MCB529 4-10-13: Reproductive Rhythms
Sep 5, 2023
of Comparative Biosciences, College of Veterinary Medicine,
right?
Yeah.
And she's going to be telling us
some very interesting things about reproduction rhythms,
which Megan knows a lot about.
She has worked in this area.
I met her at the University of Michigan
when she was a postdoc there a few years ago, not so many.
But anyway, so I know she's very knowledgeable on the subject.
But I was going to give you a little preview of what
we're going to do for the next three weeks.
I think Slim might not need to come anymore.
I know it's hard to imagine Slim.
You can listen to what we're going to do,
and then you can decide.
So I've been giving a lot of thought to this.
And what I've decided is next week,
I told you we were going to have student presentations.
But we're going to try to kind of transition into them.
So next week, the topic is going to be metabolism.
It is huge in rhythms.
It's like, you know, it's the pancreas.
It's the fat cells.
I mean, there are many different aspects
of metabolism and rhythms.
And so what I'm going to do is send out one or two review
papers, and then I'm going to organize you into groups.
And you're going to pick the papers that you present.
Your group is.
And so it's going to be just a little step forward
from what we've been doing, where we give you the papers
and you make the presentations.
And then the last week, which is four weeks from today,
but two weeks after that day, you're
going to pick your own topics as groups
and make group presentations on the topic that you choose.
And there are things we didn't cover.
There are other things to cover that we've done.
But so then there will be a component of you
guys coming up with an idea.
Two weeks from today, I've decided
we're going to do a writing exercise.
And we did this in my lab group meeting a couple of years ago.
And everybody doesn't have to chime in
and say how they liked it, but my sense
was they liked it a lot.
And that is, we're going to have an exercise on writing
specific aims for a grant.
And this is something that you do all the way
through your graduate training.
You do it all the way through your,
if you become a research scientist or any kind.
If you ever want grant money, you have to do it.
Notice Megan and I were talking about grants shortly ago.
That's why we look sad.
But it's going to be just a one-page essay in the format
that's the very standard format.
And I have this book.
You should probably need this book, Megan.
I probably have three copies of it.
It's about grantsmanship.
And I'm going to send out the section on how
to write specific aims.
The specific aim page is one page long for any grant,
no matter what size it is.
And it has the general background, usually.
And I'm going to give a little talk on this next week.
The first line is, what would you
tell your congressman if you were on the elevator for three
minutes about why you should get funded?
And this is where we all go wrong, all of us scientists,
because we're all so into the depths of the details.
You can't give people the big picture
of why taxpayer money should go into supporting your research.
So that's very important to do.
So there's that paragraph, and then there's
a paragraph that brings you more specifically into the research
area you're in, what we don't know, what we'd like to know.
And you won't know all this, but this is just
what you have to think about.
And then you have your aims.
And then why would the world care?
How many people is the NIH going to be
able to think about helping if this research is funded?
So that's going to be the exercise for two weeks
from today.
And I don't think any of the people from my lab
who are in here have done this so recently
that it won't be new to them.
But the idea is for you to pick anything
that we've talked about, because that will make it easier for you,
because you already heard it introduced.
I know this is possible, because I asked Lucas,
because his Carmudian TA organizer
kept making him be a proctor during class.
And at the same time, I said, OK, Lucas, it's not enough
just to summarize the paper.
I want you to tell me about an experiment you do.
He did a beautiful job.
You did a really nice job in that paragraph.
And it's that kind of thing.
Just think of an area you'd like to know more about
in three kinds of ways you could address it.
And I think it'll be an interesting way
to build on what we've learned.
It'll be an interesting way for you to learn about grants.
And it'll be a little experience in writing.
And what I can also tell you, I have written many, many grants.
I have received a number of grants,
but I've written many, many more that I've been funded for.
And what I can tell you is simpler is better.
Simpler writing is always better if you're
trying to communicate an idea to a committee who
doesn't want to read your paper or your grant more than once.
And so that's another part of the exercise,
is making it simple and accessible.
So this is just a preview to what
I'm going to tell you more about next week.
But that's what's going to be coming.
And I'll be sending out on Friday
the information about the groups and the paper on metabolism.
And then you can talk to your email, your group,
and pick some area in metabolism.
That's a wonderful topic.
So anyway, with no further ado, Megan Mahoney
is going to make a presentation today.
Does this control slides?
I don't know.
I don't think so.
I don't think so either.
That cramps my style.
I'm kind of a spaz.
I know.
You know.
OK, so as Martha said, this is what I do.
I study reproduction and circadian rhythms.
And their interactions.
So today, if I have time to get through it,
we're going to briefly touch on how reproduction is organized
by the hypothalamus, pituitary, gonadal axis.
We'll talk about how we know that rhythms regulates
reproductive events in rodents.
