Quantitative Elastic Measurements of High Modulus Materials with Tapping/AM-FM Mode (Ted Limpoco)
1 Video View·Sep 5, 2023
For more information, visit https://nanohub.org/resources/22617
Ted Limpoco
6/2/15
"Quantitative Elastic Measurements of High Modulus Materials with Tapping/AM-FM Mode"
Thank you very much Maura and Scott for your invitation to speak here at the workshop
It's given me an opportunity to come back here at UIUC. It's always a pleasure to see familiar faces and friends here at MRL
The talk this afternoon is on quantitative elastic measurements of high modulus materials
With AMFM mode and this is a mode that's already available on your AFM system
The
Results presented here will be from Martha Cocoon
What is our in-house expert on AMFM and Roger Proch who developed the technique?
AMFM I'll put it also in context of other
nanomechanical techniques
Most of which depend on the analysis of force curves or indentation curves to obtain
nanomechanical properties and therefore rely on monitoring the deflection of a cantilever as a tip presses on to the surface
In contrast AMFM is a tapping mode technique
And therefore we rely on the dynamic properties of the cantilever such as frequency amplitude and phase
Okay, so why AMFM?
Here's an example from an applications perspective in the development of new materials
And
Devices we normally would like to probe them in their native
environment or working state
for
Nanoscale composites we need high spatial resolution of properties small features
That is small contact areas often required gentle forces
For example in the semiconductor industry there is an increasing demand for locate dielectrics
to meet the demands of device miniaturization
achieving locate
Unfortunately also results in mechanical properties degradation for example
one third decrease in the dielectric constant of
Locate silicon oxide is accompanied by an order of magnitude decrease in its Young's modulus which may result in failure in
the
processing packaging or final use of the
device
So such small devices and interface rich systems require high-resolution properties contrast that are also
non-destructive
Okay, mechanical measurements span many length scales from feeling the stiffness of an inflated ball with your hands to
detecting the repulsive forces between
Individual atoms in a crystal so in AMFM for example the tip radius is less than 10 nanometers
We're applying forces that are in the tens of nanonewtons on the sample and detecting
sub nanometer to several nanometers of material deformation
Just as important
Mechanical measurements span many time scales as well in the context of AFM which
In which the measurements are rendered as an image by rastering the tip across the sample
Line times and frame times are in the order of a few seconds to a few minutes and a few minutes force curves and
indentation curves are
performed usually usually in a second or several seconds and in terms of
Tapping mode or AC mode AFM. We're talking about cantilever
Oscillation frequencies in the range of tens of kilohertz to hundreds of kilohertz
Okay, we're also probing different mechanical regimes that may involve
Reversible deformation irreversible deformation as well as time different dependent response and therefore would like to measure
different parameters such as Young's modulus for the linear elastic
deformation strength and hardness for plastic deformation or loss tangent for the viscoelastic response
Okay, so here's a chart that shows
The type of nanomechanical measurements you can do with AFM
Showing their operational range in terms of the moduli
Covered and the measurement time scales notice that there is no one technique that covers the entire range
However, if you take all of them together, they cover a wide
range of applications
Therefore what we need is a toolbox that gives us an array of techniques that allow us to probe the mechanical properties of
materials
in addition as the
Area that you're measuring is shrinking to a few nanometers on the side the material properties that you
Are probing may be similar to what you see in a macroscopic scale, but maybe totally different as well and without any
Good references or good standards. It's easy to fool yourselves
and
AFM for example has a lot of uncertainties in the measurement. The first of which is the tip shape and
contact area
therefore
Self-consistency and validation of measurement across several measurement techniques gives us confidence in in our
Measurements and therefore one technique is not enough and certainly one size does not fit all
AMFM gives us elasticity and dissipation measurement, which is complemented by other techniques such as lost tangent
Imaging for viscoelastic response contact resonance imaging, which I think you also have for stiff materials such as metals and ceramics
force curves and force maps for softer materials for
Polymer materials and cells for example and other biological materials and finally nano indentation which
Gives you strength of hardness and modulus for plastic materials
Okay
So why a tapping mode for nanomechanical measurements?
force curves are
Low frequency or below resonance measurements and for all but the softest levers
these sub resonance
Measurements are
Live in 1f noise until you get to resonance
AMFM is a tapping mode technique which uses resonance unlike the sub resonance technique
Which is destined or doomed to live?
