Spokesperson Matthew Miller leads the Department Press Briefing, at the Department of State, on September 27, 2023.
Transcript: https://www.state.gov/briefings/department-press-briefing-september-27-2023/ ---------- Under the leadership of the President and Secretary of State, the U.S. Department of State leads America’s foreign policy through diplomacy, advocacy, and assistance by advancing the interests of the American people, their safety and economic prosperity. On behalf of the American people we promote and demonstrate democratic values and advance a free, peaceful, and prosperous world.
The Secretary of State, appointed by the President with the advice and consent of the Senate, is the President's chief foreign affairs adviser. The Secretary carries out the President's foreign policies through the State Department, which includes the Foreign Service, Civil Service and U.S. Agency for International Development.
Good afternoon, everyone.
Let's start with some brief remarks.
The United States has secured the return of Private Travis Keane from the Democratic
People's Republic of Korea.
Earlier today, he was transported to the border between North Korea and China, where he was
met by our ambassador to the People's Republic of China, Nicholas Burns.
He then boarded a State Department OPMED plane and flew from Dandong, China, to Shenyang,
China, and then on from Shenyang to Osan Air Force Base in South Korea, where he was transferred
to the Department of Defense.
We appreciate the professionalism of our diplomats who worked with their counterparts at the
Department of Defense and coordinated with the governments of Sweden and the People's
Republic of China, and we thank Sweden and the People's Republic of China for their assistance
in facilitating that transfer.
He is now on his way to the United States, and we expect him to arrive in the coming
hours.
With that, questions?
That's it?
That's it.
Okay.
Well, when I woke up this morning, I thought the news of the day was going to be about
Israel and the visa waiver program.
We'd like to keep you on your toes.
Yes, exactly.
But obviously – can I just ask you, on Travis King – sorry, where did you say he – what
base in South Korea?
Osan Air Force Base.
Osan?
Okay.
And then – and you're confirming that he has now left Osan on his way?
Correct.
And is on his way back to the United States.
Back to the U.S.
And how did he get from North Korea to China?
He was – so I don't know how he got inside North Korea to the border.
I'll let the North Koreans speak that if they want to.
But then he was transferred.
Okay.
How did he get?
He was – I believe he was driven by the North Koreans.
But again, I don't have perfect – Driven by the North Koreans or by the Swedes?
Let me just finish.
I don't have perfect fidelity on his movements inside North Korea, but let me – he was
taken to the border at Dandong, where he was transferred to U.S. custody.
And then where?
And that's where Burns and the other – Dandong.
That's where Burns met him, Dandong, China.
Okay.
And that – he didn't go anywhere else in China before leaving for Osan?
The plane – he got on board an OpMed plane, which stopped in Xinjiang, China, and then
continued on to Osan.
And this OpMed plane – I don't know how many you guys have, but it's getting a lot
of use – or if there's only one, is this the same plane that brought back the people
from Iran?
Or from Iran?
I do not know.
I don't know how many we have.
I don't know if it's the same plane.
An OpMed plane you said?
An OpMed plane.
State Department OpMed plane.
Yeah.
Can I just ask about the – sorry, about the diplomacy regarding this?
Sure.
What does it mean?
I mean, obviously, the U.S. wanted Travis King back, but does it mean something broader
with North Korea?
Could this be an opening for something broader?
What is – what are the motivations as far as you can detect for a North Korean agency?
So I would not want to speculate on any motivations on the North Korean side, and I don't know
that I would take from this that it heralds some breakthrough in diplomatic relations.
Obviously, we're pleased to have secured his return.
We're very thankful for the Government of Sweden for their work as the protecting power
that they did to help facilitate his transfer back to the United States.
I will restate, as I have said from this podium before, and as we have said, we are open to
diplomacy with North Korea.
We would welcome diplomacy with North Korea.
They have always rejected that.
We tried to reach out to them when Travis King first crossed the border into North Korea.
We tried to reach out on a number of occasions.
They rejected our direct approaches and ended up talking to Sweden, and Sweden talked to
us and helped negotiate this transfer.
But I would not see this as the sign of some breakthrough.
I think it's a one-off with them being willing to return this private.
Yeah.
QUESTION.
Can I follow up on China's role a little bit?
Do you see them more as a transit point in this situation?
Did they play any role as a mediator?
They did not play a role as a mediator, but their role in providing transit or in facilitating
transit is one we very much appreciate.