We'll talk about the reverse, how
we know hormones regulates the expression of rhythms.
And then we'll talk a little bit about humans
and what we know in humans, trying
to parallel those results to what we know in rodent work.
And then at the end, talk about shift work.
So for a brief summary then of how reproduction
in the female, and that's mostly when I focus on females,
but that's mostly what this talk is focusing on.
It's regulated by cells in the hypothalamus,
GNRH cells, who release their product that comes down
and acts on the pituitary.
Pituitary, stimulated by the GNRH,
secretes luteinizing hormone, LH, as well as FSH.
And then at the time when LH gets released,
it's usually released in a pulsatile manner.
In rodents, every four days there's
something called an LH surge.
That circulates in the blood to get to the ovary,
where it causes the release of the egg.
The follicle ruptures and ovulation occurs.
So there is feedback where we've got the ovary develops
and makes increasing levels of estrogen.
So hypothalamus, pituitary, gonads,
we have this estradiol that feeds back and talks
to the hypothalamus.
The GNRH neurons are getting this hormone signal
and deciding when they're going to release their product.
And again, they cause the release of luteinizing hormone.
So I'm going to tell you that in addition to needing GNRH
neurons and estrogen levels in order to induce ovulation,
in rodents, we have a lot of data
that the circadian clock is involved in this.
So you can map out all the hormones that are involved.
And these hormone changes that I'm going to show you here
are the same as what would occur in the human menstrual
or reproductive cycle.
But it just happens on a larger time scale.
So here we have increasing levels of estrogen.
As the follicle grows, more and more estrogen happens.
What have they done?
One, two, three.
This is a five-day estrous cycle.
We call it estrous cycle in rodents.
We'll call it reproductive cycle in humans.
Estrogen increases at some point.
And then we have LH.
We'll have a big surge.
And after LH, sorry, I've got to back up.
Estrogen causes this change in GNRH,
which causes this surge of LH.
And then ovulation happens.
Following all that, progesterone goes up.
So now notice that we're talking about circadian rhythms.
And this is, I said, five days.
And this is only happening once every five days.
Well, four or five days.
So how can I tell you that there's
a circadian rhythm to all of this
if this is happening every four or five days?
By the way, you can divide up the estrous cycle
into different stages.
They do this based both on the hormonal states
and cytology, vaginal cytology.
So diestrous, proestrous, estrous, and metastrous.
So here's all these events that I've just
told you about with the hormonal changes.
And here is our estradiol going up, increasing,
and with this resulting surge in LH.
Why does it only happen every four days?
How could you even get a four-day cycle
like that, circadian cycle?
So if you ovariectomize a female rodent and give back estrogen,
so here this little red dashed line
is mimicking if I gave them a constant source of estrogen.
If I gave them that constant source,
you end up having a daily LH surge.
So there is definitely a circadian timing signal
that comes every day and tells the animal
when to have an LH surge at a certain time a day.
Now, I want to also point out that it's definitely only
happening at one time a day.
Despite having this chronically elevated levels of estrogen,
it's not like the animal just freaks out and dumps
all of its LH all at once.
We call there's a window of time when
that LH is getting secreted.
So we do know, then, that there is a circadian timing signal.
We know that these cycle lengths are very regular.
In the rodents, it's either four or five days.
It's not four and a half.
You can't really have a half day.
So that's LH surge.
I'll get to the SCN in a minute.
I'm assuming you all know that.
Boy, I left that little slide like, hey, everybody,
look at these rodents having sex.
So another reproductive event controlled by the HPG axis
would be mating.
So I'm going to assume you all know actograms.
Yes?
Yeah, you're like, enough with the actograms.
So this is a female rodent, and she's free running.
And so, of course, these are all erectivity things.
If I put the dots on this one.
So they've put little dots on this figure for the days
when that female went into heat, that day of the estrous cycle
that we call estrous.
You may actually notice, since this is a hamster,
you may actually notice that on that day, when
they've put a dot, she actually had a phase advance.
She woke up earlier.
And in general, the activity is, the alpha
is elongated on that day when she's in heat,
when estradiol is highest.
So we have these dots indicating that every four days,
this hamster is going into heat.
So an additional piece of evidence,
then, that this is run by the circadian system
is that the estrous cycle free runs.
And instead of free running, it free runs,
what do they call it, quadrillion rhythm.
So the animal is having an estrous in an LH surge
every four days.
And it's four times the tau of that animal,
if that makes sense.
So if the animal's free running period is 23.2,
four times 23.2 hours, every unit that's about that,
so it can be 95.36 to 97.54 in this paper,
that's when that animal has that LH surge.
OK.
Further evidence, then, so this happens to be an LL.
We have this LH surge happens, and then the activity happens.
So the LH surge happens right before activity onset,
and it's phase locked.
