An investigation into the greatest man-made structures of all time, exploring how new materials and construction techniques have allowed engineers, builders, and architects to work to the limits of their ability. The series focuses on the buildings that re-wrote the rulebook and the architects, engineers, and builders who made the impossible possible.
First Aired: November 26, 2000. Content Provided By TVF International. Any Queries Please Contact [email protected]
Subscribe to Spark for more amazing science, tech and engineering videos - https://goo.gl/LIrlur
Hello, I'm Dr. Scott Steedman and this is a series about my heroes, fellow engineers
and the greatest structures they built on earth. The tallest, the biggest and the most
expensive buildings ever built. The kind of structures that beg the question, how did
they build that?
In our first program we travel to Paris to take a look at the Eiffel Tower and then visit
the Grand Serre, one of the finest examples of late 20th century structural engineering.
But our story begins at the spectacular Garibaud Viaduct in the heart of France.
The development and mass production of iron and steel in the 19th century radically transformed
the nature of engineering. These newly plentiful materials offered pioneers undreamt of opportunities
to bridge any expanse and scale unbelievable heights.
Alexander Gustav Bonikasen Eiffel was one such pioneer. Born in Dijon in 1832, he trained
as a chemist, but a curious twist of fate drew him to the burgeoning railway industry.
It was in building bridges and viaducts that he made his name, and that reputation won
him a commission to bridge the gorge at Garibaud.
The Garibaud Viaduct, here in the Massif Central in the heart of France, was the finest
of Eiffel's bridge designs. A spectacular bridge built with mathematical precision,
this viaduct illustrates the best of the new, bold civil engineering which emerged in the
19th century.
The viaduct at Garibaud was to be the highest iron arch bridge in the world. This design
was an ideal way to span the steep gorge. A 563 metre long railway deck sits on an
enormous arch which straddles the Trier River below. Eiffel used wrought iron because no
other material had the strength and reliability to make the viaduct possible and allow the
relentless progress of the railways to continue.
The giant arch is pinned onto huge concrete abutments that are built onto the sides of
the valley. The weight of the bridge passes down the arch into the abutments. The deck
stands 122 metres high above the bottom of the gorge.
Engineers at that time did not have access to the complex computational methods of today
and they had to design a structure which they knew they could analyse. They had a shrewd
idea of the direction of forces and the strength or resistance of materials and their structures
reflect that fact closely.
Eiffel opted for iron trusses for the huge arch supporting piers and railway deck. A
simple element, the iron truss is easy to analyse and can be used in almost any situation.
The whole truss has to be stiff enough and strong enough to carry its own weight and
the weight of a train. The whole truss works like a beam trying to bend. So the top is
in compression, it's being squashed and the bottom is in tension, it's being stretched.
The criss-cross members in between work in either tension or compression and one of their
key functions is to keep the top and bottom in position. The stiffness of the whole bridge
comes largely from the distance apart of the top and bottom, the depth of the truss.
The bridge is made up of giant trusses, but within the giant trusses there are also smaller
trusses. It works on just the same principle. The top and bottom pieces which carry the
bending forces are held apart by this cross bracing in between.
All the pieces for Garabit were prefabricated, brought to the site and then riveted together.
It's like a giant Meccano set. Riveting was a skilled job. It must have been quite hairy
doing it out here at this height. Riveting is a good process though and the rust that
can develop around rivets can help actually fuse it all together. It's a nice system for
bonding metal. Let's go on.
Eiffel was very concerned about wind forces and he carried out experiments to determine
the wind resistance of different sorts of truss. Here on the great arch and up there
on the piers you can see that they flare out which gives the bridge the lateral stiffness
that it needs to resist the fierce winds that funnel down the gorge. Eiffel's method of
construction of the arch was ingenious requiring no scaffolding underneath. Instead he built
each side up from the concrete abutments as two cantilevers suspended on steel cables
from the piers on either side. The whole operation was extremely precise and when they finally
met in the middle only a very small adjustment was needed. Finally they put the deck over
the top. You can feel the whole bridge vibrating under the weight of the train. Quite a funny
feeling really. Yeah it's passed over now. Wow that was quite exciting. Staircase is
wobbling but you can feel these main girders vibrating quite strongly. Eiffel calculated
that under the weight of a train the centre of the arch here would deflect just 8 millimetres
about that much and he was proved exactly right. In a traditional arch bridge the weight
on top is carried down to the arch through the spandrels, the solid part between the
deck and the arch which you can see in the masonry bridges on either side. Here solid
spandrels would have been so huge that Eiffel's engineers concluded the forces would be incalculable.