We have always thought that China could play a useful role in any number of issues as it
relates to North Korea.
The Secretary has said that directly to his Chinese counterparts.
We've said it publicly on a number of occasions.
And we do appreciate the role that they played here.
And, I mean, your working-level diplomats must have communicated on this.
Do you think that these conversations can be described as a set of positive exchanges,
or how would you describe these?
Well, we didn't have direct exchanges with North Korea, so certainly we had positive
exchanges with Sweden.
With China.
With China, yes, absolutely.
And is there – I mean, the relationship's not in a great place at the moment.
of seeing this as sort of a jumping-off point for more communication, for better relations?
I would say that we have seen an increase in the tempo of our conversations with the
Chinese Government across a number of fronts since the Secretary traveled to Beijing in
June.
Of course, you've seen that at the Secretary level, not just here, but at other departments
in the United States Government.
You've seen that at the Assistant Secretary level.
We have other meetings that we'll be able to make public in the very near future where
we are exchanging views with China on a number of issues.
And we do think there is an opening to work with China.
I think you saw that the Department of Commerce – or the Department of Treasury just announced
new working groups on economic issues, and we continue to pursue ways to work with them
on stopping the trafficking of fentanyl, on returning United States detainees.
So any time we can work together on areas that advance U.S. interests or that address
shared concerns, we see that as a positive and hope that it will lead to more work together.
And in the wake of this and Blinken's meeting last week in New York, do you see the meeting
between Biden and Xi on the sidelines of APEC in San Francisco as more likely now?
I wouldn't want to say more likely, less likely.
It's always tough to make those assessments from here, really from anywhere, with any
degree of accuracy, because there are two parties at work here.
I will just reiterate what we have said, which is that we think there's no substitute for
leader-to-leader communication.
The potential for a meeting between the two leaders is something that Secretary Blinken
discussed with the Chinese vice president last week at UNGA in New York.
We believe it would be important to have that meeting, and we hope it will take place, but
we don't have anything to announce yet.
Let me go to Alex first.
Thank you.
This all seems rather sort of unilateral on the North Korean side.
They let it be known to the South – to the Swedes that they were willing to release
King.
Understanding that this was the culmination of intense diplomacy, was there anything that
the North Koreans asked for or received in exchange?
Was there a trade at all?
I am not aware of them asking for anything.
It doesn't mean that they didn't, but I'm not aware if they did – I'm just
not aware whether they did or did or did not ask for anything.
We did not give them anything.
We've made no concessions as a part of securing his return.
Do you have any idea why they decided to suddenly expel him?
I am going to follow my general rule here and not try to get into the heads of foreign
governments, and certainly not that one.
Janet, go ahead.
Thank you.
Travis King voluntarily chose North Korea.
What punishment will he face when he comes home?
I would refer you to the Department of Defense for that question.
He is an active member of the military, and that's a question they'll have to speak to.
But he's violations for the –
I'm sorry?
He had violations of U.S. laws, his active militaries.
Again, I'm going to refer that to the Defense Department, who would be the agency that would
be – that would speak to that question.
Yeah, one more.
One more on North Korea.
North Korea's ambassador to United Nations Sung Kim said that the nuclear war on the
Korean Peninsula was imminent and blamed the United States and South Korea.
How would you comment on this?
We would obviously find those remarks irresponsible, as we find any number of statements the – that
North Korea makes threatening its neighbors or raising tensions in the region.
And I will say we will continue to work with our partners in the region – the Republic
of Korea, Japan – to ensure their security and prevent North Korea from taking such aggressive
actions.
Go to the back.
So after this whole travel thing, do you think communicate with DPRK is getting more easier
to compare to before?
Do I think what?
What was the –
Communication to North Korea getting more easier to compare to before?
No, I wouldn't say that, given that, as I just said, they refused all of our attempts
to communicate with them over this matter.
They have always had communications with other governments, and we found it possible to communicate
with them through Sweden, which, as I said, is our protecting power.
But I don't think – as I said, I think in response to an earlier question, I do not
see this as a sign of any diplomatic breakthrough that will have implications for other issues,
other areas of concern we have with the DPRK regime.
Thank you.
Yeah, Latvia.
Thank you.
Private King was described by U.S. officials as being in good spirits and good health.
What do you know about his treatment while in the custody of the North Koreans?
I don't know anything at this point.
