The energy endgame - with Mario Molina and Robert Laughlin

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
In the next 100 years or so, we will run out of fossil fuels. In this film, Nobel laureates Mario Molina and Robert Laughlin challenge three young physicists to think seriously about the energy endgame and their children's futures. Molina believes we can solve the looming crisis through international collaboration -- as happened after he showed that CFCs were damaging the ozone layer. Laughlin disagrees. He wants engineering solutions, and says nations will go to war unless we find them.
Mario Molina helped to discover the link between CFC emissions and the depletion of the ozone
layer. This experience has made him optimistic that science and politics can come together
to solve the energy problem. Robert Loughlin is much more sceptical. He believes economic
forces may make any political solutions impossible.
We've not met, I think, Bob Loughlin. Hi.
Mario Molina, yes.
I think there's a huge prospect for fusion, but I think what you can learn from the past
and from Fukushima...
Which laureate will our young scientists agree with?
How do we convince people that the energy problem of 2020, of 2050, are crucial now?
We can't just wait until 2019 to resolve a 2020 issue.
To solve the problem, you have to put a price on emissions. That is, you have to charge
more for energy to induce the other uses, because they are not yet quite as cheap.
Many people in society are sort of very reluctant, say, to pay more for gasoline. In the United
States, if a politician say, OK, I'm going to raise a price of gas, it's like political
suicide. But it makes sense.
We have to ask the question, why is the price of oil what it is?
We're using too much?
No, that's a non sequitur. The price of oil is what it is because we're using too much.
That's not true. It's supply and demand.
So it's people who have drilled for the oil, they've got it, and now they charge the most
they can to make the most profits.
Why can't you just pass laws that fix the price?
Well, you just can't. Fuel is more or less twice as expensive in Europe as it is in the
States.
But think about that a minute. You'll see it can't be.
If you have an internationally competitive industry like airlines, it cannot be so that
Lufthansa is paying twice as much for its fuel as United Airlines because it's a fuel
intensive industry. And if you double the price, they'd go out of business.
So it must be so. There's an exception.
There's a byline in the EU laws specifically exempting airlines from high prices of fuel.
You're describing what I call a market failure.
Of course, oil is cheap. You can just take it off the ground.
So of course it's going to be hard to compete with.
Solar is coming down in price but not fast enough.
So that's why to fix a market failure, we're talking about government intervention.
But it has to be a global agreement.
All the countries agree and it's done.
In principle, it could be done, but of course it's extremely difficult.
Well, the point I was trying to make is that it isn't possible. That's just wrong.
The energy problem is an engineering problem. You must put on an engineering hat and solve it.
And that's different from passing laws to change economics.
He is more interested in using the legislative process to pass laws that regulate people's behavior.
So he wants to regulate, I want to engineer. That's the difference.
If the price of these alternative energies doesn't come down fast enough,
there has to be some sort of international agreement
which directly or indirectly compensates for this market failure.
Are you folks at all concerned about the future of your progeny?
Yes, most certainly.
So let me float a question now.
How long before the fossil energy runs out?
How long is that?
Depends on consumption.
Guess. No, no, you're evading the question. Just guess.
A hundred years.
You say a hundred years?
That's the rough estimate, so plus or minus.
Okay, a hundred years.
Now, let's do a worst-case scenario.
Everyone fails, the hundred years comes, the fossil energy runs out. Then what?
I think we can't let it get there.
No, no, this is not an allowed answer.
Because as you know, the way of politics is the worst possible solution
is almost always the solution you get.
So it's not an unreasonable question to ask.
What is the consequence?
Do you think that needs to happen?
We do have precedents. It doesn't have to be that way.
If I may butt in, that statement is false.
If you cut down on the fossil fuel use by 20%,
which is almost unthinkably hard, but if you do that,
it merely takes 20% longer to burn it all up.
So it's running out is not a crazy thing to think about.
So I'm going to press you to the wall and ask, what happened?
We will be forced to come up with another solution.
And we always have, as an industry.
You mean magic will happen?
No, I think research will happen.
And research has happened.
Let me remind you that research does not make energy.
Energy is conserved.
Research only makes papers.
Right now, it would have to be nuclear.
So it depends how soon.
Nuclear and some of the renewables.
I mean, we do have...
What happens when the nuclear runs out?
Well, that buys us more time.
And then we're...
Solar and biofuels and other things have to be...
It's true, we do have to face the reality that
we have limited resources.
So we do have to think about when fossil fuel runs out.
However, in tandem, we also need to be proactively
working on dissolving of renewable energy sources.
