Photonic Crystal Enhanced Microscopy for the Study of Cell Attachment
2 Video Views·Sep 5, 2023
"Photonic Crystal Enhanced Microscopy for the Study of Cell Attachment"
Erich Lidstone, M.D./Ph.D. Scholar, Bioengineering
CNST Nanotechnology Workshop 2013
So, I am Eric Woodstone, I'll be talking about our work using photonic crystal biosensors
in the Cunningham lab for the characterization of cell attachment.
So it's a 15 minute talk, I thought maybe I could do without an outline, but just so
you know there's an end in sight.
We'll be talking about photonic crystal enhanced microscopy, which is a new technique we've
developed and then we'll specifically use it to study how two different cell types interact
with one another in a sort of co-culture environment.
So there are a few different ways to analyze cell attachment or quantify cell attachment
using label-free techniques, including SPR imaging, impedance-based imaging, and interferometric
techniques.
And then we have photonic crystals that we're hoping to add to that list of techniques.
So to perform this imaging, we take advantage of some of the far-field properties of PC
biosensors, which basically consists of the fact that if we take a photonic crystal, which
is basically a repeating grating structure that is laid down on top of a low refractive
index substrate, and then we use a high refractive index coating to get this repeating photonic
crystal structure, if we shine a broad wavelength of light at that crystal and then look at
the reflected light, we can see a peak reflectance or a dip in transmission.
So here's just a little bit of characterization of our sensors.
We use a low refractive index photoreplical moldable PET for the foundation of the grating,
and then we use, as a high refractive index coating, we use titanium dioxide.
And we can be relatively flexible in manufacturing these sensors, so here are a couple sensors
affixed to standard microscope slides.
We can also fabricate similar sensors and affix them to microplates.
So here's a little bit of characterization for the specific sensors that I'll be talking
about today.
Basically our resonant wavelength is around 633 or 638, and then our resonant angle is
at about three and a quarter degrees for this sensor.
So in addition to being able to quantify shifts in the resonant wavelength as a result of
localized refractive index change, we can quantify shifts in the resonant angle as well.
And it'll become a little more clear what I mean by wavelength and angle over the next
few slides.
So another interesting property of these sensors is that when large items or when proteins,
basically anything with a refractive index that differs from that of the surrounding
environment, comes within a close range of the sensor, so within a couple hundred nanometers,
that structure can actually couple into the electric field created by our photonic crystal.
And by doing so, it will change the resonant characteristics of the sensor over that area.
And so here we see that if we scan over a range of angles, so if you look at the plot,
we can scan over a range of angles and see that there's a dip in transmission at what
we call a resonant angle.
So our instrumentation is basically a standard fluorescence microscope with the addition
of an angle-tunable translational mirror, which is shown in the lower left-hand corner.
And by adding this mirror, we can take a series of images over a range of incident angles
and then compute the angle of minimum transmission, which is our resonant characteristic.
So here are just a few images walking us through the process.
So if you look at panel A in the top left, we have basically a bright field image of
a few cells we have in culture.
And then if we take the red pixel and the blue pixel and plot out the intensity of transmission
that those areas of the sensor receive over a range of angles, we can see that the area
of cell attachment in the blue curve shows a lower angle of incidence, a lower angle
of minimum transmission than the red pixel.
And so then if we map all of the pixels in the field collected by our CCD, we can see
that we have relative peaks or relative increases in the shift of angle of minimum transmission
corresponding with the areas of cell attachment.
And we believe this to be due to the cells actually laying down a protonaceous attachment
or a protein matrix over those areas.
So here in one of our first papers using this technique, we looked at how apoptosis could
affect this cell attachment and whether we could measure it using our technique.
And we see that in the top set of panels, we can see a cell that has outstretched cell
attachments.
And then after we induce apoptosis, we see kind of retraction of those attachments and
rounding up of the cell body.
And that correlates with a return of that area of cell attachment on the green curve.
It looks more like the area off the cell after we induce that treatment, after we induce
that cell death.
So one of the problems that we hope to address using this technique is that of specific apoptotic
recognition.
So when cells undergo programmed cell death, they actually display a number of residues
that indicate something about that cell death.
And they either indicate that it's a benign process or that it needs to be cleaned up
by local histiocytes or macrophages in a certain way.
And so basically it's a way for the dying cell to educate its neighbors about the process
that caused its death.
And so today we'll be looking at how our model apoptosing cells or cells undergoing apoptosis
interact with our responder cells.
And so our target cells will be the T cell line where we are capable of inducing apoptosis.
And then our responder cells, our local histiocytes, macrophages, we're currently using HEK-derived
cells for that.
So current detection methods for this type of interaction rely on fluorescence and proliferation
and tracking cell populations over a number of days.
Now this kind of removes you a few steps from the event with which you're concerned and
doesn't really have single cell resolution.
It also requires that you know the specific markers that you're interested in working
with prior to your experiment.