So they opted for no spandrels at all and instead used this great depth of truss bent
into the shape of an arch to give the bridge the stiffness it needed to carry the trains.
The most dangerous moment in any construction project in terms of the project as a whole
is often just before the construction is complete. Eiffel must have been very relieved when the
two halves of the great arches were finally riveted together and he'd accomplished his
dream the biggest iron arch bridge in the world. With the completion of the bridge at
Garibet Eiffel's reputation as one of the greatest civil engineers of his time was complete.
It's a working bridge of course, functional like all of Eiffel's structures had been up
to that time. Such a simple form of construction. Eiffel must have wondered how far he could
go with it. Paris at the end of the 19th century was the second largest city in the world,
a city of wealth, a city of empire. There was a mood to celebrate the centenary of the
revolution of 1789 and France's new global status. A universal exposition of industry
and commerce, a grand exhibition was launched and it needed a centrepiece. The invention
of the lift and new skyscrapers in America must have inspired Eiffel. He jumped at the
chance to build a huge and lasting monument, the Eiffel Tower. Of course the images that
we have of the Eiffel Tower are usually from a distance and it's not until you get underneath
it like this that you really realise how huge it is and the feeling of space under these
great symmetrical legs is very impressive, very impressive indeed. Eiffel used 250 men
to build the tower and his engineers produced over 5,300 drawings of all the component parts.
As at Garabit, everything was pre-fabricated and all the holes were pre-drilled. Parts
were then brought to the site where they were lifted into position by cranes and riveted
together. It must be very exciting going up in the lift. They were just recently invented.
Quite exciting today really. To a Parisian in 1889, the highest thing you'd ever have
been in would be a seven-storey apartment block like the ones down here. This is a waxwork
of Eiffel in his office at the top of the tower. He was very interested in scientific
experiments and one of his justifications for the tower was the study of the lower atmosphere.
Although Eiffel is obviously closely associated with the tower, in fact it was originally
conceived by two of his engineers, Monsieur Koechlin and Monsieur Nugget, who'd sketched
out a scheme for a super tower as early as 1884. Of course they were all railway engineers
really so they used the techniques they knew best and what this reminds me most of is a
gigantic railway pier and we're right inside it. Eiffel's tower was to be the tallest structure
in the world. Only iron or steel would be strong enough and rigid enough to support
itself to these heights. Steel was a relatively new material so Eiffel opted for what he knew
best, puddled wrought iron. Eiffel had an excellent and reliable source of top quality
iron in the foundries of Lorraine. Good quality iron was important because his whole reputation
depended on the success of the project. Eiffel had made a deal with the city. He would put
out five of the six and a half million francs it would take to construct the tower. In return
he would keep revenues from visitors during the exposition and for 20 years thereafter.
It was a massive financial gamble and the biggest risk of his career. So in order to
ensure a profit from the venture, Eiffel had to keep his overheads down. And one way Eiffel
could keep costs to a minimum is to standardise as many of the components as possible. Looking
up to the third level you can see many of the lattice girders are identical. Under each
of the main floor levels are huge girders which span across the tower, tying the legs
together. That's what makes the distinctive gaps in the lower levels of the Eiffel Tower
possible. Looking up here from the first level towards the second level, you can see the
four legs very clearly. The weight of iron in the structure is 7,300 tonnes and with
the lifts and the other equipment, the weight of the tower in total is over 10,000 tonnes.
Finally back at ground level, behind me is the base of one of the legs, disguised with
stone. If we go over to the north pier we can get a closer look at the foundations.
Inside the stone base of the legs, each of the 16 ribs sits in an iron shoe resting on
a concrete foundation. The shoe carries a weight of over 600 tonnes here and the thickness
of the iron is 100 to 150 millimetres, about the same as this thickness here. During construction
each of the ribs was secured to the foundation using these bolts to stop them bending over
as they were built up. Hydraulic jacks inside the shoe were able to align the structure
perfectly.
I don't usually go for this kind of thing but there's something else I want to show you.
The tower has come to symbolise Paris but it's the curved shape of the legs which is
so well known. The obvious shape for a giant railway pier would be straight like this or
inclined but to resist the wind loading these shapes would have to be braced to ground level.
