight
that big blue bar in the middle is
Falcon and everyone else
is everywhere else so you can see
in a
mild second place is the Long March
family out of China, you can also see
poor Atlas here at the bottom with just one launch
and the R7 family
is the Soyuz family
as well so you can see
just how far ahead the Falcon family
is compared to everything else
India has launched more
rockets than ULA has?
yes by
a significant margin, Japan
with its H series has launched more than
ULA has and
the Kuaizhou family which is a private
Chinese entity
entity's rocket has launched
more than Atlas, Atlas has launched
once so far this year
Delta has launched once
so far this year so
ULA really is
this is not a great year for ULA
in terms of launch cadence
I'd say
on a good year they'd hit 7, 8, 9, 10 launches
this year we're in October now
and they've launched twice
this is like the sports
ball conversation
is there a rebuilding year? it's fine
yeah
kind of working around with that there
Vulcan has been
hogging slick 41 for a little while
in the earlier parts of the year whilst they were testing
that so let's be honest they have
been testing Vulcan
they just haven't launched it yet
yeah it still appears
to be one of those things where
boy this
I don't want to say how the mighty have fallen but just
oh boy how the mighty have slowed down
but
you know I think with Vulcan we'll see it
pick back up with United
Launch Alliance and cook along
with that there I can't imagine
them fully slowing
down to the point where it's like
yeah that's just not
going to
ULA won't allow that to happen
the US government won't allow that to happen
so
remember two providers
yeah ULA doesn't
have the luxury of having
a pad in Vandenberg for Falcon 9
two pads at the Cape for Falcon 9
and a dedicated development facility in Texas
for Starship right? ULA
has to share slick 41 between Atlas
5 and Vulcan so they don't
have the luxury of having a dedicated
launch facility just to test their
rocket so when they
need testing on that rocket it's going to
be hooking up their only pad from
the east coast for Atlas
I wonder if that's going to be a deal breaker
for some of their contracts like they're
going to have to secure another
pad for one or the other
of the rockets
yeah and Bennett actually
for their readiness I mean
they've got certain things in their contract that says
that they need to be ready to launch payloads
for DOD and things like that
oh absolutely yeah and those are
those are NSSL
security space launch contracts
so those are
you hit those marks or you get
into a little bit of trouble
I was going to say real quick in our chat room Mike was
saying to call back to my comment from
another episode how many Falcon launches are not
Starlinks just to remind you
we found that so far it was 27
I believe is where we were
at with that so
27 Falcon 9
launches that were just essentially for
commercial or military providers
this year
anything that's not Starlink
yeah
so yeah of the 70
that we've had so far this year
and then to go back
to Bennett's point which is that is ULA
going to speed up to their 10 per year cadence
from before do we think that that's
what's going to happen
Jason says to be fair ULA
for Atlas they are waiting
for their customers
for Vulcan
they have their fingers crossed on that Centaur test
yeah
so I think
Vulcan cadence could
potentially in the future rely on
the ability to get the
smart reuse section back
because if they
only need to make a Centaur
and essentially
a fuel tank for the
first stage and then they can just stick the
engines and what not on
the bottom if the
BE4 production
really is going to be
a bottleneck then smart reuse could be a way to
bring up that launch cadence
for Vulcan but if the bottleneck
then I don't know becomes manufacturing an entire
Centaur second stage then
that could be the bottleneck
so I think Vulcan's cadence
really relies on whatever bottlenecks
the production because
it's not fully reasonable they can't
just bring the first stage back if first
stage construction is just meant to be
just build a fuel tank and stick the
engine section on the bottom maybe that
could fly quite quickly so
it just really depends
in the pipeline where a bottleneck would
exist and if they can iron that out
yeah and
smart reuse I don't think would be on
the table with them because they
have talked about smart reuse but
there's yeah
I find it very
I don't want to say near unbelievable but
I don't think they're
I think they've talked quite a lot about
it and they've shown some very pretty
charts and graphs and pictures but
I don't believe outside
of the
inflatable decelerator test
that just recently happened I don't believe
ULI
specifically has done much of anything
if even anything
on that front with them there so
yeah
so yeah and of course
I think that's a really good point with the Atlas V too
that they're waiting on customers as well because
Kuiper is going to be their big
close out customer if you will
there and we're still waiting
to hear
waiting to hear that
with that there and
