America's WORST Airlines? (Allegiant vs Frontier vs Spirit)

Autoworld
12 followers
5 Video Views·Sep 7, 2023
Get ready for seats that squeeze, no space for your knees, and endless fees.
Allegiant, Frontier, Spirit, which is the best and worst ultra low-cost airline in the United States?
Let's find out as we try all three back-to-back.
Hello jet setters, I'm Jeb Brooks from greenergrass.com. We're about to fly
three of the largest low-cost carriers in the United States back-to-back over the next three
days. Join us as we try out Allegiant, Frontier, Spirit. This is the low-cost carrier comparison.
Here's the plan. On day one, we'll start with Allegiant and Punta Gorda, Florida near Fort
Myers. We'll fly north to Cincinnati. On the second day, we'll make our way to Denver with
Frontier, and we'll wrap up the adventure on day three with a flight on Spirit to Las Vegas. When
it's all done, we'll rate everything and compare these three airlines to help you decide which one's
right for you. Our first flight is with Allegiant. We're flying from Fort Myers up to Cincinnati.
Now, Allegiant tends to use smaller airports outside major metropolitan areas, so we're
actually flying out of Punta Gorda, which is about 30 minutes north of town.
Each of these airlines approaches pricing in a similar way. Sell a dirt-cheap basic ticket,
and then allow passengers to pay extra for however they'd like to tailor their experience.
And we booked basically the same thing each time. We paid to pre-select a seat near the very back,
ensured we could carry on an extra bag, and also paid to board early. That was to facilitate
filming. On Allegiant, that brought our total cost to $291 for two of us. Thankfully, all three of
these airlines participate in the TSA pre-check program, and as members, we were through security
in no time. It's my first time flying Allegiant. See how it goes. Allegiant is the only airline
serving Punta Gorda, and their passengers certainly filled the terminal. Part of Allegiant's
business model is to operate out of some of these smaller airports where fees tend to be lower,
and in theory, they pass that along to you. For example, there's no jet bridges here,
so they get a pay less when they use gates here. The junction behind security offers sundries,
everything you could possibly want, including sandwiches. So Suzanne grabbed a cheeseburger,
I'm having a turkey panini, and you know, so that's your food option. There's also a bar
back here that has really good views of the ramp, but we're just hungry at this point.
You're gonna get the most bang for your buck on a low-cost airline. If you can pack in a personal
size item, they can go under the seat. That's free. However, we're carrying carry-on size bags
on this trip. This trip is kind of a week for us, so we couldn't fit everything into a smaller bag,
so we're paying up for the carry-on bag. It just occurred to me I better check my bag, so...
Easy, it's a perfect fit. Well, you know, the only delay on the board is our flight to
Cincinnati, but these things happen. That's why we built padding into the schedule,
so we're only taking one of these flights a day each day for the next three. And that's really
one of the key pieces of advice we can offer when it comes to booking any travel, but especially
with low-cost carriers. Give yourself plenty of padding between your flights and whatever you're
flying to. You see, most low-cost carriers have smaller fleets than the major airlines, which
means they can't just magically find another airplane if something goes wrong. Add to that
the fact that most of their routes are served once a day, if not less. Well, that's a recipe
for trouble in the event of delays or cancellation. In our case, it took two and a half hours between
when the delay was posted on the board and when a gate agent finally made an announcement about
the delay. We just got our first announcement. The airplane's about an hour out of Punta Gorda,
and they've put out some drinks for everybody on board to take advantage of. It's a full flight,
so hopefully that is an incentive for Allegiant to get it out of here, because we've got to make
our way out to Denver tomorrow. There it is. I see it. Airplane's here. Ready to go outside.
The hard-working ramp workers fought the Florida heat, pushing the ramp up to the plane. 150 or so
passengers streamed off, making room for us to join the return flight up to Cincinnati.
And boy, was it hot out here. Another shout out to the ramp workers. Again, we paid $11.50 each
to board early in order to make filming easier. Now on board, you'll find a pretty basic 3-3
configured cabin. We'll measure the seats we were in, the most common and basic in the fleet,
but you can pay extra for more legroom in the exit rows and toward the front of the cabin.
