CLAIRE SAFFITZ PERFECT KEY LIME PIE RECIPE | DESSERT PERSON

Healthy food
927 followers
For any citrus dessert, if it's sweeter than it is sour,
I feel like it's a missed opportunity. I always want it to be like really tart.
Today I have a recipe for you that is a perennial favorite, a recipe that I'm like,
why don't I make this more? It's so good, so easy, so few ingredients. It is key lime pie,
the best dessert there is that has no season. Make it all year round.
Key lime pie is so interesting. I did do a little bit of research into the history.
When I think of key lime pie, I think of Key West. It's like, must be a dessert from there.
Apparently the origins are a little bit contested. What do you want, cat? What is, what do you want?
I want the ball that's behind it.
Oh, you want your ball? Okay, okay, here.
I did do a little bit of research into the actual origins. Turns out it's like slightly contested
and not really certain, but certain evidence points to it coming from actually like recipe
developers for sweetened condensed milk. It makes sense to me. This is kind of one of those
like very American desserts that is sort of based on like pantry ingredients. So every key lime pie
recipe is built around a can of sweetened condensed milk and the filling is so simple.
It's just egg yolk, lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, a little lime zest often, and that's it.
There are little details here and there that I'm going to try to use it to like enhance this already
really delicious recipe, but for the most part it's like I'm not, I'm not messing with perfection here.
Let's start with the crust. I have six ounces of graham crackers, four tablespoons unsalted butter,
a little bit of granulated sugar, salt. For the filling, I have vanilla extract, one can of
sweetened condensed milk, a whole bunch of limes, which I'm going to zest and then juice, and egg yolks.
Then for the topping, I have a cup of heavy cream, a couple tablespoons powdered sugar,
and a little bit of an unusual addition, four tablespoons cream cheese. The only special
equipment you'll really need is a nine inch pie plate. I have a metal one here, which I don't
typically use, but I think it's going to look kind of good. And then you don't even need a mixer.
It's all going to be done by hand. See this bag and how it's like kind of gnarly looking?
This is my graham cracker crust bag that I use to crush graham crackers or like other cookies,
and I save it. And every time I look at it, I'm like, should I throw that away? And then I'm happy
that I have it. So I'm putting the graham crackers inside the bag and then kind of pressing up the
air and sealing it. Yes, you could do this in the food processor. Yes, you could use like pre-ground
graham cracker crumbs, which is kind of a great time saver, but I do like doing it by hand because
one, I think it's easier to control how fine the crumbs are, and two, you get irregular sizes.
These are going to go into my bowl. This I'll save for the next time. Then I'm going to add
a half teaspoon of kosher salt. I like having a kind of slightly salty base. It's a nice contrast
to the filling. Then two tablespoons of granulated sugar. And I forgot to melt my butter. So I do
want to melt this. This is four tablespoons of unsalted butter, which I will melt. I know you're
not supposed to do this, right? What? Be that close to a microwave? Look, microwaves, microplastics,
just a lot of things out there that are not good for you. Okay, so I'm not adding a lot of sugar,
just two tablespoons, because I'm not really trying to sweeten it. The point of the sugar
is that the sugar mixes with the butter that I'm adding, and as it bakes, those things kind
of form, like they fuse in the oven as they bake and help to set this crust. So I'm going to add
the butter. Because I'm not adding a lot of sugar, I want to increase the sturdiness of the crust,
and that's why I add one egg yolk. It's not really a typical addition to graham cracker crust, but I
think it does help to hold everything together really well. So I have five yolks remaining,
that's going to go into the filling. I'm going to stir all this together really well with a spatula,
you could use a fork. So once I have it well combined and everything incorporated, I'm going
to switch to my hands. It helps to just even out the moisture so that I have a mixture that looks
uniformly like wet sand, and that's how you know you're ready to press it into your pie plate.
I have some, you know, some larger crumbs and some finer crumbs, but it's all pretty uniformly
mixed with the butter and the yolk. So it's well incorporated, and I have this mixture that kind
of looks like wet sand. You can see that it doesn't look wet or greasy, but when I pack it together,
it holds. So that's what you're looking for. This is a nine inch, not a deep dish pie plate.
So I kind of go in with my hands and start to build the bottom, and then work the mixture up
against the sides, kind of evenly distributing it all the way around. So now I'm going to take
my measuring cup, and I like to start on the bottom and really press it in to kind of flatten
it. And now I'm going to, working at like, you know, an angle to match the angle of the side,
I'm going to use the measuring cup to press it up the side. This is going to have great texture
because while it's going to hold together really well so I can take out a nice, clean, sharp slice,
it has lots of different size pieces of graham cracker, so it'll be like a nice kind of light
crunch where you hit a bigger piece, and sort of a more firm, like even crust texture where
the crumbs are a little bit finer. My oven is on 350. I'm going to bake this, and there's not like
a super distinct indicator when your graham cracker crust is done. Oftentimes you see ones that are
just no bake, and this is like where you stop, especially if it's served chilled. But I like to
bake it. I think it's really important, and you know it's done when you see like that the edge
is nice and dark brown. It's going to smell like super toasty and delicious.