yeah just some
interesting oh how the
turns have tabled over this past decade
yes
and let's be fair to Kuiper
the project
the prototype is currently scheduled for Friday
in the
afternoon so
I believe there's two
test pegodes on there
obviously they're not ready to fully
ramp up into production but
they are getting there
that's kind of the whole story with ULA at the
moment they're getting there with Vulcan
Kuiper they're getting there
it's just a bit of a slow roll
to get them started and hopefully these things
will eventually pick up the pace
as they gain more experience with Vulcan
and payloads start to come online
this is really the first
push off the start line
hopefully things will speed up over the next
couple of years or so
yeah and don't forget as
well that they're going to have a second launch pad
with Vulcan once
Slick 3
out here at Vandenberg Space
Force Base comes back online
which it's almost been a year
since they've started working on that to
convert it over to Vulcan so I wonder
how much longer they have
for that there
there's limitations on
which orbits you can hit so that it
doesn't explicitly double your
cadence oh no but I'm
just saying several more
launches per year perhaps
out of something there
I would imagine at this point any
increase in cadence is a good
increase in cadence from
2 to 3
per year so
we'll have to see
so yeah
I don't know whether ULA has any customers
which would be interested in using the
Southern Launch Trajectory which Starlink is famously
using now out of Florida
depends of the efficiency of Vulcan
but say if they have customers that want
a 43 degree inclination they can
hit that out of Florida or Vandenberg
or and Vandenberg
so those crossover
inclinations depending how
popular they are for say big internet
satellite constellations
maybe that could offer
a bit of flexibility
there because Vandenberg
and Florida can both hit that
yeah that's definitely happening now and
I can tell you those of us here in Southern California
appreciate those 43 degree inclination
launches they're pretty spectacular
to see
quite all the time
I like Bennett here saying it depends on how
many moon rakers you need
in order to pull this off
that's a really good point Bennett
didn't even think about that
with that there
so yeah
so pretty
funny with that
so good one there Bennett appreciate it
and I did want to talk a little bit about another launch
provider today which was Rocket Lab
and they had a failure of
their Electron rocket in its
just its last
launch which didn't happen
too long after our previous episode
Ryan do you have any details about that
have we heard anything new about that besides
something with the upper stage
the
I imagine we won't
really hear anything until
well into their investigation
processes if we
think back to I think it was NS
23 Blue Origins
failure last year
where the first stage decided it no longer wanted
to be a first stage
that
whole kind of investigative
process has
taken quite a long time
to go through it is a human rated
vehicle it is a suborbital vehicle so
there are different factors to take
into account however I think it was
back in March of this year they
released a document on their website which
is their findings from that so they're being
quite open and transparent with that but the actual
investigation process only wrapped up a couple
of weeks ago the FAA mishap report
only wrapped up a couple of weeks ago so even
if the company comes out and says this is what went
wrong they're not going to be ready to launch again
so that whole process takes quite
a long time to go through starships
mishap report that only took a few weeks slash
months depending how you want to look at
it so potentially this
could be a quick process for rocket lab
but until that actually wraps up I don't
think we'll hear anything they've only
really been tweeting
about kind of the
things that they've been doing
that isn't launching satellites
and looking back on
Electron's history and things like that
there hasn't been any kind of
like this is what went wrong
this is how we're going to fix it kind of statement yet
because that's not what you would expect
this close to
a mishap happening on a
launch and before the questions come in
even though this launched from New Zealand
because Rocket Lab is a US company
they are licensed by the FAA
it is the FAA's job to do this mishap report
so it's the same process
we can expect with all other US launch providers
I think I had seen that they
said they were closing in on a root
cause but they weren't ready to say anything
about it. And I mean that's what you'd
expect. Yeah
usually it's a couple months to
kind of knock down the problem unless it's a very
very obvious problem
with it there so
we'll have to see
what ends up happening with them but best of luck
of course to Rocket Lab and Blue Origin
as well with both of them working together
on that and yeah Blue Origin coming to the
conclusion of that with the FAA
now it's just up to them to implement all those
things. Sounds a little familiar doesn't it?
