The Effect of Substrate Stiffness on the Apparent Stress Cells Experience during Cyclic Strain
Sep 5, 2023
"The Effect of Substrate Stiffness on the Apparent Stress Cells Experience during Cyclic Strain"
Heather Huntsman, Kinesiology and Community Health
(Advisors: Marni Boppart and Hyun Joon Kong)
CNST Nanotechnology Workshop 2013
So like Laura said by way of Marnie, I'm going to be presenting my work from Germany
So it's slightly different in that this is a little bit more of a proof-of-concept
Project that I was able to complete in a really short amount of time, but it has a lot of applications to my to my main work
so
Yeah, we're just gonna go with that
so
In talking about the way that cells experience their environment
There's this component called the mechanical micro environment and there's been several groups that have looked at
how this affects cell behavior whether you're talking about differentiation with
Dennis Disher and Angler's group or you're talking about
protein expression or proliferation or migration
You have many different mechanical signals that are influencing cell behavior
and this is also or this can be described by not only substrate stiffness, but also
exogenous strain that is applied to the cell and that these are examples of
the differences in cell behavior due to their mechanical environment
The main focus of this project was to see if we can get these two components of the mechanical environment to
To not it. Can we get their components we if we can get them to
Interact and if there's a difference in cell behavior because of their interaction. Does that make sense?
So substrate stiffness and the exogenous strain that's placed on cells
Does that have an interaction and is that gonna regulate cell behavior differently? So that's kind of big picture concept of this project
The challenge was really just establishing this system
so there's a lot of groups that have tried to do it and it's really difficult to get soft substrates to
To be able to
Deform them and strain them. And so I feel like I was kind of in the right place at the right time
They basically knew about 15 ways that didn't work
so we decided to try a simple way and that's just taking PDMS at different ratios and casting it them directly into a base and
Then cyclically straining that so there was no gluing that took place. It was really just
Casting the gels directly into the base
And what we were able to come up with is a range of stiffnesses within
11 kilopascals all the way to 110 and
we tested that through the
Determining what the shear modulus was with a rotational rheometer and
Significant for my work is within that range you have the physiologically relevant stiffnesses of both healthy skeletal muscle and
Diseased aged skeletal muscle because as you have disease progression you have increasing in
Stiffness, so I'm going to come back to that concept later when I talk about future application
But just kind of keep that in mind. I have four different stiffnesses and they're within the range of
skeletal muscle
So again, just really simple concept
All we're going to do is we're going to strain those different stiffnesses all at the same rate
so there's going to be an 8% deformation and
At different time points we kind of freeze the cells in time and see if the response is different
at the different time points by stiffness
assessing 60 cells per time point and the response that I'm looking at the mechanical response is
cells in response to the strain this is well established from the work that they have done at Max Planck is
Specifically fibroblasts will reorient themselves 90 degrees perpendicular to this uniaxial strain
And that minimizes the amount of stress that those cells experience. So
It's just a really simple marker of
mechanical response
The hypothesis being that they're going to they're going to respond differently at the different time points on the different stiffnesses
as far as analysis goes I
Fixed the cells I stained them with phalloidin to be able to visualize their action stress fibers
And then I looked at at the kind of the macro level the cells orientation itself and then intracellularly
The orientation of the action stress fibers themselves. So kind of a macro to
internal
measurement of reorientation
and one of the first first things that we noticed is that
This is what we expected and other people have shown this but on the different stiffnesses you have different spreading of the cells
so the area of the cells
If you look at the red line for the stiffest
Substrate 110 kilopascals. They spread out more and are are in contact
with greater area
With the stiff with the substrate itself
So they potentially have greater
Capacity to sense the strain that they're experiencing because there's more focal adhesions and those focal adhesions are attached to this actin
cytoskeleton and
Over time that that difference is maintained and then this is these are just
population level images phase contrast of just what the cells look like representative images and
Again, the axis of strain is in the XY
Direction and if you look over time, there's pretty much randomness on the first two stiffnesses
They're what they're I'm going to show you the graphical
Representation of this but if you can see that there doesn't seem to be a preference for perpendicular to that XY direction
But if you look at the two stiffer
Substrates, sorry
You can see at the later time points. You're starting to see that preference for 90 degrees
Which is the cell response that I'm interested in. So this is just putting it into
a
Quantitation and that is over time. I know this is kind of a lot to take into
a
Lot to take in at this point, but I thought it was really important to be able to see them
Contrasted by time. So the lines are the different stiffnesses and you can see over time
Well, if we started at time zero at baseline, there's really no preference around along the x-axis. You have
180 degrees of orientation and if you look at time zero, there's really no preference for any one direction
But as you increase in time the two solid lines the red line and the blue line are the two stiffer
Substance or substrates you can start to see there's a preference for that 90 degree orientation
And it does kind of seem to be a dose response
The stuffer the substrate the less preference you have for that time point. We decided to go out 12 hours
Because what they had shown on this on a one mega kilopascal, sorry one mega Pascal
Substrate in eight hours. There was complete reorientation
So we thought 12 hours was enough and I didn't analyze the data until I wasn't no longer in Germany
so
Even though it's still only about 60 or 50 percent at time point 12 hours. You can still see that there's a difference in the response
