Illinois Nano-Bio Node - AVS @ UIUC Sept. 6 - Interfacial Processes in Li-ion Battery Anodes
Sep 5, 2023
September 6, 2012. AVS Materials for Energy Meeting. University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign
Hadi Tavassol, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
"Interfacial Processes in Li-ion Battery Anodes"
Let me first thank the organizer for organizing the event
and letting me share my research with you.
So, today I'm going to talk about interfacial processes
in lithium-ion batteries.
And, you know, we had a talk today
about lithium-ion batteries, so I will skip some
of the fundamentals about lithium-ion batteries,
but I will emphasize some part of that.
First, let me, you know, acknowledge some people.
So, Maria, actually, John and Jeff Greeley did some DFT
calculation for us in Argonne,
so I will show some of those data.
Maria is actually one of the undergrads in our group.
She did some of the MALDI experiment.
I will show you some of that stuff.
And, David Cahill, actually, is our collaborator.
We used the stress measurement setup, actually,
in that room over there, over there.
And, so, let me start with that.
Okay. So, lithium-ion batteries, you know,
Daniel Avram explained how lithium-ion battery works.
So, let me explain, emphasize a couple points.
First is, you know, as Daniel said,
it's a rechargeable battery.
So, you have exchange of lithium between two electrodes.
So, you're putting lithium into one electrode and removing it.
Ideally, this thing should be very reversible.
And, another thing I want to emphasize is,
as you exchange lithium between electrodes,
you form this interface on top of the electrodes,
and especially anode, which is the negative electrode.
And, we call this thing solid-electrode interface.
And, I will emphasize the solid-electrode interface
throughout my talk.
And, here, you know, I'm just showing that.
So, we have a stability window for each electrolyte we use.
Right? So, if we go lower than a potential limit,
we start oxidizing and reducing that electrolyte.
So, now, we form a CI layer on top of two electrodes.
Then, that will give us a little bit more higher window
that we can go, because that's a protective layer
on top of the electrode.
So, we can have extended window of potential.
So, this CI layer is amorphous layer.
So, it has a lot of different things in it,
inorganic compounds, organic compounds.
And, that thing, we want to see what is the mechanical effect
of this layer on the electrode in lithium ion battery anodes.
So, people have done a lot of studies on SCR.
And, they showed that it's a very complex mixture
of inorganic compounds and organic compounds.
And, they did spectroscopy, XPS.
So, the basic message of all of these studies was
that it's very complex.
Because, if you have organic compounds,
they are actually repeating units.
They are some sort of polymer or something.
And, you're not going to get
that much spectroscopy data from those.
Because, they are exactly the same thing.
They're repeating the same thing.
And, inorganic compounds, because we are
in a very reducing environment, it's actually very complex
to interpret a lot of spectroscopy data.
Okay. With that, I'm going to explain how we are going
to measure the mechanical changes on the surface
of the anode material in lithium ion batteries.
So, this is the setup we use in David Cahill's lab.
And, Jim Langer was actually the student who showed me how
to work with this instrument.
And, actually helped me a lot at the beginning.
So, the basic of the method is we have a very thin cantilever.
So, this cantilever is around 150 micron.
So, as the surface stress of the substrate changes,
the cantilever will start bending.
And, if you reflect the laser from the surface
of the cantilever, we can detect how much the cantilever is
bending.
And, that bending of the cantilever is related
to the surface stress of that material
through the Stoney's equation.
Okay. So, some people, some other group,
actually did some studies with different methods
on surface stress changes on lithium ion battery anodes.
And, especially on silicon.
So, the important thing about silicon is
because you have a big expansion as you put lithium in and out
of the silicon substrate, you will get a lot of stresses
on the surface.
And, it's a lot of stresses developed
on the surface of the silicon.
And, the bottom line of all of these studies was
that as you put lithium inside the anode material,
you develop some compressive stress on the surface.
And, as you remove this thing,
you pretty much remove this compressive stress.
But, the point is, especially on silicon,
and on this high capacity material,
because you have a lot of expansion and contraction,
you start breaking the surface as you put lithium in
and you remove it.
Especially if you have single crystalline silicon.
So, the system we chose to study this effect was gold.
And, gold was, for us, was a model system
for anode material and not lithium ion batteries.
So, what you can see here is a cyclic voltammetry.
So, what we are doing here is we are cycling
from two volts and we are going to more cathodic potential.
