Venez poser vos questions et discuter avec moi en direct pendant que je suis en live sur Twitch. Vous pouvez même me joindre en audio en rejoignant le Discord ! Cliquez sur le lien ci-dessous 👇
Ne me croyez pas sur parole ! Je ne suis un expert dans aucun domaine et je fais principalement ces vidéos pour tenter d'en apprendre davantage sur ce qui m'intéresse puis de le partager avec d'autres personnes. Je vous encourage vivement à vérifier par vous-même ce que je dis et n'hésitez surtout pas à me corriger si vous pensez que j'ai fait une erreur ou que je n'ai pas compris un sujet.
Si vous souhaitez me contacter, vous pouvez m'envoyer directement un message à [email protected], ou bien sur Twitter ou Discord.
So, what is Molineux's principle?
It's a problem raised by someone named William Molineux to John Locke
John Locke was a philosopher in the 17th century
and the principle is that he wondered
whether a blind man of birth, by definition someone who has never seen anything
would be able to distinguish, simply with his eyes
if he found the vision, cubes, spheres, geometric shapes
that he would have only touched all his life
The idea is that if all your life you have not been able to distinguish spheres, cubes
all these shapes, for example my keyboard in front of me
with the touch, if I found the vision
I would be able to distinguish them simply with my sight
And Molineux, in the correspondence he addressed to Locke
asks himself this question
Locke, who is an empiricist, says to him, a priori, no
since the senses for him are distinct
and so if we have never made the association between the two
we are not able, simply by sight, when we have never seen
to say that a sphere is different from a cube
simply by seeing it
and it turns out that for a long time it remained a purely theoretical problem
and since quite recently, thanks to modern medicine
since now we are able to cure a certain type of blindness
there are some people who are blind from birth
and we are able to make them regain their sight
and suddenly we realized
basically the answer is that
no, these people are unable to distinguish simply by sight
things that they are able to distinguish by touching
and that's interesting because
even things that seem obvious
like, I don't know
I see that
I almost put it everywhere
I see that this is different from this
from my mouse
and yet
if
I had never seen them
and I had only touched them
simply by sight
I would not be able to distinguish them
which seems quite weird because
a sphere is really different from a cube a priori
and yet
and yet it's not the case
and yet if it's the case, it's really different
but in any case, a blind person from birth
would not be able to distinguish them simply by sight
by regaining sight
in 2003 there was a study
carried out by Pawan Sinhwa
at MIT
and apparently after the surgery
they were still unable to
distinguish the shapes
because there is no association
between the senses
if, concretely, I know
that the bottle that I touch
in front of me, I touch a bottle
I know that the bottle that I touch has a certain shape
that I associate with what I see
because concretely, at the same time that I touch it
well, I see it
but if I only touch it or only see it
well, in fact, I am not able
to make the association
independently of the senses
there is another experience
that was carried out in the same style
with blind people from birth who were able to regain sight
we realized that
when they regain sight
in fact, what they see
even if it is really a perfect vision
there is no vision problem
it's just that we are used
by what we see
to make the distinction between certain objects
like the bottle
I know that I have a bottle concept
that is associated with what I see
and so I am able to distinguish it
from my hand, I am able to distinguish it
from the desk in the background, etc.
but if
I never had the habit
to make this distinction and that spontaneously
I regain sight
well, in fact, the bottle, I would not be able
to distinguish it from the background
from the desk that is there
everything I see would simply be
a kind of collection of different colors
but I would not be able
to make the conceptual distinction
between the objects
I find it quite interesting
what you say
that we can distinguish the perfect material
from the sphere, because the sphere
there is no angle and everything
so a priori
it seems normal
to be able to distinguish simply by sight
even if we have never seen
what a sphere looks like
because concretely, if I touch something
that is more spherical
than angular
well, I see that there is no angle
so I hardly see
but it's precisely because
maybe I don't have
I don't have this experience as a blind person
but it's the same
I hardly see how
we can not associate the two
but then I have a spatial representation
when I touch an object
in a way, I do it from what I saw
so maybe
a blind person is completely different
I don't know exactly how it can be
yeah, it can be a little
well, it's precisely in this context
that it happens a little
precisely
the debate between innate ideas
and empiricism
because precisely for Locke, since we don't have
innate ideas, we are unable to have
a spontaneous knowledge
of what we see
associated with the senses
but the same, I have a hard time understanding
how it's possible actually, because for me
but it's maybe precisely because I'm so used to
seeing and feeling
in fact, by touching it
something spherical, that the two
are intimately linked, but maybe it's completely different
for someone who has never seen, I don't know
but apparently, in any case, the experiments that were
carried out, apparently in any case
a blind person is unable to make the distinction between the two
but Youm, yeah, there's something really
interesting too, a question that was asked
it even has a name, so it's even a Wikipedia page
The Missing Shade of Blue
the missing shade of blue
and the question they ask is
if, basically
in the spectrum of colors
we had seen all the shades of blue
except one
if you see, imagine
all our life, we had seen
the colors as we see them now
but in fact
there is a shade of blue
that
we would have never seen
well, would we
be able to
imagine it, or
the fact of having never seen it
it prevents us from having
access to it, you see, because
if we have already seen
the color of blue that is
from 420 to
430 nanometers
the color of blue, the shade of blue that is
from 431 to
440 nanometers, can we
imagine
the one that is precisely
at 430 nanometers, or
since we have never seen it, we are not able to
imagine it? I think it's an interesting question too
I think, concretely, the current answer
is to say no, that it is not possible
if we have never done the experiment, we cannot
invent it, but
it's the same, it's a thought experiment that is quite interesting
I think, because you see, if
on the one hand, by the way, we can see well
if I had only seen
green, and if I had only seen
orange, concretely
I don't think I could have invented the yellow
in the middle