The relationship of that is always the same.
So it's between one and four hours,
but this is a really tight relationship.
You phase advance activity, you're
phase advancing the LH surge.
OK.
The other thing that's happening in this,
guess I'll go back to this one, is
that they gave this animal something
that we call heavy water.
It's radioactive, I think.
I hadn't thought about this paper in a while.
And it lengthens the tau.
And so the same thing happens.
This animal gets a longer tau, and that estrous cycle
free runs, matching the length of that new tau.
OK.
All right.
So here's another reproductive event that happens,
and this would be the timing of birth or parturition.
Animals, of course, it would make sense
that you wouldn't want to be out and eating or running
from a predator, and then suddenly you're
giving birth in the middle of all that.
That kind of would be poor planning.
So it would be best to be timing your birth that
occurs when you're in your little nest.
OK.
So in this paper, I liked how they
named different countries here.
They ended up phase advancing and delaying
these animals at different times to try and see
if the animals were going to give birth
with a duration of time, or if they were going to time it
to a light-dark cycle.
And you can see, here's our control animals.
They clearly are giving birth during the lights-on period.
These are rats.
They don't want to give birth when they're
active, as we mentioned.
And another interesting thing to this pattern
is, so the majority of them are happening here in the light.
A few animals gave birth during the dark.
And then there's another kind of smaller clump over here.
They did do some delaying and advancing of animals.
These phase-advanced animals were
able to keep their birth happening
during the time of lights-on.
These delaying animals had a little bit of a problem.
You can see some that ended up giving birth
during their active period, or at least during the dark.
But for the most part, these animals
are basically entraining their rhythm
so that way they can give birth during their time
of inactivity.
So we have all these reproductive events.
And they all appear to be circadian.
But people have gone on to establish
that the SCN is critical to these events.
So here is a hamster.
You can see they've got our activity double plotted.
And here they put two little pluses for each of those days
that the animal was in estrus.
People love hamsters for reproduction and circadian
biology because they're so precise.
And their estrus cycles happen every four days.
This animal stopped having estrus cycles
after the SCN lesion.
And then they free ran it.
And those estrus cycles never came back.
As a side note, if you plant the SCN back in,
diffusible factors, do you guys hear about those?
You never get estrus cycles back.
You get activity patterns back, but not estrus,
indicating that the estrus rhythmicity regulation
needs a neural signal and a neural connection
and not just a diffusible factor.
People have taken this farther.
And if you take hamsters and put them into constant light,
you can get them to split their activity
bout into two components, a morning bout
and an evening bout.
In a female hamster, you can get these two components
to each have an LH surge phase locked
to the onset of activity of each of those bouts.
So here they put it in red and blue.
Sorry, colorblind people.
And they put a little sign like, so here
that star would be where this LH surge happened.
And that star is where that one happened.
So they end up having the phase locked relationship
that we've already talked about.
But they have two LH surges, essentially.
Also interesting is that LH surge
happens to be about half the amplitude of a full LH surge.
Physiologically, what does that do?
Whether or not they really ovulate?
They made it at either time?
I suppose they would.
What's the consequences?
I don't think anyone's ever followed up on it.
You know what?
I bet they have.
I bet they just haven't published it.
I think Luke has had a question.
Yeah, so if you added the deuterium water,
what was the physiological significance of that?
It ends up lengthening the tau, the free-running clock.
But I'm not sure what the mechanism is underlying that.
Do you know?
No, people, you irradiate animals.
You change the period.
Nobody knows.
It's sort of like people used to do those kind of manipulations,
sort of gee whiz, whether you're changing the mutating clock
genes, maybe something like that.
But nobody knows for sure.
It changes it consistently?
This animal actually looks like it affected it
for a period of time.
And then it regained its original tau,
just because I see this angle and that angle the same.
It lengthened it for a while.
Nobody really knows.
Yeah, that's probably from the 70s or something.
And they're still out there.
Yeah.
Why did they try this?
Yeah.
Yeah, there's not a whole lot of research
on females and reproduction.
So even though I'm showing you stuff from 1976,
I still cite this stuff.
There's not much.
Well, there's getting more new stuff.
So here's our split female hamster.
She's got two different activity bouts.
She's got two LH surges.
Then they did this really cool work.
So I've mentioned already, we had the hypothalamus
pituitary gonadal axis.
And so we've got GnRH neurons that we know
need to trigger that LH surge.
So they looked in the brains of these animals.
They killed animals at each of these LH surges.
And they stained them for GnRH and FOS.
And what they found was a hemi-SCN lit up with FOS.
Remember, they're having their LH surge
right before light's off, right before they're active.
So you're going to expect to see FOS
because the light might have stimulated it.
And so they have more FOS on one side.
It literally, if you'll have a picture,
I'll have to show you a picture.