So I have probably more limes than I need here, but you want to zest before juicing because it's
a lot easier to zest like a whole lime than it is to zest like a squeezed wedge or half.
I have my microplane here. You want to be careful that you're just taking off
the green part and not any of the pith underneath. I have watched so many people use a microplane.
I've always done it this way, but people do this. But like I don't, I just, it's just not my way.
I totally get it, and this I believe is the proper technique. Actually it does kind of work.
It's a question of do you want to move the microplane or do you want to move the lime?
I'd rather move the lime. So I'm at a probably about a tablespoon. Now I'm going to juice the
limes. I want to juice them until I get about three quarters of a cup of lime juice. These
fortunately are relatively thin skinned limes. By the way, I'm not using key limes. I love the
flavor of key limes, but they're harder to find. They kind of have a specific season and they're
really small, so they're a pain to juice. So rarely do you see key lime pie that's actually
made with key limes. So just using regular grocery store limes. So I'm just using this
little citrus reamer here to juice them. I'm going to pour them through the strainer into my
measuring cup and I'm just going to keep going until I get to three quarters of a cup. I probably
won't need all of these. The crust has been in only for eight minutes. It already smells really
done and that edge is really brown. So I'm going to pull it out. So you see that nice dark ring
around the top. Crust is done. I'm going to let it hang out there while I finish the filling.
One thing I really like about key lime pie is it uses one full can of sweetened condensed milk
because it's not the most convenient thing to split and like save, you know, part of the can.
But then the quantities of yolk and juice vary. So you could decrease the amount of juice and
you'll get something a little less tart. You can increase obviously if you like it
like a lot more sour. If you want something a little richer, add more yolks. If you like a
looser, you know, not as quite firm a set, you can add fewer. So it's really up to you, but I like
this particular balance. So I have my main components, my lime juice, my yolks, my sweetened
condensed milk. I also have kosher salt and vanilla extract. So I'm just adding a little bit
of both as flavor enhancers, but really it's just in the background. So I'm going to put together
my filling. Start by opening my can. This can is kind of lethal though. It's never going to come
off. You're in trouble. There we go. So obviously I'm not adding additional sugar. There is plenty
of sugar in sweetened condensed milk. So then about a teaspoon of vanilla extract goes in.
Just a little pinch of kosher salt. I'm not really going to measure.
Then I'm going to add my yolks. Again, five large egg yolks. Whisk all of this together.
When all that is smooth, then in goes the lime juice and just whisk this until you have a smooth
mixture. Oh, this looks so good. I have this nice, thick, smooth, custardy filling and I love seeing
the flecks of lime zest. So this has cooled slightly in my crust, but it's still warm. I do
like actually pouring custard fillings into a hot pie crust because it does help to set it at the
bottom really quickly and then it bakes faster. But one important note is I bake this at 350 and
I want to turn down my oven to 325 because with any kind of custard filling with eggs,
you want to kind of go low and slow. Oven's preheated. So now I'm going to pour this filling
into my pie plate. Smooth the top a little bit. Very limey. Now into my oven. So I want to bake
that until I see that the filling has set. It's going to be particularly set around the edges
and the center will have a slight wobble, but I don't want to get any color on the surface. So
I'm going to keep an eye on it. I think it's going to go like 15 to 20 minutes.
My timer is about to go off. So I set the timer for 15 minutes. It wasn't quite done. I set it
for one more. There it is. I think it's ready. There's no color on the surface. That's the way
we baked it at 325. I just want it to be cooked enough so that the eggs are set. So when I give
it a little wobble, well, actually when I give it like a shake, basically the whole thing kind
of holds together as one piece, but there's a little bit of movement. I want to jiggle it like
that. So this looks good. So this is really hot. I want to let it rest at room temperature,
have it release a little bit of steam. And then once it's had a chance to cool a little bit,
I'm going to put it in the fridge and then I want to let it get really cold. It'll take a few hours
because this is best served chilled. So then we're going to top it with our whipped cream,
cream cheese topping and taste it. In most cases, the topping for key lime pie is just whipped
cream, which is great, but I'm adding a little bit of cream cheese. Something I've been playing
around with as a way of stabilizing the whipped cream. It's common to add like creme fraiche or
sour cream or another kind of cultured dairy product to stabilize whipped cream, because if
you were to whip cream and just let it sit there, it tends to like liquefy again and kind of fall
and deflate. So not only do I like the little bit of tanginess that it adds and it kind of gives it
like a slight cheesecakey quality in a good way, but it also is functional because it just makes
everything more stable. I have two ounces or four tablespoons room temp cream cheese, also
important. Let me get this into my bowl. I have really tart filling in my key lime pie, so I'm
going to add two tablespoons of powdered sugar to my topping to sweeten it a little bit and that
goes. So then I'm going to use my spatula. I'm going to use my spatula to kind of work this together
and because the cream cheese is room temp, it's pretty soft, so this is easy to do. So when all
that is smooth, I'm going to switch to my whisk. So scrape off that spatula, get everything back
into the bowl. Here's the only part of this where you want to be careful. I'm going to add my cold
cream to that room temp mixture, but I'm going to do it very very slowly because if I were to pour
all of this in, the cold from the cream would stiffen the cream cheese and I would get some
lumps in there. I want it to be super smooth, so I'm just going to start by adding a little bit of
just like a couple teaspoons at a time and whisking really really well to incorporate it.