With another company that may have
blue in its logo
so yeah
there's
with that there yeah that's pretty
pretty interesting that we've
got two of them happening at the same time
kind of I don't want to say crisscrossing but it feels
just like you know Blue Origin's working
on it or
Blue Origin working
on it and also Rocket Lab working on it
as well with that there so
yeah so good luck to both of them
we'll have to see
with that and Arvale
saying that it sounds like Blue will be doing another
uncrewed launch in the next few
weeks and yeah they're definitely not going to put a crew
on for the first couple of flights
back from that there
you want to get all the data and make sure everything
looks good and work on that
they also owe their customers
for the flight that went wrong a flight
because they didn't get what they paid for
so I think the most
realistic situation I don't know this for certain but
what I think Blue Origin would do is
just take the capsule
that flew NS23 and
fly it on NS24 if that's what they end up
calling it with a new booster
so the customers can actually get the
data that they were looking for
yeah and that's
part of the deal
with it there you know you got to make sure that you
provide what you have said you would
provide to your customers and Blue Origin
is going to do that
so free rides everybody
so
that means if there's a crewed flight
and they have that
that the crew gets to fly again
or how does that
work? Would I want to fly again? I don't
know
yeah actually I was about to say
Aerospike
in the comments putting it out there which is
I mean some of us would ride New Shepard
because it might fail
you wanted to light the booster
that's true
wasn't it Blue Origin that said
that they had actually had customers that had
asked them
if they could light the booster
the escape booster at Apogee
they could get a little extra kick
with it there so
I would ask
for that how much is that option?
how much is that option? 2-3 million?
Blue Origin
specifically had to say that that is not
a selectable flight option
because people have
legitimately requested that
so they've had to officially say this is
not something we are offering
unless stage one
fails on the way up you don't
get that
you need the ULA sniper to
intentionally sabotage the first stage
right at the end of its flight
and then the second
the capsule will
abort
clearly that's exactly what it was
I read it on Twitter
so Arvale
I like Arvale's little slogan
for our idea here
which is buy one get one half
Apogee so pretty good
with that
speaking of launches because we want to keep
this on rolling
Toonverd
Toonvanderpass in our
chatroom is asking
Ryan are you still going to attend
the Psyche launch or have your
plans changed? In case you didn't hear
Psyche is going to
launch this month in October
finally after a year of delays
a literal year of delays
more than a year
actually yeah
excuse me a little bit more
definitely more than a year
now they've already had to push it a week
because of spacecraft issues
so Ryan what's up with that?
what's up with you because you had a little fundraiser
to make that happen
are we still going?
yeah I'm still going I had to move everything
I'm still waiting for budget to give me
my money back for the car hire
yeah I'm still going
for the car hire okay
that's how you phrase that
that is definitely I suppose
that's an English phraseology
oh yes yes
aware of that
I've never heard it used before
so that was pretty
pretty entertaining to say the
least and then our brain was like
that does make a lot more sense
to call it that
so still coming over to
cover it?
I'll be there
are you
feeling any way about it?
with it being delayed again?
how are we doing?
are we ventilating into a bag?