It's completely filled with FOS on one side
and completely blank on the other.
And correspondingly, this picture here and this one here
are showing you a cross section through the brain.
This is a little rostral to where the SCN is.
This is the optic chiasm in the third ventricle.
These are where all these GnRH neurons are.
I think they're really super beautiful.
And I would get one as a tattoo if I could.
After I get hormones tattooed on my fingers.
Hormones, okay.
I digress, all right.
So these GnRH neurons are these huge bipolar neurons.
Then they have long, long dendritic processes and axons.
And so here they're indicating
that this GnRH neuron is active.
At the time of the LH surge,
you can stain this tissue for FOS
in the nucleus of GnRH neurons.
About 40% of them will express that,
indicating that they were transcriptionally busy.
Okay.
GnRH neurons, only one half of that brain
will express FOS, okay.
And it happens to correspond to that same half of the brain
where the SCN lit up.
And if you kill animals at this one,
they also have a hemi-SCN and GnRH neurons
that match the same side of the brain.
Okay.
I can't tell you like,
it's always gonna be left, right, left, right.
I mean, that's the assumption
because clearly this animal already died
and we can't check it at a later time point.
Okay.
But that's the presumption.
Okay.
So, evidence then on our circadian system
is regulating reproductive events.
And this is an incomplete list.
I could go on and on and on.
We know there's a daily rhythm
in the timing of the LH surge.
We actually know there's a daily rhythm in mating as well.
We know that the LH surge and estrus,
that period of heat,
free runs with a period four times tau
and we can phase shift it.
And when they phase shift,
they remain phase locked to one another.
Then we know lesions of the SCN
eliminates our estrus cyclicity.
It never comes back.
And split SCN hamsters,
split hamsters indicate that the SCN
is transcriptionally active at the time of the LH surge.
So, we get a pretty good idea about
that the circadian system is critical
and I'm gonna say specifically in rodents
for timing these reproductive events.
Okay.
So, what about the reverse relationship?
Do reproductive hormones alter rhythms?
And the answer is yes.
We know in females,
I've already just pointed out that every four days,
the hamster becomes more active
and she runs a lot more in her wheel.
So, we know that there are changes across the estrus cycle.
When hormones are changing,
we can look at activity in gonadectomized animals
compared to intact ones,
both males and females.
And we know hormones change during pregnancy.
We also see a change in rhythms.
We know that a change is just activity in a light-dark cycle
and we know gonadal hormones modifies our free running tau.
And there's a lot of new evidence,
you know, it's not a lot,
but there's new evidence saying
that there are hormone receptors within the SCN
that could be responsible for how hormones
feeds back on to the circadian clock.
All right.
Okay, so.
Hormones, if you're, you know,
female hamsters that are intact,
female hamsters, rats, degus,
surprisingly not mice.
Bummer for me.
Rats, grass rats,
whatever female rodent you can think of,
except for the one I work on apparently,
which stinks.
When estrogen is high,
they're going to run more,
they're gonna have a phase advance,
and they're gonna have a huge amount of activity.
I like to think of it as that they're up
and running in their wheel
because they're looking for a mate.
I gotta get out there.
I'm only in heat for four hours, okay?
We also know that their free running period
gets shortened on that day.
If I replace estrogen back to an ovexed animal
or variectomized animal,
the free running period will be shorter.
Female hamsters have an interesting pattern
of activity onset called scalloping.
And I was trying to allude to that.
I think this was a GenSwan paper where she had this.
So they call it scalloping
because it kind of looks like a little,
she wakes up early on her estrous day,
and then actually the next day she has a phase delay.
I like to think she has to sleep in
because she's so tired of all that running
she did the day before.
So they refer to this as scalloping.
It's really obvious in hamsters
and less obvious in other animals.
But so, they know from these intact studies
and again from the ovex studies
that if you give back estrogen or estrogen is high,
then the tau is shorter.
All right, we know that progesterone,
which is the hormone that comes on board after ovulation,
also lengthens circadian rhythms.
It always seems to, in general,
do the opposite of what estrogen does.
All right.
But we also know that there are sex steroid hormones
that affect daily activity rhythms in males.
So here's my small shout out to boys.
Okay.
All right, so here's a couple of examples.
So we have two different individual animals
and you can see them free running
in constant darkness up there.
And so the int is intact
and GDX is after they removed their gonads.
You can see an incredible difference
in the amount of activity
as soon as you remove their major source of androgens.
Okay.
You can also start mapping it following their gonadectomy.
It actually rearranges when they do wanna be awake
and running versus asleep.
So it changes that relationship as well.
So the alpha changes as well as the free running period
and the level of activity.
How do they know which hormone was responsible for this?
They took out the gonads.
Well, androgen receptors accept
both testosterone and dihydrotestosterone.