It's possible that people who were on the plane with him have gotten further information.
It hasn't been communicated back here yet, so I don't have any information other than
to confirm that, yes, he was in good spirits, he was in good health, but with respect to
his treatment, it's not something I can read out from the podium today.
So no indications right now that he was interrogated or harshly treated in any way?
I just – I would certainly imagine that he was interrogated.
That was – that would be consistent with past DPRK practice with respect to detainees.
But I don't have any readout from his conversations with the people on the plane with him or the
people that he met at Osan Air Force Base.
Okay.
And did his release come as the result of an explicit ask by the United States, even
if conveyed through Sweden, or do you view this as a sort of voluntary or even benevolent
act on the part of Pyongyang, again, conveyed to Sweden?
I think it could be the result of both an ask and a voluntary decision.
It was a request.
We made it clear to North Korea that we wanted to secure his return, and they ultimately
decided to do so.
And one more.
When did their willingness to release him get conveyed?
In the past few days, I would say.
In the past few days.
In the past week, past few days, yeah.
Was it the subject of any conversations between the Secretary and other interlocutors while
at the UN General Assembly?
Not that I'm aware of.
I was in most of those conversations, and it didn't come up.
It certainly didn't come up in our conversation with the Chinese Vice President.
This was handled more at the working level, not at the Secretary level.
And – sorry, but just to put a fine point on it, when did the U.S. become aware that
they were going to get Travis King back?
I don't have a specific date.
We've been working on this for some time, but it takes – as we've seen with the
release of other detainees, it can take some time from the time that you get indications
that he might be returned until you know it for sure, until you can actually negotiate
the specific details of the transfer.
Anything else on North Korea before you – yeah.
When the plane stopped in Shenyang, did Mick Burns get off the plane?
I don't actually know if he was on the plane.
I don't know if he was on the plane, the first leg of the plane, or whether he got
off.
I don't know.
I just did not get a briefing on the manifest before coming up here, so.
Okay.
Well, I mean, you just said you didn't know.
He agreed to – You didn't know of anyone who had spoken
to him on the plane, but presumably if Burns was at the border and met him and then got
on the plane and then gone and then flew to Shenyang, he was on the plane for however
long that flight is.
Yeah.
Right.
Let me say this.
I presume he was not on the plane by himself.
I don't know if it was the ambassador or other people – either – whoever was on
the plane with him.
I haven't gotten a readout of anything he might have said to them.
So, Alex, go ahead.
I have a few topics, but let me start with Azerbaijan.
I really don't mind.
As I understand, senior officials are currently in Azerbaijan.
We have eyes and ears on the ground.
Can you give us a sense of what you have been observing in the past 24 hours that calls
for international community to prevent ethnic cleansing, something that the Azerbaijan government
also doesn't necessarily say, please?
Where exactly is going on?
And the sides are talking about also returning back to Russia.
What's going on there?
So I would say a few things.
Number one, as you noted, Samantha Power, the USAID administrator, and Acting Assistant
Secretary Yuri Kim are in Azerbaijan today, where they stressed a number of things, the
same things that the Secretary stressed in his conversation with President Aliyev yesterday
and that I reiterated at the podium, which is that, number one, we want to see the ceasefire
maintained.
Number two, we want to see humanitarian needs addressed.
That means keeping the Lachin Corridor open.
It means ensuring that humanitarian supplies can come in.
And that it means an international monitoring mission to ensure that humanitarian needs
are addressed.
And I will say that we did welcome the comments by the Government of Azerbaijan just a little
while ago before I came out to this podium that they would welcome such an international
monitoring mission.
That's something that the Secretary had directly pushed the President for, and we're glad
to see his having agreed to it.
And we will work with our allies and partners in the coming days to flesh out exactly what
that mission will look like.
But then ultimately, what we do want to see is a return to the negotiating table where
they can ultimately reach a dignified, lasting peace.
QUESTION.
Speaking of negotiating table, for months and months you had dialogue going on in Washington,
in Brussels.
Senior officials told us just last month that the sides had agreed to return back to Washington.
Who dropped the ball, and when, and why?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't know what – so first of all, I reject the characterization about dropping the ball.
We have been pursuing negotiations.
The Secretary has been having direct conversations with the President of Azerbaijan, the Prime
Minister of Armenia.
We've had a number of officials travel to the region, not just in the past week or ten
days since hostilities broke out, but going back months and months and months.