it's mildly annoying
one week is certainly much better than a year
I do have to say
but you know
it's a launch you expect this
it's not going to happen on this time at this
date and you can predict it 12 years in the future
like I don't know a solar eclipse
a launch happens
when a launch happens
it scrubs
these things happen
there's no other way of putting it
it was expected
and I planned around that
for that exact reason
I was going to say
scrubs and pushes
and delays are very much a part
of aerospace
welcome watching your schedule
move to the right
that's kind of just how it goes
and ourself and Dutta
you have
we both have been on the
receiving end of scrubs
Bennett saying
you sound
I can't read
I'm sorry you're still pretty psyched up
about it
so very very good
Arvail said don't sound so excited
Ryan
so don't
Ryan calm down
don't blow up
I've got to be careful with my levels
my levels are through the roof
good lord
also
Aerospike reminding us that the window
does extend two weeks past
the current launch date
for Psyche
so don't forget that
welcome to the
wonderful world of physics
with that there
I don't know what it's like to go to England in
October for a launch in
January or anything
yeah I'm sure Dutta
you've got zero stories about
something like that right
no
nobody would know anything about
having to wait months for a launch
in a different country
than you live in
except for maybe
one guy
that I can see
maybe we can talk about
Andy Law too soon
so I guess it's too soon
hey my stuff worked
true it did work
it did
Ryan coming on over
you've got to be doing something other than
covering Psyche
what else are you going to be doing
conveniently there's an annual solar eclipse
happening on the 14th which
unlike a rocket launch can't scrub
so I've got my solar filter
I've got my zoom lens I'm going to be doing
fingers crossed it's not
cloudy because knowing my luck
I'll bring the clouds with me
but I'm
hoping to be able to
see that properly which would be quite cool
yeah
so it'll be partial where you're at
but yeah
and I'm not going to go to the
path of annularity
for this one
but yeah you can probably catch me
at Griffith or something that day
helping the public watch it
but don't forget on April 8th we are
going to have one April 8th 2024
we're having a total solar eclipse
rolling through the middle of the United States
that one I will be there for that
I am not going to be missing that
I'm still considering
popping over for the day to see it
I'm not sure because
on timeanddate.com
the prediction
the diagrams they give you for how it will look
there's a teeny little
smidge that's meant to
be visible from the western edge
of the UK so I'm contemplating
either popping over to the US
for the weekend to see
the eclipse or going back down
to Cornwall or maybe even
hopping over to Ireland and just trying to
bet my chances to see even if there's a
glimpse of an eclipse
from western Europe which would be
obviously not as spectacular as a total solar
eclipse but also kind of interesting to see
just a little smidge on the end
and not having to get an 8 hour
flight to Texas or something
Well if
I can I highly recommend
and this goes for everybody that's watching
if you can find yourself in the path
of totality of a total solar eclipse
you need
to get to it because it is
an experience that
I cannot describe to you
and I had a multitude of co-workers say
I can't describe that experience to you
you've just got to go experience it and I was like
what are you talking about? You should be able to
explain this to me and I really
again, boy were they all spot on
I just, having gone to the one in 2017
I just can't
I can't explain the
whole experience
to you. You see stuff, you feel
stuff, you hear stuff
there's the changes in the
weather and the
view and
the enormity of
it all is just
you've got to go to it to take it in
so yeah that's why I'm
going back to Texas
to get another four
and a half minutes
to add to my
in the shadow of the moon time
that I've already experienced
in my life so far. My two minutes
one second I've already had
more, more
there
I totally understand why people
spend the rest of their lives chasing these
events and things
yeah Jared, Eclipse
hard, yes it was amazing
yeah there's
very few words, big
spectacular, amazing
just yeah
go see it, go see it if you can
uh
yeah
okay and yeah I was going to say
Nick Chair actually says the last total
visible eclipse in the
UK was 1999
which is probably before you were
born Ryan
it was, I think we had a total
not a total, remind me
a partial last year
either early this year or late last
year, I can't remember now
I do remember that
it was relatively recent
with that there
yeah, Jan saying
a total eclipse is indeed nothing
that you can explain, mine was 1999
I think in the English channel and yeah
again, it really does seem
so cliched for
anyone to say, I can't explain
it to you, you just have to go
you just have to go experience it, but no
really, I could try to
explain it to you but
just the magnitude of it
I can't explain it
just go, just go
go, if there's a
if the path of totality is within a reasonable