They're two separate androgens.
And so here is testosterone propionate.
They replaced it to a gonadectomized animal
and here's an animal that got DHT, another androgen.
So you can see very little activity
and replacing the hormone,
they get a restoration of activity.
That hydro testosterone is not,
I mean, it's restored, but look at the difference.
You know, and that's not the best picture
because they actually really believe
the whole thing is an androgen effect.
Other papers from Ray Silver's lab
all say that it's just pure androgen.
I don't, I mean, I think she'd accept it
if I talked with her and said,
I think there's an estrogen effect,
but she's sold on the androgen.
Oh, yeah, because the other one is
if you give all these androgens back to females,
you get the exact same results.
Okay, so here's period and they're showing
intact animals, animals that are castrated
and then animals getting back androgens
and these two different kinds
and you can see the restoration of it.
This little black dot is because
they're indicating that there's a sex difference in period.
Here's activity duration, alpha,
and amount of activity and again,
as soon as you castrate these animals,
their activity goes down, their alpha,
their whole period of when they feel like running
gets a lot shorter and hormone replacement brings that back.
Yeah, but you're right over there.
That one didn't seem to bring back the amount as much.
I think it, but I think in other papers it does.
Okay, so they give back all these hormones
and so in males, the effect is the same
as what I've been describing for females.
All right, okay, so what about these mechanisms?
Well, in this male work,
they looked at androgen receptors
and it turns out the SCN is chock full of androgen receptors
and boy mice have more than girl mice.
If you castrate these animals,
you eliminate those androgen receptors
and if you give them back hormone,
you can restore those sex differences,
you can amp it back up, okay?
And as I mentioned, the gonadectomizing,
the males alters their pattern of activity.
You lose some out of it and you can restore it.
See my picture, okay.
So here's male and female and that top picture
is just to orient you to the SCN
so they stained that for arginine vasopressin.
This one, which is kind of dim, is androgen receptors
and then they show you the overlay.
So boy mice have a ton of androgen receptors
that females don't have, okay?
See, I'm all about the estrogen receptors
so there's estrogen receptors there too, just not a lot.
Okay.
Oh my goodness, I spelled rhythms wrong, look at that.
Shame on me, wow.
I'm gonna be drummed out of SRBR, okay.
All right, human rhythms.
Is there a daily rhythm in these same reproductive events
that I've just told you about in humans?
What about LH inovulation?
What about human mating behavior?
What about the timing of birth?
So let's talk about those in women.
The end all be all kind of bottom line for human work
in reproduction and circadian rhythms
is that circadian rhythms may not be nearly as important
to I should say animals because it's true of women
as well as other species that have this long estrous cycle
as they are to animals that have a short one,
the four day one, okay?
So humans, again, have that same hormonal events
that I was telling you about in rodents
but the days are extended so it's a lot longer.
We still have that rise in estrogen,
just takes a long period of time, we still have an LH surge.
And then after the follicle ruptures and releases the egg,
we have a corpus luteum that forms, okay?
So that follicle kind of scrunches up
and becomes a new structure.
The corpus luteum is making progesterone,
the follicle is what makes estrogen, okay?
So we can actually call that a follicular phase
and we call this one a luteal phase for that reason, okay?
Rodents, most rodents don't have a true luteal phase.
The progesterone goes up but not for very long, okay?
Okay, all right, she means business.
Okay, so are there rhythms associated
with the menstrual cycle the same way rhythms
are associated with changes in the estrous cycle?
Yeah, this is an example of risk-taking behavior
changing at different stages of the menstrual cycle.
Menstruation, postmenstruation, ovulation,
premenstrual cycle stages, okay?
Changes in food craving, changes in mood.
Women are more likely to have depressive symptoms
during the luteal phase of their cycle
than in the follicular phase, okay?
In fact, there's even the premenstrual dysphoria disorder
where there's a huge change in mood
that's linked to the menstrual cycle stages.
Food cravings, I think you might get anecdotes
from your friends about changes in activity levels,
et cetera, okay?
What is the pill non-coding?
Oh, it's contraception and non-contraception.
So, cycling women are in white, okay?
So, risk-taking scores, at the time of ovulation
it's going, it's lowest at ovulation
but she's having a normal cycle.
These ones in white bars and the ones
that are on the pill have their reproductive hormones
kind of clamped with contraception.
Okay, so is there circadian rhythm
in the timing of the LH surge?
Now, I said the LH surge is phase-locked
to the timing of activity.
Humans are day-active or diurnal,
they wake up during the day,
so is the LH surge happening when they wake up?
So, here's 8 a.m. to noon, here's 4 to 8 a.m.
This was a study using 155 women
and they did get the majority,
this is frequency of the LH surge,
the number of individuals,
and they do get the majority of them
having an LH surge at these two times.