We have done everything we can to pursue diplomacy, but ultimately, remember, it's up to the
two parties here who are – the parties that have direct disagreements.
We can do everything we can to push them, but ultimately, they have to agree to talk
and they have to agree to ultimately come to some resolution.
That's what we're going to do, is continue to play our part to facilitate that.
QUESTION.
And how much about this also can be pointed at Russia?
I'm asking because Kremlin loves pointing at the West and also the fact that Pashinyan
chose Western orientation of Armenia.
So where is Russia's role here, and how do you – is it time to come out and call
Russia out for what it has been doing?
MR.
CROWLEY.
I certainly do not think Russia has played a productive role here in the past week.
We have seen them at times.
There have been times where they facilitated negotiations, and that was something that
we welcomed.
But certainly in the last week, their role has not been productive in this situation.
QUESTION.
I have one more on Russia, if you don't mind.
MR.
CROWLEY.
Yeah.
QUESTION.
In the wake of today's sanctions and also yesterday's business advisory on Shihan,
I want to ask you about business advisory on Russia.
It's been more than a year and a half that we're into this war.
There are big calls from different sides – Ukrainian business community and diaspora.
The fact that you guys still allowing the U.S. companies, business companies, to operate
in Russia – some of them have left and returned back and earning money and paying taxes – is
not consistent with your policy to isolate Russia, is it?
MR.
CROWLEY.
Let me say a few things about that.
One, that since Russia's full-scale invasion in February of last year, a number of U.S.
and international companies have looked at the legal, looked at the reputational risk,
and decided that those risks were too high to continue involving – to continue operating
in Russia.
In fact, over 1,000 U.S. companies have withdrawn from Russia in that time.
In addition, Russia has passed restrictive new laws that I think have discouraged a number
of businesses from operating.
I will say this is a decision that every business has to make on its own, looking at the operational
and legal and reputational risks of operating in Russia.
But I do want to be clear that we have always emphasized that there are certain types of
commercial activity that we are not trying to shut down with respect to Russia.
All of our sanctions have had exemptions for food, for medicine, for other humanitarian
purposes, because we do not see the United States in conflict with the Russian people.
So we have not tried to tell businesses that are working to provide food or pharmaceutical
goods to the Russian people that they should stop doing business there.
We have targeted our sanctions, our export controls on the sectors of the Russian economy
that fuel Russia's war machine, and we'll continue to do that.
QUESTION.
Can I actually pull up one more?
Armenia, Azerbaijan.
Yeah.
One other development is that Azerbaijan says it's arrested the head of the self-styled
in the separatist entity in Nagorno-Karabakh, which, of course, has fallen, Mr. Vardanyan.
Does the U.S. have anything to say about that, either the arrest or about what treatment
you'd expect?
MR.
RATHKE.
We are aware of the arrest.
We're closely monitoring the situation.
I don't have any further comment today.
Said.
QUESTION.
Thank you.
Changing topic to the visa waiver, which – is the – this department and the Secretary
of State, Secretary Blinken, completely convinced that Israel has totally fulfilled all its
obligations to join the visa program?
MR.
RATHKE.
We are convinced that it has met the requirements to join the visa waiver program.
It's a recommendation the Secretary made to the Department of Homeland Security, and
it was ultimately decided by the Secretary of the Department of Homeland Security.
Over the past few months, as we've been trialing this program with the Government
of Israel, we've seen more than 100,000 American citizens enter Israel without a visa.
That includes tens of thousands of Americans on the Palestinian Registry who have traveled
into Israel without a visa.
And that said, we have a – we have ongoing monitoring programs that will be in place
for Israel, as they are with every other member of the visa waiver program.
We'll be closely monitoring their compliance as we go forward.
QUESTION.
Okay.
So you are convinced that Israel is exactly like all the other countries, the 40 other
countries that belong to this program?
MR.
RATHKE.
I didn't – I —
QUESTION.
So you are convinced that Israel is exactly like all the other countries, the 40 other
countries that belong to this program?
MR.
RATHKE.
I said that they have met the requirements of the visa waiver program.
As we have discussed many times from this podium, there are differences, especially
with respect to Gaza.
We have to remember that Gaza is controlled by a foreign terrorist organization.
We would expect there to be different procedures.
There are different procedures for entering the United States if you're coming from
a territory controlled by a foreign terrorist organization.
So we do understand that there are different procedures.