And boarding continued as we settled in. Legroom is tight, but there was room for our personal
items under the seats. We were glad to have boarded early because most of the overhead
bins back here are either filled with the life raft or a reserve for crew bags. The tray table
seemed a little small, but would seem absolutely luxurious by the end of this low-cost carrier
comparison. Allegiant's route network stretches across the entire country, and their buy-on-board
program is fairly robust. We'll be ordering similar snacks and drinks on all three flights
so we can compare both prices and the experiences. PSA, middle seat gets the armrest. That's true.
And just like the other two airlines we'll be trying, there's no in-flight entertainment.
Two hours, seven minutes, wheels up to wheels down, cruising altitude of 28,000 feet. We're
expecting a few bumps in the climb out with associated weather. We'll do our best to find
It felt good to be in the air about three hours later than we thought,
and still no explanation from anybody about why. Departing Florida on a summertime afternoon
almost always guarantees some turbulence, and our flight was no exception.
It's time for the green grass tape measure. Let's check the pitch.
24 inches, a whopping 24 inches, and now let's check the meter.
And one more. That's the shoulder width. It was 15 inches. As always, it's best practice to never
forget your own in-flight entertainment. However, be sure to download your content.
No Wi-Fi on board here. We'll purchase drinks and snacks on each leg of this adventure,
and here on Allegiant, two gins, a can of tonic, and Doritos cost us $23.96.
And just in case you're curious, here's the full menu, which is available on the
Allegiant Airlines app. Now those two hours and seven minutes passed by relatively quickly,
and pretty soon we were on the ground again, this time in the great state of Kentucky.
Well, that was a pretty bumpy three-hour delayed flight, but we're here in Cincinnati.
That's good news, because tomorrow morning, first thing,
we're headed out to Denver with Frontier. We're just getting started.
Another day, another ultra low-cost airline. Let's check out Frontier today.
We don't fly Frontier Airlines enough to justify paying $60 to join their discount den club,
so the base fare for our flight was $49 each. But once we added our reserved seats at the
back of the plane, and carry-on bags, that included boarding early,
our total came out to be just shy of $275 for the two of us.
Don't miss our behind-the-scenes video here at Cincinnati. We went and made an
Airports Revealed highlighting everything behind the scenes, but finish this video
before you watch that one. But know it's out there. And we're skipping that line because
we went ahead and paid for these carry-on bags again. Same as we did yesterday,
trying to keep these experiences as similar as possible in order to make the comparison
as accurate as possible. It's been a hot second since I printed out a boarding pass,
but it costs $20 to check out the counter here for Frontier, so you gotta think ahead.
What do you think of when you think of Frontier? I think of the animals on the tails.
Absolutely. I think of that, and I think of Denver. That's probably their biggest hub.
Yeah, certainly. Let me fact check that. I'm sure you're right. That was my first
Frontier flight was into Denver as well, so excited to go back.
And it's time to fuel up for the day. The need for caffeine is real.
We just finished breakfast here at Braxton Brewing, and I gotta tell you, those breakfast
tacos were the best airport breakfast I've ever had. Highly recommend this place next
time you're coming through Cincinnati. You gotta check it out. That's a must-do.
This is a really, really good airport.
Frontier's fleet tends to be younger than Allegiant's. For example, the plane we were
on yesterday was nearly 20 years old. We were originally scheduled to be on a brand new
Neo, A320 Neo today to Denver, but we were just swapped to one that's seven years old.
And thankfully, I'm good to go with this bag. Looks like our airplane, Sammy the Squirrel,
may be in need of a visit to the paint shop, but no time to think about that now. Boarding
was beginning, and because we paid for that extra carry-on bag, we were able to be among
the first to board. Frontier's fleet is made up of three three-configured air buses just
like Allegiant's. You'll find more legroom if you book the more expensive seats at the
very front or in the middle of the plane, but we kept making our way back. I stopped
in one of the last open bins. Turns out Frontier also blocks some of the bins at the rear.
And thanks to that last-minute aircraft swap, we've moved from the next-to-the-last row
to the very last one.
If you thought yesterday's seats were bare bones, these are even more basic.
The tray table's even smaller. But we did not have trouble finding space for our carry-ons.
