Brandon Staley Being Criticized For "Worst 4th Down Decision Of All Time" Going For It On Own 25

The Pat McAfee Show
1 follower
Sep 26, 2023
Talk about fourth down decisions.
There was two of them yesterday that are certainly in discussion.
Let's talk about the Raiders, okay?
The Raiders make a decision to kick a field goal on fourth and three from the 12 down
eight with over two minutes left and the entire three timeouts left.
So four timeouts with the two minute warning taking place.
If they're able to get a stop on the Steelers who pick up a massive third and two with a
great play call from Matt Canada to do that, they're able to get the ball back.
But since they don't get the ball back, the question is, Josh McDaniels, you're down eight,
you're at the 12, it's fourth and three.
Why are we kicking a field goal there?
What were your thoughts on it, AJ?
Because he was going to do it like a minute before that, and then a penalty extended the
drive.
And then at two minutes and 30, he decided to do it again.
What were your thoughts on it?
And how do you think you would have played it?
Well, so he had an explanation after the game, didn't he, where he tried to say why he did
this?
He said, we're going to have to score twice anyways to win or something like that.
Yep.
Yeah.
And I was like, okay, I just don't know.
I honestly, I don't really understand why he did it.
Yeah, me neither.
I think two minutes and something with three timeouts.
Yeah.
Understand that's forever if you're tied.
Like if you're tied or only need a field goal or something like that, that conversation
is different.
On the 12th, going in, because even if you don't make it, you've got a full field still.
Exactly.
So you still have the three timeouts and the two minute warning.
I mean, we're Monday afternoon quarterbacking right now, which is easy to do.
If they end up getting that ball back and go down and score, we say, what a genius.
They go back and win this.
And then on the other one, everybody's talking about is Brandon Staley.
Just, you know what I mean?
Can't help it.
You know, they say like, if it walks like a duck, talks like a duck, good chance it's
a duck.
Right.
And when somebody shows you who they are, believe them.
And all this different stuff, Brandon Staley is always going to be Brandon Staley.
That decision they made in the fourth quarter to go for it on their own 25, whenever they're
up one score in a game that was obviously is absolutely bananas.
They end up getting a win though.
So he's able to kind of peacock around and say, hey, we do what I wanted to do.
I wanted to show faith in our offense.
I thought we could have picked it up.
We can pick it up.
That game is over.
Also, I appreciate where our defense is.
We're protecting four points, not three points.
Brandon Staley making these decisions is something that obviously took over the world a couple
of years back because the stats community came out and was like, he's doing the right place.
He's doing the right decisions.
You know, 62.475% of the time, whenever he goes forward on his own end, up one score
in the fourth quarter late, he picks it up and they win that game.
I'm like, well, what about the other 38%?
You know, that 38% where you get your ass fired.
That 38% wherever careers are ruined.
Like stats don't account for the human element of it.
If it's not 100% to 0%, it's hard for me to believe because even if it's 99 to one,
that 1% can lose your ass a game, a job, and a livelihood for the rest of your entire time.
I appreciate Brandon Staley's big old gut sack.
Okay.
That guy's got a lot of guts.
That guy's got a lot of courage.
He likes to prove to his team how much he believes in them.
But damn, at some point, don't you got to look in the mirror and say, look at this sometimes.
We don't have to do this all the time.
And it feels like Brandon Staley doesn't have that governor at all.
Also, if you are going to go for it, your quarterback that you just paid a ton of money is 40 of 47 for over 400 yards.
And you give it up the middle when Eckler's not even, he's not even in the game.
He's hurt.
He's out of the game.
He didn't play at all.
That like the play decision on top of going for it was even more of a mind blow for me.
But then they win.
Yeah, they did.
So we just go on to the next step.
Whatever.
Don't you have to do it all the time though, Pat?
If you're going to use like there's analytics and go for it and be ballsy and all this stuff.
It's kind of like the whole blackjack book to where, hey, if you're going to, if you're going to sit on 17 or like you just have to follow the rules where you got to do it all the time to maximize, you know, the numbers that they put out there.
So isn't he always going to do this?
Well, you got to sit on 17, depending upon what the dealer's showing.
If you're sitting at a table with somebody, I mean, there's a full, I don't want to get into a blackjack conversation right now.
But that's what I'm saying though.
Like they'll say, oh, by the book though.
Yeah.
16.
You're not hitting it.
15 maybe.
No, your hand doesn't even qualify if you're at 16.
So like I get it.
You're trying to save your ass.
Okay.
But also you're about, I get so mad, but there was a nice balance between the book and being a human.
And I think we all thought that Brandon Staley would have developed that by now.
I think we all appreciate how aggressive he is.
I think we all appreciate how much he says to his team.
I believe we can get it.
I think the boys rally around that, but also you're putting some people in some bad situations and going to lose games that you shouldn't lose because of these types of things.
Just a little bit more feel I think is all we're asking for.
Yeah.
But Staley won the game.
Who are we talking?
Yeah, with that field position, I kind of understand because every time the Chargers defense have been in a position to close out, they haven't.
And I'm kind of with Tone though.
If you're going to go for it, put it in Herbert's hand.
You know what I mean?
Throw the ball, sprint out, do something.
Don't run it right up the middle.
But to make that call, even with the win, you can look at that and be like, hey, that was a stupid call based on field position.
He did not say that.
But if you're going to go, at least throw it and put it in Herbert's hand.
What did he say?
No, he didn't say it.
Literally everything I just said is pretty much what he said.
I want my guys to know that I believe in them.
Our defense is doing this and I'll do it that every single time.
And I think there's people on the Internet that are stating that his decision was the right one, which has been the new thing with these analytic discussions.
Yeah, the model that they have said to go for and so did everyone else's model.
But why are we acting like there isn't a fourth down play that has 100% success rate that the Eagles do every other week?
Why doesn't every team just do that?
I still don't understand.
Like I get Jalen Hurts is more of a mobile quarterback.
Herbert's a big boy.
Herbert is 6'4", 230.
Can we not just put a fullback and a couple tight ends behind him and they just push him forward?
Why isn't every team just doing that?
You talking about the tush push?
The tush push, yes.