amount of distance
and you're not going to the center of it
and figuring out where to go in case of
whether I, there's something wrong
with you as a person and I don't think
we can, we won't get along
with that there
so
let's talk a little bit about
Stokes Space
because they did something really cool
and it seems like the extra
extremely very cool
things always happen
after
our episodes are wrapped up
right, so like this
came out just a few hours
after our episode
wrapped up
and
what happened, who wants to
explain what happened
I can try
I can do it too if need be
so this is the little gumdrop
right, what's up
this is the little arrow spike gumdrop
yes, or arrow
I love that name for
an arrow spike
gumdrop
you're right, that is delightful
I really, I actually
I quite like that
arrow spike gumdrop
so, there's a lot
of people forget you can, you know
it's a good shape
with that there
but Stokes Space, they are a
small spaceflight company
that is working on
developing a fully reusable
launcher, so which is
really really awesome, right
because that's what you need to do nowadays
either full reusability or
your company's not going to make it
but
why don't I go ahead and pull up the video of it
they showed us
doing a hop
and that's a really cool thing
right, because we haven't seen a vehicle
do a hop in a very very
long time
oh, is this my screen
or did somebody have it
I'm pulling it up
yep, and look at that shot
it's so amazing, I love it
it looks so beautiful
but if we'd like to see it
in motion, I'm going to go ahead and pull it up
here on my screen
get what I got
with it, ok, now we should have it
alright, everybody ready
here we go
alright, get up
come on
light
and
it's away
that's pretty cool
it was a bit of a bumpy landing though, I will say
not perfectly smooth, but you know
any landing
you can walk away from
it was a good landing apparently
even though it can't walk
but apparently it still counts
yes it does, it indeed does count
with that there
so that was great
we got to actually see
the vehicle
in action, how great is that
that's so cool
I was just wondering, have we seen
a photo with somebody
right by that
have you ever seen
I'm not sure to be honest
I think it's meant to be
7 metres
in diameter
or 7 metres tall, it's one of the two
probably 7 metres tall
and slightly smaller in diameter
because the rocket itself isn't that
tall, it's quite a
stubby rocket
I think it's shorter than Falcon 9
by a bit
I think it's probably neutron kind of scale
but it is
unlike neutron, it is intended to be
fully reusable, bringing the first stage back like Falcon
and then bring the second stage back
like a Starship
except, well not really like a Starship
more like a capsule, it's essentially
a big capsule with an aerospike on the bottom
that is also a regeneratively cooled
heat shield, which is just kind of
you know, sticking three
epic things together in one
reusable aerospike with a regeneratively cooled
heat shield, that is the aerospike
I think it's probably
one of the most, if not the
most efficient kind of combine
everything together design that there is
because you get an engine, you get a heat
shield and you get an
aerodynamically stable vehicle
with one design
Yeah, and by the way, just to
let you know, the Hopper that they have
there is a dedicated Hopper vehicle
it is about the size
of the second stage
of Stokes launch vehicle
It doesn't have the payload fairing on it
very important thing to note there
but 4 meters in diameter
6 meters tall, so Ryan you're right on it
with it there, so excellent
with that
It will probably be 7 or 8 meters
with the whole shebang
on top of it as well
Yeah, once the fairing gets put on there
you're going to need to have a bigger
fairing on that there
so it will get huge
it will get large
in size
and yeah, very very exciting
to see that
and as many of you
were noting
in the chat room
they use differential thrust
as their thrust vector control system
with that there
Yeah
Oh yeah, go for it Ryan
I'll take it, this is in my opinion
hmm
I want to say this without sounding really mean
but I hope they don't
fly humans on this vehicle
or they don't have any goals to fly humans
with differential thrust
instead of engine gimbling
because famously
the N1 rocket
from the Soviet Union used
differential thrust instead of engine
gimbling on the first stage
and their solution was
in order to counteract the loss
of an engine on one side
to stop the vehicle from tipping over
they would have to shut down another engine
on the other side
so if you lost one engine
you'd lose two, and that had about 30
engines in total, and they could only lose
I think six or
eight engines, so that means
if you lose three engines, you're toast
because you have to shut down the opposite engine
Now, that was on the first stage
Stoke are using this system on the
second stage, so maybe that will make this
more reliable, maybe they won't have to shut down
the opposite engine if they lose one
because of instability or what not
but I do find it interesting that they have
gone down this route, especially
with their aerospike, instead of trying to figure
out some kind of alternative
