Bob Costas on Shohei Ohtani's Future

Sports Zone
361 followers
Bob and BK sit down to discuss what lies ahead for Shohei Ohtani for this season and the years ahead.
#sports
How is Otani playing game two of
that double header.
It's a straight double header.
He pitched a complete game.
He's never done it.
They roll him out to D.H.
to get a hit to home runs.
Everyone's going to say that
today.
He almost like if that's his
oblique that he was clutching we
got a real problem.
How are they in real time Bob.
I'm thinking how are they
rolling him out in game two.
He's show hey Otani he's he's
blown out already.
Bob he had surgery on his arm.
They've already he's blown out
before.
I get it.
You have a point but it's not
overly convincing.
Because he's not hurt right now.
But right because he's not right
now.
So you're not convinced that
he's not in the hospital right
now.
Right.
If I see him being wheeled down
the corner then you sold.
Well you got your wish.
All right.
I hope you're happy Bob.
Timing and context is
everything.
That conversation takes place
the day after or within two
days.
Artie Moreno and the Angels have
declared we are not trading
Otani at the deadline.
And not only that they go in as
two players and they bring in
G Alito and Lopez and Otani
plays both ends of a double
head.
At that point they're like three
maybe four games out of a wild
card.
And it looks like they're in
good shape to at least make a
run.
All right.
The good feeling as I pointed
out elsewhere in that segment
the good feeling surrounding
that team at that time they're
playing this double header in
Detroit.
They sweep the double header.
Yeah.
He pitches a one hitter a
complete game one hitter in the
first game and hits two home
runs in the second game.
It's sort of symbolizes what
this whole move is about.
Moreno saying even if we don't
resign him we're going to give
our fans two more months of a
once in forever not once in a
lifetime once in forever player
in the whole history of
baseball.
We haven't seen this and maybe
we can retain him.
So in that moment when they were
within striking distance what I
said made perfect sense.
Not necessarily the only thing
made sense because what you said
made sense too.
Like they never should have
pitched him in the rain at 11
o'clock in the morning in April
coming off the WBC at Fenway
Park.
And then the next down three
days rest after that.
Yes.
Bad.
OK.
Once they fell out of it you
know the Angels are star-crossed
right.
The trapdoor opens they make the
move.
That's not the right thing.
The trapdoor opens once they're
ten games out of the third wild
card.
They should have backed him off
even if he continued to back
himself off.
He took off 13 days.
Yeah.
But that day Bob he came out.
I'm just the small point.
It was the day after he pitched
the complete game.
Yes.
And they brought him out to hit
two home runs in game two.
Mike why are they playing them.
And everybody's point was just
you were because they were
symbolic of it.
They were making a statement
that we will ride this guy until
he breaks and he broke in that
game.
He's clutching his side.
Yes he was.
The body was breaking down and
then the arm went.
Now it could have happened
anywhere.
But I didn't like the way they
met.
If you would ask me that
question a month later I would
have been entirely on your page.
What now that his UCL.
No no no no.
Now that they were so far out of
it I would have backed him over.
You still have to be smart to
back him off.
You can't keep full day's work.
You have a complete game shut
out.
That's enough work for me.
It's like no let your body rest.
That didn't break him.
But cumulatively you know what
you know.
This is a little bit like
there's an emotional thing no
matter how carefully and
analytically you want to look at
something.
A guy is on a strict diet but on
Thanksgiving he has extra
helpings.
This felt like Thanksgiving for
them.
We're not going to we're not
going to trade Ohtani.
We're going to make a run.
We got the other two guys.
He hits two home runs in the
back end of the doublehead after
pitching a complete game one
hitter in the first that felt
like that.
And he had a clogged arteries
after Thanksgiving or something.
Maybe that can be an analogy.
That can happen.
He's continuing the season as a
hitter.
He should be or foolish.
I think that's the right thing.
Unless there's some unless
there's something within it
within surgery unless there's
something within his swing that
no I think that further damage
is he for his own.
I'm saying admirable.
I think you're saying he's to be
admired for that.
Yes.
For his own business
considerations.
He could get the surgery now and
be closer to pitching and being
that hitter.
Yes he should again because his
team is out of it.
Like you even said the angels
are out of it.
If the angels were in it's like
show hey we need you even though
your contract is expiring.
And he says yes I'm going to
honor my contract.
I'll play you out that they're
out of it now.