We have looked at the plans and the policies that Israel has put into place and decided
that they meet the visa waiver program, but we will continue to monitor their compliance
going forward.
QUESTION.
So you are not concerned that Israel could use this pretext of this caveat that it has
special security needs and so on to abuse this requirement that you demand of them?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't know what you mean with respect to taking advantage of it, but we will be
watching for compliance with the program very carefully.
QUESTION.
So what record do Americans that are not treated equally upon entry or departure, what record
do they have?
MR.
RATHKE.
They should report that to the United States embassy.
QUESTION.
And in the event that there are repeated incidents, will there be, like, a pullback in that program?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't want to get into any hypotheticals other than to say, as I just said, that we
monitor ongoing compliance with the program and have ability – have the ability to take
steps up to and including – excluding people from the program – countries from the program
going forward if they fail to stay in compliance.
QUESTION.
Last question on this.
A group of American rights groups – Arab American rights groups have filed a suit against
this step.
Do you have any comment on that?
MR.
RATHKE.
I would – I don't.
I would refer you to the Department of Justice for comment on that.
QUESTION.
Can I ask you about the stat you just gave?
You said since when more than 100,000 Americans have entered Israel without a visa?
MR.
RATHKE.
Since we started this trial period, which was July or something like that.
QUESTION.
I'm sorry.
That includes people like me and you?
MR.
RATHKE.
I said over 100,000 —
QUESTION.
Palestinian Americans?
MR.
RATHKE.
No.
Hold on.
Over 100,000 American —
QUESTION.
Matt, that means nothing.
MR.
RATHKE.
You didn't —
QUESTION.
Americans who get into Israel with Palestinian Americans —
MR.
RATHKE.
I think you missed this.
I think you missed the second part of what I said.
Over 100,000 Americans since we began trialing this program have entered Israel without
a visa, and that includes tens of thousands of Americans on the Palestinian registry.
QUESTION.
All right.
But saying tens of thousands, not 100,000, since the trial period began means absolutely
nothing, okay?
MR.
RATHKE.
It —
QUESTION.
No, it means nothing, because you and I could go to Israel without a visa for years.
That's not the issue.
So when you say tens of thousands of Palestinian Americans or tens of thousands of Americans
who are on the Palestinian registry, how many?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't have the exact number.
Tens of thousands.
QUESTION.
But how do you know that there — how do you know it's reciprocal?
MR.
RATHKE.
How do you know that this is reciprocity if you can't give an exact number?
MR.
RATHKE.
I'm giving you tens of thousands.
I don't – I oftentimes walk out here with numbers that are in a range without the exact
number to tell you that it's down to the decimal point.
QUESTION.
How many – well, tell me how many was it before the trial period began?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't have that information.
QUESTION.
Well, then what – the point – there's a meaningless statistic.
MR.
RATHKE.
I think it is important information that certainly the – given that the —
QUESTION.
Hold on.
Okay.
MR.
RATHKE.
I'll just say given that the criticism —
QUESTION.
Okay.
MR.
RATHKE.
— is that there has been no response to or through Israel.
No one is saying that there haven't been.
But the question is the reciprocity issue.
So let me ask you something.
Will Israeli citizens need to get permission from the U.S.
Government to leave the United States?
MR.
RATHKE.
To leave the United States?
I would refer you to the Department of Homeland Security for that level of specificity.
QUESTION.
Okay.
Is it correct that Palestinian Americans who are on the Palestinian registration list who
are in Gaza need to get permission, specific permission, not just checking a box on an
ESTA form or whatever, to leave?
MR.
RATHKE.
They do have to go through a different —
QUESTION.
So how is that —
MR.
RATHKE.
They do —
QUESTION.
How is that reciprocal?
MR.
RATHKE.
I said they have to go through a different circumstance because of the unique nature
of the fact that they live in a place that's controlled by a foreign terrorist organization,
which is something that we fully understand.
So it is different, but we expect —
QUESTION.
Okay.
But that is —
MR.
RATHKE.
But we —
QUESTION.
But you're saying that they shouldn't be in the program for whatever reason except
for the fact that that is not reciprocity right there.
That is —
MR.
RATHKE.
It —
QUESTION.
That is discriminatory, whether it is based on sound national security strategy or not.
It isn't reciprocity.
It doesn't meet the requirements of the law, and that's what this lawsuit that Said
was just talking about is about.
