The White House sent out a memo calling on news outlets to “do more to scrutinize House Republicans.” It included 14 pages of talking points for them to use when defending President Joe Biden in the newly launched impeachment inquiry.
Its cover email reads like a call to arms for state-controlled news outlets. It says, “It’s time for the media to ramp up its scrutiny of House Republicans for opening an impeachment inquiry based on lies.” Since when does the White House declare that it’s time for supposedly independent news outlets to attack its political enemies? It also calls on the media to break from the normal news cycles while launching these attacks. It says they shouldn’t cover the impeachment as just a “process story,” where, as it states, coverage may include “Republicans say X, but the White House says Y.” No, instead of covering the news and showing both sides, the memo calls for more active attacks against House Republican leaders.
- Epoch Original Documentary DVDs: 🔵 Check out 'The Real Story of January 6' documentary DVD here: https://ept.ms/3cxGVEO 🔵 'The Shadow State' documentary takes a deep dive into the environmental, social, and governance (ESG) industry. ORDER DVD: https://ept.ms/3XxcWir 🔵 'The Final War' Documentary DVD: https://bit.ly/41PTIWC
Good evening and welcome to Crossroads.
The White House sent out a memo calling on news outlets to quote, do more to scrutinize
House Republicans.
It included 14 pages of talking points for these outlets to use when defending President
Joe Biden in the newly launched impeachment inquiry from House Republicans.
Now it's cover email reads like a call to arms for state controlled news outlets.
It says it's time for the media to ramp up its scrutiny of House Republicans for opening
an impeachment inquiry based on lies.
Now since when does the White House declare that it's time for supposedly, you know, independent
news outlets to attack its political enemies for it?
It also calls on the media to break from the normal news cycle while launching these attacks.
It says they should not cover the impeachment as just a process story where it states coverage
may include Republicans say X, but the White House says Y.
Nope.
Instead of covering the news and showing both sides as you normally would, the memo calls
for active attacks against House Republican leaders.
It alleges that Republicans are launching the impeachment inquiry on shoddy ground.
And it alleges that even Republicans don't seem to believe there's enough evidence to
impeach Biden.
And it provides a detailed roadmap of instructions on, you know, for news outlets on how to challenge
the validity of the impeachment inquiry.
Now of course, it's not uncommon for government agencies or even big companies to issue fact
sheets when they're facing accusations.
You know, typically the way this normally happens, they'll release statements to the
press.
It will often detail their rebuttals as a way of clearing the air.
Journalists often show both sides of the argument, even if one side is wrong.
It's the nature of reporting.
It's the he said, she said.
And when it comes to fact checks, well, journalists will often include analysis and interviews
to show which side is telling the truth and which one is not.
But this White House memo went too far.
Rather than give counter arguments, it appears to be instructing news outlets to violate
basic standards of journalism.
It's not calling on journalists to just report the facts and then provide them with facts
for their fact checks and so on.
It's directly telling them to not take the usual, you know, Republicans say X, but the
White House says Y approach.
Instead, it's framed as a so-called call to arms.
It instructs news outlets to go on the offensive against House Republicans on behalf of the
White House.
In fact, the memo went too far, even for the establishment news outlets.
It was CNN of all places that actually leaked the email and memo.
It was made public by CNN media reporter Oliver Darcy.
And the backlash on the Biden administration has been palpable.
Journalist Matthew Keyes was widely cited in this criticisms.
He wrote on X that this is not OK.
The White House should not be encouraging, influencing or interfering in the editorial
strategies of America's newsrooms, including CNN and The New York Times.
Now, the White House, meanwhile, appears to be standing by its approach to avoid the debate
on evidence, the he said, she said, and to instead attack the Republican leadership.
In fact, here's White House Press Secretary Kareem Jean-Pierre today.
You know, that's why we call it baseless.
That's why I just called it baseless, because they have said themselves that there is no
evidence.
There does not.
The evidence does not exist.
And this is a political stunt.
They could not even support their own votes.
They couldn't.
Speaker McCarthy could not even get support for this vote.
And so I'm going to just leave it there.
Now, she's also accusing Republicans of distracting the government from things that really matter.
Watch.
And they are distracting from top priorities that we have, like fighting the fentanyl crisis,
delivering disaster relief, and helping Ukraine fight Russia's illegal war.
House Republicans should keep their word and do their job.
Several establishment news outlets appear to have gotten the memo, let's say.
Many of them barely covered the launch of the impeachment inquiry into President Biden.
New York Times, for example, they had one impeachment story on their front page today.
Now, contrast that with how they reacted when Democrats announced their impeachment inquiry
into Trump back in September of 2019.
This was the New York Times front page when then House Speaker Nancy Pelosi announced the
impeachment inquiry into then President Donald Trump.
The New York Times dedicated a lot of space on that front page to that topic.
In fact, you can see the lead story there with the headline, Pelosi will open formal
impeachment inquiry accusing President of betrayal of the nation.
But today?
Well, a comparatively little sliver of space on the side of the paper, you can easily miss
it.
But back to that memo.
There's something else that's important.
The CNN piece says that the White House memo was sent not to reporters, but to the executives
of various establishment news outlets.
In fact, among these were CNN, the New York Times, Fox News, the Associated Press, CBS
News, and others.
It cites an unnamed White House official on that claim.
But that raises another serious issue with journalistic integrity.
Look, normally press statements and fact sheets, they're sent to individual reporters.
Normally they're posted online out in the open where the public can see them.
And at the very most, they're going to be sent to editors or producers who can then
provide the materials to the journalists.
They're not normally sent to the top executives of news outlets who are not involved in the
actual process of researching or covering the news.
This gives the appearance it's a directive from the White House to the news outlets themselves,
and not just a set of arguments for the individual journalists that they can consider when they're
covering the news.
It ties into one of the big criticisms often lobbed at the big corporate media.
It's the suspicion that their news coverage is not independent, that the power is not
in the hands of the journalists, and that instead, their coverage tends to have the
ever-present hand of top executives, restricting what journalists can say and what they cannot
say.
Now, if the White House is in fact informing these talking points coming from the top,
that's a big deal.
But as for the fact checks, the memo lays out a lot of claims that are, let's just say,
debatable.
It's half-truths, and it's a whole lot of nuance.
It notes a handful of Republicans did not seem to agree before that they would have
enough evidence to impeach Biden.
That's true.
They agreed they did not have enough evidence on it to actually impeach him.
But the play on words here is Republicans are not impeaching Biden.
They're launching an impeachment inquiry.
That means they're investigating, and based on the evidence they have, they believe there's
enough to launch that investigation.
Depending on what they find through those investigations, then they will decide on whether
they move to impeachment.
And the memo also questions the basic grounds for the impeachment inquiry.
The defense has gone from the White House outright denying the claims relating to Joe
Biden and Hunter Biden to claiming that there is no evidence, and now they're claiming there's
no direct evidence.
The language here is important.
Now, it's not clear how they differentiate between evidence and direct evidence.
House Republicans have gotten documents, whistleblower testimony, emails, text messages,
and many other forms of evidence.
And apparently even testimony from Hunter Biden's former business partner is not being
regarded as, quote unquote, direct evidence.
Presumably based on this, we can assume direct evidence would only include maybe testimony
from someone directly involved in the alleged actions, like maybe Hunter Biden or Joe Biden
themselves.
But that's the problem with this type of manipulative language.
They have the evidence, but they don't have direct evidence.
See how that works?
It's the same way they're trying to confuse between an impeachment and an impeachment
inquiry.
It's those small nuances that you argue are factually accurate, but that use subtle techniques,
the subtle manipulation of language, to confuse the public.