The Cosmic Distance Ladder

Hubble Space Telescope
12 followers
Sep 5, 2023
How do we know how far away things are in the universe? What Yardsticks to we use and how accurate are they?
On Monday, March 31, a workshop will be held at The Space Telescope Science Institute to discuss these topics and more. As an added bonus, Dr. Adam Riess, winner of the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics will join +Tony Darnell and Mario Livio to share his unique insights into this important topic in a hangout Monday Evening.
Dr. Riess won his Nobel Prize using one of the best yardsticks in the universe to measure distance: Type 1a supernova. We hope you can join us and bring your questions!
Where are you Tony? I am in my home office and we are now live.
Okay. Hello everybody and welcome to a very special edition of our Hubble Hangouts.
My name is Tony Darnell. I'm the Social Media Manager at Space Telescope Science Institute
and this is a very special edition because we've got an opportunity to talk with people.
Two guys I have been very much interested in getting into a Hangout and I finally have them here.
We only have a few minutes so we'll make this as brief as we can
because they have other things they've got to get back to.
With me tonight is Dr. Mario Livio. He's an astronomer from the Space Telescope Science Institute.
Hi Mario. He is an author and blogger and his latest book is on scientific blunders
which we did a Hangout on a few months back. Actually it was almost a year ago now
which was a great book and I guess it's been getting a lot of attention out there
because I keep hearing about it from people.
Also with me is Dr. Adam Rees. He is also an astronomer at Space Telescope Science Institute
but he has also won the 2011 Nobel Prize in Physics for his work on the discovery
that the Universe is accelerating as it expands by doing observations of Type Ia supernovae.
So welcome guys. This week you guys have been very busy putting together, among other people,
a workshop at the Institute called the Cosmic Distance Ladder.
I guess it's a series of talks and papers and presentations on how well we know,
how well our techniques for measuring the Universe and how far away things are.
Is that correct? Who wants to go? How about you Dr. Rees? Go ahead.
Yes. We know how to measure distances in the Universe and in some cases we can measure them
starting from the beginning, the Big Bang, and in other cases we start from nearby
and this week we're trying to see if our measurements meet in the middle,
sort of like building a bridge on both ends. We want to make sure they connect.
Okay. I'm hearing your feedback come back a little bit.
Hopefully that will get better as we go on.
Why do that? Is this something astronomers periodically do?
Do you just get together and see how well you're doing? Mario?
Yes. This measurement of the distances ties into something very important,
which is the age of the Universe. Also, we try to determine all the parameters
that determine what our Universe looks like.
This parameter, which is called the Hubble constant,
acts as an anchor, if you like, to many other parameters.
By measuring this to a very high accuracy and precision,
we think that we can know much more about our Universe.
So this Hubble constant, tell us a little bit about that. What is that, Adam?
The Hubble constant is the relationship between how fast galaxies move away from us
and how far away they are from us.
So, if you imagine a loaf of raisin bread rising in the oven,
the further away a raisin is from another raisin,
the faster it will appear to move away, because there's more dough between those raisins.
So, this is one of the amazing facts about our Universe,
is that because it's expanding, but maintaining its proportions,
when we measure ever more distant galaxies, they will rush away faster.
It's this important number, the proportionality constant, known as the Hubble constant,
that tells us the relationship.
And the inverse of the Hubble constant tells us approximately how old the Universe is, as Mario said.
So, that's the way in which we sort of run the clock backwards,
to see what the Universe was like at different times in our history.
So, what is the relationship? Is it linear? Is it a straight line?
The farther things are, the faster they're going? Is it very complicated?
Yeah, no, it's actually, it is linear, almost linear,
in the sense that, yes, there is a direct proportionality,
something that is twice as far, appears to recede twice as fast.
And, you know, it would have basically stayed like that,
had it not been for this discovery that Adam was involved with,
which says that our Universe is not just expanding, but the expansion is actually speeding up.
So, this speeding up makes it so that, you know,
the age of the Universe is not quite one over this Hubble constant,
but we need to take care of this acceleration, and so on.