And the window offers a nice view of Sammy. Frontier's route map is more extensive than
Allegiant's, though. You can even fly with them to Mexico and the Caribbean.
And here's the menu. But now, it's time to hear from our captain.
Probably a few bumps on the descent into Denver. We got a little wonder around Missouri. We have
And as we crossed 10,000 feet, I pulled out my iPad.
No Wi-Fi here on Frontier. And also like Allegiant, plenty of bumps.
Two gins, a can of tonic, and Pringles on Frontier cost $26.98.
Now, I wouldn't normally be drinking a gin and tonic at 8.30 in the morning on a flight,
but this is for data collection purposes.
The last time I flew with Frontier, there was an option to leave a tip
when you paid with a credit card. This time, she just had us tap the machine with the card,
so I'm not sure if something changed. Let me know in the comments, are they still accepting tipping?
Almost like popping champagne.
With a snack, drinks, and iPads, the tray tables were pushed to their limit. I guess my point here
is that if you're looking to try to get work done on a laptop during your Frontier flight,
these seats are probably not for you.
I measured the pitch at 24 inches. We found 11 inches of leg room,
and there are 14 inches of shoulder room. The lavatories on all three of these airlines
are essentially the same, so here's the one in Frontier.
Our two-hour and 30-minute flight was soon coming to a close. We began our descent into Denver,
where we touched down at the country's largest airport by land area.
Well, we've made it to Denver. Actually, we got in early. Now, that's a benefit of
taking an early morning flight, which we're not doing tomorrow with Spirit.
That said, that flight was the longest one of the trip,
and I would say that wasn't the friendliest crew we've ever experienced in our lives.
Nobody was rude to us, but I saw some unfriendly behavior to other passengers,
which is too bad. I know how difficult that job is, but I was sorry to see that.
That said, again, we're not done yet. Wish us luck, as we head out with Spirit tomorrow.
Spirit Airlines' Savers Club didn't make sense for the same reason that Frontier's
competitive offering didn't make sense yesterday, so our base fare was just over $95 for the two of
us. We added our carry-on bags and paid to select our seats again, and that brought our total to
just over $250. After we bought our tickets, I decided to add Wi-Fi. I got one voucher for
browsing speed and another for streaming to compare them for you.
Security here at Denver was so brutal, we didn't have time to stop by the ticket counter. Now,
the good news about that is we had no need to. You see, we paid for our carry-on bags,
and we checked in online, so thankfully we were able to come straight to the gate.
Speaking of, let's go check on it and see if the flight's on time. Our plane is not here yet.
It's actually coming in from Las Vegas as we speak, but we're looking on time so far.
Hopefully that holds. Which, thankfully, is something I can also say for the carry-on
bag-sizer for Spirit Airlines. Well, it's time for Spirit. Did we save the best for last?
Or is it going to be a big womp womp? Time will tell. We should be boarding up here pretty soon.
Some of you may be wondering why we didn't include Southwest in this low-cost carrier
comparison. Well, that's because we think that Southwest, JetBlue, and Breeze might be a better
match for each other. Let us know in the comments if you think we should make another
comparison of those three airlines. After a quick bite, we caught a glimpse of our
inbound aircraft. When we flew this route in August of 2023, Las Vegas is the only city
Spirit served from Denver. Spirit's ground handlers here in Denver got to work offloading
this Airbus A320. However... Just like that, found out our Spirit flight is delayed. There's wind in
Las Vegas, and so that's caused a little bit of a delay here. We hope it's only a half an hour,
but we'll find out. Yeah, there's one thing you can take away and we could take away from this
experience. It's, you know, no matter what airline you're flying, you're flying first class, you're
flying main cabin, fly in the morning. That's probably the best bet to avoid delays. Most
definitely. The airlines really want to start the days off right, and as I've always said, weather.
Weather is the great equalizer. By the way, quick shout out to the ground crew here in Las Vegas at
They did a nice job of telling us exactly why the delay. Can't say the same for Allegiant the other
day. Went to board up. It's really great when airlines go out of their way to communicate.