And what I also liked a lot about his contribution
was that it's not really a question of
whether you believe in global warming or not,
but that you just have to accept this limitation of the resources.
So that was, I think, a very clever thing
to get emotions out of this and just to say,
OK, but we know it's finite, so what do we do?
There's an idea that I'm trying to get to float to the table here.
Usually, when human beings don't have enough of something,
they fight.
They fight.
Now, it's not just historical, it's the way we are.
Now, just imagine what happens
if the second most important thing in all the world,
after food, becomes in short supply.
What happens?
And we're talking about highly advanced technical fighting.
And who's going to be doing this fighting?
Not me, I'll be dead.
Not you, probably you will as well,
but your great-great-great-grandchildren
will be forced to make a terrible choice,
whether I'm going to protect my family
or whether I'm going to let the other people win.
And usually, people put themselves first.
So the point is, if you're thinking about saving the future,
it's your children that are at stake.
That's the issue on the table that is supremely important.
Namely, the possibility that when the transition happens,
there will be terrible struggles and people will die.
I personally think that's a more imminent problem
than destroying the world.
Now, other people have different views,
but I think that's the big one.
Look, there are optimistic and pessimistic views.
Civilization, on the other hand, has been advancing.
We're much better off.
Of course, there are many difficulties,
but we have solutions at hand.
Solar energy, of course, it's more expensive,
but not so much more expensive
that civilization has to come to an end or to fight and so on.
It's clear, if you do the calculations,
it takes a small piece of the Sahara Desert
to power the entire planet.
But you people, of course, have to work very hard to do this,
precisely to avoid this alternative,
which I don't think is unavoidable.
Yeah, I think this time is especially crucial
because so many of the developed countries,
we've actually been using about the same amount of energy for a while,
but it's really the developing countries,
that their energy is skyrocketing.
They have this knowledge, and they can skip some of those phases.
They have solar panels in soccer balls.
They're not starting with the grid.
Jump in all the soccer balls, making energy with soccer kicking.
That's the optimistic view.
I'm really pleased to hear it, Todd,
but I don't want to hear silly things, okay?
This stuff is deadly serious.
If you come up with some crazy science fiction,
nonsense number for the jewel budget of the world,
all you're going to have is war.
This is serious.
Now, right now, we are rich
because civilization discovered how to take energy out of the ground.
Our wealth is energy.
It is a non sequitur to say that we will continue to be rich
after the fossil fuels are gone.
There's no reason at all to believe this.
But how much more expensive is solar?
Economists, I'm sorry, but I disagree with that.
The external, many others,
they are talking about the cost of replacing
that being 1 or 2% of global GDP.
It's in the noise.
The economy will double or triple.
So the consensus among people,
look very carefully at this, it's definitely possible.
This is nonsense.
The consensus among people who make energy,
who make our lives, is that solar energy is nonsense.
That's why they don't invest in it.
This is wrong.
Economists are idiots.
They don't make energy.
They just sit around making theories.
The people who make energy...
I just came from Seville,
and there's a big concentrated solar power plant,
and they sell that.
It's, of course, more expensive.
But they are making photovoltaic cells in such a large scale
that they can sell cheaper than concentrated solar power.
So the cost of solar energy is not that far
from the cost of fossil fuel.
And the difference in cost
between solar energy today and fossil fuel
is a minor fraction of the overall economy.
I trust that young people like yourselves
work together with other young people,
and these complications with the economy and so on,
if you're clever enough, you can actually deal with them.
And we do have positive examples.
We do have things that have worked.
Pick those up.
And we have things that have failed terribly.
Find them out and make sure they don't happen again.
Do you think we're in the situation as dire as McLaughlin described it to be?
Will we be going to war in the next 100 years over resources?
I think it's important to realize that there's that possibility
because energy is such an integral part of our lives.
We need to be aware of that and how important it is,
but use our time to do the research
and make sure we're making advances in energy
so we don't get to that point.
It's making the students think hard
about some very important things that aren't abstract.
Trouble in the future when the world's energy supply gets tight.
Now, what I believe is probably more optimistic.
I think people can solve problems, but they won't unless they're scared.
So I won't scare them, and then they'll fix it.
I like the more positive attitude of Molina.
The pessimistic picture may be good to raise attention
and to raise the awareness for an issue,
but to get to solutions, I think it's more interesting
to look at possible solutions and not to paint everything in black.
I think the future is bright.
I don't agree with Dr. Laughlin that it's so pessimistic
and that people will go to war over limited resources.
Yes, we will always fight because people will always disagree,
but people certainly have also shown in the past
that we get together to solve the larger global issues.
© transcript Emily Beynon