I mean, it's a big window, midnight to 8 a.m., okay?
A later study with a smaller number of women,
it was only about 16, actually narrowed it down
and said it happened between 4 and 8 a.m., okay?
Great, so circadian system is important, right?
Not really, actually, okay?
So, in this study they brought in intact,
I shouldn't call women intact,
women with their ovaries came on in
and they did a continuous, constant routine,
so they kept the women up for 32 hours,
so that's why their activity pattern up there is constant.
The gray period was when they normally wanted to sleep.
Body temperature maintained a rhythmicity
where it went down at times
when they normally would be sleeping.
I mentioned LH can be pulsatile
and so all those little triangles
are indicating when it went up,
which is kind of an hourly thing.
But they did not get a rhythm,
so this is one individual woman, okay?
They did not get a rhythm in LH or FSH, okay?
So this is in the early follicular phase,
so not at the time of the LH surge,
but they're not getting a daily rhythm in this.
Here's all the women they had, so they have 11.
This is between days one and seven,
like I said, early follicular.
Absolutely no circadian rhythm
and their definition of no circadian rhythm
was that they fit lines to it
and so they get a sinusoidal curve
is the best one for temperature
and linears were the best ones for LH.
Okay, so does that mean the circadian system
is not important for the LH surge?
Well, all the grant reviewers are convinced
that I do not need to study it because of that.
Oh, I'm getting bitter, okay.
All right, all right, what about timing of mating?
In rodents, again, timing of mating happens
on that one day when estrogen is high
and it is phase locked.
You can't make a mate at all times.
They're only gonna mate at one window.
Humans with our estrous reproductive cycles,
we have a menstrual cycle, not an estrous cycle.
Humans and primates can copulate
at any stage across the cycle, okay?
So it doesn't matter if estrogen's high or not.
So we have this unique ability
to not have that event timed to hormones.
There is a strong circadian component to intercourse
with a major peak at late night
and a small peak in the early morning.
So really the question is, is that circadian?
What do you think?
No one's gonna be like, I'll tell you when I have intercourse
and I'll tell you if it's circadian.
Okay, you're not gonna tell me, fine, fine.
All right, humans do have a pattern at mating
and it does actually correspond to estrogen secretion
but doesn't have a circadian component.
So here's time of day and here's where people
are having intercourse, they're doing it right before sleep.
This happens to be college age people in this study.
Yeah, they don't ask people with kids, that's for sure.
Okay, so they did actually ask them,
no, really, it's factual, not personal, okay?
All right, don't be like, now I know too much about her.
No, I didn't tell you anything about me, trust me.
Okay, so they did interview these people
or ask them in a survey about why they were having
intercourse at these times of day
and it comes out to societal or personal issues
like that's when we were in bed
or that's when I wasn't tired, right?
So it's very unlikely that this rhythm
is a circadian rhythm in humans.
All right, there is a rhythm in human mating
linked to estrogen though.
So here's females that are initiating.
So female initiated is here in black bars
and so females at the time they're ovulating,
estrogen's high, they're more likely to initiate
than at other stages and this is where they point out
that if you just looked at couples
and how often they had intercourse,
then they'd have this line.
But if you looked at when women were initiating,
well, if you were gonna ask that question,
then a different pattern emerges, okay?
Okay, so that's, and of course,
what about timing of birth?
Well, you all probably know someone
who was in labor for days and days and days
but they do can look at labor onset.
I said in rodents, they're gonna give birth
when they're in their burrow.
We're diurnal, so we're gonna give birth
when we are inactive, so typically at night.
There's been a gajillion studies
and they all typically find the same thing
although sometimes the timing shifts a little bit.
So here is labor onset and rupture of membranes
and they looked at the time of when those things happen.
One study looked at when women showed up at the hospital
which I think may not have been nearly as accurate
but at least they can say labor begins at times of rest
as occurs in other animals, so you see this big peak here,
kind of around midnight, okay?
All right, so I could show you
a gajillion pictures of that.
Okay, so humans may or may not be circadian.
I think the jury's out on that.
What if we asked what happens if you disrupt rhythms?
What if we changed rhythms in humans
and then saw if that impacted reproduction?
So this is International Agency for Cancer.
This came out in 2010.
This was their top 20 list of things that cause cancer.
Shift work is number 19, okay?
So everything else on this is a tangible,
I'm a chemical, I'm a fume, okay?
And then we have this one kind of ephemeral thing.
You can't really put it in a jar, et cetera,
and it's shift work.
So they say shift work
is a significant cancer-causing agent, okay?
And we all know, we've all experienced jet lag.
Probably we haven't done shift work as much.
Vacationers, sleep-deprived students,
yes, you really are phase-shifting yourself.
Traveling athletes, they have sleep disruptions.