So, lower potentials.
So, ideally, if you go, you get very close to zero,
you are going to lithium, bulk deposit lithium into the gold.
But, we are not going, in this graph here, we are not going
that low in the potential.
So, we are not bulk depositing lithium into the gold.
But, the point is, we are seeing, you know,
a couple features here.
One here, one here, and one over there.
So, people previously started this system
and assigned this peak to lithium UPD and that peak
to the stripping of the lithium UPD.
And, they said, you know, this peak is pretty much reduction
of the solvent and electrolyte.
This is a, you know, I emphasize here
that this is a very reducing environment.
So, this is two volt versus lithium.
In the surface stress, what we can see is, as, you know,
other people reported in other material, in gold also,
as you go to lower potential,
you develop that compressive stress.
And, when you go, come back to the anodic potential,
you remove that compressive stress.
Come back exactly where you started.
And, the magnitude of the stress from beginning
to the end is around 6.5 newton per meter.
If we get the derivative of the stress versus potential,
we will see a couple more features
that they are not shown in the cyclic voltammetry.
So, this is not a very simple process
that you just put lithium in and out.
So, something else is happening on the surface.
So, we wanted to know exactly what's happening here.
So, we started more on the electrochemistry of the system.
So, we started at two volts, and we switched the potential
at different potential to see exactly where this peak happens.
So, where this peak starts showing up.
And, you can see that even before this peak,
if we switch before that peak,
we still have that feature in one volt.
So, this means that, you know, this peak, whatever it is,
it's not lithium UPD.
So, it's not related to putting lithium in.
Because, even before that peak,
we are getting some lithium out of the surface.
And, if we get another material that is different
than this system, so this system is lithium perchlorate PC.
So, if we get an ionic liquid,
that the ionic liquid is supposedly more stable
to walk reduction in this environment, and you don't see
that much reduction of the ionic liquid.
So, you can see there's no peak over there.
So, that peak is probably related
to solvent or electrolyte.
So, and another important thing here is that the amount
of lithium we are putting in and removing
from the surface is more than monolayer.
So, it's, here we have around six monolayer
of lithium putting in.
And, this is not like other UPD system.
In UPD system, we usually deposit just a monolayer
of lithium.
So, this shows that we are forming some sort
of surface alloy on the surface.
So, lithium and gold are alloying on the surface.
Jeff Greeley and Maria Chan, they did some DFT calculation
and to show how much stress is developed
if we put just a monolayer of lithium
on the surface of the gold.
And, what they actually, bottom line, their result was
that the lithium has a very high tendency
to alloy with the gold.
So, lithium wants to be surrounded by gold atoms.
So, because of that, the full monolayer
of lithium is not stable.
And, we will show that because of that,
you can see this full monolayer of lithium.
So, here is the voltage and coverage.
The full monolayer happens at zero volts.
But, we will see that it's experimentally,
that the alloy formation of lithium
and gold happens a little bit higher than zero volts.
So, it means that this full monolayer is not stable.
And, before getting to that potential,
gold and lithium start alloying themselves.
But, the point here is calculation also shows
that as we increase the coverage of the lithium
on the surface, we develop some compressive stress on the surface.
The value of the stress is less than the experimental value.
And, the reason is this model is just
for a monolayer of the lithium.
But, in the experiment, we showed that we had
at least six monolayer of the lithium on the surface.
Okay. So, as I said, that was a surface alloy formation.
So, what would happen if we go lower in the potential?
So, as you can see, if we go lower in the potential,
we start bulk depositing lithium in the surface.
And, if you compare these peaks over here in current
with these peaks over here and there,
you can see the current over there is a lot less
than this current.
So, here we have like 10 microampere centimeter square.
But, when you get to bulk, we have at least 500,
even 1 milliampere square, per centimeter square.
So, these are different phenomena.
So, this is surface alloy formation.
But, if you go low in potential,
then we have the bulk alloy formation of lithium and gold.
So, now the question is what will happen
with the surface stress?
So, when we get to these potentials,
and when we cycle, we go negative in potential.
We put lithium into the surface.
When we come back analytically, we remove that lithium.
And, we develop the compressive stress
where we remove that compressive stress.
But, unlike the surface alloy region,
now we have some residual stress on the surface.
So, unlike that system that went back exactly where we started
at the beginning of the cycle,
now we have some residual stress developed on the surface.
And, we wanted to know what is the reason
for this residual stress.