So how – you're just saying that, okay, it's all right that some Palestinian Americans
are going to be discriminated against and —
MR.
RATHKE.
That is not at all what I said.
I said that —
QUESTION.
But that is what it is.
MR.
RATHKE.
I said that Palestinian Americans coming from Gaza have to go through different procedures
because they're coming from a place that's controlled by a foreign terrorist organization.
But —
QUESTION.
But —
MR.
RATHKE.
But —
QUESTION.
But that doesn't mean that they have to leave Gaza, to leave Israel, to get back to
the United States, presumably.
It is not a U.S. requirement that they have to do this.
It is an Israeli requirement, and that means that it is – that the treatment is not reciprocal.
MR.
RATHKE.
We believe that under the procedures that the Government of Israel is —
QUESTION.
Hold on.
You can spin this all you want to, but it's not reciprocal.
MR.
RATHKE.
They will be able to travel.
Americans on the Palestinian registry in Gaza or any American citizens in Gaza will
be able to travel into Israel without a visa.
There are different procedures, but ultimately, they may have to go —
QUESTION.
But that doesn't mean —
MR.
RATHKE.
But ultimately, it's —
QUESTION.
So reciprocity is only getting in?
It doesn't include getting out?
I don't —
MR.
RATHKE.
I'm going to —
QUESTION.
You know, it's really just what – because you don't know.
MR.
RATHKE.
No, I'm not —
QUESTION.
And because it doesn't make any sense.
MR.
RATHKE.
I would disagree with that.
We believe that we have set up a program that allows them – first of all, again,
including Palestinian Americans who have not been able to fly into Ben Gurion before
now, who have not been able to transit in and out of the West Bank.
There are different procedures for Gaza.
We understand that.
We expect it.
We think it's appropriate for there to be so.
But at the end of the day, those American citizens who are in Gaza have the ability
to transit with different procedures but without a visa.
QUESTION.
I don't – I am not arguing, and I don't think anyone else is arguing, that this isn't
a good thing for U.S.-Israeli relations or that Israel should – that Israeli citizens
should have the – the question is whether they meet the legal criteria, okay?
MR.
RATHKE.
And —
QUESTION.
And honestly, what you have just said now does not meet the criteria for reciprocity.
We have made it —
MR.
RATHKE.
It doesn't.
You – no, it doesn't.
MR.
RATHKE.
So I am not a lawyer, but we have looked at it inside the State Department —
QUESTION.
I'm not a lawyer either.
MR.
RATHKE.
— and come to a different – well, then we're really in the – we have come to a
different determination.
I don't know how many —
QUESTION.
There's a two-tier – there's a different system for Palestinian —
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't know how many —
QUESTION.
Who would agree with that?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't know how many times I have to say this, which is that there is a —
QUESTION.
I understand, but —
MR.
RATHKE.
There is – there are different requirements for people that live in Gaza, and I think
for understandable reasons.
QUESTION.
So the Israeli citizen wants to leave the United States and go back to Israel?
MR.
RATHKE.
An Israeli citizen?
QUESTION.
Yeah.
Under the visa, right?
So they can get in without a visa, but they were going — no.
MR.
RATHKE.
Right.
QUESTION.
So, like, if they're in Arizona or something —
MR.
RATHKE.
So I —
QUESTION.
They can – you know, that we think is suspect?
MR.
RATHKE.
So I'm not going to —
QUESTION.
Do they have to apply for an exit visa to get out of the U.S.?
MR.
RATHKE.
Now you are getting beyond my knowledge of immigration law.
We started talking about —
QUESTION.
I understand.
MR.
RATHKE.
When we start talking about Israeli citizens here —
QUESTION.
Because I've read the DHS talking points of the group.
They don't address this question.
And not only do they not address the —
MR.
RATHKE.
Well, Israel is not even meeting right now the criteria for the West Bank, for Palestinians
who are going – Palestinian Americans who are on the registry who are going into the
West Bank.
Now, yes, it has improved, no doubt.
No one's saying it hasn't.
But they're not meeting that requirement either.
So it's not an issue of whether Israel should get into the program based on it being a partner
of the U.S. and a strategic ally in the Middle East.
It's a question of whether they meet the legal criteria under the law.
And they don't.
And what your answers have just said is that they don't meet the criteria and you're
letting them in anyway.
MR.
RATHKE.
That is not at all what I have said.