The wind acts on the side of the tower trying to bend it over just as if the tower was fixed
to a wall and its weight was trying to bend it down. The curved shape of the legs acts
like half an arch carrying the force directly down to the foundation so there's no need
for bracing. Eiffel's entrepreneurial skills made him a very rich man but more importantly
he made a major contribution to the image of modern France for which he is duly recognised.
His tower was the last great wrought iron structure which at the time represented the
cutting edge of engineering, an ultra-modern building in a classical city. Since then Paris
has built on its reputation as home to some of the most spectacular modern structures
although iron is no longer the material of choice. On the other side of Paris in the
northeast corner of the city is a structure that represents the very best in modern engineering.
Almost a hundred years after the Eiffel Tower was built President Giscard d'Estaing decided
to establish a new museum, the City of Science and Industry, to enable the French people
to discover the industrial adventure of today and to celebrate the very best in modern science
and technology. The museum was completed in March 1986.
This is a wonderful museum, a mixture of exhibits and exhibitionism. These great trusses on
either side could have been plucked straight from the Eiffel Tower but they look huge even
for this building. But that's not why we're here, we're here to see the work of one of
the greatest structural engineers of the 20th century, Peter Rice.
The late Irish engineer Peter Rice was one of the most brilliant of his generation. He
was instrumental in the realisation of projects as varied as the Louvre Pyramid and the Sydney
Opera House. Rice was invited by the architect, Adrien Fensilbert, to design Les Grands Sers,
three massive glasshouses intended to unite the museum with the park outside. The spacious
units represent the pinnacle of refinement in steelwork. They are light to the point
of seeming to lack substance, making even the airy structures of the Eiffel Tower and
Garibet Viaduct appear bulky. The contrast between the heavy industrial trusses inside
and these beautiful refined glass ser is total. From the engineering perspective, this is
what makes the building so remarkable. The structure of the glasshouses is light years
ahead of the Eiffel Tower but still beautifully simple. Glass is in fact a very strong material
in its pure form but in practice it's rather weak and extremely brittle and breaks in an
explosive way when any scratch or defect, however microscopic, causes a stress concentration.
Steel can take huge loads in tension and compression and it has the property of ductility.
It will stretch before it breaks. This gives protection against overloading, a sort of
warning if you like, that the material is about to break. The challenge is to bring
these two very different materials together. Each of the three ser has 24 steel frames
which hold 16 glass panels, each one two metres wide by two metres high. The 16 panels in
each frame weigh two tonnes. Carrying that vertical weight and coping with the wind load
from outside is what this lightweight steel frame and connections are all about. In simple
terms, the glass plates have to carry their own weight and the force from the wind outside.
The glass plates hang one on another and their weight is carried right up to the top. There's
a spring up there which locates the top panel. The wind force is taken completely separately
through this stainless steel cable truss. The two systems are totally independent and
they only come together in the tubular steel frame around the outside. The connection is
really very clever. Inside each of these five points is a ball and socket joint. Inside
the glass here and inside this metal unit. Like a hip joint, a ball and socket joint
enables the glass sheets to move independently so the whole system is articulated. This is
the tubular steel frame that surrounds the glass walls. You can see where the glass meets
the building itself. There's a flexible seal and the joint here is free to rotate so the
whole wall can move inwards with the wind. Rice had a great admiration for the 19th century
engineers like Eiffel. He talked of their structures as having a simple honesty that
goes straight to the heart of the physical characteristics of the material. But his own
work is more Swiss watch than railway pier. The meticulous attention to detail and sophisticated
calculation in this design allowed Rice to refine every element. Like a racing yacht,
each component has a precisely defined function. There's no excess baggage. There's some irony
then that in a museum celebrating science and engineering, Rice's brilliant and innovative
design isn't acknowledged or explained anywhere. Rice also believed that the role of the engineer
to building structures that people warmed to and that conveyed a feeling of having been
designed by one who cared. Rice's genius for structural engineering is clear. He had a
mission to enrich people's experience of the structures around them, which is where he
differed from Eiffel. However, both Rice and Eiffel were like artists, masters of their
materials and the knowledge available to them. But new materials and techniques are evolving
all the time. Who knows what brilliant structures people will be enjoying a hundred years from now.
Next week, we look at the nature of defence. We start at a dramatic medieval Scottish castle,
travel to France to see a spectacular fortress and finish at the massive
barrier that protects the people of Holland from the sea.