Penguins: the flip side of flipper bands - by Nature Video

nature video
11 followers
Sep 5, 2023
Scientists often study penguins to see how climate change is affecting the marine ecosystem. To keep track of individual birds they use flipper bands. But a new study shows that these bands reduce the penguins' breeding success and survival, thus biasing the data. For more, listen to the researchers talk about the study on the Nature Podcast http://www.nature.com/nature/podcast/index-2011-01-13.html and read the original research paper http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v469/n7329/full/nature09630.html
These king penguins live on a small island in the Crozet Archipelago,
halfway between the southern tip of Africa and Antarctica.
Here, in the Southern Ocean, the penguin is at the top of the food chain.
So scientists study populations like this to gauge how climate change
is affecting the whole Southern Ocean ecosystem.
To keep track of individual birds, they use flipper bands,
which the birds soon get used to wearing, or so it was assumed.
But a 10-year study now shows that banded birds produce fewer chicks
and have a lower survival rate than their unbanded neighbours.
This casts doubt on data collected from banded penguins,
jeopardising attempts to use this data to assess the impact of climate change
on marine ecosystems.
The researchers followed the fate of 100 king penguins from 1998 to 2008.
Each penguin had a minute transponder tag inserted under its skin.
Using these tags, together with a system of antennas and video cameras,
the researchers were able to monitor their penguins
as they moved between the island breeding site and the sea.
Half of the penguins also wore conventional flipper bands.
These metal bands are easy to spot at a distance using binoculars,
but compared with the transponder tags, they're heavy and they damage the flipper.
The team noticed that the banded birds arrived later for breeding
and spent more time at sea foraging for food.
In the water, the metal band seems to increase drag,
which affects the hydrodynamics of the penguin.
This makes swimming less efficient and more tiring,
so it takes longer to catch food.
And this means the banded birds' chicks get less to eat.
Over the decade, the researchers found that the banded penguins
had 39% fewer chicks and a 16% lower survival rate.
If the way we monitor penguin populations changes how they behave,
there's a bias in the data.
Researchers may need to find less harmful ways of identifying
and following individual animals.
And where we use data collected from banded penguins
to make conclusions about climate change,
we must take into account the flip side of flipper banding.