I remember, I think, back in the day, this was many, many years ago,
back when I think you were just embarking on this work, Adam,
that I don't think it was very obvious in the beginning
that the Universe was accelerating as it was expanding.
Everybody knew it was expanding, we've known that since Hubble's time,
but the idea that it was accelerating caught everybody by surprise, didn't it?
I mean, didn't I see a paper, maybe it was you guys who said,
there was a subtitle called,
Measuring the Deceleration of the Universe.
You were pretty sure you weren't going to see an acceleration, weren't you?
That's right. The expectation was that because the Universe is full of matter,
the gravity between matter and the Universe is attractive,
and so it would act to sort of put a halt or a break on the expansion.
Like if you took a pair of keys and tossed them in the air,
you expect gravity to pull them back down.
The question really was how much matter is out there,
and so by how much your keys decelerate back to the Earth,
you're essentially weighing the Earth.
We thought we were doing that experiment,
and when we looked at the keys thrown up in the air,
which in our case was supernovae,
they were taking off, they were going up, faster and faster,
as though they were accelerating away from the Earth.
This sounds very strange, and it is very strange,
because we don't experience that on a regular basis,
but it actually is a feature in Einstein's theory of gravity,
that you have a material, which we call today dark energy,
that represents an energy built into the vacuum
that would cause this, a repulsive gravity,
and the Universe accelerated.
That blows me away. I'm a big fan of the NFL,
and they always tell you every Sunday,
well, that's why you play the game,
because you can't just say for certain how...
That's right. That's why you experiment.
Yeah, and so here, it's like, well, that's why we do the observations,
it's because we got to know for sure what's going on.
So, that's what you guys are doing with this workshop,
you're sort of commiserating, seeing how well you're doing.
How well are we doing?
How well are we doing with how well we understand these cosmic distances?
You know, until about 20 years ago,
we didn't know this rate of expansion,
or the uniconstant,
better than we did about the factor 2.
We have now reached a point where we know it with an error
that is no more than about 3%,
and in fact, we have some different values
coming up from the very distant Universe
and coming from the local Universe,
which are different from each other by that kind of number,
you know, a few percent,
and we reached a situation where we're discussing,
you know, is that even a discrepancy or not?
Does it point to some new physics that we need to understand?
Or, you know, is it just still within the errors of the method?
But we've made huge, huge advances,
you know, from knowing that number to within a factor of 2,
to now arguing about 3%.
Just to put a minor point on that even,
right now, the differences between
measuring the expansion rate far away and nearby,
Mario's decision is 3%.
The difference is maybe more like 6% or 7%.
So we've been arguing a little bit
about whether that is significant,
and if it was significant,
what kinds of new physics could explain that discrepancy?
We heard a very interesting talk from Wayne Hu,
who showed us that by having another kind of neutrino in the universe,
you could explain that discrepancy perfectly.
Another possibility is more exotic dark energy
than even Einstein's cosmological constant.
So we're quite interested in how well do we need to measure this
to really discover if there is any more new physics
within the cosmological model.
Wow, boy, I wish I had, like, two more hours with you guys.
So Adam brought up the talks that were being done today,
and I want you guys to know that I put a link down
in the description box of the event.
I also put it in the YouTube video,
where you can go and watch today's talks.
I've been watching them on and off throughout the day,
and they've been really, really good.
So you guys have a lot of tools in your tool bag
to measure cosmic distances.
You've got things like, well, what Adam studied,
which were type Ia supernovae.
We also used Cepheid variables to find out how far away things are.
Why so many?
Why do we have so many ways,
and what other ones are there that maybe I haven't mentioned?
So first of all, there are many other methods,
and many of them will be discussed at this meeting,
things like gravitational lensing.
There will be binary stars.
Cepheid, and so on.
The reason that we want to use more than one method
is because every one of those methods,
first of all, you know, there are both mistakes,
errors in measuring them,
both because of the statistics of the measurement,
but also because of what we call the schematics of the measurement,
namely how different is the value that you measure
from, you know, assuming that there is some absolute value
that is the right value that you want to hit.
