Did you miss the latest Ramsey Show episode? Don’t worry—we’ve got you covered! Get all the highlights you missed plus some of the best moments from the show. Watch entertaining calls, Dave Rants, guest interviews, and more!
Brought to you by the EveryDollar app.
Start budgeting for free today.
Jeremy's with us.
Jeremy is in Tucson, Arizona.
Hi, Jeremy.
Welcome to the Ramsey Show.
Thank you.
Thank you for taking my call.
Sure.
How can we help?
So, quick question.
My son, youngest son, got himself stuck into a whole life policy, and of course I want
to talk him out of it, get him to invest in something else.
So I know the biggest hook is he can borrow against his policy.
I know that with the 401k, he'll get penalized, which leads me to maybe mutual funds, which
I don't know a whole lot about.
So I was wondering, what's the major difference between the 401k and a mutual fund that he
may be able to borrow against in the future?
Okay.
How old is your son?
He's 23.
Well, I don't think ... I mean, number one, let's just ask the question.
Why is he going to listen to you?
Well, I've got a really good relationship with him, and the whole reason he got himself
stuck in here was because I kept pushing for him to invest, to save money, to think about
his future.
Yeah, but then he picked a bad way of doing it.
Right.
And when you say, son, this is a dumb way of doing it, it's not a good investment program,
what does he say?
Oh, I can borrow against it?
That's his big hook, yes.
Okay.
Well, no one ever got rich borrowing their investments.
Right.
They invest them and they forget them.
And then you're completely against it.
Yeah.
Borrowing against it is not a method of wealth building.
It's a method of selling insurance, crappy insurance, but it's not a method of wealth
building.
Right.
And that's what got him in.
He was actually looking for health and disability and death insurance is where he started looking,
and then they hooked him on the whole life policy.
Yeah.
So, I mean, my point is that ... We can answer your question.
A 401k is not an investment.
It is how an investment is treated for taxes.
Typically, inside of a 401k, you're going to find mutual funds.
So you have a mutual fund that's either covered with a coat keeping it warm from taxes, and
the coat is called a 401k or an IRA or a Roth IRA, or it has no coat and it's out in the
cold and has taxed.
But in both cases, it's still a mutual fund.
Could be the exact same mutual fund.
Wealthy people don't build their investments in order to borrow against them.
And so if he wants to become wealthy, he's picked a really bad way of doing it.
Number one, borrowing against it.
Number two, he's picked probably one of the worst financial products alive today, and
it is the whole life policy, because it has a horrible rate of return.
In the first three years that you pay 20x, 20 times more for the same amount of life
insurance.
So you buy a $100,000 whole life policy, you buy a $100,000 term policy, if the $100,000
whole life policy is $100 a month, the $100,000 term policy is $5 a month.
That's what research tells us.
So it's 20x more expensive.
$95 extra per hundred.
Now where does that go?
It goes into an investment called cash value.
And the cash value has no buildup for the first two to three years.
They keep 100% of your investment as commissions the first three years.
You have zeros on your cash value buildup the first three years.
Well that sucks.
And once you get past having a really front-loaded, horrible commission off the front end, and
it finally starts making money, the average whole life policy, according to research,
averages 1.2% rate of return.
Not going to get rich on that either.
Oh, and then when you finally get past all of that, if you actually build it up, you
can borrow and pay them interest to use your money.
So if you have a savings account, and you want to borrow, and you want to take money
out of your savings account, you don't have to pay money.
You just take money out of your savings account.
But with a whole life policy, you want to take money out, you have to pay them interest
to use your money that you paid 20x more to build up.
This thing sucks.
Oh, and it's even worse than that.
You finally build up inside your whole $100,000 policy $20,000 worth of cash value, and then
you screw around and die, which we all do.
Oh, guess what happens to your $20,000 that you paid $95 extra per month to build up after
getting past horrible rates of return, and no build up at all for the first three years
because they kept it all as a commission.
Once you finally get $20,000 in there and you die, they pay $100,000.
They keep your savings account.
So if you had a savings account at the bank, or if I start pitching you a savings account
on TikTok, and I said, hey, here's your savings account.
The first three years you put money in, nothing happens.
We keep it all.
After that, it makes 1.2%.
And when you die, you lose your money.
No one would put money in that.
That's a whole life policy.
So nobody ought to put money in a whole life policy.
So you can just play this rant back for your son, Jeremy, when it comes out on the podcast
and it'll answer it's perfect.
Exactly what I would do.
And I'm not even, I mean, that's exactly, son, watch this.
Yeah, this is just, don't do it.
Don't do it.
Son of Jeremy, you have been screwed by the life insurance industry.
And they are very good at their business of screwing people.
It's unbelievable, horrible product.
Let me tell you, if you're poor, the way they get you is the pawn shops.
The way they get you is the rent to own.
The way they get you is the payday lender.
The way they get you is lottery tickets.
If you're middle class, the way they get you is they make you believe you're going to get
rich on airline miles using your stupid credit card.
Well, that's a dumb butt idea.
The way they get you is they get you into a whole life policy.
That's a dumb butt idea.
The way they get you is they go sophisticated, rich people lease their cars.
No, they don't.
It's a dumb butt middle class thing to do.
So the whole life policy is the payday lender of the middle class.
It's a signal that you intend to be in the middle class to stay there the rest of your
life because you got screwed by the insurance companies.
And I got to tell you, man, if you don't like that and you sell whole life, you need to
actually learn how your product works.
And then if you have integrity, you'll quit selling that crap.
Because there's only two types of people that sell whole life, the ones that don't understand
it and the ones that are crooks.
Because if you understand that crap and you sell it, you by definition are a crook.
Because anybody that would sell someone an investment that the insurance company keeps
their money that they put in there upon death and call that a good deal is a crook.
That's just bull.
Okay?
It's just absolute scam stuff.
It just pisses me off.
And I'll tell you what, whole life, I thought it had just about gone away.
And freaking TikTok has revived whole life.
TikTok of all things.
I mean, listen people, if your social media sounds like a TikTok, there's only one thing
you should listen to on TikTok and that's stuff we put out.
But other than that, it's awful.
It's a barren landscape of morons.
It's crazy.
Absolute nuts.
Oh God.
And whole life stuff is all over it.
Like they just invented it yesterday.
It's the oldest financial product.
Ma'am, the financial planning community completely abandoned this garbage 35 years ago.
No one sells whole life life insurance except life insurance agents.
No one in the financial planning community believes in it.
We've all been looking at it going, you gotta be kidding.
For decades.
And now that stuff comes back on TikTok.
It's unbelievable.