I have said we have made the determination that they do, and ultimately we have the ability
to monitor this going forward.
All right.
Go ahead.
MR.
RATHKE.
Yeah.
When Secretary met his Indian counterpart, Mr. Jaishankar, in New York for the Quad meeting,
did he raise the issue of Canadian allegations with the Indian?
MR.
RATHKE.
Did he raise the issue of what?
MR.
JAISHANKAR.
Canadian allegations.
MR.
RATHKE.
No, not in that meeting.
It was a – that was not a bilateral meeting.
It was a meeting of a number of countries, and it did not come up in that meeting.
But we have engaged with our Indian counterparts on this issue and urged them to fully cooperate
with the Canadian investigation.
MR.
JAISHANKAR.
And the minister is going to be here in the city this week.
The Secretary has plans to meet him and raise this issue again.
MR.
RATHKE.
Tomorrow?
Yeah.
And what?
MR.
JAISHANKAR.
Will he be raising this issue with Mr. Jaishankar?
MR.
RATHKE.
I don't want to preview the comment – the conversations he will have in that meeting,
but as we've made clear, we've raised this – we have engaged with our Indian counterparts
on this and encouraged them to cooperate with the Canadian investigation, and we continue
to encourage them to cooperate.
MR.
JAISHANKAR.
So the engagement you had with the Indians, do you see sense of cooperation from them?
MR.
RATHKE.
I'm not going to read – I'm not going to speak to our private diplomatic conversations.
MR.
JAISHANKAR.
Go ahead.
QUESTION.
Thank you.
Sehun Kim, Global Stratview.
Last week, the visit of President Raisi's – President Raisi's visit to the United
Nations actually carried on a lot of conversation in the public sphere.
However, there were incidences where journalists from Iran International were harassed and
attacked on the streets by Iranian diplomats, namely the – Iran International's journalist
Kian Amani was directly attacked and harassed by the protocol officer of Raisi, Reza Nagipour.
I'm just wondering what your comment on that is, and for – also would like to see
your comment regarding the constant harassment and the targeting of Iranian dissidents located
in the United States who are U.S. citizens, green card holders, and a lot of times asylees.
MR.
So with respect to the first question, we actually put out a statement on this last
week during the UN General Assembly in which we made very clear that we condemn the harassment
and intimidation of journalists.
And with respect to the harassment and intimidation of Iranian citizens living in the United States,
of course, we condemn that as well.
We condemn transnational repression wherever it happens in the world.
Go ahead.
QUESTION.
Thank you.
Today, Serbia is holding Day of Mourning after violent clashes in Kosovo on Sunday.
The State Department so far didn't send a message of condolences to the Serbian victims.
And while Secretary Blinken expressed condolences for the loss of Kosovo police officer, there
has been a noticeable absence of any mention of the Serbian victims in his statement.
What kind of message does this convey to the Serbs in Kosovo?
MR.
I think we have pretty consistently expressed our condolences to the victims of violence
in – both in this situation and around the world.
And one of the messages we have had for both sides in this conflict is that they should
refrain from violence and return to the EU-facilitated dialogue.
That continues to be our message.
QUESTION.
Thank you so much.
Jahanzaib Abu from ARY News.
Congresswoman Ilhan Omar, in her statement, expressed concerns on the allegations of the
involvement of the Indian Government in Canadian citizens' killing.
She also said that she has requested a briefing on whether there are similar operations in
the United States.
Does she have any briefing schedule or is she contacted with the State Department?
MR.
Not that I'm aware of.
QUESTION.
So secondly, how United States see this Khalistan campaign as all these operations managed by
U.S.-based group 6 for justice?
MR.
I missed the first part of the question.
Can you just repeat?
QUESTION.
So how you – how United States see this Khalistan campaign?
Because all their operations are managed by a U.S.-based advocacy group 6 for justice.
MR.
I just don't have any comment on that.
Sorry.
QUESTION.
So how do you expect United States to ban Khalistan operations in the United States?
MR.
I'm not going to read out any private diplomatic conversations.
Go ahead.
QUESTION.
Thank you.
Late yesterday, in a wedding party in Nineveh province, Hamdania district in Iraq, where
more than 100 people killed and many more injured.
MR.
Yeah.
QUESTION.
So some of the victims are treated in local hospitals and some are in Kurdistan regional
hospitals.
But will you provide any medical assistance?