So adding the cream really really slowly in the beginning is going to help to prevent lumps from
forming. Your bowl is moving around. Here's my pro tip. Grab a kitchen towel, grab it from two
opposite corners and tie it around the bowl. This is also great if you're making mayo.
Okay, not unlike this actually. So just sort of like slowly drizzling in the cream
and once you have the mixture thinned out to the point where it's kind of pourable,
which is basically where we are, you can basically just whisk the rest of the cream
in. You don't have to go slowly. There's no more risk of lumps forming. So that's the rest of the
heavy cream. I'm going to actually just scrape in anything that's left in the cup. So now I have my
cream and my cream cheese incorporated and now I'm just going to whip this. It's been a while since
I've whipped cream by hand. One time my sister called me and she was like, how long does it take
to whip cream? I was like, in the stand mixer, and I was like, how much cream do you have? She was
like, two cups. I was like, what speed is it on? She was like, high. I was like, how long has it
been going? 45 minutes. I'm going, oh no, something went wrong. It was not the right kind of cream.
It does go faster in a bigger bowl. It's getting pretty thick. Now it's really up to you. It's
kind of an aesthetic choice if you go, like how much you're going to whip the cream. If you want
a kind of like natural sort of easygoing look, you can go to soft peaks and then just kind of
like swoosh it over the surface. Or if you want something a little more decorative, you can go
to firm peaks and then you can pipe it. It's really up to you.
All right, so I'm kind of between soft and medium peaks here. I think I'm just going to swoosh it
over. Get such a nice color from the yolk. Now that it's cold, I know it's cold because the bottom
is like super cold to the touch. No, no wobbling or wiggling to that filling. It's nice and firm.
So now I'm going to just scrape that topping onto the surface. Okay, so right onto the top.
I'm going to just kind of smooth it around. You don't want to touch it too much. That's really
kind of the key to getting it to look good. Okay, that's probably all I should really do to it.
I can feel that the cream is already kind of like tightening a little bit.
And that is in large part to that cream cheese that I added. I kind of can't stop eating it.
I could go ahead and serve this right now because we have the cream cheese in that whipped topping.
It's going to hang out in the fridge. It's not going to fall. So this is a great do ahead.
If you want to make this for company, go ahead and you can add that topping before dinner,
keep it in the fridge, and then go ahead and slice it later. So I'm going to just throw it
back in the fridge. And then we'll do a little final lime zest garnish and taste.
All right, just ignore whatever. Okay, time to taste the key lime pie. I'm gonna grab it from
the fridge. Just ignore what's happening over here. So here's the pie. I'm going to give it
a little bit of lime zest, mostly for color. So I have my one extra lime right here. You can hold
the grater up a little higher so that the little flecks of lime zest spread out. Here we go. It's
ready. I'm going to cut a slice. Oh my gosh, I'm so excited to eat this. It looks so good. The
texture you get with that combination of yolk and sweetened condensed milk, it's so silky. I'm very
excited to try it. I like the proportion a lot of filling to topping. I think if it's like a really
thick slice, it just gets a little bit overwhelming in how citrusy it is. It's not too tart. I like
the topping. It's only a little tiny bit sweet. What I also really like is that that very like
point of the pie, which is in the very center, still has a little bit of crunch to it. It didn't
get soggy and wet and you just get this like perfect set in this silky filling. I don't think
that there's a more perfect dessert. No, there is, but it's pretty perfect. What is it? There's a lot
of perfect desserts out there, but what would be more perfect than key lime? Chocolate chip cookie?
Chocolate chip cookie, for sure. I don't know. I can't think right now. I'm kind of busy with this,
but it's pretty good. Come try this. Come here. The whipped cream has cream cheese in it.
You still have that thing on your nose. It might be attached. I love the cream cheese. Yeah. Do you
want it even more tart? I think it's good. I think it's a good balance. No, I think it's right off.
I think it's right off. Nice. It seems to me like a pretty low effort dessert. There's something
about it that feels very kind of like tropical. It's fruit forward, but really it uses like mostly
pantry ingredients, so definitely worth trying. If you're a beginner baker, I think this is a great
recipe to start out. Can't be improved. Love it so much. Key lime pie. Can't wait to finish my slice.
Thank you so much for watching, and don't forget to like and subscribe.