Right.
Some of this might be connected
to the slim possibility that the
angels can resign and that there
are conversations going on
indicate that to them that they
have a fighting chance for that.
And now they say which do you
prefer because we're not going
to base this on your statistics
this year or anything else.
We want to keep you.
What are the circumstances that
allow us to keep you.
And even if it means you're
going to miss all of next year
as a pitcher and maybe come back
as a pitcher in twenty twenty
five.
You tell us the terms we want to
keep you.
Yeah but he is going to test the
market and him not pitching for
a year a full year is going to
affect his market value.
And even if he has a surgery he
comes back as a hitter.
Even Bryce Harper did that and
he was back in May and that was
a quick timetable.
Yeah.
So this is affecting his future
finances.
Here's here's a reasonable
assumption.
Let's say he was completely
healthy now and still able to
pitch at the very high level and
still do what he's doing at the
plate.
Eventually if he gets eight
years and some team might say
look we'll give you ten even
we're sure that in the last
three four years we're not
getting our money's worth but we
will do what it takes to sign
you.
Nobody thinks that he's going to
be pitching at the back end.
He's twenty nine years old when
he's thirty nine forty years old
he's not going to be doing this
even if he's completely healthy.
He's just not going to be able
to do it at the same level.
So then why would you give him a
ten year contract to get those
first five years.
Yes because it might be what's
necessary.
I just think to break a log jam
with other teams that are
willing to meet his price.
Good luck.
Five hundred million.
Good luck.
All right.
What is Steven Strasburg's
legacy.
He's retiring in September.
Nerve damage.
Seven year two hundred and
forty five million dollar deal.
A handful of innings after that.
But he won that World Series in
twenty nineteen.
Yeah it's no one thing.
It's a combination of things.
It's one of the great bookends
in baseball history.
His debut fourteen strikeouts
much value.
You called you called that game
house.
Yeah he was.
He was exciting electric that
night and then essentially the
end of his career since he only
pitched like three and a third
innings after that and then a
few appearances is twenty
nineteen where he had not a
Cy Young level season but I
think he finished fifth in the
Cy Young voting he won 18 games
and he was winning.
He was great.
He was great in the postseason
five and oh in the postseason
two wins in the World Series.
So that's the bookend.
But the contract is a cautionary
tale and it also shows that even
thoughtful people can make
emotional decisions.
This is in the afterglow of the
twenty nineteen World Series and
all their success.
And he's the MVP of the World
Series and he was able to opt
out of his contract.
So he's a free agent and they
wanted to keep him.
But he was kind of a horse.
He had over two hundred innings
like for the first time.
So the second time he had over
two hundred innings.
Take a look at.
Yeah but he was a horse who had
broken down previously.
This is my point that I'm always
making.
The analogy is I will break down
and the history was there.
But I understand it coming off
the World Series title.
He was so clutch.
Yeah.
Don't was so clutch repeatedly
every round.
But yeah cautionary tale.
You know what happened.
That's one in nineteen World
Championship bought them a grace
period with the fans that
allowed them to gut the roster.
Not long after.
I know you'd appreciate this.
Bob I put I like putting this
up and see there's El Duque in
the middle of all time.
Great.
These are the clutch guy.
These guys were made of Sterner
stuff.
Bumgarner Schilling.
Look at the innings and the ERA
the innings in the ERA.
Now John Smoltz has two hundred
nine innings two six seven.
Dave Stewart was super clutch
one hundred and thirty three
innings.
Now Strasburg's only got fifty
five innings.
I get it.
So maybe it doesn't quite belong
there.
But a one four six.
Yeah.
That's that's significant.
And the key is that those guys
pitched complete games or near
complete games.
You know Dave Stewart.
I don't know if he's still
ticked off at Tony La Russa.
For a long time he was mad at
Tony La Russa for pulling him
from game one in nineteen
eighty-eight even though he had
Dennis Eckersley to finish the
game and Gibson hit the home
run.
But that's the kind of
competitor that Stewart was.
Don't take the ball from me.
Yeah.
Well even like Strasburg being
on that list with the all time
clutch.
We were like nice.
He's the Orchard.
He seems fragile.
Yeah.
But there's that the ceiling is
just so yeah so high.
The two seasons seventeen and
nineteen and the beginning in
twenty ten.
Those were flashes of what might
have been.
We haven't settled the legacy
but we have time for that.