method in order to introduce
the ability to steer the exhaust
because my opinion is that
if they do have to do that opposite shutdown thing
this could become a very
not dangerous, but
potentially difficult
vehicle to control if
you lose a certain number
of
combustion chambers
because it's actually just
one engine, but it has separate
nozzles all around the outside
so it's a very unique design
but it just depends if it's reliable
or not. Yeah, and
aerospike was kind of bringing
up that reliability issue, which
that it's one engine to feed all those nozzles
which we talked
about
Jason actually has a really good
I've pulled up
a couple pictures real quick of
what it looks like
compared to humans near scale
Yeah, that's pretty good size, I gotta say
I like Jason
Jason's description here is actually really well
which is that Stokes' approach is
more akin to the RD-180
so the engine flying on the Atlas V
where you've got
a single combustion chamber with multiple
nozzles
that's what we're talking
about
also
here from
Aurovale, which I think is a very important
way to differentiate
between the N1 and now
which is that our computers
and engine validation options are
a lot better than the N1 days
though, so I think that things like
differential thrust are
reasonable for
something like Stokes because we can
actually pull off
it's been about 50 years and we've gotten
a little bit better at
rockets and computers to control those
rockets, at least I would hope we have
but
TSM
Space does bring up a really good point
which is that
there's a lot of stabilization
that needs to be used with these valves
and things, you gotta hold the valves open to the
right positions
I don't know if I would describe it with that kind of
complexity as complex
as a walking robot, but it is
absolutely
a significantly more complex system
than most rocket
engines because of what you
have there
yeah, so holy moly
that's still really
cool, I love what Stokes has been able to
do with that and how
rapidly they've been able to do it too
I think it was
just a year and a half ago when they came up on
the scene and
already they've got a hopper
going
the company was founded
by two people who left Blue Origin
because they, I think this is correct
because they thought that Blue Origin was moving
too slowly, so
ironically
Blue has yet to
fly any tests of
their orbital vehicle, New Glenn
and Stoke already has, but
to be fair to Blue, New Glenn
is on a completely different
scale to what Stokes' vehicle
currently unnamed
vehicle is
yeah, Hulk
smokes, that's really really
rapid and then of course mad props to the
aerospike
going down with it there
always love us
an aerospike engine baby
I mean that is
I want an aerospike so bad
and it always breaks my
heart when I see
Tim's
video that says are aerospike engines
good or bad and it's just like no Tim
I can't do this
so yeah
super excited to see that
with them there, alright
anybody got anything else before I talk about
some asteroids coming back
I think we should let you get on with your
astrology, you want me to talk about
not astrology, not
this week
this is local
this is planetary science
which is different
it's planetary science
which is different from
astronomy
which your shirt there
Ryan, I'd like to point out, talking about
Pluto, a whole bunch of astronomers
voted for Pluto
to no longer be a planet
not a whole bunch of planetary
scientists did it
as the great
Dr. Alan Stern
who's the principal investigator
on the New Horizons mission that Pluto once told me
having a bunch of astronomers
decide what kind of object Pluto is
is like going to a podiatrist
for your brain cancer
anyways
he's got a way with words
what's up, sounds like fighting words right there
well I'll tell you anything
Dr. Stern, thank you so much
for your
really great ones
I do want to talk about
this super awesome thing
that happened last Sunday
which was
we had some
samples drop off
finally, there we go, there's our samples being
dropped off at the Dunway Proving Ground
out in
Utah from the OSIRIS-REx
mission, so six years
excuse me, seven years in the making
for this
launching with one of my favorite configurations
of rockets, the Atlas V
and the 411 configuration
so we had a single solid
so it did the power slide off of the
launch pad there
and as you can see, a good parachute
coming down and we actually do have
those samples back
and yes, the
samples from asteroid Bennu
which it was expected to maybe
get like, I don't know,
60 grams or so
and we've got almost
I believe several hundred grams
of materials from it there
so it overwhelmed
the sample container
I'm going to kind of skip ahead on the video here
a little bit with it
as they hunt it down and of course
very happy to get those samples
back, these are
the first samples the United States
has returned of an asteroid
from space, not
the first country to do it
that would be Japan, Japan's actually
done it with both Hayabusa 1
and Hayabusa 2
so very cool missions
that we've had that with there
so awesome
and OSIRIS-REx, the main
spacecraft is
still out in space and it's now
turned into the OSIRIS APEX
mission which is going to