And if needed, will you welcome them in – here in the United States?
MR.
So first of all, we mourn the loss of life in the horrific fire that took place at a
wedding in Jamdania in northern Iraq that killed more than at least 100 people, and
to our understanding, critically injured 150 others.
We express, of course, our deepest condolences to the families who lost loved ones, and we
hope for a speedy recovery for those wounded.
With respect to the second part of your question, we do stand ready to support the Government
of Iraq and its people at this tragic time.
We have always stood by – we will always stand side by side with the people of Iraq
and be ready to talk with the Iraqi Government about what – any assistance that we can
provide.
And with respect to the last question, I think it's too early to get into what might occur.
Go ahead.
QUESTION.
Thank you, sir.
If you please comment on the Moscow format meeting on Afghanistan scheduled for September
29th, which is tomorrow, there is no representative of the U.S. invited.
How do you see that?
And second, a high-level delegation of the Taliban, led by acting Foreign Affairs Minister
Amir Khan Muttaki, has traveled to Russia to participate in the two-days meeting.
Does the travel ban on Taliban leaders still exist?
Aren't they in the blacklist?
MR.
HARDINGER.
So I don't have much to say about that other than that we're aware of the Moscow format
meeting taking place.
We are not members of the Moscow format, so a U.S. representative will not be attending.
Go ahead.
QUESTION.
The Mexican media is reporting that Secretary Blinken will be hosting a high-level delegation
of Mexican officials on Friday.
Given the current situation at the U.S.-Mexico border, will this be the topic of discussion
on Friday?
MR.
HARDINGER.
So I don't want to get into two days before the meeting what exactly we will talk about,
but certainly migration issues are often issues that we talk about with our Mexican counterparts
when we meet with them both here and in Mexico.
QUESTION.
When will you be taking part from the U.S. side on this meeting on Friday?
MR.
HARDINGER.
Stay tuned.
We'll make announcements of that in the coming days.
QUESTION.
But you confirmed the meeting is happening?
MR.
HARDINGER.
I'm going to make – we'll make announcements about that in the very near future.
QUESTION.
Thank you.
MR.
HARDINGER.
All right.
I'll do a few more.
QUESTION.
Hi, Matt.
Could you talk a little about what may happen if Congress fails to pass the appropriation
bills in regards to the compact of free associations for Micronesia, Palau, and the Marshall Islands?
MR.
HARDINGER.
We are still working through the exact implications.
As you can imagine, there are – we have to look at everything that the State Department
does and determine what kind of work can continue in a government shutdown, what kind of work
would have to be put on hold.
We are concerned about the fact that Congress might not do its job and pass appropriations
bills to keep the government open, and so we are doing the kind of planning that we
have to do to respond to that situation if it occurs.
But I'm not at this point ready to talk about what any specific implications might
be.
QUESTION.
Yeah.
After Cambodia's election in July, the U.S. cut off —
MR.
HARDINGER.
Whose election?
QUESTION.
Cambodia.
MR.
HARDINGER.
Oh, yeah.
QUESTION.
The U.S. cut off $18 million in aid in apparent protest, I guess, against the legitimacy of
the election.
On Friday, Huynh Myint, the prime minister of Cambodia, met with the acting deputy secretary
of Victoria and New Orleans, and the Cambodian Government says that that aid has been restored.
Can you confirm that?
And if so, why was that aid restored?
MR.
HARDINGER.
I'll get that one back, get you an answer.
All right.
We'll do last one.
Janne.
QUESTION.
Thank you.
On Russia, Russian Air Force plane arrived in Pyongyang this week, and North Korea and
Russia are taking steps to realize military cooperation.
Any comment on that?
Are you concerned about this?
MR.
HARDINGER.
Sure.
We have spoken to this a number of times and warned that arms discussions between Russia
and the DPRK almost certainly continued during Kim Jong-un's trip to Russia, and we believe
that they continue in the aftermath of that trip.
We think a burgeoning military relationship between Russia and the DPRK, including additional
transfers of weapons from the DPRK to Russia and technology transfers from the DPRK – from
Russia to the DPRK, will further undermine the global nonproliferation regime, would
be in violation of United Nations Security Council resolutions that Russia itself voted
for.
So we would urge the DPRK to abide by what it has said publicly and refrain from supplying
arms to Russia.
And with that, we'll wrap for today.
Thank you.
QUESTION.
Thank you.