Under 1f noise and we know from our experience
Extensive experience with tapping mode imaging that it is gentle. It is fast and it is able to achieve high resolution and
with AMFM
we have a simple method for
quantifying
nanomechanical properties
So, how does AMFM work? Well, we excite the cantilever to frequencies
At the fundamental bending mode as well as or typically the second bending mode
we apply the same drive amplitude in the first mode as he would in regular tapping mode imaging and
use the
the
Amplitude of the deflection of the the oscillation amplitude
as a feedback
For your for getting the topography of your sample just like in topographic imaging
This is the AM or the amplitude modulation part of AMFM
Then we then excite the cantilever at a second or higher bending mode
and
face lock
This resonance frequency from which we get directly the frequency shifts
We excite this at only a fraction of the drive that we use for the fundamental mode in order not to perturb that mode
from here
from the lock-in outputs of the
First resonance we get the topography and actually you also get the lost tangent and
From the second resonance we get a stiffness or elasticity contrast as well as dissipation
So the second mode is the FM or the frequency modulation part of the measurement
Okay. So this is a polymer sample composed of a thin polymer film in which
It has separated into its different face components consisting of polystyrene and polycaprolactone
Which are 3 and 0.5 gigapascals respectively
The topography and face here is obtained from the first
Mode
While the modulus is obtained from the frequency shifts in the second mode
This is on the left
Here is similar data from the previous slide for polystyrene and polycaprolactone. Well this data on the right shows
polystyrene with polypropylene with modulus of about
3 and 2 respectively if we overlay the histograms of these two images
We see that the modulus of polystyrene converges to around 2.5 to 3 gigapascals
Which shows us the self-consistency between the two?
measurements
Okay
so
This example shows you how AM FM can be used for stiffer materials
For example for metals in this case a tin and lead components of a solder
For the if you look at the face image you see very hardly any contrast in the face from the first mode
Except for some edge effects due to topography
But when you look at the frequency channel in the second mode
you see a sharp contrast between the two faces or the two domains, which
Represents a 40 gigapascal difference in modulus between tin and lead
Finally in this example, this is a
200 nanometer titanium stripes on silicon which are both over 100
gigapascals in modulus we can see that
AM FM can also see the contrast between
The stiffness of these or the modulus of these two very stiff materials, which are 50 gigapascals apart
Normally you can do these measurements in contact resonance mode as well
Okay, so how are we able to measure these such stiff materials with AM FM?
Well for conventional tapping mode imaging you're only
Exciting the cantilever and detecting its response at a single frequency. Lots of information may be lost in
AM FM. We're also exciting the higher bending mode which gives us access to the stiffer bending modes of the cantilever
For example, the second bending mode is about 36 times stiffer than the first bending mode
Okay. So for the first mode again in summary
We get amplitude and phase from which we can calculate a frequency shift
and
Here we get topography and actually from from these parameters also the loss tangent in the second mode
Since it is phase locked loop
We get the frequency shift directly and we can also operate a third feedback in which we keep the amplitude of the second mode
Constant or at set point by adjusting the drive amplitude know that contrast in the drive amplitude gives us the energy dissipation
Okay. So how do we quantify?
Mechanical properties from the observables in AM FM you're
Typically familiar with how we calculate modulus from a force versus
Indentation
plot by
Fitting it into some contact model here. For example our Hertz contact of different
probe geometries
We then use this theoretical work
that relates the theoretical work on
FM AFM that relates the frequency shift in FM AFM to the
Interaction force
to the
Fractional derivative of the interaction force at the
At the lowest point of the cantilever swing when the cantilever is in contact with the sample we can therefore derive
the
modulus as well as indentation in terms of
The parameters that we measure in AM FM such as frequency phase and amplitude we just need a reasonable
Assumption for the tip geometry and tip radius and we get modulus and indentation images
So, how do we do an AM FM experiment first you need to calibrate the cantilever to get its spring constant and optical lever
sensitivity
Then you choose a reasonable model parameters that is the tip geometry and tip radius
Finally you need to do a careful tune of the cantilever and by that we mean you need to tune very close to the surface and
Make sure that the phase at the peak of the resonance curve is set close to 90 and then acquire images
In this case, you will have to adjust the frequency I gain for the frequency feedback loop or the PLL
Loop and the drive I gain just as you would for
Adjusting the I gain for topography to make sure that you're tracking these two parameters. Well, so the frequency shift here gives you the
modulus image and this gives you the dissipation and then you can run a reference sample a sample, you know
The modulus off that allows you to choose better
Tip geometry and tip radius parameters before running a test sample. Okay, so this is an example of how
The modulus how how the amplitude in phase is affected by changing the set point the top in
topography while
The modulus is not affected at all by changing the set point
So the first and second mode measurements are
Related but you know here you see that modulus is not affected by changes in the first mode
So some tips and tricks you have to image in repulsive mode, especially for hard materials. The face should be set near
40-degrees
Remember when you're doing when you're measuring mechanical properties, you want to tap hard or poke hard at your sample
the amplitude in second mode has to be set to a fraction only a fraction of the drive amplitude of the first mode and
Then you have to tune carefully you have to be almost on resonance
Adjusted to less than 10 Hertz error from the resonance peak and set the face close to 90 and finally which is also very
important is
Cleanliness of your sample. Remember you're making very very small deformations on your sample. So you don't want to be
Probing dirt on the surface, but the substrate or the surface itself
So in summary AM FM is a tapping
Imaging mode that is fast high resolution and gentle
It has wide dynamic range from megapascals to gigapascals and it is quantitative
Models can be used to estimate the modulus and with that I'd like to thank you for your attention