rendezvous with asteroid Apophis
coming up towards the end
of the 2020s
if you've ever heard of asteroid Apophis before
that's because it is
well known for
being an asteroid
that was first thought that was actually going to hit the
Earth but then after some more
observations that we did of it we were able
to figure out oh yeah it's
actually not going to be hitting
the Earth at all
which is good, we don't want things to hit the Earth
and this is why we study
these kinds of things as well because
we want to know what it's like
if we have to
work with that so yeah
there you go, that's what we got
so really cool to get those samples back
once the pictures start
rolling out in mass I'll grab
some and hopefully next week I can
show you some very cool things
Adam Baker asks
did the drogue
open? Yes, the drogue
did open so as far as
I know it did, it went through
all that it should have, it's just that the capsule
is not very big, capsule is like
how big was it? Maybe
a couple, like a meter and a half
roughly, something like that so
yeah, not very big
as far as I saw it did
it's just that it's very
very small so you didn't really
it's really small and you didn't see it
from far away so
yeah, Aravella
said I assume someone has done the math and confirmed
that booping Apophis won't put it back
on course for Earth, oh well
we're not going to, so
Osiris Rex can't sample anymore
it's kind of done
with that
so yeah
it can't boop
anymore, it's just going for
observation or what not
and things, yes
and it's going to arrive in time for
Apophis to do it's very
close pass
of the Earth in 2029
so I'm actually really excited
about that because I hope that they get a
really great image
of
Osiris, or of
Apophis and the Earth in the
same frame, I think that would be
stunningly amazing
with that there
so that would be cool, look but don't boop
yes, exactly
look but don't boop
so yeah
I thought I saw another
question, like a serious
question
with that there, oh yeah
theoretical question, would it be
possible to provide Osiris
Apex with a new container to boop
Apophis, or is it
technically impossible?
nothing's impossible, it's just depending
upon how much money you got
I think that probably would have had to
have already launched, yes
that would have had to have launched in rendezvous
with Osiris Apex
to pull that off
unfortunately, so yes
but I mean
you know, nothing
says that we can't
we can't
get a new mission ready
to go, it's just that you gotta
run through the process of everything with it
I think, unfortunately
though, if anything, the reports
from this previous week of anything to go
it is no longer the James Webb
Space Telescope eating the budget, it's now
Mars sample return that's deciding to
feast upon NASA's budget, so
oh boy, here we go
again
with a project
having its schedule and its
budget run out of control, so
did we forget how to do that?
so, I don't know
but anyways
the government forgot
how to budget anyway, so
it doesn't matter, yeah I was
gonna say
we came pretty
close to having the shutdown
of NASA
along with the federal government here
in the United States
our annual tradition of shutting down the government
yeah, or nearly
shutting it down, should we say
but yeah
we came pretty close to it
NASA, there would have been a lot of
NASA that would have shuttered
but I also do know that
Psyche was declared a
exception
to that and the work on that would
have continued as was planned
because unfortunately
launch windows don't
care what's going on here on Earth
so, turns out
physics doesn't
care what's going on inside of
the capital, so physics will do
what physics wants to do
yep, that's very very true
so that's
so it goes, that's the way it is
for us
so, anyone else got
anything with that there?
because that's it for me for this
week, so
if that's it for us, we can always go in
to thanking our folks who help
make the shows of tomorrow
possible, we are so
so so thankful for all of
your support, you
amazing, amazing folks
and if you would like
to help become a Tomorrow member
and support us here, you can go over to
youtube.com slash t-m-r-o
slash join
which means that
you get
to
join us for our members only show
which I'm not going to be at
unfortunately for much today
but you get to join us where we
kind of loosen up a little bit and talk
about some funnier stuff and
kind of work for
that there and
we'll have a good time
for those of you that were going to catch the first narrow stream
thank you for being our Tomorrow Model 33 Plaid Pro
Plus Edition member
and once again, just to remind you
if you'd like to become a member of us here
on Tomorrow, you can get those
free cool things like going to the member stream
right now, consider becoming one, go to
youtube.com slash t-m-r-o
slash join, it's literally
as little as 99 cents a month
not even a quarter of a cup of coffee
that's how that works, alright
that's it for me, I'm Jared
that's also Ryan, that's also
Dutta, you guys are over there
this whole week, I didn't even
know where you were this week until the end of the show
that's it for us, thank
you all so much, we'll be seeing
you next week, if you're going to be joining
us, later