More information is always better for passengers, and a better informed passenger is less likely to
be, well, upset. So shout out to these guys. And after only about 30 minutes, we're ready to board
up, so it's time to get on this bird. We paid $7.99 to board with Zone 1. Unlike the first two
airlines, Spirit offers a unique configuration for their planes. At the front, you'll find the
so-called big front seats. They're arranged in a 2-2 configuration. They're extremely comfortable,
although like all of the seats on all of these airlines, they do not recline. The rest of the
plane, of course, is arranged in a 3-3 configuration. Spirit does seem to have more overhead bin space
toward the back of the airplanes than the other airlines. We had no problem with our personal
items fitting under the seats. Spirit's buy-on-board program looked pretty similar to the others,
but their route network is definitely more extensive. You can fly all the way to South
America with them. We're running a bit of a behind schedule today. They had some delays this morning
in Vegas when we left there, and now there's more delays going back. So bear with us. We're trying
to get a time for departure here to take off and work with air traffic control. Once airborne,
though, one hour is 54 minutes. It's a little bit longer flight this afternoon. A lot of weather
around Las Vegas, so they have us flying at different speeds. Once we were above 10,000 feet,
I unfolded the tray table and opened up my iPad. Unlike our previous flights, we were also able to
check out the onboard Wi-Fi. Again, we'd gotten a voucher for the slower and the faster speeds
to test them both, and you know what? They're essentially the same. So just get the cheaper one.
Unfortunately, Suzanne's tray table had some residual residue from a previous passenger,
and that's too bad. However, that didn't stop us from checking out the menu. Again, this is on the
app. Once more, we ordered two gins, a can of tonic, and this time, a massive bag of Cheez-Its.
All of that for $25.50. Now how about these seats? Well, knee room came in at 12 inches.
We measured the pitch at 24, and the shoulder room was 15 inches. Although it won't weigh into
our comparison metrics, this flight turned out to be one of the most visually amazing in the last
year or so. Thankfully, those winds that delayed us earlier picked up again in Las Vegas, and that
meant we had to hold before we could land. But that wasn't too bad in our book, because the desert
southwest is insanely beautiful. But before too long, we'd begun our descent into Las Vegas.
Well, that's spirit in the bag. Now weather delay can affect anybody, so we'll fault them for that,
but now it's time to compare these experiences. And we'll do that by comparing each airline's
ground game, seats, buy-on-board program, on-board service, and in-flight entertainment.
Pricing is really a non-factor, since all three flights were essentially exactly the same.
First, the biggest loser in the ground game category is Allegiant. If only the ground team
in Punta Gorda had made some kind of announcement. At one point, I approached a supervisor during the
delay and asked for an update personally. She said she didn't even know it was delayed, but that the
gate agent working the flight would make announcements every 30 minutes or so. We hadn't
heard one, and it took two and a half hours to get an update. The biggest winner award goes to Spirit,
whose contract ground handlers made regular updates during the mere 30-minute delay we
encountered. Plus, the pilots updated us throughout the flight, as we had to hold because of wind
changes. When it comes to seats, they were all pretty much the same. That said, Frontier is the
biggest loser. Their slim line caused us the most back pain. The biggest winner? That's Spirit,
thanks to that one extra inch of knee room their seat allowed. Just like the seats, the buy-on-board
program is virtually identical among these three. But I guess the winner was Allegiant,
because their price was the cheapest, beating Spirit by $1.54. The biggest loser in terms of
service? That's Frontier. Their crew were downright rude to several passengers who were clearly
confused by last-minute changes to their seats because of that aircraft swap. The winners,
though, were Allegiant, who, despite the delay, all had great attitudes. Finally, the clear winner in
the in-flight entertainment category was Spirit, thanks to the existence of Wi-Fi. Allegiant and
Frontier tie here, since neither offers anything. No matter who you're flying, always bring your
own IFE. But the winner of the low-cost carrier comparison? It's Spirit Airlines. But the real
winners? Well, it's us. I still can't believe that worked out. Now, be honest, did you think
we'd be here right now? Did you think you were going to make it? No, I thought there was, like,
very little chance we were going to pull this off. But the schedules worked, and we were able
to make it. Only a couple of delays along the way, but we did it. Between now and the next time,
see you in the sky.