So, if we continue cycling so that this is the first cycle,
some residual stress, second cycle,
even more residual stress on the surface.
So, we wanted to know what's happening here.
So, another technique we used was QCM, electrochemical QCM.
So, basically, which is cross crystal microbalance.
So, the thing it does is actually measure how much mass
you put on the surface as you start cycling.
And, we can see, you know, as we start cycling,
during each cycle we are putting some extra mass
on the surface.
And, this extra mass is the SCI layer that I mentioned
at the beginning of the talk.
So, you are putting a layer on top of the animal
that's the solid electrolyte interface that has a mass
that we can see in QCM.
And, we think that this SCI is actually cause
of this residual stress on the surface, that we didn't have it
in the surface alloy, because in surface alloy,
we don't form that much SCI.
But, when we get to the low potential,
then we are forming more and more of this SCI layer.
And, this actually causes
that residual stress on the surface.
So, we showed, you know, recently that a big part
of this SCI is a very long chain product.
And, this is a multi matrix assisted laser desorption
ionization mass spectrometry.
With, what it does is actually it can ionize very big ions.
So, polymers.
So, ions with a very high mass ratios.
And, you can see here, after first cycle, we have polymers
that develop on surface with mass ratios to 2500.
And, even we go, if you continue cycling,
you have even 3500 mass ratios of the ion,
of the polymers on surface.
And, we showed that, you know,
the structure of this thing is something like that.
So, it's a polymer with this type of structure on surface.
Okay. So, I already said
that the SCI causes this residual stress on surface.
But, how it does that?
So, in the beginning, so in this surface alloy formation region.
So, we go lithiation, we develop the compressive stress.
When we remove lithium from surface, we remove
that compressive stress from surface.
When we go back exactly where we end up.
So, this is a reversible process.
So, we can put the lithium in, remove the lithium,
we will get exactly where we started.
Now, if we go to the bulk lithiation region,
and we form the SCI.
So, we go compressive when we lithiate.
But, when we remove the lithium from surface,
because we now have this polymer in the SCI.
So, this polymer actually contracts the surface together
and develops the tensile stress on surface.
And, this is how this tensile stress is developed
when you go low enough in the potential.
Now, I wanted to know why exactly is there any way
that we can show why it's not forming here,
when we are in the surface alloy region.
And, when we did, we went
and did actually multi-experiment
in different potentials.
So, when we take, when we start from two walls,
at one wall we take it out, take a multi-experiment,
there's not much on the surface.
At .3, there's not much on the surface.
.15, there's not much on the surface.
But, if we come back, we start anodic potential,
we can see there are some polymers forming on surface
as soon as we reverse the potential
and go to the anodic direction.
And, this shows that that SCI polymer
actually forms during the lithiation of the surface.
So, when the lithium is removed from surface,
at the same time, cilantro polymers are formed
as part of the SCI.
And, this is the reason for that residual stress
in the surface of the gold electrodes.
Okay, with that, I will come to my conclusion.
So, in conclusion, actually,
with one of the most important thing in my view
with that thing was in the surface alloy formation region
was that people previously thought
that lithium will form a monolayer
on the surface of the gold, but that's not the case.
Lithium and gold with alloy
at the beginning of the potential window,
and that alloy formation is not a monolayer formation.
So, it's a multilayer alloy formation,
surface alloy formation.
And, we also showed that
if we do first principle calculations,
we can show that there's a compressive stress
developed on surface.
And, the values are not exactly the same thing,
but the calculation model is just a monolayer.
But, we showed that there are more than monolayer
lithium formed on the surface
in the surface alloy formation region.
And, when we go to the full lithiation SCI formation,
because of that irreversible formation of the SCI,
we develop irreversible tensile stress on the surface.
That's a residual tensile stress on the surface
that we can contribute to the polymers
on the surface in the SCI layer.
And, with that, I will come to my acknowledgement.
I will acknowledge my advisor, Professor Goers,
and our collaborator, Maria Chen, Jeff Creeley,
Glenn from Ferguson, and Larry Curtis
in Argonne National Lab.
Maria and Jeff, they were my undergrad students
working with me.
And, Joe is our QCM expert in our group.
And, Dr. Yao actually helped me with a small experiment
in Mass Tech Center of the Chemistry Department.
And, all the Goers group members,
my fellowships, and Department of Chemistry,
and funding agency.
Thank you very much for your attention.
Thank you.