Now, these schematics are different from different methods,
so only by taking the most precise methods that you have
and combining them,
you can actually try to get above these schematics
and see what the real values are.
Are there certain regimes that certain methods work better in,
like Type Ia supernovae may be good for a certain distance regime,
I would guess, and maybe supernovae.
I know certainly parallax, when you do parallax measurements,
and that's this sort of apparent shift of background
against a foreground object.
Those certainly aren't good for really distant measurements.
Most distant indicators we use
change from being, I would say, common but faint.
Those are the ones we use nearby,
to luminous and rare.
Those are the ones we use far away.
So I wish that Type Ia supernovae would all go off right around us,
you know, 100 parsecs away,
because I can measure the parallax of those,
although it might be less comfortable for us.
But the reality is that they're so rare,
there's only one in a galaxy every 100 years,
that we have to look out pretty far before we find supernovae.
So there are long-range distance indicators.
Sepia variables are common in terms of,
a given galaxy may have 100 of them,
but they're rare in terms of stars.
Most stars are not Sepia variables.
So you have to go out to kiloparsecs
before you find the nearest Sepia,
which challenges our ability to measure parallax.
So different distance indicators are good at different ranges.
So in many cases we have to knit them together
to get out to a smooth expansion of the Universe.
Right, so basically we construct it like a ladder, kind of,
where, you know, the nearby things provide some of the nearby ones,
and then, you know, you have to go to the next level
to provide some more ones,
and eventually to connect to the farthest objects.
So, Adam, with respect to your research on Type Ia supernovae,
you took some observations,
and your research involved, obviously, measuring a whole lot of these.
But wasn't that a certain instance or a certain period
in the Universe's history?
I mean, I guess my question is,
how certain are we that the Universe has always been accelerating at the same rate?
I mean, could it have been different at different times in the past,
and wouldn't we notice that through these different measurements
that you guys are currently looking at?
Right. Well, Type Ia supernovae, we've used them to see very far back,
all the way back to about 12 billion years out of a Universe
that's about 14 billion years old.
The law was that the acceleration only started about 5 billion years ago.
Before that, we could see the Universe was decelerating.
And what we make of this is that there's two important components in the Universe,
dark energy and dark matter.
Dark matter was dominant earlier when the Universe was denser.
Dark energy is the thing that's dominant now.
And whether that acceleration is constant or not
really gets at what the nature of the dark energy is,
which is something we're trying to measure by observing many more supernovae.
Wow. So that's the first time I had heard that.
5 billion years ago, the Universe was actually decelerating.
Right.
Wow. And dominated primarily by dark matter.
And then at some point, the expansion got to a certain area
where dark energy took over and started accelerating.
Dark energy is pretty, we think it's fairly constant in its energy density.
But the density of matter drops as the Universe expands
simply because there's more volume and the same amount of matter.
So at some point, the density of matter drops below the density of dark energy
and the Universe accelerates.
Oh my gosh. Wow.
So I've got to let you guys go, but what's in store for the rest of the week?
What else do you have going on?
So we just have more of these different methods.
And we try to compare notes, so to speak, between these very different methods,
each one of them with its strengths and weaknesses.
Some methods are very accurate, but you can only find very few objects,
so at the end your precision is not that great.
Other methods, you find lots of objects, but maybe they're not as accurate as that.
And we hope that by the end of Wednesday,
we will have scanned all these methods that we think can provide us
with an accuracy and precision of a few percent
and then look towards the future,
because our goal is to reach a value of the Hubble constant
that is, we have an error no larger than about a percent or so.
Wow. That's amazing.
Okay, well, guys, I want to thank you both for taking time out
to just give me a few minutes.
Adam, am I going to get you again in a Hangout in the future,
maybe for a little more time?
Sure. Yeah, let's hang out.
Good. I'm glad to hear you say that.
You'll be hearing from me.
Mario, as always, it is a lot of fun to talk to you.
Thank you for taking time out to talk to me as well.
I wish I had more time, guys, but I'm going to have to let them go.
They've got to get back to what they're doing.
I want to thank you all for watching.
And as always, keep looking up.