You get sleepy at the wrong times of day.
You're wide awake at other times of day.
There's definitely memory impairments.
Gastrointestinal upset is one of the most significant ones,
changes in appetite, okay?
So this would be like an acute change in rhythms.
All right, what happens to female fertility
in reproductive cycles?
So that's kind of the questions I like to ask.
All right, so female shift workers in airline crews.
So I would just point out
that this is now kind of more chronic.
They have, they're more likely
to have irregular menstrual cycles,
either lengthening or shortening.
They're more likely to experience pain
during their menstrual cycle.
They have a much harder time getting pregnant.
Once they get pregnant,
they're more likely to miscarry or have preterm birth.
When their babies are born,
their babies are typically more likely
to have low birth weight.
Women who are shift working
do have an increased risk of breast cancer.
And if women are gonna have a C-section,
they've looked at medical outcomes
of C-sections given during the morning
and the afternoon and at night.
If they have it at night,
there's an increase in medical complications.
I hesitated putting that last one on
because it was things like infection,
and I thought maybe the problem was the doctors
who were sleep deprived and not the woman.
So I'm not sure what shift work issue that was, okay.
Okay, again though, the jury's kind of out on this.
So not all studies find
this significant effect of shift work, okay?
Sure, the risk of breast cancer could be there.
But typically most studies find that it's only moderate.
And most times they only find it
in women working on shifts for 15 years or 20 years.
Some studies have not found any impact
of shift work on menstrual cycle regularity.
Shift work has a minimal impact
on preterm birth and birth weight.
So people aren't finding a lot of effect here.
And shift work doesn't really seem to impact other issues
like gestational hypertension or preeclampsia,
so it's not increasing those problems.
All right, so I tell you all this stuff about rodents
and then say this is really significant.
And then you go to the human literature
and it's tougher sometimes
to find a significant health problem.
Now you can come up with lots of reasons why.
Some of it can be that people
self-select right out of shift work.
So people who don't handle it as well
can choose not to do it.
And people who stick around for 20 years
stay with it longer.
So that's one issue.
Yeah, that's one of the bigger ones that comes up.
We can look at disruptions in rhythms
by looking at clock knockout animals.
And here again we do see,
we begin to see all those problems.
So first of all, clock gene rhythms,
even if they're slave oscillators,
they're found in the ovary,
the uterus, the fallopian tubes,
every reproductive organ you can think of, basically.
We know in PER1 and PER2 knockout mice, KO mice,
they typically have irregular estrous cycles
and decreased fertility.
So they are still having hormonal changes,
but it's just not working as well.
Clock knockout mice, this was one of the first studies
that really looked at all of the different ones,
the different issues that could happen.
They had irregular estrous cycles.
Their LH surge just wasn't happening as much.
They had decreased fertility,
and they think with the knockout of that gene
they had trouble giving birth,
like it was missing something.
BMAL knockout mice, they mate,
but they don't produce young.
And you may not even see that published too much,
because my friend who did that one
said she couldn't get them to have sex at all.
So they just weren't into it.
Yeah, she said they were weak little things.
So they get them all from heterozygous.
They must, yeah.
That was, Takahashi had those.
That was, or Meneker, it was Jen Mohawk who was doing it.
She said they just were tiny little sick things
that didn't feel like doing it.
All right, all right.
So what about clock genes in women?
Do we know anything about clock genes in people?
Good question.
So of course we can't go mutate clock genes,
but they can find clock gene polymorphisms,
slight variations in the sequence
for each of these genes.
And so they can look at NPAS2 and clock variants,
and they do see certain variants
associated with an increased risk of breast cancer.
They do see polymorphisms in aryl hydrocarbon receptor,
nuclear translocator, blah, blah, blah,
something like that, ARNTL,
are related to an increase in pregnancies and miscarriages.
Women with this certain ARNTL1
had both an increase in the number of pregnancies
and an increase in the number of miscarriages.
Okay.
And women with this NPAS2 variant
had a decrease in the number of pregnancies.
So there is some link of clock genes
to reproductive outcomes varying in people.
But again, these of course are all correlational studies.
Okay.
All right, so that's what I want to tell you
because I knew your class was probably an hour.
Do you have any questions?
I do talk a mile a minute, I know I do.
I can show you, I'm gonna show you another funny one.
Okay.
This is another human one, 207,000.
This is the one where women present to the hospital
with uterine contractions.
I want to show you,
there's another funny one about human rhythms.
Oh, here.
Whoa!
Frickin' MacBook, all right.
I'm not a Mac person.
Okay.
That's the rhythm in when people have sex.
And so it's a weekly rhythm.
Okay.
So they looked at random distribution
if you're gonna do it every day,
and that would be your average,
but really it's just on Saturday.
So it's probably a, yeah.