Yes, all fiberglassed
and so
Again, looking at five different graphs all at once can kind of be overwhelming
So what I mean what I did was I took out kind of the response region that I was interested in. So 15 degrees within
that reorientation
response
window and
This shows it a little bit better. So by time by stiffness, you can see there's a quicker response on the stiffer
Substrate so the red compared to the orange or any of the other colors for that matter
Then the next data point I wanted to show you is just the the actin stress fiber orientation so
In order to do this analysis, it was just a image J macro and it went through doing a fast for your transformation to
kind of tease out where those actin stress fibers were and then it would give me a mean orientation of the
internal structures within the cell and
what I did then was I took that number and I
Correlated it with the orientation of the cell as a whole to kind of say that maybe the internal structures are driving that response
Because they're those are what are sensing the the strain itself. And as you can see
On all of this all of the substrates over time that correlation. These are just the R values are increasing
So if you go from 0 to 12 all those numbers increase and then if you go from 11 to 110
Then you can also see that the correlation strengthens
So the relationship between the cell orientation and internal structures is tighter on the stiffer substances
so just
kind of overarching conclusions that I drew from this information is that
Cells spread varying they the spread of the cells varies by the substrate stiffness and
They have a greater
Capacity to sense that mechanical strain. That's kind of a no-brainer. We thought that's what was going to happen
And that's that is exactly what happened
The cellular force avoidance reaction, which was the mechanical response that we were measuring varied by substrate stiffness
in accordance with our hypothesis
There was a relationship between the whole cell and the actin stress fibers and it was more strongly correlated on the stiffer substrates
and then
This is kind of where I start reaching a little bit, but this may have implications for signal mechano transduction
And so when you're considering the mechanical micro environment
This is something you need to take into consideration the stiffness of the tissue
In addition to the exogenous strain that's placed on the tissue whether it's shear stress
Tension compression
Stuff like that. So as a muscle physiologist
And a muscle physiologist that works with stem cells the mechanical environment is a very big component of our
Of a big very big signal in the cells that we
Are studying so the mesenchymal stem cell found within muscle tissue
Main focus of our lab is looking at how do these cells contribute to growth and repair and
I'm also in the kinesiology department
So I call it mechanical strain when I'm with you guys and then when I go to the other meetings, I call it exercise
so exercise
Mechanical strain we know from some of our other work that that's an important signal for growth factor release for these cells
And that has the potential to influence the growth and repair and adaptation for several different tissue types within skeletal muscle
and so
What's exciting about this project for me is now I have this PDMS cell culture system that mimics skeletal muscle microenvironments
And I can do a better job of kind of teasing out that mechanical microenvironment component and how that regulates
cell behavior and specifically I work with looking at restoring or
Preventing the loss of skeletal muscle in aged individuals, which is something that everybody
unfortunately has to deal with at some point in their life, so
I'm excited about using this new system in my future work. So
with that I'll thank my lab all the people at Max Planck and
Some of my engineering friends that have reached out and helped me analyze the data and my funding
funding sources as well
Thanks
It's good exercise
Have you looked at the focal adhesion in all the cases?
I'm wondering if anywhere on this deeper subject you will have more focal adhesion in your body cell
and if you think about outside the signaling
they provide probably the heaviest in the signaling path
they will provide some cues
so I'm wondering
the increased response that you're seeing
is because of the already higher focal adhesion percent
because of the higher signal
so I'm wondering
if you think about outside the signaling
they provide probably the heaviest in the signaling path
they will provide some cues
so I'm wondering
is this just because of higher signal
or you could say because of the higher stiffness
I think maybe
on the
microchyitis
and will analyze
the area
you can my identify
by the orientation
we'll see a little bit of orientation
from the software
and you could see that with the graphs as well
Right, yeah, I actually did a Paxilin stain, so I have those images, they didn't turn out
as great as I had hoped, but I could look more into that, but I definitely agree that
there's probably a tight relationship between the response and the focal adhesion, so.
Thank you.
I'm just curious, I'm not sure if any difference in the actual strain of the cells talk, like
if the cells start to say that?
Yeah, I don't really know how to explain that, so I left that out of the talk, but on the
stiffer gels, you definitely saw greater deformation, so I would apply, I would give them 24 hours
of attachment time, and then I would, just in real time, do imaging of a relaxed substrate
and then 8% deformation, and there was 23% greater deformation on the stiffer, wow, I
can't say that word today, substrates, but I don't, I just don't know what that means,
I don't know how to explain that, it makes, I don't know, I'm just going to stop with
that.
Yeah, I would say yes, and I would think that that again ties back to the first question
is that it's just how the cell is interacting with the substrate and how many focal adhesions
are there, and yeah, I would definitely think that there would be, but in 10 weeks I couldn't
pull off 3D, so.
Yes?
So in Rob's lab, as far as I remember, the A before the strictional sequence, strictional
sequence, there was one B in this.
Yes.
It was just the base.
Correct.
Yes.
And also fiberglasses.
Yep.
So that's it, one B and A, of course.
Yes.
In 8 hours they would see complete reorientation.
So is that similar to what you saw in ice thicknesses?
I was seeing about 50% in 12 hours, so, but I mean, one MPA versus 110, I mean you've
got a 9-fold difference there, so.
If I'm doing the math right, please don't check me.
You scared me with modeling.
I don't know.
I don't know what to say to that.
Ask Ralph.
Ask Ralph, yes.
Any other questions?
Okay, let's thank this speaker again.