So you can't go in blind and really learn something about your system.
So with a label-free approach, we hope to change that.
And basically this little animation is going to show us how the responder assay works.
So we culture our responder cells first on the sensor and then wait for them to attach,
which we register as a shift in wavelength.
And then we add our target cells, which have maybe been treated to induce apoptosis or
maybe not, and then see basically how those cells interact with our responder cells.
And so in certain situations, if these target cells are undergoing apoptosis, certain cell
types will respond and increase their attachment.
Other cell types or benign conditions will not elicit that same increase in attachment.
So if we have a label-free way to basically quantify this increase in cell attachment,
we can get at characterizing that interaction without the use of fluorescent labels.
So here we have, we basically performed that experiment and multiplexed it in multi-well
plates and basically found that at a 30-minute interval, we have maximal shift between the
different treatment conditions.
And so the maximal shift is seen with our apoptotic cells added at a 10 to 1 ratio and
at about 30 minutes after treatment.
And then the line of triangles indicates the addition of viable cells, which induced a
shift in cell attachment, but not that much from the responder cells.
And then if we don't add anything at all, we see a minimal shift that kind of falls over time.
And so if we move on and try and characterize this at a higher resolution using our angle-based
setup, the microscope basically, we can see that we can basically find these areas of
cell attachment using our brightfield mode and then perform our AMT assay and look for
cells that have an increased area of cell attachment.
And then after we add our targets, we note that those cells that have had a good attachment
to begin with have a markedly increased attachment after treatment.
And so if we quantify and basically look at a number of these cells, count them and average
them, we can see that prior to target addition, there are relatively similar levels of attachment.
Post-target addition, we see increases in attachment density in response to the addition
of apoptotic cells.
And then just to make it a little bit easier to look at these graphs, we've subtracted
the difference.
And so the bottom net AMT shift, we can see that a one-to-one ratio of apoptotic to responder
cells results in a greater AMT shift than a lower ratio or a one-to-ten apoptotic to
responder ratio, basically showing that there's a dose-dependent response in terms of this
response to apoptotic or display of apoptotic antigen.
So in conclusion, we've shown that we can measure cell-matrix interactions nearing the
single-cell level with our new approach.
And we've demonstrated that we can detect cell-cell signaling and interactions between
multiple cell types.
And through a combination of high-throughput and high-resolution methods, we can kind of
use our label-free techniques to understand which interactions or which cell types we
might want to take a closer look at and maybe invest some time in finding specific interactions
and specific markers.
And so with that, I'd just like to thank you for your time and attention, and I'd be happy
to take any questions.
Oh, I forgot, it's actually a couple days after Marty McFly returned to the future,
so I don't know how many of you have received this internet meme via email, but Marty McFly
should be around somewhere.
We have time for a few questions.
Oh, sure.
So thank you, Eric.
I have a question about the sort of ratios.
Is there a reason why you think we were getting a higher response to the one-to-one interaction?
Even though you had that ten-to-one ratio, was it really ten-to-one interaction?
We can see you kind of do it when you see it that way.
So that's actually a little bit difficult.
So we actually found that our one-to-one ratio here is a one-to-one ratio of responders to
– I'm sorry, our one-to-one ratio here is our ratio of targets to responders.
So perhaps I misspoke.
So basically the higher concentration of targets gave us a higher response here.
So this does make sense.
When we switched to imaging, to doing our higher-resolution imaging, we found that if
we used the same concentrations we used in basically the high-throughput system, if we
used those concentrations, we basically couldn't image the cells based on how many floating
cells were kind of passing through our field as we imaged our series.
So it was kind of difficult to get a sharp image with those concentrations.
I understand that when they sell the radiance also, they sell the radiance being shipped.
So what causes this kind of resonance?
So because the surrounding medium in this instance is closer to that of water, we kind
of reference our shifts of angle of minimum transmission from basically what the medium
is without the presence of cells.
So we take a background image of basically just the sensor with cell medium on it, and
then we add our cells, allow them time to attach, and then take another measurement
and subtract the difference.
So what we believe that we're imaging as a result of that cell attachment, an increased
protein deposition, is the increased refractive index of the protein with respect to the medium,
which has some serum protein floating around, but hopefully not as much as the attachments
the cells are putting down.
So in terms of the refractive index change, because all the cells have pretty much the
same level of composition, how about the selectivity of this?
So this assay has zero selectivity.
The way that we can kind of bypass that is if we introduce some sort of specificity.
So we can code our sensors with different growth factors or different proteins.
So we have some other experiments where we've coded with collagen and fibronectin and cultured
fibroblasts, or I'm sorry, cultured myocardial cells.
And we've seen that the myocardium can grow basically, that the myocytes can grow if those
factors are present.
But if they're not present, the cells basically round up, stay on the verge of viable for
a couple days, and then eventually die.
Thank you.
No problem.
Okay, that's the time.
Everybody, well done.
Thank you.