Okay.
Okay, so I really could go on and on
about all sorts of genes and rhythms,
but I will leave it at that.
Because I've been told I can overwhelm people
with too much information.
I do this to undergrads when I'm like interviewing them,
I'm like, let me tell you what I know,
and then I do that to them, yeah.
Yeah.
Do hormones like luteinizing hormone
and follicle stimulating hormone,
do they have,
well, I guess they're under control of the hypothalamus,
but does, so then GNRH,
does that have like E-box elements upstream of it, or?
GNRH neurons within the brain,
oh, no, that's estrogen receptors.
GNRH neurons have clot genes within them.
I think they find it more likely when they do it
in the dish more than in vivo tissue,
but they do find that.
Luteinizing hormone and follicle stimulating hormone
do synchronize clot genes on the ovary.
If you put ovarian tissue in a dish,
and it was cycling with PER genes,
if you dumped those hormones on it,
seems to be important.
In one study, they took the ovaries of rats
that had not had babies or even had estrous cycles,
and they put them in a dish,
and there was no clot gene rhythms
in these immature ovaries.
They dumped LH on it, and PER rhythm started.
There is a possibility that the LH
is some kind of factor to start that.
Yeah.
Yeah, well, yeah.
I'm not sure if anyone's looked at estrogen receptors.
For the boy mice, yes, it definitely goes away.
Yep.
If you put back testosterone on either male or female mice,
you will get androgen receptors in both, both sexes,
but females ordinarily don't have androgen receptors.
They're presented with receptors.
Yeah.
So in that story about hormones acting on receptors,
I like to think about estrogen
and its effects on circadian rhythms,
but I think about females.
In general, no one's really looked at that.
The consensus would be, though,
that if estrogen increases activity,
it's doing it by acting on estrogen receptors
in the medial preoptic area outside of the SCN,
primarily because there's only about,
of all the SCN cells,
only like 4% of them have estrogen receptors,
and there's more estrogen receptor beta than alpha.
So people, that's why the people
who do the androgen receptor story
believe androgen receptor is really much more important
because it's everywhere,
and how could such a few small number
of estrogen receptors have an impact?
But it's a good question
about what happens to estrogen receptors in the SCN
in ovexed females.
I mean, yeah.
So, I mean, we know that estrogen feeding back
changes per genes, both in the brain and in the ovary,
so in female rats, we've seen that.
But again, no one's thought of that mechanism
about whether it has to be hormones directly on the SCN
or if it could just be hormones
that talk to the POA that talks to the SCN.
So would you therefore predict
that whatever's happening on the day
where they start running early
and have the long active period,
that that's not acting at the SCN,
but it's some other site that...
That's the thought.
There's also the possibility
that if estrogen increases activity,
people have even talked about
being like a peripheral activation,
it just makes them run more jittery or something.
And then you get the additional issue
of increased activity has a non-photic feedback effect
on the clock, and there's a direct link
to the amount of activity in tau.
Tau is shorter in animals that run more
and have a longer alpha.
So you have to separate some of those things out as well.
No one's looked at hormones
and their effect developmentally,
so I like to think about that issue as well.
I mean, you may have heard about developmental issues
with respect to circadian rhythms,
but we certainly, I mean, alcoholism,
there's one guy who did a bunch of alcohol effects
on the SCN, but no one's looked at hormones,
and yet we're really concerned about BPA
and all sorts of other environmental estrogens.
So I think that's something to think about.
And that doesn't need estrogen receptors in the SCN
or anywhere else to have those changes.
Yeah, but no, the general consensus
is that the estrogen receptors in the SCN are not needed.
And I may be the only one who cares,
so I may go figure that out.
Yeah.
This is kind of a question about the diffusible factors.
So with the SCN ablation, we lose most,
I mean, all hormone cycles.
Do you think that, or do you know
if the GnRH cells in the, I believe it's the arcuate,
do they express VIP or ABP receptors?
No, so, no, kispeptin's what you're thinking of
that's in the arcuate, and GnRH is mostly,
it's all in the preoptic area.
Oh, okay.
But GnRH neurons, probably I should publish this,
have VIP receptor two on them.
That changes with changes in the estrous cycle.
I should really get on that.
That was my hypothesis for the timing of the LH third,
that the increasing estrogen is telling GnRH neurons
what time of day it is, or basically,
like, you should get busy,
and that's when the VIP receptors show up.
So the daily signal's coming.
Why isn't anything happening?
And it only happens every four days.
It's gotta coincide with that high estrogen.
So yeah, they do have VIP receptors.
There's a sex difference, if I remember,
in VIP receptors on GnRH neurons,
and with boys having more than girls.
There's a couple papers about that, yeah.
Well, thank you.
Thank you for your computer and your adapter.
Thank you.

